How much better is VDM than HV?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

ATP485

Ghoul
Nov 12, 2011
178
Glasgow
Zombies
131
I was curious about the interaction between poison and re-rolls to hit and wound. I was under the impression that there were some instances where re-rolls to wound would be better on ghouls than re-rolls to hit, so I went about trying to figure it out. Fortunately I had written a script that calculates combat results and accounts for both types of re-rolls. Here is what I came up with.

Assumptions:

1) My math is correct (There may well be errors in the script. If you spot errors let me know and I will correct them. Thanks.)
2) 40 attacks coming from the ghouls in each instance (if we calculated 100,000 attacks, the percentage of total attacks table may vary by up to 1% in each instance. This would be more accurate and better reflect the difference between different WS and T characteristics. However 40 attacks is a better reflection of actual gaming scenarios)
4) Average results
3) No saves of any kind.

The first two tables below show the number of wounds you will do as a percentage of the total number of attacks. The first table shows data for Van Hels, the second table shows Hellish Vigour. These percentages should stay relatively similar (up to 1% variance) regardless of the number of attacks that you actually have.

For example if you have 1 attack, or 40 attacks against a WS10 T10 model then your total wounds will be 32.5% of your total attacks with VDM and 22.5% of your total attacks with HV.

The final table at the bottom quantifies how much better VDM is compared with HV in terms of the percentage of extra wounds you will do with VDM versus HV.

RhDRtRE.webp


Conclusions:

1) I was wrong!

2) Vanhel's Dance Macabre is always worth casting if you have the choice between it and Hellish Vigour.

3) Vanhel's excels against all low toughness models, or high toughness models with high weapon skill.

4) There is no difference between both spells versus equal or higher toughness, low weapon skill models. So if your opponent dispels your VDM, you know HV will give you the same effect if your opponent is likely to fail his fear check.
 

Attachments

  • eeCC0Ik.webp
    eeCC0Ik.webp
    42.5 KB · Views: 153
Last edited:
I'm probably way of here. :)
Is poison taken into account?

If you have 40 ghoul attacks with Vanhel's and you attack an opponent with WS3 T 3 shouldn't the numbers be like this?
4+ to hit and 4+ to wound.

20 attacks hit where 3.333 are poison, 20 miss.
20 misses get rerolled and get 10 more hits which 1.666 are poison.
25 total hits where 50% wound so we end up with 12,5 wounds.
Then adding the poisoned attacks we end up with about 17.5 wounds total.
 
I'm probably way of here. :)
Is poison taken into account?
If you have 40 ghoul attacks with Vanhel's and you attack an opponent with WS3 T 3 shouldn't the numbers be like this?
4+ to hit and 4+ to wound.
20 attacks hit where 3.333 6.666 are poison, 13.3333 are either 4 or 5, 20 miss (either 1,2 or 3).
20 misses get rerolled and get 10 more hits which 1.6663.333 are poison, 6.666 are either 4 or 5. 10 miss.
19.999 total hits where 50% wound so we end up with 10 wounds.
Then adding the poisoned attacks we end up with about 19.999 wounds total.

If you have 60 attacks, 10 will be poison. If you have 40 attacks, 6.666 will be poison. If you have 20 hits from 40 attacks, 6.666 will be a 4, 6.666 a 5 and 6.666 a 6 etc

Your poison calcs were off :tongue:
 
Last edited:
Great math thanks for doing all this work!xD Another plus towards vanhels dance is it is cheaper to cast and gives you free moves. I don't think anyone should ever cast hellish vigor on ghouls unless of course they got both off... :devil2:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu