cannon question

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

heldantes

Black Knight
Oct 21, 2013
389
Zombies
293
Hi guys, my brother shot a cannon deliberately at a spirit host knowing that it would bounce over and hit my Terrorgheist who was in combat. Looking at the rules, this seemed legal so that's how we played it, but it was something we thought we'd check.
 
Not entirely sure how this is played by the book, I'll leave that to other players. I know however that things like these are generally frowned upon and that both ETC and Swedish comp has FAQs and guidelines about it. The short answer there is no, the cannon may not be used that way.

SWFAC v4.2.0, page 8 question 4.5:
Q: Can shooting attacks that do not use scatter dice fire in a way that has a chance of hitting friendly models or models in close combat?
A: No, unless hitting friends is only possible due to misfires (such as Doomrocket).

SWFAC v4.2.0 page 33:
7. Cannons Overguessing
Cannons firing perfectly at unseen targets is deemed an unintended result of sloppy writing in the main rulebook and is therefore limited slightly. A cannon may, at most, guess so as to hit any visible part of any unit’s footprint with an initial artillery die roll of 10. The bounce may then hit hidden models. Models partially on hills are considered wholly visible for this purpose. If there is a close combat or a friendly unit blocking this shot, you’re allowed to overguess the minimum needed to clear the units in the way, possibly making it easier to hit hidden models. However, if there are multiple possible lines of fire that would result in the exact same amount of expected maximum damage to visible units, the player must always choose a line that cannot hit any hidden models.

Do note that these are by no means official but they do offer some kind of guidance I believe even in games where ETC or Swedish comp is not used.
 
That is not a legal shot. Cannons cannot be fired in a way that they could hit friendly models or models in combat. So the point on the table that the shot starts has to be more than 20" away from models in combat so that any dice roll on the artillery dice will not hit them.
 
Cannons may not be fired in such a way that they could possibly hit a friendly unit, or any unit engaged in close combat. Not at my book at the moment but it is under the cannon targeting rules.
 
True say, thanks owain_b and LordTobiothan. We were looking under the normal shooting rules at the time for some reason!

It makes me feel even more sorry for dwarfs.
 
Thanks LordTobiothan ;)

I find if you are looking for a rule it's best to look in every section that is applicable to your situation as GW likes to hide then ;)
 
I'm sorry you just have to tell that story, how did a single direwolf take out hammerers?
It was in Triumph and Treachery and basically comes down one poor decision stacked with bad dice rolls. A unit of 3 Direwolves/doom (previously wounded) charged and killed a cannon, then reformed to charge another. the second cannon shot and killed a DW. they charged and I caused 2 wounds but took one. Next turn, last direwolf kills cannon. I then move to the rear of a unit of hammerers that has Grimm Burlikson because the wolf doesn't really have much else to do. The Hammerers were moving to engage the High Elves player's cavalry. Before they get into combat, my lone wolf champion charges across the board and hits the rear coming btb with 3 dwarves. The dwarf player says that doesn't feel like making way with Grimm or issuing a challenge. So I deal 2 wounds making my combat res 5 (1 for charge, 2 for rear, and 2 for wounds). He then fails to wound the DW with his three dwarves. His static CR is 4 (3 extra ranks and a banner) so he loses combat. He is steadfast at LD 10 and fails his break test! I choose to pursue (again, because what else is he going to do?) Dwarf player rolls a 3 for flee and I roll a 9. All hammerers dead and Grimm Burlikson. HE player slays heroic wolf on his turn out of fear. Dwarf player refuses to ever play against Direwolves again and Dwarves (players) are really good at holding and carrying out grudges.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Draykorinee
The sheer unlikelyness of that wolves 2 ws 3 strength 4 attacks both hitting wounding and neither being saved is a number with a stupid amount of zeros after the decimal point.

That's not even counting the break test and flee rolls.
 
And don't forget the dwarves attacks that all missed. Those sorts of dice roles are priceless, I'll never forget the time my friend played a horde of 50 chaos warriors with 3 characters including a bsb against my ogre and I got braingobbler off (forces a panic test) turn one. He let it go off as he had LD10 with reroll, the look on his face when the 1500 points just ran off the board was just unforgettable ;)
 
And don't forget the dwarves attacks that all missed. Those sorts of dice roles are priceless, I'll never forget the time my friend played a horde of 50 chaos warriors with 3 characters including a bsb against my ogre and I got braingobbler off (forces a panic test) turn one. He let it go off as he had LD10 with reroll, the look on his face when the 1500 points just ran off the board was just unforgettable ;)
Once I challenged a Chaos Warrior Sorceror/General with my Doomwolf and the Doomwolf not only won, but killed the general. The rest of the wolves were slaughtered and the champ died to CR, but it was still epic. I have begun naming my wolves of epic stature after the Direwolves from Game of Thrones.

I have Sisters of Battle for 40k and one Sister Superior (sergeant) was my only living model for three turns. She survived multiple Dark Lances and a flame template and then power mauled a tank to death. I ended up naming her during the match as Kerrigan from StarCraft.
The sheer unlikelyness of that wolves 2 ws 3 strength 4 attacks both hitting wounding and neither being saved is a number with a stupid amount of zeros after the decimal point.

That's not even counting the break test and flee rolls.
All of those hammerers could have been saved if Grimm had made way...
 
Once I challenged a Chaos Warrior Sorceror/General with my Doomwolf and the Doomwolf not only won, but killed the general. The rest of the wolves were slaughtered and the champ died to CR, but it was still epic. I have begun naming my wolves of epic stature after the Direwolves from Game of Thrones.

I have Sisters of Battle for 40k and one Sister Superior (sergeant) was my only living model for three turns. She survived multiple Dark Lances and a flame template and then power mauled a tank to death. I ended up naming her during the match as Kerrigan from StarCraft.

All of those hammerers could have been saved if Grimm had made way...

Not really. The sheer improbability of what ended up happening is basically the equivalent of your dog beating the snot out of grimm anyway.
 
One time, in 7th edition....I had a Prophet of Doom (Flagellant Unit Champ) I was in a tournament and I was getting absolutely screwed by a dark elf player. My 40 man strong flagellant squad just got done taking on something like executioners or blackguard or what not and only one model remained...being unbreakable and immune to all tests at the time. I charged a dark elf lord on a black dragon, not having to take a terror test because well, the prophets crazy and doesn't care. I run in, I randomize my attacks between the dragon and the lord, I roll all 3 on the lord. He has some stupid saves...1+ armor 3+ ward or some such, ws 7 or 8 ...my ws 2 Prophet swings all 3 times, hits all 3 times and the lord fails all 3 armor and ward saves. The dragon whiffs all his attacks...then takes a monster reaction test....rolls Rarrrgh or whatever the one that makes him charge the nearest friendly unit (however that rule worked at the time) which happened to be his other elite unit....decimates it and wins the tourny for me.

And everyone always gave me shit for taking flagellants.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu