Hi guys,
Just looking for some critique on this list i got, theres a com battle system going around. & for that in mind i have built my list around it!
now would this be effective under these "guide lines" & if everyone ignored the guide lines & went all out got comp score 0, would this be able to come out on top with some struggle but still effective?
in anycase ile let you decide & point out somethings that i may have missed or overlooked/should take.
First of all, here's the system:
Tournament Rules
-The tournament is a Warhammer 8th edition event.
-Armies are to be 2500 points in size. (Plus an objective model!)
-No Special Characters. Special Character Models can be used to represent standard characters. No Chaos Dwarves or Dogs of War Armies allowed (they are no longer supported unfortunately).
-Hills are to be considered as high as a Large Target – hills of the appropriate size are too dangerous for precious models. (But if a Large Target is on a hill it can see & be seen from behind another hill etc). All Terrain & LOS rules otherwise as per book.
-Units that are fleeing at the end of the game count as destroyed for VP purposes.
-The magic phase will have a “Hard Cap” of 12 dice. NO Item, spell or ability can increase a magic phase to above 12 dice, any additionally generated are wasted (ie The Sacrificial Dagger, Death Magic Lore attribute etc can all be used, until the casting player has generated a total of 12 dice to use in their magic phase). In the case of a miscast, the lost dice still count towards the 12
-The “Irresistible Force” rule is to be modified, requiring THREE 6’s to be rolled, not 2. Any roll of Double 6 to cast a spell will still be counted as a miscast once the spell (if successful) is resolved (both dispelling, or spell effects). If double 6 is rolled and the casting level of the spell is not met, a Miscast still results. A dispelled spell cast with a double 6 still produces a miscast on the caster. (Dispelling armies can still dispel a spell rolling Double 6 as per the irresistible dispel rule). Magic Items effecting miscasts still require the double roll (i.e. Infernal Puppet), whilst Magic Items affecting Irresistible Force will require a triple to be rolled (i.e. Book of Hoeth, Power Scroll).
Tournament Scores for WHFB
Composition
Dogcon will be employing the “Combattle” system. However, we will be doing this in a far more “heavy handed” approach than has previously been used in an Australian Warhammer tournament.
In short, the Combattle system takes the composition score from both players, and looks at the difference between the 2 scores. This difference will be divided by 2, and the player with the higher composition score will add this amount to their battle point total, whilst the person with the lower composition score will subtract this amount to their battle point total, in each game.
In this tournament, the “Standard” Composition score will be 6 – with the possibility of being increased to a “Lucky 7” score. The lowest possible score is 0, and if the panel decide an army is not a “standard” 6, then it will receive a score of 4 or less – probably less. Note you do not have to comply too any or all of the guidelines below – take the (legal) army you want to. However, your composition score will be lowered because of this, which will effect how many battle points you can earn throughout the tournament. The T.O. reserves the right to ask players to resubmit their army.
As a general guide, players will be receiving a composition score of 4 or less if there army does not correspond to all of the below guidelines. The more of these guidelines you break (and they are not all „equal?) the lower the comp score you can expect your score to be. THUS – you can take whatever legal army you want to this event, but your composition score will reflect this choice as opposed to your fellow players, who are looking for a fair, equitable and enjoyable game. However, to achieve a comp score of the following, you will adhere to all of the below:
-The percentage breakdown of your army should be no more than the following: Lords – 20%; Hero?s - 20%; And a minimum Core of 30%.
-If you repeat the same unit twice, neither unit should be larger than 40 models. If you repeat a unit 3 times, neither unit should be larger than 30 models, if you repeat a unit 4 times, it should
5
not be bigger than 20 models. (i.e. you could have 1 unit of 100+ Skaven slaves, 2 units of 40, 3 units of 30, or 4 units of 20). Don?t take 5 of the same unit. Trust me.
-Rare units are supposed to be Rare. They should not be repeated, unless they are 80 points or less, in which case they are ok to be repeated once. (Bolt throwers are an exception and a max of 2 are seen as ok)
-Take a maximum 4 War machines. However if a War Machine is repeated, then only 3 war machines may be taken. (Steam Tank considered as 2 war machines, 1 of which is a cannon. 2 for 1 War machines do not count to this guideline, but do towards the 4 overall) expect taking 5 war machines to be an instant resubmit.
-The majority of ones models should not use missile weapons (ie a gunline approach).
-Taking multiple cheap characters with “one use only wonder weapon” type magic items, or multiple “template weapon” items/units in the army should be avoided.
-Masses of unique units (ie Fanatics, units with random movement special rule, Doomwheels and Hellpit Abominations) should be avoided.
Saving Graces – things that you should do, & will stand your army in a positive light, aiding you to possibly achieve the “Lucky 7” composition score include:
-Avoid taking a level 4 mage, or mages that know all spells from a deck
-Avoiding Magic decks with the “wonder spells”
-Taking character setups that are unusual, or using a variety of magic items instead of the “standard” setups currently seen (ie 3+ ward Tzeenetch marked Warriors of Chaos characters are a standard set up)
-A Lack of Template weapons in your army
-A variety of troop types, light cavalry to heavy cavalry, infantry, monstrous class units, monsters, missile fire etc – including many elements in your army.
-A variety of unit sizes across your army of similar troop types.
& Finally my list in response:
Dogcon rev3 Vampire Army 2500 (2499)
Lords
Vampire Lord, +1 Magic Level, Vampiric Powers: lord of the dead, summon ghouls, Avatar of death [Sword n Board], Master of the black arts, Magic Items: Helm of commandment, Crown of the damned, earthing rod, dragon helm
455pts
Heroes
Wight King, BSB, Lance, Skeletal steed + Barding, Flag of blood keep (+75) 207pts
Vampire (100) VP: Dark Acylote (+30) avatar of death [sword n board] (+20) MI: Talisman of preservation (+45) 195pts
402pts
Core
30 Skeleton Warriors w/ spears, musician, banner, Banner of hellfire, 297pts
15 Skeleton Warriors w/ spears, musician, banner, Lichebone, Pennant, 162pts
40 Crypt Ghouls, 320pts
7 Dire wolves, Doom Wolf 64pts
843pts
Special
28 Grave Guard w/ Great weapons, FC, Banner of burrows
449pts
Rare
5 Blood Knights, Musician, banner, Royal standard of strigos
350pts
Just looking for some critique on this list i got, theres a com battle system going around. & for that in mind i have built my list around it!
now would this be effective under these "guide lines" & if everyone ignored the guide lines & went all out got comp score 0, would this be able to come out on top with some struggle but still effective?
in anycase ile let you decide & point out somethings that i may have missed or overlooked/should take.
First of all, here's the system:
Tournament Rules
-The tournament is a Warhammer 8th edition event.
-Armies are to be 2500 points in size. (Plus an objective model!)
-No Special Characters. Special Character Models can be used to represent standard characters. No Chaos Dwarves or Dogs of War Armies allowed (they are no longer supported unfortunately).
-Hills are to be considered as high as a Large Target – hills of the appropriate size are too dangerous for precious models. (But if a Large Target is on a hill it can see & be seen from behind another hill etc). All Terrain & LOS rules otherwise as per book.
-Units that are fleeing at the end of the game count as destroyed for VP purposes.
-The magic phase will have a “Hard Cap” of 12 dice. NO Item, spell or ability can increase a magic phase to above 12 dice, any additionally generated are wasted (ie The Sacrificial Dagger, Death Magic Lore attribute etc can all be used, until the casting player has generated a total of 12 dice to use in their magic phase). In the case of a miscast, the lost dice still count towards the 12
-The “Irresistible Force” rule is to be modified, requiring THREE 6’s to be rolled, not 2. Any roll of Double 6 to cast a spell will still be counted as a miscast once the spell (if successful) is resolved (both dispelling, or spell effects). If double 6 is rolled and the casting level of the spell is not met, a Miscast still results. A dispelled spell cast with a double 6 still produces a miscast on the caster. (Dispelling armies can still dispel a spell rolling Double 6 as per the irresistible dispel rule). Magic Items effecting miscasts still require the double roll (i.e. Infernal Puppet), whilst Magic Items affecting Irresistible Force will require a triple to be rolled (i.e. Book of Hoeth, Power Scroll).
Tournament Scores for WHFB
Composition
Dogcon will be employing the “Combattle” system. However, we will be doing this in a far more “heavy handed” approach than has previously been used in an Australian Warhammer tournament.
In short, the Combattle system takes the composition score from both players, and looks at the difference between the 2 scores. This difference will be divided by 2, and the player with the higher composition score will add this amount to their battle point total, whilst the person with the lower composition score will subtract this amount to their battle point total, in each game.
In this tournament, the “Standard” Composition score will be 6 – with the possibility of being increased to a “Lucky 7” score. The lowest possible score is 0, and if the panel decide an army is not a “standard” 6, then it will receive a score of 4 or less – probably less. Note you do not have to comply too any or all of the guidelines below – take the (legal) army you want to. However, your composition score will be lowered because of this, which will effect how many battle points you can earn throughout the tournament. The T.O. reserves the right to ask players to resubmit their army.
As a general guide, players will be receiving a composition score of 4 or less if there army does not correspond to all of the below guidelines. The more of these guidelines you break (and they are not all „equal?) the lower the comp score you can expect your score to be. THUS – you can take whatever legal army you want to this event, but your composition score will reflect this choice as opposed to your fellow players, who are looking for a fair, equitable and enjoyable game. However, to achieve a comp score of the following, you will adhere to all of the below:
-The percentage breakdown of your army should be no more than the following: Lords – 20%; Hero?s - 20%; And a minimum Core of 30%.
-If you repeat the same unit twice, neither unit should be larger than 40 models. If you repeat a unit 3 times, neither unit should be larger than 30 models, if you repeat a unit 4 times, it should
5
not be bigger than 20 models. (i.e. you could have 1 unit of 100+ Skaven slaves, 2 units of 40, 3 units of 30, or 4 units of 20). Don?t take 5 of the same unit. Trust me.
-Rare units are supposed to be Rare. They should not be repeated, unless they are 80 points or less, in which case they are ok to be repeated once. (Bolt throwers are an exception and a max of 2 are seen as ok)
-Take a maximum 4 War machines. However if a War Machine is repeated, then only 3 war machines may be taken. (Steam Tank considered as 2 war machines, 1 of which is a cannon. 2 for 1 War machines do not count to this guideline, but do towards the 4 overall) expect taking 5 war machines to be an instant resubmit.
-The majority of ones models should not use missile weapons (ie a gunline approach).
-Taking multiple cheap characters with “one use only wonder weapon” type magic items, or multiple “template weapon” items/units in the army should be avoided.
-Masses of unique units (ie Fanatics, units with random movement special rule, Doomwheels and Hellpit Abominations) should be avoided.
Saving Graces – things that you should do, & will stand your army in a positive light, aiding you to possibly achieve the “Lucky 7” composition score include:
-Avoid taking a level 4 mage, or mages that know all spells from a deck
-Avoiding Magic decks with the “wonder spells”
-Taking character setups that are unusual, or using a variety of magic items instead of the “standard” setups currently seen (ie 3+ ward Tzeenetch marked Warriors of Chaos characters are a standard set up)
-A Lack of Template weapons in your army
-A variety of troop types, light cavalry to heavy cavalry, infantry, monstrous class units, monsters, missile fire etc – including many elements in your army.
-A variety of unit sizes across your army of similar troop types.
& Finally my list in response:
Dogcon rev3 Vampire Army 2500 (2499)
Lords
Vampire Lord, +1 Magic Level, Vampiric Powers: lord of the dead, summon ghouls, Avatar of death [Sword n Board], Master of the black arts, Magic Items: Helm of commandment, Crown of the damned, earthing rod, dragon helm
455pts
Heroes
Wight King, BSB, Lance, Skeletal steed + Barding, Flag of blood keep (+75) 207pts
Vampire (100) VP: Dark Acylote (+30) avatar of death [sword n board] (+20) MI: Talisman of preservation (+45) 195pts
402pts
Core
30 Skeleton Warriors w/ spears, musician, banner, Banner of hellfire, 297pts
15 Skeleton Warriors w/ spears, musician, banner, Lichebone, Pennant, 162pts
40 Crypt Ghouls, 320pts
7 Dire wolves, Doom Wolf 64pts
843pts
Special
28 Grave Guard w/ Great weapons, FC, Banner of burrows
449pts
Rare
5 Blood Knights, Musician, banner, Royal standard of strigos
350pts