I personally cant say what it the best for you or your VL as i dont know your play style, i dont know what your gaming group meta is like, i dont know how you use your VL + Skellies.
For example if the primary role of the VL and Skellies is to engage infantry units, id say without a doubt Sword of Strife/Bloodshed is the way to go. With high stats and reroll to hit you cant go wrong with having 7-8 base attacks. Against crap troops your getting roughly anywhere between 10-11 kills a turn (not including any type of armour or ward save against T3 or lower Infantry).
If the primary role of the VL was to engage tough blocks, high T, high armour. Having a sword increase your base strength would be the way to go, 5 base attacks with S6-7 against crack troops (sword and board chaos warriors) youre killing about 6 a turn and they wont get an armour save (even with the parry save). Knights would also fall under this category, as 1/2+ AS knight would be saving at 5/6+.
Ill probably get shot for this, but i actually quite like Skabscrath...i personally havent used it before. +1A from Frenzy, +1A on a Charge, Magical and Flaming with a Scream thrown into the mix.
With an average roll of a 7 and a +3 modifier from having 3 wounds and the average stats of troops is LD7 you have a 58% to roll 7 or higher and kill parts of units outright in the shooting phase. The 8" of this weapon also helps when youve decided to not charge your enemy and let them come to you, if youve set and measured it up right a failed charge might but them right at your doorstep within 8" for a scream.
The other boon of this weapon is against nuisance units which are designed to be charge blockers, Terradons, Fast Cav, etc etc. Having the tools to blow them away with something like this is extremely helpful.
There is also the likelihood you will roll low and it wont do anything...its always possible. But the counter to it is, the high rolls that can be made - a roll of 10, 11, 12 is enough to safely remove a whole unit of knights, half a block of Chaos Warriors, put enough wounds on a lord they fail enough ward saves, any chariot in the game, big gribblies with low-average LD would lose most if not all their wounds the list goes on.