Search results

I agree with najo here. The miscast table needs to be more nasty. Way to often people get that one uber spell and just keep 6 dicing it with little care of the consequences. I like the idea based on the number of dice you throw.

Actually I believe that najo is wrong on his break down. A spell is not considered successfully till the enemy attempts to dispel or does not wish too. If you look on pg 32 under casting value, 3 paragraph. " If the casting value result equals or exceeds the spell's casting value,THE SPELL IS...

But what rule is there that you think that allows you to attack into a challenge though? Not opinions, rules. It is pretty specific that no CC attacks, which impact hits are, can be directed into a challenge. Does it make sense that a chariot crashing into a dude fighting another dude and...

Nothing rules wise is ever settled in a White Dwarf battle report. Those things are so full of mistakes and rules breakage it isn't even funny. Correct. And at this point the rest is mote. You have answered the question right here in the rules! But still you continue with "opinions" not...

And your Ork buddy is correct. Manglers and fanatics only cause hits on units they pass through. There is no randomizing hits between units in CC.

Well I don't plan on opening this can of worms again Skittz. We will have to just disagree on the whole impact hits and challenges. We already went a couple rounds on this topic before. Just like all of a sudden the chariot hitting only characters and then distributing the hits the all the...

If there are less than 5 R&F then you would distribute the hits as you see fit allocating them one at a time till all hits have been given out. You have to give each model 1 hit before giving someone a 2nd. Impact hits cannot hit characters in a challenge as they are CC attacks.

Mad'At is correct. Even if the chariot is touching just character/characters the hits are distributed as shooting into the unit. I have had this happen often when playing Ogres and running a character meat shield in the front row.

Actually you are wrong here. All attacks at the same Int would strike at the same time. The character has to allocate his attacks and so does his unit if they are the same Int. He can't attack, kill a character so that r&f step up and the unit can attack them. You can slow roll all the dice you...

Unfortunately there is no exception in our rules that would state otherwise so we are stuck with the BrB ruling.

You do realize that the lore you get is random. So are the spells. So a 1 in 8 chance to get life. But going on the premise that you did get let's go over the spells. The Sig spell gives you a 5+ regen but only in the wizards unit. Not really helpful if your guy is not in a combat unit. And if...

And did he show you where in the BrB it states he can target him? Bet he can't cause it's not in there. Only command model that you can "target" is the champion.

Actually the rules state that a character on a chariot has the troop type chariot. First paragraph under Chariot mount. A chariot mount otherwise followers all the "rules" for ridden monsters.

I think the way crumble is now is terrible. If they made steadfast helpful so if we lost combat and were steadfast we would crumble over what the units LD was. And make it so that characters didn't crumble. I mean a VC Lord has been around for 500 years and all of a sudden falls to pieces cause...

If the character dies the chariot is still there and does not need to take a monster reaction test. If the chariot is destroyed the character is hoofing it for the rest of the game.

Up to the limit of 10. It would help though if someone got a LD spell off lowering your Generals LD. Then the banner would help out by raising by 1.

No. Stats cap at 10. Would be nice though.....

You are correct Sir........

Mad'At is correct. Using your example of calvary being 2 profiles you still can't attack the horse. You have to attack the rider. same thing here. Using the riders saves for the whole model. Which is now MC.

You are correct here.