3v3 magic phase question

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

PureSphinx

Ghoul
Jul 16, 2014
178
Zombies
153
Hey all, I play warhammer each Saturday, but last week we had a new guy come in with us and he does his magic different. I would like clarification on this, if it's in the rules, or the best way to follow the spirit of the game if it isn't expressly written.

Anyway, we were doing a 3v3 3000 pt game, VC, DE, and Skaven vs Empire, HE, and WoC. Chaos didn't have a sorcerer. We decided to do what my group normally does, which is each player rolls winds of magic and casts spells for himself with his wizard, and we each get assigned an opponent to dispel for us. The Empire player (new to our group) said he plays it so that each team just rolls 3d6 and then we would split it as evenly as possible.

We didn't like this idea because the WoC player without a Mage wouldn't be using his dice, so all in all it would make it so more spells were cast by our team than theirs. I also pointed out that I spent points on a lore master for a reason, and if I'm getting 4-5 dice per turn instead of 7+, it nullifies having Mannfred in my army, and I would have reconsidered taking him.

So my question is this: in the rules, is there a specific way to do this that I missed, or is it up to the players? If it's up to the players, how do you guys usually do it?

Thanks,
PureSphinx
 
I've seen some people use the Storm of Magic rules as far as dice generation goes in larger games, then they usually just share the dice pool. GW did this in the Blood in the Badlands games (but they were actually playing SoM).

In the BRB, as far as I'm aware, all it states for any magic phase in any game, regardless of size or amount of players, is roll 2d6 for power and dispel is highest. However, when you get into bigger games, especially with multiple people, this starts to make the magic phase not as effective.

GW did come out with a book that has rules for games with more than 2 players (Triumph and Treachery?), although I don't own it so I'm not sure if there were any amended rules as far as the magic phase is concerned.
 
I've seen some people use the Storm of Magic rules as far as dice generation goes in larger games, then they usually just share the dice pool. GW did this in the Blood in the Badlands games (but they were actually playing SoM).

In the BRB, as far as I'm aware, all it states for any magic phase in any game, regardless of size or amount of players, is roll 2d6 for power and dispel is highest. However, when you get into bigger games, especially with multiple people, this starts to make the magic phase not as effective.

GW did come out with a book that has rules for games with more than 2 players (Triumph and Treachery?), although I don't own it so I'm not sure if there were any amended rules as far as the magic phase is concerned.
Triumph and Treachery is for up to five players, but it's not team based. The premise is that some prized artifact(s) are in this area and (up to) five armies arrive at the same time and a great battle over it/them ensues. Either way, the magic phase is still 2D6 power dice with the higher being the dispel amount. Really, only two players ever take part in any one phase, save a few event cards that allow more players to participate.
 
So the basic rules say 2D6 and SoM says 4D6, regardless of players. It seems to me like GW didn't think about multiplayer games all that much. 3 level 4 wizards and a few level 1-2 wizards cannot share 7 dice. 14 dice is better, but 7 dice apiece (21) seems better to me.

As vampire counts we rely on getting off invocation multiple times, Vanhel's, and maybe HV or Raise Dead to be at maximum efficiency in battle. It feels to me like if I'm giving my dice away for doombolts and dreaded thirteenth, then my army is going to suffer because they don't have the magical support that is the backbone of our lists.

It seems like something that should be put in errata or something, maybe 2D6 +1D6 for each player beyond the first, or 2D6 per player, divided as they choose among their wizards like a normal 1v1. Or maybe I'm just greedy with my wizards :P do you guys play with 6+ people in your games?
 
Hi!

I started a thread on the desperate allies trying to find an issue: https://www.vampirecounts.net/threa...layers-teams-2vs2-and-desperate-allies.26461/

Your main problem is there. RAW you have to play Wind of magic as a normal game (2D6). The way to split your dices is depending of your team composition (P.136 BRB). Playing a 3vs3 uses the rules of "Grand Alliance" (P.139) and is quit unclear on your type of alliance.


IMHO, I would say:

Wind of magic: 2D6

Team 1: VC, DE, Skaven (Trusted allies, how many rounds since you are a Fragile alliance?) You're splitting power dices as you wish. (You can take all of them if your friends doesn't care, at least for the first round... since you have 87,5% each round to drop your alliance by a step)
Team 2: Empire, HE, WoC (Empire and HE are Trusted allies and share 2/3 of the pool while Warrior of Chaos have 1/3 even if he doesn't have a wizard)

I realy dislike those rules. You could houserule that everyone is ALWAYS Trusted allies.
 
Yeah, we do house rule that unless we come up with a scenario beforehand saying otherwise. I agree though that the rules make it hard for multiplayer games. An average of 7 dice is hard enough to split between my level four and my 2-3 level twos, let alone adding a DE sorceress or two and a Grey Seer to the pool. I feel like it's one of those things that should be left up to the players to rule within reason, so that magic dependent armies like us don't suffer because of it.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu