Mortus946736 said:
I threw six dice at thralls first turn.. Since i KNEW i needed it to get off. He had three scroll runes, and two of the break spell runes if i recall...
I admit, id id get lucky with the lord... Four attacks, only missed one... And two wounds out of the three hits. I tend to have good luck with 4+s for things that actually do damage, like stone throwers. I was in ONE rank with those blood knights so the cannons only hit once... Only thing i worried on was organ gun, and grudge throwers.. And he threw those at the blocks because they were easier to gut with them.
On the charge... his armor save wasnt there. Ironbreakers where wide, seven wide i believe. No armor against strength seven. he just had parries... though my luck was quite good... I lost four of my knights in that combat though.. I will say most of my infantry ended up dead...
I only killed ONE war machine with the dogs.. The rest was infantry blocks after the knights bailed them out of combat.
Ill try and get another game in and see if i can do it without that level of luck again if that makes you guys happier.
Whoa, I'm confused... by throwing six dice at your thrall you mean your lord and casting pha's right? So you miscast then with your lord (gutsy!)? Didn't you lose any knights to that? I mean what happened there? If not, why didn't he just use a dispel on that and be done with it.
I'm not sure if you meant the spellbreaker/dispel runes were all the anti-magic he had but if so that is not an anti-magic heavy list for dwarfs!
"Finish off the grudge thrower, cannon im down to one dog, he has one crew. " You killed one machine (that's four crew members... unless he didn't take an engineer in which case FOR SHAME!) and took out another 3 on a cannon... wolves hit on 4+, wound on 5+ and get passed a 6+ armor save (odds are you'll kill 5 after 36 attacks...assuming engineer doesn't have anything special.) while crew hit on 3, wound on 4 and no armor. Killing 2 crew before your dogs get wiped is pretty impressive, actually killing 3+ on not one but two machines is just amazing. I would consider it very lucky if the 5 wolves didn't get wiped due to CR by the second CC.
And am I understanding you had 10 wide 1 rank bld knights? Why did he keep in his ironbreakers in 7 wide then? That's only advantageous against 5 wide units. He should've reformed when he saw the cavalry coming at him (since he shouldn't have been moving anyways)
"I admit, id id get lucky with the lord... Four attacks, only missed one... And two wounds out of the three hits. I tend to have good luck with 4+s for things that actually do damage" Not too mention a 5+ (or 4+) armor save and a parry save... those combined should've saved one of them.
It's not just the fact you had a lot of luck, it's also a matter of your opponent's tactics. Infantry do die easier to siege fire than bld knights, but that doesn't make it a wise decision to fire at them. His 25 warriors should be able to tear through your any of your core without many problems. Thunderers are also a great way to thin out your infantry if he's worried since no one get an armor save from them. But cannons, grudge throwers, and organ guns should've been making minced meat out of your bld knights AND your lord. He may have also invested far too many points in runes for his siege (something my dwarf friend says is a novice mistake). The ironbreakers being 7 wide for the charge is something that makes me raise an eyebrow as I don't know why he did that... nor why his war machines were available for charging by round 2. In short, he let you do what you want and that's a luxury my dwarfen friend never allows me (especially in magic), which is why I wouldn't use them on him.
@leadros: I figured they were both mounted (otherwise it wouldn't be allowed), but I still don't see the point. Why not just put the thrall in the unit of bld knights... and you know leave him there? I usually read about the shadow movement as a way to avoid combat for a caster, but this puts him right back into CC... and it leaves him without a Lo,S no matter which unit he is in. If I had to employ this strat, I would just keep him off a mount and put him in GG... at least he gets Lo,S and you save on points. The only advantage of Bld knights is that they I guess are a little closer, but since GG are moving into the exact same combat anyways they can't be too far away to use spells?