What would you like to see in 9th

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I play Warhammer Fantasy for a reason. I do not want to see Fantasy "Spess Mareens..."
I do not care all that much for Sci-Fi. I'll maybe watch a movie on the genre but that's it. I enjoy medieval fantasy.

GW has it in their heads that altering the lore of the game so it is borderline sci-fi is a good idea but it will turn people off faster than you can say, "Wil Wheaton."

<snip>

Should such a thing not occur, and if 8th edition armies are so outdated that they feel like you are playing Dogs of War, then this guy is out of the hobby. Playing a game from the older edition won't be an option for me as I want to attend competitive events. Pickup games with your friends get old if they mostly play for fun and don't have an interest in tournaments.


Welcome to my World Seneschal. That's how I have been feeling too. One question...why the hate for Wil? ;) We joke but this shit really isn't funny. :swear: Damn you GW! :thumbsdown:
 
We still have no clue to what extent these rumors will go. We can probably count on losing some of the generic elements and ending up with more units like Blightkings, Morghasts and Stormfiends, but if done in proper balance that won't be bad. Fantasy doesn't have to be generic. One of the main issues is few players want overly historical/generic fantasy looking models. All the new wood elf models they made with the new army book were headed into being unique to warhammer and they are awesome!
 
If it's as you said with the Lizardmen Najo then that's fine by me, I just don't think it will go that way since we have things like the soul grinder, skull cannon, blood throne, skaven marines etc.

Yorga, you're in Cali, right? You might have a better chance of finding eighth edition events around there than other people.

I want to be optimistic about ninth and it's not all carved in stone so I'm not stressing about it, I'm just thinking ahead in case certain scenarios occur.

Maybe I'll give the skirmish game a shot if what I said does come to pass and events with big armies go the way of the Dodo. I'll have to wait and see. In the meantime, I'll clear my head of any worries that pop in and focus on enjoying eighth and teaching some young elven whippersnappers that it's not nice to go digging into a mummy's tomb...
 
  • Like
Reactions: najo
I would personally like to see:
-Changes to steadfast
-ASF not being so ridiculous OR Elves not getting re-rolls from ASF
-Characters on large mounts being less of a liability
-Attempting to cast the huge nuke spells should be higher risk
-Line of sight rules should be more streamlined and based on unit type

Used to be that charging always meant you fought first. The designers, in their infinite wisdom, decided to remove that in favour of always striking at your initiative step.

They missed a trick. They should have introduced a raft of modifiers to initiative instead of something either granting ASF or imposing ASL. Great Weapons could be -2 Initiative. Charging lances could be +2 initiative. Stationary spears could be +1 initiative in the first round, etc.

Apart from that the biggest problem with this edition is that disrupted units remain steadfast. Disrupted units should not be steadfast.

What I like to see:
-Small buff to cavalry, asf on the charge sounds great
-Turn cannons into cannons again, instead of giant laser-guided sniper rifles

Most importantly for me: leave Blood Knights as a unit of some description. Not all of us became skulcrushers.

Also, I am very happy with the upcoming change, may we live in interesting times indeed.


I sometimes feel like I'm playing an entirely different game than other people.

Perhaps it's just because I play in a rather savage all-tournaments-all-the-time gaming club, but I pretty much never see infantry unless it's an army with no other choice (Vampires, orcs, skaven, lizardmen, beastmen), carrying the Banner of the World Dragon, or specifically required/rewarded by a tournament pack.

Outside of skirmishers, the only real purpose that infantry has is tarpiting. For everything else they're too slow, too cumbersome, and bleed too much CR. Take away steadfast and you ruin their ability to fulfill their one purpose.

As for cavalry, I quite honestly have no idea where people get that they need any sort of buff. ALL I see competitive players putting onto the table is cav buses. Not for the cav themselves, mind you, but because they're a mobile bunker for hitty and durable characters and don't bleed wounds easily. Let disruption break steadfast and then cavalry will dominate even more than they do already.


If anything, what needs a buff is INFANTRY! Spears should definitely have some sort of anti-cav benefit. ASF and +1S in the very least, if charged and attacking in the front. Would give an actual reason to do big phalanxes of spearmen.

Also as much as I hate cannons, I fear what would happen if they were to get nerfed in any way. Monsters are only BARELY contained by them, and already there are so many monsters that still dominate the meta. Frost phoenixes, demon princes, HPAs and chimeras. K'daii destroyers. Nerf cannons and they'll run even more rampant.

What DOES need to happen is to nerf cannons in their ability to snipe characters out of units. I'm a big fan of place token, scatter d6-BS, overshoot/bounce as normal. Wouldn't affect most artillery overmuch against monsters with their larger bases, but WOULD make it harder to hit a 20mm infantry model than a 100mm zombie dragon. Would also reduce the gamey defense of deploying monsters sideways, which I've always found to be ridiculous, by making it better to have a narrow front (as...you know...makes sense).
 
Maybe I'll give the skirmish game a shot if what I said does come to pass and events with big armies go the way of the Dodo. I'll have to wait and see. In the meantime, I'll clear my head of any worries that pop in and focus on enjoying eighth and teaching some young elven whippersnappers that it's not nice to go digging into a mummy's tomb...

I will bet good money that 9th will not invalidate the current mass-battle style of play. If a skirmish game is introduced, it will be ancillary to the main game. I wouldn't be surprised if we see more skirmish-based UNITS (a la the stormfiends), but I would be absolutely shocked if GW goes through with the rumoured "make everything everyone knows about WHFB obselete." It's just absolutely ludicrous from a business perspective, especially given how much they've been pouring into WHFB with the End Times.
 
See, IMO this whole last edition was all about buffing Infantry. Hordes, supporting attacks, stepping up, steadfast, swift reform, striking in Initiative order. Infantry got a huge boost this edition. Even the 2d6 charge mechanic favors infantry more than cavalry. Infantry got so boosted, they built in nuke spells to keep deathstars in check. I personally see plenty of competitive infantry armies and in my neck of the woods the only armies really going heavy cavalry are wood elves, dark elves and WoC. Of course some armies can really only do infantry (i.e. skaven and dwarves). But the rest of the armies have solid infantry builds and tactics, as do the three aforementioned armies too. I honestly see Warriors of Chaos as infantry heavy (with a pair of Daemon Princes lol) more often than I see them in their Cav/Chariot builds.

As for cavalry being weak. What tends to happen is cavalry hits hard on the charge, but then loses its potency right away. Unless cavalry can grind it out well, all to often it sits there mired down in one of those infantry tarpits, keeping it from earning its points back all game. Monstrous Cavalry is another matter, its very effective as it grinds better, can stomp and doesn't lose attacks as it suffers wounds (until whole models are removed).

I mainly see infantry dominating the armies at the tournaments too.

So, weird :P
 
Honestly, I think 8th Ed. is a pretty good edition.

Here is what I think 9th Ed. needs to be the most successful edition of Warhammer yet. Keep in mind I'm also doing this with the business in mind and the direction of the company from what I've seen so far.

1. Simplified ruleset, mainly in the movement phase of the game e.g. Kings of War.
2. Reduce barrier of entry for the game to be played e.g. scenarios designed for smaller games, horde units being less effective.
3. Reduction in power for magic spells e.g. Purple Sun, Mindrazor, Dwellers Below.

When you think about it, there's not too much to improve. Stuff like laser cannons and the such while good, is not needed for the game to be successful. Reducing the barrier of entry, having a simpler ruleset (while still maintaining tactical gameplay), and generally making the game more fun, is what is needed.
 
Yorga, you're in Cali, right? You might have a better chance of finding eighth edition events around there than other people.

That is not necessarily true. Where I live we have to travel a minimum of an hour and half to play in any Tournament of size. So if I am not playing with my group then playing in general is a rare event. Especially when my son goes off to college next fall. Of course, if the rumors of 9th are true he won't have a viable army anyhow. o_o
 
I agree with Seneschal about loving WHFB for its epic sized battles and the Medieval Fantasy setting. I don't care too much for sci-fi so all this talk about somehow things being "linked" with 40k is slightly scary

- The ASF for charging cav would be great as I rarely see them at our club.
- spears getting +1 strength against charging cav/monsters AND asf is cool
- I really hope movement rules are not simplified.
- I hope the new rule book has many new scenarios.
 
I personally think this whole obsession with what you call Medieval Fantasy is extremely close minded. Warhammer is full of outlandish things that make it anything but a Medieval Fantasy.

Anyway what I would like to see in 9th edition is changes to steadfast so that it can actually be disrupted.

I would also like to see the removal of nuke spells and less random, less risky magic but for magic to be reliable and stable instead of one extreme or the other.

I would really like to see RPG elements like stat modification for units based on traits, more unique magic items, far less dice rolling and more number-based gameplay (eg S5 - T3 = 2 wounds inflicted) also less limits on magic item and power selection. This way you'd be able to give your units a unique identity and no two units would be the same.

Another overlooked thing is strategy. A battle should always feel like it's part of a campaign and therefore there should be a strategic element such as warlord traits (but not random, preselected in army list) reinforcements, unit upgrades, unit experience, fatigue, fatigue affecting morale and combat performance etc.
I also want to see unbound armies in fantasy.

I also want to see armour save modifiers changed so that S3 can't hurt someone with a 1+ armour save.

I'd really like to see a Flying High type rule introduced.

Another nice addition would be cavalry ASF on charge.

Bring back pikes. Make them available to most armies and make them obliterate cavalry.

More combat formations (column = faster movement, square = balanced, orb = defensive, no flanks, triangle = attack formation especially effective for cavalry etc. Each unit could have a list of available formations too.

Make Nagash a god.
 
Last edited:
Undying scourge: I like most of your ideas but unfortunately they would overcomplicated the game. What you are talking about sounds cool as a campaign.

Yes there are a lot of outlandish things in warhammer, mages, monsters, engines of war etc. But if you read any warhammer novel, in the end, everything is settled on the battlefield blade vs blade.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu