How 9th could be AWESOME!

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I wanted a reason to start an art project so I went to the local GW (which is disturbingly sad in NYC by the way) and I was torn between VC and Necrons. I chose Necrons. My first year I assembled and painted a beautiful Necron army and got into 40k.

Despite how gorgeous the models are in 40k, I simply did not have fun. The "walk 4 inches, shoot 100 dice" play style bored me to tears. Setting up these imaginary objectives and trying to stand near them sucks. I bought a stupid Doom Scythe because I was told I need one to win games. Once game I won because at the end of my turn I flew it into my opponents deployment zone which gave me a "point". This style of points and objectives and shooting 100+ dice per turn is simply not fun for me. From what I hear its Eldar vs everyone else as well, the balance is even worse than WHFB. The lore is uninteresting to me as well, nothing that really excites me. The space marines are absolutely the worst. I played the video game "Space Marine" through to the end and it really hammered it in for me how much I simply don't enjoy the world of 40k.

After turning my back on tabletop altogether I painted a cool knight model I randomly bought and for some reason - it just felt right. I decided to suck it up and buy some cool skeletons and Isabella and see where it takes me. I started reading 8th edition and I got really excited - the rule system felt a lot more like an attempt to recreate the flow of a real battle than a mathematical rule system. I found this message board (the best of any WHFB board I've found so far). The people here were really helpful and got me excited to try different units and builds. I love the lore and have read a lot of army books, the BSB lore and I'm reading a lot of the End Times. I found a local hardcore group of WHFB players and made some new friends. I have been hooked ever since and now have 3 full armies.

My point is, 40k and fantasy are two very different realms. I haven't tried 7th yet (Necrons are a race devoid of Psychers...) but I doubt I'll be interested. Even with the new Necron Codex I have no plans to even get more models. Frankly I'm scarred by my experience. It seems to me that 40k is fueled by a million teenagers that beg their parents to buy them a codex and a few boxes. WHFB players generally seem older & wiser as well as more friendly and dedicated to the game. There's always a bunch of tweens playing 40k when I go to GW.

So what is going to happen with WHFB now?

First off all you have to consider that Magic Cards are very different. It probably takes the average hobbyist a year to buy, assemble and fully paint a 2500 point WHFB army. You can put together a Magic tournament deck in a day. You can release and discontinue a model but the rules will have be somewhere for years to come. Even so, this is idiotic IMO. I went to the GW website at 2PM last Friday and the Skaven dice were already sold out. Limited Edition is a great way to say "we don't want your money anymore". This is not what GW needs right now, they need money for WHFB. With each new release last year, the (non limited) models got hot and were sold out every other day. Why decide to discontinue a model after a certain number and just end your profits?

You can see whats happening with End Times. Basically its downsizing in the coolest way ever. Unpopular models are getting absorbed and cut. If you are still a Kislev player, that means your time is over. If you play a popular faction of WHFB, I highly doubt your models will get discontinued. Probably the bottom half of the unpopular models will be cut, so we'll all lose a few models, but in turn there will be a lot of new models, and with 6 armies, less exclusive to one group.

Speaking of the "6 armies" thing, I think that is a misinterpretation of the old rumors of combined books. I think going forward there will be 6 big army books, including a few different armies with combined factions in between (Just like End Times: Khaine).

The End Times itself is exactly what were talking about. Every few weeks were getting completely new rules sets to experiment with. Undeath lore, scenarios with caves and city fighting, Kaine Magic. Has this stopped us from enjoying the game or got us all more excited about Warhammer?

Regarding round bases, the evidence is piling up. WHFB is one of the only ones still using square bases. Unfortunately these blocky bases clash with varied terrain types. This means that with round-base games, you can make much more varied and interesting terrain boards. I think that they are simply moving more toward this, with skirmishers war machines, monsters, etc on round bases. Maybe there will be round bases for infantry as well, but I'm sure they will still rank up as normal.

Does this mean that WHFB is moving to a skirmish game? Not likely. There are other skirmish games out there if you want to play. If this was truly the case, Mordheim would be much more popular - but it mostly died out. WHFB is a game of epic all out fantasy warfare and I doubt they want to mess with that core concept. A tie in with 40k however, seems more likely. In fact, Araloth supposedly goes to another dimension and meets a space marine in Khaine. The idea of dimensional rifts or "bubbles" suggests that the entire world is moving into the types of scenarios where 40k has collided with WHFB in past lore. At that point, it wouldn't be all that strange If some Skaven collided with some Eldar and a battle ensued. I'd love a way to take out my Nercons and have some fun again. Hopefully with WHFB rules ... or will we be forced to play 40k with WHFB models? Maybe even a new third game (skirmish game?). Bringing 40k and WHFB players together would be brilliant. However, wood elves shooting at marines in power armor doesn't seem like it will be very effective...

I have high hopes for 9th edition. I know they will do a great job, and while it might be a big shakeup, I don't think it will effect most of us as much as we are afraid of. I think it will be much of the same as it has always been - beautiful models, fun lore and new rules to put our models on the table and play epic fantasy battles with.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Emicrania
I wanted a reason to start an art project so I went to the local GW (which is disturbingly sad in NYC by the way) and I was torn between VC and Necrons. I chose Necrons. My first year I assembled and painted a beautiful Necron army and got into 40k.

Despite how gorgeous the models are in 40k, I simply did not have fun. The "walk 4 inches, shoot 100 dice" play style bored me to tears. Setting up these imaginary objectives and trying to stand near them sucks. I bought a stupid Doom Scythe because I was told I need one to win games. Once game I won because at the end of my turn I flew it into my opponents deployment zone which gave me a "point". This style of points and objectives and shooting 100+ dice per turn is simply not fun for me. From what I hear its Eldar vs everyone else as well, the balance is even worse than WHFB. The lore is uninteresting to me as well, nothing that really excites me. The space marines are absolutely the worst. I played the video game "Space Marine" through to the end and it really hammered it in for me how much I simply don't enjoy the world of 40k.

After turning my back on tabletop altogether I painted a cool knight model I randomly bought and for some reason - it just felt right. I decided to suck it up and buy some cool skeletons and Isabella and see where it takes me. I started reading 8th edition and I got really excited - the rule system felt a lot more like an attempt to recreate the flow of a real battle than a mathematical rule system. I found this message board (the best of any WHFB board I've found so far). The people here were really helpful and got me excited to try different units and builds. I love the lore and have read a lot of army books, the BSB lore and I'm reading a lot of the End Times. I found a local hardcore group of WHFB players and made some new friends. I have been hooked ever since and now have 3 full armies.

My point is, 40k and fantasy are two very different realms. I haven't tried 7th yet (Necrons are a race devoid of Psychers...) but I doubt I'll be interested. Even with the new Necron Codex I have no plans to even get more models. Frankly I'm scarred by my experience. It seems to me that 40k is fueled by a million teenagers that beg their parents to buy them a codex and a few boxes. WHFB players generally seem older & wiser as well as more friendly and dedicated to the game. There's always a bunch of tweens playing 40k when I go to GW.

So what is going to happen with WHFB now?

First off all you have to consider that Magic Cards are very different. It probably takes the average hobbyist a year to buy, assemble and fully paint a 2500 point WHFB army. You can put together a Magic tournament deck in a day. You can release and discontinue a model but the rules will have be somewhere for years to come. Even so, this is idiotic IMO. I went to the GW website at 2PM last Friday and the Skaven dice were already sold out. Limited Edition is a great way to say "we don't want your money anymore". This is not what GW needs right now, they need money for WHFB. With each new release last year, the (non limited) models got hot and were sold out every other day. Why decide to discontinue a model after a certain number and just end your profits?

You can see whats happening with End Times. Basically its downsizing in the coolest way ever. Unpopular models are getting absorbed and cut. If you are still a Kislev player, that means your time is over. If you play a popular faction of WHFB, I highly doubt your models will get discontinued. Probably the bottom half of the unpopular models will be cut, so we'll all lose a few models, but in turn there will be a lot of new models, and with 6 armies, less exclusive to one group.

Speaking of the "6 armies" thing, I think that is a misinterpretation of the old rumors of combined books. I think going forward there will be 6 big army books, including a few different armies with combined factions in between (Just like End Times: Khaine).

The End Times itself is exactly what were talking about. Every few weeks were getting completely new rules sets to experiment with. Undeath lore, scenarios with caves and city fighting, Kaine Magic. Has this stopped us from enjoying the game or got us all more excited about Warhammer?

Regarding round bases, the evidence is piling up. WHFB is one of the only ones still using square bases. Unfortunately these blocky bases clash with varied terrain types. This means that with round-base games, you can make much more varied and interesting terrain boards. I think that they are simply moving more toward this, with skirmishers war machines, monsters, etc on round bases. Maybe there will be round bases for infantry as well, but I'm sure they will still rank up as normal.

Does this mean that WHFB is moving to a skirmish game? Not likely. There are other skirmish games out there if you want to play. If this was truly the case, Mordheim would be much more popular - but it mostly died out. WHFB is a game of epic all out fantasy warfare and I doubt they want to mess with that core concept. A tie in with 40k however, seems more likely. In fact, Araloth supposedly goes to another dimension and meets a space marine in Khaine. The idea of dimensional rifts or "bubbles" suggests that the entire world is moving into the types of scenarios where 40k has collided with WHFB in past lore. At that point, it wouldn't be all that strange If some Skaven collided with some Eldar and a battle ensued. I'd love a way to take out my Nercons and have some fun again. Hopefully with WHFB rules ... or will we be forced to play 40k with WHFB models? Maybe even a new third game (skirmish game?). Bringing 40k and WHFB players together would be brilliant. However, wood elves shooting at marines in power armor doesn't seem like it will be very effective...

I have high hopes for 9th edition. I know they will do a great job, and while it might be a big shakeup, I don't think it will effect most of us as much as we are afraid of. I think it will be much of the same as it has always been - beautiful models, fun lore and new rules to put our models on the table and play epic fantasy battles with.


I agree almost with everything.
However IMO round bases is an horrible idea, bubblehammer makes me wanna cry and a skirmish idea of warhammer Is simply not happening: Mordehnaim (I always misspell it), has been out there for long time.
I do have some hope for the 9th. And I do hope the scale down the game a bit. We need new players and I like to start new armies.
My dream is an apocalypse version of fantasy AND a smaller,faster version of the 8th edition.
Just please stop to fuck up the fluff!!!!!!
 
Meh as long as I can still play some version 8ish edition of fantasy with my VC I don't really care if they add in a skirmish game. Would like to see magic slowly scaled up with larger games rather than normal, normal, normal STORM OF MAGIC.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu