8th Edition Blood Knights - More Viable?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I threw six dice at thralls first turn.. Since i KNEW i needed it to get off. He had three scroll runes, and two of the break spell runes if i recall...

I admit, id id get lucky with the lord... Four attacks, only missed one... And two wounds out of the three hits. I tend to have good luck with 4+s for things that actually do damage, like stone throwers. I was in ONE rank with those blood knights so the cannons only hit once... Only thing i worried on was organ gun, and grudge throwers.. And he threw those at the blocks because they were easier to gut with them.

On the charge... his armor save wasnt there. Ironbreakers where wide, seven wide i believe. No armor against strength seven. he just had parries... though my luck was quite good... I lost four of my knights in that combat though.. I will say most of my infantry ended up dead...

I only killed ONE war machine with the dogs.. The rest was infantry blocks after the knights bailed them out of combat.

Ill try and get another game in and see if i can do it without that level of luck again if that makes you guys happier.
 
REAAAAAALLLLY?!?!!?!?!

the people arguing with me are running blood knights EXACTLY as I described will work very well? and it performed well?!

a 10+ strong block including a lord with blood drinker red fury and infinite hatred is what I have been suggesting the entire time. Mortus how many blood knights did you have dead at one time during the battle?

Vandurian id love your input to! it would be alot of help.

as far as your friends strategy leandros's, he is bloody insane, putting mounted characters in an infantry unit is a horrible idea, I dont see the reason to switch them at all either your thrall is the one your trying to save from getting sniped by a cannonball or your lord is, and in your situation they are both horribly open to getting sniped as no matter which one it is you dont get a look out sir roll.
 
Mortus946736 said:
I threw six dice at thralls first turn.. Since i KNEW i needed it to get off. He had three scroll runes, and two of the break spell runes if i recall...

I admit, id id get lucky with the lord... Four attacks, only missed one... And two wounds out of the three hits. I tend to have good luck with 4+s for things that actually do damage, like stone throwers. I was in ONE rank with those blood knights so the cannons only hit once... Only thing i worried on was organ gun, and grudge throwers.. And he threw those at the blocks because they were easier to gut with them.

On the charge... his armor save wasnt there. Ironbreakers where wide, seven wide i believe. No armor against strength seven. he just had parries... though my luck was quite good... I lost four of my knights in that combat though.. I will say most of my infantry ended up dead...

I only killed ONE war machine with the dogs.. The rest was infantry blocks after the knights bailed them out of combat.

Ill try and get another game in and see if i can do it without that level of luck again if that makes you guys happier.

Whoa, I'm confused... by throwing six dice at your thrall you mean your lord and casting pha's right? So you miscast then with your lord (gutsy!)? Didn't you lose any knights to that? I mean what happened there? If not, why didn't he just use a dispel on that and be done with it.

I'm not sure if you meant the spellbreaker/dispel runes were all the anti-magic he had but if so that is not an anti-magic heavy list for dwarfs!

"Finish off the grudge thrower, cannon im down to one dog, he has one crew. " You killed one machine (that's four crew members... unless he didn't take an engineer in which case FOR SHAME!) and took out another 3 on a cannon... wolves hit on 4+, wound on 5+ and get passed a 6+ armor save (odds are you'll kill 5 after 36 attacks...assuming engineer doesn't have anything special.) while crew hit on 3, wound on 4 and no armor. Killing 2 crew before your dogs get wiped is pretty impressive, actually killing 3+ on not one but two machines is just amazing. I would consider it very lucky if the 5 wolves didn't get wiped due to CR by the second CC.

And am I understanding you had 10 wide 1 rank bld knights? Why did he keep in his ironbreakers in 7 wide then? That's only advantageous against 5 wide units. He should've reformed when he saw the cavalry coming at him (since he shouldn't have been moving anyways)

"I admit, id id get lucky with the lord... Four attacks, only missed one... And two wounds out of the three hits. I tend to have good luck with 4+s for things that actually do damage" Not too mention a 5+ (or 4+) armor save and a parry save... those combined should've saved one of them.

It's not just the fact you had a lot of luck, it's also a matter of your opponent's tactics. Infantry do die easier to siege fire than bld knights, but that doesn't make it a wise decision to fire at them. His 25 warriors should be able to tear through your any of your core without many problems. Thunderers are also a great way to thin out your infantry if he's worried since no one get an armor save from them. But cannons, grudge throwers, and organ guns should've been making minced meat out of your bld knights AND your lord. He may have also invested far too many points in runes for his siege (something my dwarf friend says is a novice mistake). The ironbreakers being 7 wide for the charge is something that makes me raise an eyebrow as I don't know why he did that... nor why his war machines were available for charging by round 2. In short, he let you do what you want and that's a luxury my dwarfen friend never allows me (especially in magic), which is why I wouldn't use them on him.

@leadros: I figured they were both mounted (otherwise it wouldn't be allowed), but I still don't see the point. Why not just put the thrall in the unit of bld knights... and you know leave him there? I usually read about the shadow movement as a way to avoid combat for a caster, but this puts him right back into CC... and it leaves him without a Lo,S no matter which unit he is in. If I had to employ this strat, I would just keep him off a mount and put him in GG... at least he gets Lo,S and you save on points. The only advantage of Bld knights is that they I guess are a little closer, but since GG are moving into the exact same combat anyways they can't be too far away to use spells?
 
Pha's protection is what i threw six dice at a turn.... Not thralls... I dont know why i typed that... Late night for me last night.

And Forge...

At any one time i usually had around half the unit dead... But by then most of his engines were tied up or had combats between me and them.

The angle was funny... They went seven wide in front of one of my blocks which i hit in the front... He reformed to face one of my ghoul blocks, and i was just barely not in his flank with the blood knights...

It took some finagling to get it in... But i did... Lucky there was decent space between his unit and my ghouls or i wouldn't have fit.
Oh and on the war machine thing... the war machines that i charged got hit by one or TWO units of wolves in succession... as in two charges in.. So 10 wolves, over two turns, not just 5. Notice how many wolves i had?

I have another game against him on Tuesday, ill try this again then.

Oh and btw: Organ gun, 8 shots, on average.
Wounding on 3+s: 2-3 dont wound, on average.
6 Wounds. Strength five, armor peircing. -3 to armor.

2+ goes to 5+.
1/3 saved by armor, 1/2 saved by wards... thus: 2 Stopped by armor on average, then another 3 stopped by wards, using strictly averaged results.

That means, on average, an 8 from that organ gun kills 1 knight.... Explain their survivability more?
 
It is insane... Some things just doesn't work in theory...
The example I told you was used to flank an O@G army...The first charge was against 6 trolls... It worked pretty well destroying all of them... Maybe it was situational but I told you what I saw...

Actually Mortus did pretty close what i said... You got to build a list around them... And according to his sayings he barely lost a rank... So no need for 10+blood knights...
The difference here is that I told that you got to build a List around them. Not just a lord and a BSB to acompanie them...

Anyway... Actually the whole discussion got quite comical... Me posting insane tactics and everyone else being huh?
Just built a list around them and try it. Nothing is perfect in theory...

@Forge: Dude the way you are taking this so serious is almost as you want to be trolled...:):):):):):)
 
Most i lost in any given time was 6 due to a 5 on the miscast chart, it hurts but sometimes you need a spell to go off. I agree that light is awesome to take. It fixes undead problems fairly well, speed, attacks, ranged protection, WS, and the occasional net.

I think that a fast hard hitting style of vampires is a viable choice. Different then most would assume but that surprise combined with Invocation/Blooddrinker, hard hitting characters and excellent unit-wide upgrades makes for good stuff. A couple units of Black Knights with supporting chars, some Blood Knights and a bunch of wolf screeners can put a heck of a hole in someones line, and quickly. Means less to have to raise and more power dice to vamp up your troops/etc. Plus it gives your opponent something to focus on while your core/GG cross the board to his lines.
 
Mortus946736 said:
Oh and btw: Organ gun, 8 shots, on average.
Wounding on 3+s: 2-3 dont wound, on average.
6 Wounds. Strength five, armor peircing. -3 to armor.

2+ goes to 5+.
1/3 saved by armor, 1/2 saved by wards... thus: 2 Stopped by armor on average, then another 3 stopped by wards, using strictly averaged results.

That means, on average, an 8 from that organ gun kills 1 knight.... Explain their survivability more?
Not really. How does a 4+ ward save average out to save 3/4 wounds again?
6 wounds = 4 after armor save and 2 after ward save... that's two knights down from one organ gun (1/7 of his war machines). Now the other organ gun can fire, a cannon can snipe out heroes, grudge thrower etc. And those grudge throwers have a really high chance to direct hit due to rerolling scatter, so b/t three of them taking out the lord shouldn't be a problem.

It was still a tremendous mistake for ironbreakers to be 7 wide.

"They went seven wide in front of one of my blocks which i hit in the front... He reformed to face one of my ghoul blocks, and i was just barely not in his flank with the blood knights..." not only did he reform 7 wide (unnecessarily) but he almost reformed to have the knight in his flank?
Hmm, I think I see what happened now...
Vandurian said:
Most i lost in any given time was 6 due to a 5 on the miscast chart, it hurts but sometimes you need a spell to go off. I agree that light is awesome to take. It fixes undead problems fairly well, speed, attacks, ranged protection, WS, and the occasional net.

I think that a fast hard hitting style of vampires is a viable choice. Different then most would assume but that surprise combined with Invocation/Blooddrinker, hard hitting characters and excellent unit-wide upgrades makes for good stuff. A couple units of Black Knights with supporting chars, some Blood Knights and a bunch of wolf screeners can put a heck of a hole in someones line, and quickly. Means less to have to raise and more power dice to vamp up your troops/etc. Plus it gives your opponent something to focus on while your core/GG cross the board to his lines.
How many points are you talking about?? at 2k, 500 for your core, ~400-450 for lord, so about 1k left for bld knights, blk knights, heroes, wolves AND GG?
 
leandros said:
It is insane... Some things just doesn't work in theory...
The example I told you was used to flank an O@G army...The first charge was against 6 trolls... It worked pretty well destroying all of them... Maybe it was situational but I told you what I saw...

Actually Mortus did pretty close what i said... You got to build a list around them... And according to his sayings he barely lost a rank... So no need for 10+blood knights...
The difference here is that I told that you got to build a List around them. Not just a lord and a BSB to acompanie them...

Anyway... Actually the whole discussion got quite comical... Me posting insane tactics and everyone else being huh?
Just built a list around them and try it. Nothing is perfect in theory...

@Forge: Dude the way you are taking this so serious is almost as you want to be trolled...:):):):):):)

first off, you were arguing in favor of 5 blood knights and a thrall. if you werent, then you should be reading the entire conversation.

he took 9 blood knights and a lord. I suggested at least 7 blood knights and a lord not thrall but a 9 being the optimum build.

HUGE difference

And im sorry to break it to everyone, I was kinda angry about it too, you CANNOT break steadfast by any other means other then the enemy unit being in a forest or river i think too, or you must have more ranks then the enemy in the same combat. you CANNOT break ranks due to having at least 2 ranks and charging a flank it says specifically on the next page after where steadfast is listed.

more reason not to take ANY cavalry at all.......... GG are 100 billion times better in every regards of the game other then speed.
 
Forge said:
And im sorry to break it to everyone, I was kinda angry about it too, you CANNOT break steadfast by any other means other then the enemy unit being in a forest or river i think too, or you must have more ranks then the enemy in the same combat. you CANNOT break ranks due to having at least 2 ranks and charging a flank it says specifically on the next page after where steadfast is listed.

more reason not to take ANY cavalry at all.......... GG are 100 billion times better in every regards of the game other then speed.

Yeah, I think most people mean disrupt ranks when they say break ranks, which gives you a lot of cr (or more accurately denies CR). But I think most of them that use bld knights accompany them with inf to deny steadfast, which as pointed out seems silly when you can get GG and just have it deny steadfast itself.
 
I think, tbh... Black knights are cheaper for the denying steadfast thing... And more effective at it with the ethereal movement. with that blood knight deathstar.... Your goal is to hit something from the front and hack it down... dealing 5-7 wounds a turn is AT LEAST a rank a turn... Most cant take that... Unless its a very big horde... You WILL hurt them more then they hurt you.

Of course.... Its a deathstar... Which has inherent problems associated with it... But its fun.

Not sure its maximized... But im going to tinker with it and see how well it does against more competitive lists.
 
I have skimmed through the last several pages and noticed a few instances of comments which are borderline.

[mod]Please keep this discussion civilized or formal warnings will be issued to offending parties.

~ Bishop [/mod]
 
Mortus946736 said:
I think, tbh... Black knights are cheaper for the denying steadfast thing... And more effective at it with the ethereal movement. with that blood knight deathstar.... Your goal is to hit something from the front and hack it down... dealing 5-7 wounds a turn is AT LEAST a rank a turn... Most cant take that... Unless its a very big horde... You WILL hurt them more then they hurt you.

Of course.... Its a deathstar... Which has inherent problems associated with it... But its fun.

Not sure its maximized... But im going to tinker with it and see how well it does against more competitive lists.

Blk knights really can't deny steadfast. You have to have more ranks than the enemy and doing that with 24-28point/model guys isn't worthwhile (or possible in most cases X.x). Best you can hope for is disrupting ranks which denies CR, but still gives them steadfast.

Also "They kill 5 to that side with horses," Now you mentioned you had one long tine of bld knights for your formation... how did you kill 5 in the flank then as there would only be one bld knight in contact with the warriors?
 
In response to the question, I was referring to a 3000 point game. Of course that is a lot of points to have to take, I was merely trying to list options and possibilities, not make a list on the spot.

I will give calvery a few trys, as i love playing with them, even though they seem (are) nerfed in 8th. Perhaps new possibilities will arise. If i discover anything (good combos etc.) ill post in here.
 
Another point is you discuss the use of wolves to screen... you realize that with TLoS the wolves will only help against BS shooting attacks (which aren't too deadly usually), but do nothing against siege weapons right? I guess they can also help out with the frenzy a bit but still...
 
Dklyn said:
Another point is you discuss the use of wolves to screen... you realize that with TLoS the wolves will only help against BS shooting attacks (which aren't too deadly usually), but do nothing against siege weapons right? I guess they can also help out with the frenzy a bit but still...

and among that you cannot declare a charge through them because it is an impossible charge, charges are not resolved one at a time anymore. screening with wolves is a dead combo.
 
@Forge-What do you mean? that the enemy can't declare a charge through them? If your cav is being screened by wolves,your cav may declare a charge through the wolves,as long as you charge something else with the wolves and thereby clearing a path to the enemy.
BRB pg:16,as I read it, charges ARE declared and reacted to one at a time;pg 18 then states that the chargers are then moved in the order the attacker desires.
 
Indeed the Count is correct, in addition, line of sight does make them less of a screen however they will provide hard cover to anything behind them... therefore making them an annoyance. Shoot the wolves or shoot your knights with a -2, your choice. Siege weapons never bother me, they tend to scatter/blow up/not do enough dmg.
 
Count Lasombra said:
@Forge-What do you mean? that the enemy can't declare a charge through them? If your cav is being screened by wolves,your cav may declare a charge through the wolves,as long as you charge something else with the wolves and thereby clearing a path to the enemy.
BRB pg:16,as I read it, charges ARE declared and reacted to one at a time;pg 18 then states that the chargers are then moved in the order the attacker desires.

Your right after reading back at the rules, it used to be considered a shady illegal move in the last edition. I still dont see it doing anything but protecting you from ballistic weapons.
 
@ Forge-I enjoy surprising people by charging them w/ units that they thought they were safe from..reminds me of the 'discovery threat' tactic in chess.My roomie uses a little unit of giant rats to restrain his Rogres till fun time.The value being that you don't have to charge with the obstructing unit,but can if you need to.

On topic-Blood dragons are much LESS viable than ever...due to steadfast and the general doubling of unit sizes throughout the game.Not that they can't be used well,but compared to 7th edition their stock has plummeted.
There was a time you could expect a unit of 5 to charge a 50 block of spearmen to the face,and probably break them without getting hit back.
So no.
 
So are the BKs doomed to stay in this very expensive, arguably-viable funk forever, or could they'll get some tweaks come our next army book?

I guess I always assumed that they'd get some help since they're such an iconic VC unit and there's such a debate over using them or not. I'm new to the game, so I'm not sure how much that will affect what GW is going to do.

-aki
 
I have been on holidays and after coming home have noticed that some of my earlier comments were laughed at. I would like to comment on two things:

1) Speed kills. High strength and heavy armoured Speed kills even more. GG with their M4 can't cover a flank nor hunt small and agile units, Blood Knights can. Compairing Blood Knights to Grave Guard brings nothing to the question of "are Blood Knights more viable?".

2) Targets. All of my lists are all comers lists. One game I might be facing Sallies and Stegadons on the flank, the next game crossbowmen and cannons. Against whoever I am playing I try to create overloads where I can and play defensive where I can't. So why is it bad to attack a 60-100pt x-bow unit with my Blood Knights (with or without Thrall)? It's not. Being able to wipe out multiple small units over the course of a game is not a waste of my Blood Knights. While they are in CC they can't be shot at. The forced overruns can be annoying if they pull you out of position but it also generates extra movement and therfore extra Speed (see Nr 1).
 
Stonewyrm said:
I have been on holidays and after coming home have noticed that some of my earlier comments were laughed at. I would like to comment on two things:

1) Speed kills. High strength and heavy armoured Speed kills even more. GG with their M4 can't cover a flank nor hunt small and agile units, Blood Knights can. Compairing Blood Knights to Grave Guard brings nothing to the question of "are Blood Knights more viable?".

2) Targets. All of my lists are all comers lists. One game I might be facing Sallies and Stegadons on the flank, the next game crossbowmen and cannons. Against whoever I am playing I try to create overloads where I can and play defensive where I can't. So why is it bad to attack a 60-100pt x-bow unit with my Blood Knights (with or without Thrall)? It's not. Being able to wipe out multiple small units over the course of a game is not a waste of my Blood Knights. While they are in CC they can't be shot at. The forced overruns can be annoying if they pull you out of position but it also generates extra movement and therfore extra Speed (see Nr 1).

Its a bad allocation of points, thats your problem. 600 points for a unit with only 7 wounds to go hunt down cannons and small units, you can build a thrall on his own to do the job 10X faster. not only is it over kill on small units its a large amount of points that isnt very hard to kill and will ultimately be why you will lose the game in most cases.

Flank charges mean LITTLE now. if your unit is killy and survivable and has lots of ranks it will do fine. Grave guard are 1 million times better. if your going to go hunt small units and war machines take black knights, black coach, varghulf, or scout/flying thrall
 
I think that blood knights do excel at putting an absurd abount of attacks in a very narrow frontage. so there is sitll a place for them for me.

i think the problem is looking at them in isolation.

Sure the enemy will still have steadfast if the 7 bloods rush in by themselves. But the key in every edition of warhammer is to flank the enemy with cav and pin in place/remove staedfast with infantry and when the oppo do break, roll up the flank.

i always have 3 solid ghoul blocks supported by 6 blood knights. ghoulkin rush up, bloods flank. box in the enemy and roll up their battle lines.
 
In my opinion the blood knights are nice to play in the 8th edition. First it gives you variety, so you dont have to play the GG Horde with Drakenhoff and a rage lord in it. And it is also much more mobil than foot troops. But the problem with them is indeed that it is not very hard to beat them down for example with units that have a higher initiative or even ASF. Also spells and shooting units or war machines can break them before they even get in their first fight. Therefore you have to play great units (i prefer 9 blood knights and playing 6 in a row) and you have to put characters in there. Best is if you play a rage lord for increasing the damage, helping them holding their frenzy down and healing them with the blood trinker. The Wight King with BSB and the Drakenhoff is also a good form to let them survive much longer.

I like playing with them. It's a great fun and you have to test it! :vampire3:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu