About the "8th Edition Nerf"

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
The magic is a breath of fresh air but sadly ruined by the items and certain spells. As the miscasts are more common and much more painful items like the woc's puppet and the lizardmen cupped hands are just stupidly good. Then there is teclis, the book of hoeth and the power scroll. All of the above does a great job making the magic phase a real headache. The worst part being the OMGWTFBOOM spells which can really ruin a fun game.

Chracters are still useful, yes but painfully bland. This is more of a product of the new book though, not just 8th ed. I never had a problem with strong characters, this is fantasy after all, and he was backed up fairly weak troops. VC was always about the characters. We also need the characters to buffs the units so it balances itself out rather neatly.

I don't think there are many players who underestimate the merit of many attacks, especially if you use lore of beasts and have the HoC ready. Seen this used effectively with other armies. Most notably Beastmen, oddly enough. The list looked fairly simple and non-threatening but that was only till all of the sudden the army was T5 for the most part and S4 with Primal Fury is nothing to laugh at. Or take Bestigors swinging their weapons at S7. We can in a very similiar way with GG and Ghouls.

If the 9th edition ends up staying on the same track as 8th edition I hope they restrain it somewhat. Auto-win spells, for example, are just boring and only serve to ruin a good game.
 
Yeah, there a few really nasty ones out there.

I do find magic to be VERY refreshing overall, if not certain spells/items... but the mechanics of it.

Also, I love some streamlining they did to quicken the pace again. Charges, reforming after combat, a few other things. Also no more inching off to deny a charge (though I don't like the range being +2 to +12 over M... I'd prefer a small range).

Still, I'm starting to get a sense for VC's strengths in 8th. Curse of Years could be brutal now. As you can follow it up with spells now. Roll decently and you might be able to get a couple going if the opponent fails to dispel it on his turn...
 
I love Lore of Beasts. Cannot wait to try out buffing a vamp lord with red fury, infinite hatred and blood drinker with the savage beast of horros, giving an already killy vamp lord 7 re-rollable strength 8 attacks.
 
I personally am looking forward to not getting told "well you have vamps, of course you had an advantage" when I do win with my crappy troops...

My view isnt that we got nerfed its that 8th levelled the field by raising everyone else up. 8th so far has been a much more elegant game for me - primarily because its now 100% about managing "risks" rather than guessing distances - and with the dance + ION in our spellbooks plus unbreakable we STILL have the most reliable and most resilient army out there.

Plus we do it in style :suck:
 
I think VCs aren't as bad off as some claim; its a shame that certain units fare so badly under 8th rules though. Watching your Zombies get annihilated by Skavenslaves who are a 1/3 of their cost is just depressing. I do find Zombies are just as good as getting stuck in the wheels of a STank as before though, only now they can wound it. In theory. At least they hit automatically...

Looking back, prior to 8th the time I enjoyed playing VC the most was 2005-2006 VC. I loved the old book artistically (it might be a silly reason)
Best reason there is. The 6th ed book rocked with all that ghostly artwork done in white on grey bleeding out of the page edges; so much better than the current crappy book. Don't even get me started on the cover... *shudder*

The magic is a breath of fresh air but sadly ruined by the items and certain spells. As the miscasts are more common and much more painful items like the woc's puppet and the lizardmen cupped hands are just stupidly good. Then there is teclis, the book of hoeth and the power scroll. All of the above does a great job making the magic phase a real headache. The worst part being the OMGWTFBOOM spells which can really ruin a fun game.
Yeah, the magic seemed great for a while, until people discovered the uber spell spam... Now its 'Power Scroll Dreaded 13th, I win". Sigh. If magic resistance and wards worked vs the uber spells, that would go a long way to rectifying it.

I also do feel characters are still quite useful, but they don't overshadow the units to a point where it seems like some action flick where the hero is barely touched, if at all, by the countless and somehow comically ineffective troops and he single handedly slays them all... until confronted by the main villain.
I find the opposite is true; my troopers are taking down enemy characters regularly xD They're getting rare these days.
 
Sanai said:
I love Lore of Beasts. Cannot wait to try out buffing a vamp lord with red fury, infinite hatred and blood drinker with the savage beast of horros, giving an already killy vamp lord 7 re-rollable strength 8 attacks.


Tried Red Fury, Infinite Hatred and Ogre blade with savage beast of horros last night

7 Re-rollable S10 attacks, which gain extra attacks for wounds inflicted.

That wasnt exactly a shared fun experience but certainly gave me a new outlook on the combat lord. Oh and Savage Beast of Horros with Konrad was devastating vs ogres.
 
Quote:
I also do feel characters are still quite useful, but they don't overshadow the units to a point where it seems like some action flick where the hero is barely touched, if at all, by the countless and somehow comically ineffective troops and he single handedly slays them all... until confronted by the main villain.
I find the opposite is true; my troopers are taking down enemy characters regularly They're getting rare these days.

I second this - with always striking back killing blow is starting to take its toll on enemy characters lol :thumbsup:
 
I know last night my wights did a number on a certain dwarf lord hehe.


I don't have any experience in 6th or 7th edition, but so far I have played 6 total games in 8th edition. The first 2 games I lost, and I lost so bad that I thought VC was rediculously underpowered and I wanted a new army.

...then I remembered how to play.

I think I built a few strong lists which compliment how I play, and I've won all 4 of the last 4 games I've played vs skaven, HE, gobbos, and dwarves. (battle reports to come! ...maybe... if I can remember them... :P) And that last game vs the dwarves I miscasted and lost my general on the first turn casting VHD... and still won! lol

If I win my next game vs Brets I'll pretty much be top dog at our local gaming store so this leaves me to believe we are still superpowerful.
 
It's always funny to see these threads on any forum.

The people you are complaining about are probably on average about 13 years old.

It's like going to the public pool in the summer and complaining that some kid took a dump in the deep end. What did you think was going to happen?
 
There are always the old grognards as well,who bemoan any change in edition on the basis of some nostalgic sense of rightness they developed when first exposed.
I started with Mordheim and was leery about moving up to WHFB b/c of the big units.I was looking to reproduce an experience.I think this is hands down the best edition yet,and hopefully the next will be better than this one.
Now if you'll excuse me,I have to go sacrifice a chicken to GW.
 
...or it is just that we're not having fun anymore. Just because I do something now, doesn't mean I am going to do it tomorrow out of habit. Much like I don't listen to the same music anymore. Today I couldn't care less what label I am given and that is just what fantasy did, it "sold out". xD I don't recognise the game I've come to know and love anymore. I kept trying to convince myself the new changes were "fun" but it is hard to lie to yourself.

The transition from 7th to 8th is quite huge. Almost a new game. Big changes all attract and alienate players, that's just how it goes.

I don't think VC are nerfed though, if by nerfed you mean a weak army. They're certainly not as powerful but that is a good thing.
 
I personally dont believe games workshop ever sold out on anything. In this I know alot of people disagree with me, but I stick to my conviction as someone who has followed all games workshop games since first edition warhammer, whos father raised me around it. In 8th edition I see a big return to the warhammer (1st edition) that I am used to, in a good way. I practically worship GW as the best miniature wargaming company in the world, and I have faith in the decisions they make, and understand that they are a corporation that needs to make a profit to exist.
In the end, we are stuck with Games Workshop if we want to play warhammer, and short of creating homebrew rules, creating our own game systems or joining the company and becoming a rules writer, or providing feedback to games workshop, we cannot change the content they give us.
 
No, that wasn't what I meant. It was more tied with my music analogy. Find band, love band, band change, you don't feel it anymore and move on onto other things. For me, I'm returning to 40k as finally, my only 40k army has got a new dex. In the end, who knows, I might get lured back in.
 
I'm a bit schizophrenic about 8th edition. I do think it's better than 7th edition and I enjoy playing it BUT I do find that VC are a lot worse off than the majority of armies. Not nerfed but certainly toned down a whole lot. I still enjoy playing my VC but I find myself getting out my my Skaven and even my old horribly looking DE army a lot more whereas Undead have been my number one army for years on end.
I don't play cheesy or really powerful armies anyway as I'm more of a fluff-list kind of guy but I do notice that playing VC have been less fun for me. VC need a serious update but to be fair there are a lot more armies who have been waiting for far longer.

Maybe it's got more to do with the fluff than the actual rules. I've found both Fantasy and 40K to have become too bland for my tastes. GW is trying to put more characterful units back into the game now but the damage they have wrought is hard to undo. Yes I'm talking about the bloodlines for vamps and don't get me started on the CSM in 40K who are now bland traitor marines and la-dee-dah where have the Legions gone too?
I guess that's what bothers me the most, and yes they are improving and updating, but that's just it; when you have a nice themed list going on a new edition comes out and you're pretty much stuck with an useless army that is still fun fluff-wise but so toned down that playing it too much gets boring. It happened to me thrice now and it's getting annoying.

Love some of the changes but dislike others and it just so happens that a majority of the armies I play always feel sort of stuck between changes.
 
Sorry rocdocta but the Black Coach absorbs any dice now that roll a 6 regardless of location, the vampire errata was very informing. :P
Manfred hero level got the entire lore of vamps also. :)

Why set a lord to restrain BK?
Set a cheap 75 point WK in there instead on a stead and your laughing due to you LD 9 hero. ;)

I agree, hordes of Ghouls Now win the game and in my opinion counter the weaker magic aspect now your limited no matter the size of your army, still annoyed I have to roll to cast bound spells. :(

Mindrazor is great but useless on Zombies, though to stick a high leadership character in there but it does not work like that, its each models LD not the highest in the units.
Thats why it lists it just as Models which kind of sucks and I was disappointed to find out but I suppose you can't have everything. :P

I love BK but it makes me sad I never use them, instead I use black knights, half the price and same armours plus killing blow is hard to say no. :P



One thing I think they went to far with was the new lores and common magical, yes they are good but just to powerful, I have yet to not take the dragonbane gem when fighting skulltaker, 5 points for a 2+ ward on any fire attack?.... YES PLEASE! :D




I agree entirly about zombies, underpowered and over priced.
You say they are not and people use rat slaves to compare, then again they get fear and are immune compared to the rat slaves who WILL run but you know what else is 4 points?
Chaos Marauders and tell me the pricing is fair when you compare the 2.

I love it when people tell me undead are weak, I have nothing with less than toughness 4 in my army (I am a ghoul whore). :P

I think I will start doing more converting work now rather than just building an army, feels like time to mess around a bit. ;)

Beastmen can be a pain but thats because they are combat based and you have no range to take advantage of their poor armour and have low Initiative. (even though we do have screaming skull catapults in the Vampire Wars book) :(
You have to try and out magic them while holding them in place with cheap units.



In the whole I don't believe they did sell out with perhaps the exception of LOTR however looking at some thjings I wish they did.
The new movie for ultra marines in fact, the graphics are terrible, I wish they made something more like the cinematic start for Warhammer Online, that was 110% EPIC!


I find that Alot of the glory players who just want to win have went over to WoC again with their stupid combat power and 4 lores but will always be a VC.
Spent a entire year losing 90% of my matches before I got the hang of it but now I slaughter in almost every match and provided its a fun match I could not care less if I lost. :)


Bloodlines?
You mean when I could have a combat or a magic vamp that was good at one thing instead of being half ar*ed?
Put a vamp hero or even lore against a chaos hero and 90% of the time you are going to be scooping him right back up. :(
 
While often upsetting,I find changes like this are needed to keep the gaming world alive and interesting.Look at how much buzz it's caused,plus a new ruleset turns the tables and allows armies that were previously shitty to have a fighting chance.Taking the established powerbuilds down a notch or two is only natural but all the gamers out there who's favorite armies are weakened will feel slighted.
It's sort of like the tides of war and reminds me of the rise and fall of empires.
For instance,I hate that lone models on foot no longer have 360 vision,and the TLOS thing is still a little awkward,especially with conversions and modified bases.
If your conversion is really tall or mounted on a rock or something,do you use the modified visibility? or go with some other established standard?
That being the case if you had a unit of zombies all crawling head and shoulders out of the ground,could it sneak real good?
I could site more examples but you get the drift.I also have to note that all this controversy and speculation is the afteraffect of the the new edition.Since I enjoy the game so,I just view it as a challenge,like a scenario with modified conditions and try to make the best of it.
It's like the game is on steroids now and the stakes have been raised.I love the fact that 25% core is required,the big units give the game a much more epic feel.
I am a big fan of steadfast even though it gives VC the pickle.Multiple rounds of combat and attrition are exciting,the body count stacks up.
I was engaged with a big block of orc boyz yesterday with my VL and 3 wraiths and a banshee to the front 2 wind summoned hosts on one flank and a flying horror thrall to it's rear,he was steadfast b/c I had no ranks and the BSB was nearby and stuck in,so he had rerolls.They were hacked to death where they stood over 4 rounds of combat,there were 30 when it started.By the old rules they would have broke on the first turn when I combo charged with the VL(RF/IH/WD-SOstrife/AOdestiny/TOL)
and the wraith unit,dealing 10 wounds and taking none gives them a rerollable bid for insane courage.good luck.Even though it was grinding and I would have been better off in 7th just smashing through,I enjoyed it more.I guess I'm just a hands on person who would rather murder you personally....call me sentimental.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu