Forbidden Lore - Revival

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Smogg

Grave Guard
Jan 27, 2012
260
Zombies
206
I just realized that with Undead Legions, your general is no longer restricted to being a caster or having lore of vampires. Seems forbidden lore is suddenly much more interesting!
 
True enough but is it worth the extra points investment or would you just take one of the accessible lores anyway? I think it is going to be very list dependent but I can't see many better options than death, shadow or vamps for the lists I can think of.
 
True enough but is it worth the extra points investment or would you just take one of the accessible lores anyway? I think it is going to be very list dependent but I can't see many better options than death, shadow or vamps for the lists I can think of.
It's just that suddenly, you can take a level 4 with all of the ones that we are usually stuck with level 2s at, like Light or Metal... We can now stick LoV on the level 2s and concentrate our power on much more damaging lores.
 
I recall Johnny saying that Lore of Beasts would be an awesome addition to us, if we didn't have to pay handsomely for it.

Now that we are able to use it, I'll test the wisdom of his words :D

I was looking for the old Forbidden Lore thread, just to post the official answer now... yet you guys beat me to it, haha.


As a side note, do all rulings of Undead Legions substitute the ones in our VC book? What I mean is... this... "expansion" the new official rules, or is it exclusivelly for the End of Times? D:
 
I recall Johnny saying that Lore of Beasts would be an awesome addition to us, if we didn't have to pay handsomely for it.

Now that we are able to use it, I'll test the wisdom of his words :D

I was looking for the old Forbidden Lore thread, just to post the official answer now... yet you guys beat me to it, haha.


As a side note, do all rulings of Undead Legions substitute the ones in our VC book? What I mean is... this... "expansion" the new official rules, or is it exclusivelly for the End of Times? D:
the consensus is that it updates Warhammer in it's entirety. However, a consensus could as little as 51%. Right now, I would say it's 65/35 in favor of End Times affecting all things fantasy and I am basing that ratio on nothing in particular. I still believe there is the consensus, though.
 
I think that Lore of Death/Shadow exceeds the potential of any of the other Lores including Metal due to the buffs/debuffs making actually breaking the enemy that much easier compared to a +1 to hit or 5+ scaly skin for 1 turn. Against bretonnians/empire cavalry maybe, but you're much better with debuffing their Str/T/Ld than the weaker offensive/defensive Metal.
 
I think that Lore of Death/Shadow exceeds the potential of any of the other Lores including Metal due to the buffs/debuffs making actually breaking the enemy that much easier compared to a +1 to hit or 5+ scaly skin for 1 turn. Against bretonnians/empire cavalry maybe, but you're much better with debuffing their Str/T/Ld than the weaker offensive/defensive Metal.
Well the damage spells wound on their AS, with the exception of Final Transmutation, which is really good on WoC, Dwarves, and Brets and can straight remove their armor, which is nothing to scoff at.
 
Don't know where people get the impression that Lore of Metal is great against dwarfs. Armour on average is 5+, with shield units getting a 4+ and only ironbreakers getting a 3+. I you mean warriors of chaos: sure, but I'd rather soulblight or the withering over wounding on armour. That and initiative test or die > final transmute every time against dwarfs.

The character sniping potential against elves versus being useless against their average to nonexistent armour outweighs the odd bretonnian matchup or empire cavalry, mainly because the toolset from shadow or death is far more versatile and powerful.
 
The Nagash book works like this:
  • Lore of undeath, any wizard from any army can take in place of its own lore options. That is available now, in any version of the rules. That's how the lore itself works. You can't mix the lore with other lores unless you are using Nagash or one of his Mortarchs.
  • Undead legion is it's own army list, with its own special rules that pulls it's units from the tomb kings and vampire count army books. This list is not campaign specific. It can be fielded by anyone. Some people are confused here at what this list is. This is causing some issues as players don't know if it's official or not. It's official.
  • The changes to undead armies is exclusive to undead legions. The rules there do not modify armies written using just the vampire counts or tomb king books, with one exception: morghasts specifically state they are available to vampire count armies. So, you want marching tomb kings or no general crumble, run undead legions. You want count Manny or settra, run VC or TK.
  • The end times rules are up to 50% heroes and 50% lords. This applies to any army and states that it is an update to the rule book. This is one of the hang ups players are having, though it's WAY more minor than escalation for 40k was. You still need 25% core, so you are just eating into your special/rare units to get more lords/heroes. Not necessarily a good choice.
So, to summarize
1) Any wizard can take lore of undeath.
2) Undead legion is a new official army list
3) Special rules from UL do not modify VC or TK, except morghast which VC can take.
4) Any army can take up to 50% heroes & 50% lords.
 
The Nagash book works like this:
  • Lore of undeath, any wizard from any army can take in place of its own lore options. That is available now, in any version of the rules. That's how the lore itself works. You can't mix the lore with other lores unless you are using Nagash or one of his Mortarchs.
  • Undead legion is it's own army list, with its own special rules that pulls it's units from the tomb kings and vampire count army books. This list is not campaign specific. It can be fielded by anyone. Some people are confused here at what this list is. This is causing some issues as players don't know if it's official or not. It's official.
  • The changes to undead armies is exclusive to undead legions. The rules there do not modify armies written using just the vampire counts or tomb king books, with one exception: morghasts specifically state they are available to vampire count armies. So, you want marching tomb kings or no general crumble, run undead legions. You want count Manny or settra, run VC or TK.
  • The end times rules are up to 50% heroes and 50% lords. This applies to any army and states that it is an update to the rule book. This is one of the hang ups players are having, though it's WAY more minor than escalation for 40k was. You still need 25% core, so you are just eating into your special/rare units to get more lords/heroes. Not necessarily a good choice.
So, to summarize
1) Any wizard can take lore of undeath.
2) Undead legion is a new official army list
3) Special rules from UL do not modify VC or TK, except morghast which VC can take.
4) Any army can take up to 50% heroes & 50% lords.
I think on page 14 of nagash book in the last paragraph, it says to ignore the hierophant an vc General rule. With UL having its own rules, why is that included if it doesn't apply to TK or VC? I think it specifically says that those rules aren't needed because nagash's presence in the world eliminates their need. I think it also has something to with it being fair for VC and TK because the other armies can now take undeath and it wouldn't make sense for undead models to follow different rules for different armies.
 
I think on page 14 of nagash book in the last paragraph, it says to ignore the hierophant an vc General rule. With UL having its own rules, why is that included if it doesn't apply to TK or VC? I think it specifically says that those rules aren't needed because nagash's presence in the world eliminates their need. I think it also has something to with it being fair for VC and TK because the other armies can now take undeath and it wouldn't make sense for undead models to follow different rules for different armies.
On pg. 18 - 19 The two pages are under the heading " The Undead Legions". It specifically states that these rules are used by Undead Legions and ignore the rules in the TK & VC army books. On the bottom of page 18 it has a paragraph that is the same format as the one you are referencing and refers to how nehekharan undead and undead are all now just undead in an Undead Legion army. So, each other these rules listed are for Undead Legions. No where does it say these rules replace those for the parent army books. Then when you get to pg. 19's paragraph (the one you are speaking of) it is speaking of the absence of the rule and why in the Undead Legion. It doesn't say anything about changing the TK and VC books. It only states that "However, under Nagash's influence, the undead no longer require the constant incantations of a lesser wizard to sustain them in the mortal world. As a result, all rules pertaining to The Generals of Undeath or The Hierophant are no longer required."

So, this statement doesn't actually change the army books and the only way to get these changes to your army is to play the Undead Legions.

With that said, by 9th edition when Tomb Kings and Vampire Counts are eventually revised we are going to either see an united Undead Legions army book or separate army books for TK and VC that can ally with each other, and thus be like Undead Legions. These new books will likely have changes to them. All of us know it, and that is likely why it feels these are errata. But right now, they are just the rules that the Undead Legion army follows.
 
On pg. 18 - 19 The two pages are under the heading " The Undead Legions". It specifically states that these rules are used by Undead Legions and ignore the rules in the TK & VC army books. On the bottom of page 18 it has a paragraph that is the same format as the one you are referencing and refers to how nehekharan undead and undead are all now just undead in an Undead Legion army. So, each other these rules listed are for Undead Legions. No where does it say these rules replace those for the parent army books. Then when you get to pg. 19's paragraph (the one you are speaking of) it is speaking of the absence of the rule and why in the Undead Legion. It doesn't say anything about changing the TK and VC books. It only states that "However, under Nagash's influence, the undead no longer require the constant incantations of a lesser wizard to sustain them in the mortal world. As a result, all rules pertaining to The Generals of Undeath or The Hierophant are no longer required."

So, this statement doesn't actually change the army books and the only way to get these changes to your army is to play the Undead Legions.

With that said, by 9th edition when Tomb Kings and Vampire Counts are eventually revised we are going to either see an united Undead Legions army book or separate army books for TK and VC that can ally with each other, and thus be like Undead Legions. These new books will likely have changes to them. All of us know it, and that is likely why it feels these are errata. But right now, they are just the rules that the Undead Legion army follows.
So it is on page 18. But says that "Generals of Death and Heirophant rules no longer apply" not "do not apply to Undead Legions."
 
So it is on page 18. But says that "Generals of Death and Heirophant rules no longer apply" not "do not apply to Undead Legions."
That's because they list all the other rules from both books, have made alterations to each and then are letting people know that those rules are absent intentional from undead legion.

What GW did was release an army list that references two army books. They didn't put out errata to those army books. If you picked up vampire counts or tomb kings, you would run them as is out of the book. Undead legion doesn't change those books, it pulls in their units and then uses its own special rules.
 
It is abit odd and nonsenical.
Undeadlegion gets manny without crumble
vc gets manny but still crumbles.
Isnt nagash preventing all unstables from their crumblingfate?

in my large meta, no one wants to play end times.
Every single one thinks the rules are shite, especially the 50% lords and heroes. They refuse End times as being an official update to the rules and rather continue playing tradiional 8th ed.
 
It is abit odd and nonsenical.
Undeadlegion gets manny without crumble
vc gets manny but still crumbles.
Isnt nagash preventing all unstables from their crumblingfate?

in my large meta, no one wants to play end times.
Every single one thinks the rules are shite, especially the 50% lords and heroes. They refuse End times as being an official update to the rules and rather continue playing tradiional 8th ed.
Undead under Nagash's command within his forces aren't suffering unstable.

As for the end times rules, it's pretty minor from what I've seen. You still have to take 25% core. So, you sacrifice special and rare units for extra heroes and lords? That really weakens an army in most cases. What end times does is leave all previous builds legal, but also allows armies with fewer models who have a cool lord and some core to be legal too. End times bridges new and old players fairly decent
 
Im not complaining. i find it cool as well.
But theres 1 guy especially that refuses End times in any way.
claiming its a recipe for unbalanced lists and herohammer.
2 frostphoenixes + 2 wizard on frostphoenixes, 3 deminprinces, 3 deathhags on 3 cauldrons.
 
Assuming you are using a VL with Forbidden Lore...

Lore of Beasts-Savage Beast cast on a wraithwall...prepare for glory

Lore of Metal-Can be devastating against Empire/WoC heavy meta when backed up by a Casket for more dice.

Lore of Light-I include this because having a VL with it is far better than a Tomb King caster who cannot fight. Worth considering in a meta full of other undead players.
 
Im not complaining. i find it cool as well.
But theres 1 guy especially that refuses End times in any way.
claiming its a recipe for unbalanced lists and herohammer.
2 frostphoenixes + 2 wizard on frostphoenixes, 3 deminprinces, 3 deathhags on 3 cauldrons.

Some folks, you just can't reach.
 
Im not complaining. i find it cool as well.
But theres 1 guy especially that refuses End times in any way.
claiming its a recipe for unbalanced lists and herohammer.
2 frostphoenixes + 2 wizard on frostphoenixes, 3 deminprinces, 3 deathhags on 3 cauldrons.
Steadfast, step up, Static CR, always wound on 6 and horde all > hero hammer. Tell him to proxy and try it before he denounces it.
 
Back to the topic at hand... my earlier post was motivated by the fact that spending more points to access these lores in my mind costs efficiency. You pay more for the access and is this better value over a blender lord or similar build using LoV? Is it better than a cheapo necromancer lvl.4 if you don't want to spend that many points on a vamp to start with? I can't really see either being the case.
 
I dont think 25 points is really that much of an investment to use lores that no one expects.
You get a big element of surprise and a VC opponent that works in a different way.
And what does it cost your blender? quickblood? i can live without quickblood.
I think being able to carry 4 lore of beasts spells is awesome. its a devastating lore
 
Most of the spells in Beasts would be useful in some way, especially if you've got your Heirotitan giving you +d3 to casting total, allowing you to have a shot at the beefed up spells more reliably. Boosted Amber spear going to hurt elite units. Savage Beast of Horros would be sickening on your Blender Lord, +3 attacks, +3 strength... Wyssan's is going to help any unit out.
 
And what does it cost your blender? quickblood? i can live without quickblood.
I have to disagree. If anything I think quickblood is the most important addon for a blender lord. When you pay that many points to do damage in CC, missing with 1/3 of your attacks simply is not acceptable. You need those rerolls.
 
I have to disagree. If anything I think quickblood is the most important addon for a blender lord. When you pay that many points to do damage in CC, missing with 1/3 of your attacks simply is not acceptable. You need those rerolls.
You can get the rerolls from Van Hel's. Another option is take the SGK, give him forbbiden lore and take the beast's signature. He'd have rerolls. Can take red fury too. Then use life of vampires on your other casters.
 
Book of Arkhan is the simple solution to that.
Lately i have played with vamplord with GW and Quickblood, which means no rerolls unless i have VDM. True, it sucks when you dont get rerolls since the maximizing of hits can easily go wrong with a bad/mediocre diceroll, but i am far from disappointed by it.
Therefor carrying a Sword of Might with Lore of Beasts and Book of Arkhan can be even more terrifying. If you hit both spells (which can be done) you suddenly have a S7/T6 vamplord with rerolls to hit. Plus the entire unit he is in has +1S/+1T and rerolls as well.
Quickblood can then become less relevant or at least non-mandatory (which it isnt anyway). Just put some other vamp next to him with Nightshroud and you have a perfectly defended and most likely awesome damage output in one unit with a sick combination.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu