4 vs 5 bloodknights

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

tex577

Ghoul
Dec 17, 2008
154
Zombies
212
Hey all

Just wondering if any of you have had much experience fielding 4 bloodknights instead of 5. Do they have the same impact? Is it much easier to kill them? The fewer points better incase they die or get led around a lot?

I thought id finalised my GT list but then got to thinking about these boys. I think i need another bat and some more ghouls so thought about dropping 1 BK for them. But does this severly weaken them. My original plans for them were to give them the hellfire banner meaning they can hit anything magical and regenerating and laugh but will the loss of 3 st 7 and 2 st 4 attacks make a huge difference?

The other way i was thinking of going was dropping them althogether grabbing a unit black knights, more ghouls and maybe another character for more pd. This then leaves me the problem of having no march enablers behind my ghoulkin advanced line. Hmm i hate making lists for big tournaments it seems to rule my life for the week or so before one.

PS here is my proposed list so you can see what im thinking: https://www.vampirecounts.net/showthread.php?tid=6407
SAD i know!
 
hey tex.

the work of these BK is pretty much decided by what you are facing.
in general I would recommand and prefer a Royal Standard of Strigos to a Banner of Hellfire.
I know, this costs even more, but the hatred makes them much more effective against most units unless they have regeneration.
therefor 4 bloodknights will do a very well job and kill almost everything they are charging.
the number of bloodknights is in my opinion depending on how save you move em. losing 2 out of 4 bloodknights will make them some kind of useless.
but if you keep them from shooting for long enough i think 4 charging bloodknights will do a very good job and not much less damage than 5 would do.
however, i prefer 5 ;)
 
Cheers for the input mate

Yeh im swayed by the hellfire banner due to its cost, the fact that it gives the whole unit magical flaming attacks and that a regular oponant in my club has a treeman ancient who i kill in the first round of combat everytime! But you make a very valid point in that 4 bloodknights with std of strigos would be as effective as 5 without and i always play cagey with them when there is big shooting around. The thing is i want them in my army for the UKGT for the hurt they can put out but need the odd 50pts to up my core blocks to more survivable numbers not to mention the fact that they can help other componants of my army march. The varg can also do this but his damage output is nowhere near the knights, so in all i think 4 knights with strigos banner may well be the way forward!

Thankyou very much my friend
 
i use mine 4 strong with banner of strigos with a dreadknight vamp with blooddrinker leading them.

alot of people say this is overkill but for me its about what it takes to keep this unit alive and kicking. i have horrible luck with my blood knights and loose the unit every game ive played so far, often to terrible rolls or slightly off charges which land me in trouble. its an expensive unit but i find having the vampire there with blood drinker can bring back the unit from nothing to full strength easily. my support vamps or lord are seldom in range to use invok on the unit so the only option to keep them alive was to put a mounted vampire in there.

i played a game using this unit combo the other day and it works a treat. twice that vampire raised 3 knights back and saved the unit from wipe out, they actually went on to perform really well rolling up a flank and probably winning me the game. dunno what it is with 2+ saves i can't make them for jack.
 
Bork said:
i use mine 4 strong with banner of strigos with a dreadknight vamp with blooddrinker leading them.

alot of people say this is overkill but for me its about what it takes to keep this unit alive and kicking. i have horrible luck with my blood knights and loose the unit every game ive played so far, often to terrible rolls or slightly off charges which land me in trouble. its an expensive unit but i find having the vampire there with blood drinker can bring back the unit from nothing to full strength easily. my support vamps or lord are seldom in range to use invok on the unit so the only option to keep them alive was to put a mounted vampire in there.

i played a game using this unit combo the other day and it works a treat. twice that vampire raised 3 knights back and saved the unit from wipe out, they actually went on to perform really well rolling up a flank and probably winning me the game. dunno what it is with 2+ saves i can't make them for jack.

The largest issue i see with this set up is that the mentioned vampire wont get any look out sir protection, and hench can get cannon sniped.
 
if i dont put characters in the unit i prefer to use 4 with strigoi banner, they can kill alone almost all units if they charge.
but if put any character inside, i always use 5 to avoid him to be a target of spells from enemys :)
 
Bork said:
i use mine 4 strong with banner of strigos with a dreadknight vamp with blooddrinker leading them.

alot of people say this is overkill but for me its about what it takes to keep this unit alive and kicking. i have horrible luck with my blood knights and loose the unit every game ive played so far, often to terrible rolls or slightly off charges which land me in trouble. its an expensive unit but i find having the vampire there with blood drinker can bring back the unit from nothing to full strength easily. my support vamps or lord are seldom in range to use invok on the unit so the only option to keep them alive was to put a mounted vampire in there.

i played a game using this unit combo the other day and it works a treat. twice that vampire raised 3 knights back and saved the unit from wipe out, they actually went on to perform really well rolling up a flank and probably winning me the game. dunno what it is with 2+ saves i can't make them for jack.

just a question: you said he raised 3 knights twice
so you used nahek three times or did you raise 3 with just one nehek? because this wouldnt be possible, as cavallery can only regain 1 wound from nehek.
 
I would normally field 5; almost always with the Strigoi banner. Adding hatred to that many attacks just makes sense. I feel 4 wounds is too risky for such an expensive unit. Also with each lost Bloodknight, you lose a lot of hitting power; so if I lose a knight or two I would still feel confident about charging with this unit, and raising back a model in the magic phase (no lance bonus for those guys though). I wouldn't put a character in there as I would feel they would be better suited somewhere else. Just use IoN to repair any damage from afar. Blood knights hit harder than hero vampires normally, and for far less points.
 
Pyrlo said:
just a question: you said he raised 3 knights twice
so you used nahek three times or did you raise 3 with just one nehek? because this wouldnt be possible, as cavallery can only regain 1 wound from nehek.

i would assume he used the blooddrinker to heal them...
 
The problem with using 4 knights w/ hatred banner vs 5 blood knights is that it costs slightly more, and gives you a banner that you probably won't use for CR (since the knights are so choppy) but is likely to be captured (it's easy to bait frenzy troops for a flank charge).

As a rule, I only give banners to units that I don't expect to get wiped out, like Grave Guard or skeletons. I would consider it on Black Knights depending on what I wanted to do with them because they are much more controlable and are more likely to die from shooting than from flank charges, so no captured banner.
 
I have taken to using two units of 4 blood knights each with a magic banner. Banner 1 is the Strigos banner which means that on the charge they can trash any other cavalry unit and most enemy infantry. Banner 2 is the Hellfire Banner to take out any models with regeneration e.g. Hydra or Trolls or anything ethereal or burns easily e.g. treemen.

I find the main problem with them is not having them lured out of the line due to their frenzy - other than that they can be game winners.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu