Why the hate for the new Franz?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Sep 14, 2011
130
Zombies
90
There seem to be a lot of moaning about the new Karl Franz rules over on warseer and most of it seems to be coming from us VC /UL players. I see no problem what so ever as we have some serious OP stuff now aswell. Like Nagash being able to raise a whole army / Mannfred with his ungodly amount of power dice he can get and not crumbling when our general dies.
 
Most of the moaning I've seen is from Chaos players who are peeved that the new book is called "Glottkin" yet Karl Franz Ascended has stolen all the limelight. Glottkin's I1 is a massive achilles heel whilst Karl Franz is a combat machine.

Comparisons with Nagash are interesting, yes Nagash can summon loads of stuff but KFA just flies over all of that en route to show Nagash what his intestines look like.

I think they should have saved KFA for a separate Kingdoms of Men end times book.
 
I agree. My problem is less with franz himself, and more that it feels too early for him to be taking center stage like this, and I certainly feel for Chaos players and Nurgle fans - glotkin didn't even make it out of his own book before being completely overshadowed.

As an undead fan, I'm not too worried. If I ever run a monster mash between naggy and franz, well, he's on a big base, so as long as nagash stays close to his screens you shouldn't get charged unexpectedly. He's intimidating, for sure, but I don't feel we got the short end of the stick with Nagash.

If anything Glotkin are too weak. The way their offensive stats panned out in this combined statline gimmick really didn't work well for them, while franz made out like a bandit - his griffin even gets to swing his hammer, unlike with our mortarchs. I think it's mostly just more indication that the combined statline thing should be done more like cav, chariots, and the like - combined defensive stats, but separate offensive profiles.

Between the lackluster Glotkin and the too-soon appearance of Super-Franz, the narrative balance of the second End Times book is just seems off. The rules fail to capture what should be an apocalyptic tone in the face of an unstoppable tide of chaos when the most mechanically awe inspiring figure present is the leader of team good guys.
 
It makes no sense whatsoever for KF to re-appear at this point, since the narrative events of Glottkin actually occur at the same time as the events in Nagash. So KF is barely even "dead" at this point then WOOMF there he is in on his supergriff all shiny and new.
 
Nagash and KF seem like they would do a number on each other in CC. I think the big problem with KF is that he is probably the toughest character in the game right now with the ability to go where he likes and stomp anything he comes across. This means that most armies simply can't deal with him at all - I don't think UL/VC are alone in this regard. Even HE can't do much against him even with a big unit with BotWD.

Having said this, he is badass! I also see this combined profile being the way forward for GW. It is cinematic (their new buzzword it seems) and fun and simplifies the rules for ridden monsters massively. Just wait till VC get combo profiles with Zombie dragons, etc then KF will have something to fear!
 
I like the rules of Monstruous Cav, and all ridden Monsters should be like that (but with Thunderstomp!)

Anyways, I just like it that they say: Ghal Maraz is unique! it represents the right to rule the empire! But if you spend some time caressing it, it's power becomes bound to your fists and your ass, so that whatever you sit on is also empowered!


Fluff ... FTL D:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Seneschal
I can't seem to find stats or rules anywhere obvious.. Could anyone provide a link?
 
Thank you based Bullhax.

I am really curious to see the justification for how he got that strong, and why he suddenly has the power of Thor. I hope more order factions get champions like this.

Regarding the timeline it seems six months have passed since he vanished. Or something like that.
 
Chaos invades the empire... You think Sigmar will just let that happen? I think people underestimate the power of the Mankind. I love seeing Karl Franz curbstomp all these evil races. I friggin' love his new rules.

Of course he is stronger than some weird blob of pestilence that they just invented... this is the gawddamn Emprah! :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: Adam_Barrow
I'm not opposed to his strength, I just think narratively it's a book or two early for him to be showing up like this. Let him headline the book of the forces of order rallying to fight back, don't have him curbstomping chaos left and right before their incursion has even properly begun!
 
Lets read the fluff and see how it all works out before writing him off story wise! Rules wise he is a beast but I expect this to be the trend and things to even out eventually.
 
He's absurd, and amazing against multiwound models like basically all the big badguys. I played Glottkin off against him in the store. 1 and a half rounds of combat Glottkin lasted. After the end of the first round of combat Glottkin was on 3 wounds left and Franz had only lost 2. And that was including a magic phase, and Glottkin got the charge so including impact hits.
 
From a fluff perspective I think I can see where they're going with Karl Franz. Once the endtimes are done the timeline will jump ahead a few centuries, Franz reconquered and expanded the empire so it it now encompasses most of the old world and since his death a new church of the emperor has sprung up and the now massive empire has ground to a halt under massive bureaucracy. Making fantasy and 40k have similar fluff feels like something gw would do to try attracting 40k players to make the jump across. Just my thoughts on the matter.
 
He's got magic spell already built in, Lord of Lightning, D6 hits, then 4+ another D6 then 5+ another D6.
 
Once the endtimes are done the timeline will jump ahead a few centuries.

I just do not see this happening. What you're describing would make the big kit special characters basically limited run things. Nagash, the Glotkin, whatever comes later - they have to be planning on selling those things for years. There will be no centuries forward time skip that would render those characters redundant.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Banat
Nagash and the Mortarchs are immortal, potentially the Glotkin are too or just long living depending on the whims of the gods. If we get a massive kit that isn't undead, demonic or elven; the three that can potentially still be around a long time later then we'll know for sure. It could be only a decades jump ahead, enough that a new comfortable status quo emerges for them to continue the game with. My only hope is that the whole end times isn't just wiped from canon.
 
I'm assuming they won't resolve the story at all. ET2 being contemporaneous with ET1 made me fear 4 books of setup, then 9th starts and the fluff we have is the cliffhanger ET4 leaves us at. One minute to midnight, Who Demons the Demonmaker?, et cetera.
 
He's got magic spell already built in, Lord of Lightning, D6 hits, then 4+ another D6 then 5+ another D6.
That won't help him dispelling though. Having little to no dispelling going up against a level 4 is rather risky. The killing power of KFA will diminish if he's hexed and/or going up against a heavily augmented unit.

I don't think they will resolve the story either book 3 will be elves if rumours are true we have hear only a little and still need fluff from the month covered in the 1st and 2nd book.. Maybe the 4th book will push it somewhat further but a grand finally is not something I expect.!

EDIT:
Just mathhammered KFA against a blender Lord, Nurgle DP and Glottkin and without heavy magic backup the forces of evil are screwed..! 10 WS7 attacks with auto wound doing a minimum of 2 wounds with no armour saves allowed is sooo crazy.. A tzeentch Lord with ToP and mark plus reroll 1 power is a best guess. And for VC a lot of forced rerolls to hit and a ward.
 
Last edited:
I'm assuming they won't resolve the story at all.

This is what I expect. The final part of the series will end with Archaon unleashing the full power of his incursion, personally leading his armies into the old world, and then all of 9th edition will be the total war that follows.
 
This is what I expect. The final part of the series will end with Archaon unleashing the full power of his incursion, personally leading his armies into the old world, and then all of 9th edition will be the total war that follows.
If that is what happens I totally fine with it.. As long as the story gets pushed forward, even just a little.. Going back to square one half a year after the end times started in a 9th ed would really blow too. Rather a slow but stready pace than frog leap fluff and back to where we started.. Or very close to anyway.!
 
This makes sense. If all the End Times books are concurrent with each other and finish at about the same time, at the end of Glottkin, a massive fleet of "wolf ships" has been spotted heading towards Altdorf; ARCHAON IS COMING.

The more I think about it the more that Autowound/Ignores armour saves is annoying me. Just so rediculously OP. D3+1 wounds per wound on top of that is disgusting, even if he is 810pts...

In the actual book his Ascended Form is a huge Deus Ex Machina. No explanation given and its literally around for about a minute (and he isn't on DeathClaw, he's just on foot).
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu