Aesthetic or Performance?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Aesthetic or Performance?

  • Aesthetic

    Votes: 51 82.3%
  • Performance

    Votes: 11 17.7%

  • Total voters
    62
  • Poll votes is visible for users with special permission.

Blutsauger

Vampire Count
True Blood
Apr 10, 2013
1,089
Zombies
806
I think we can all agree that some models look much better than others. And I think we can also agree that some models perform better than others on the table-top. It's a happy coincidence when the best looking models also perform well, but just as often the opposite is true: the best looking models are outshone on the table top by their uglier competitors.

To further complicate the issue we all have our own personal bias, so sometimes we love the models generally considered to be ugly, and hate the ones that everyone else love!

So when you're faced with the choice, which is more important to you? Do you take the models you love, even though you know they'll struggle to perform? Or do you take the models that you know will perform well, even though you don't particularly like them?
 
Blutsauger said:
I think we can all agree that some models look much better than others. And I think we can also agree that some models perform better than others on the table-top. It's a happy coincidence when the best looking models also perform well, but just as often the opposite is true: the best looking models are outshone on the table top by their uglier competitors.

To further complicate the issue we all have our own personal bias, so sometimes we love the models generally considered to be ugly, and hate the ones that everyone else love!

So when you're faced with the choice, which is more important to you? Do you take the models you love, even though you know they'll struggle to perform? Or do you take the models that you know will perform well, even though you don't particularly like them?

I would never take model I thought looked like crap. If it was exceptionally bad I used to just convert my own. I am such a purist on aesthetics that I don't consider a non painted army "an army", it's just a bunch of plastic and metal imo. Since I have never played against a painted army I never lost a game of warhammer either. xD
 
I tend to include models more for the lists performance but aesthetics are still a big factor. Just not quite as big to me as performance . I think "theme" can be a major factor and be a separate choice on the poll. Some models may be cooler looking or better but may not fit into your army's theme properly.
 
Aesthetic is more important most of the time for me. And like others I convert of fin count as models when in need. For example, I hate the GW mangler squigs, so I built my own from scratch, and finding cool looking vampires from the GW range proved too hard so I turned to Privateer Press and Avatars of War.
 
Although I may come from the biased point of view that I don't actually play the Table top game, but personally aesthetic is the most important thing, there's nothing like a pwetty model

*but I guess if we were to game we would balance it, we could have to include some less amazingly good looking models if merely in lieu for the fact that we don't want to lose every single game :tongue:
 
Aesthetic all the way for me. I invest a lot of time and money on those models after all and they usually spend more time on the shelf than on the table top. So for me it's important that I like to look at them. Those ugly zombies I just move a bit more into the rear. ;)
 
the female model from the second link is very good.. reminds me of a "emotionally unstable super vampire" a bit like the witches from L4D
 
Although I have yet to paint a full army, I prefer personal taste over what is good. That said, my taste is also heavily influenced by what looks awesome, or inspires my imagination/cool ideas. I hear Abyssal Horrors are not very well played, but I plan on making more than one (It's like a monster frankenstien, I can convert anything I want into one?! YES PLEASE), and I have to make GG with shields for the sake of awesome. I probably won't ever run Varghiest (Ugly), and even though they are apparently not part of any competitive list anymore I still like Corpse Carts. Or at least I think they are dead to the world, tactics wise.

When I played Eldar in 40k, I ran a nearly 50-70% sniper army, because I loved that Craftworld the best, and let me tell you what doesn't win games.. armys of snipers!

But I have always been use to losing, either to my poor use of tactics, or bringing bad models to the board (Stat wise); I kinda prefer losing, because at least if I go into it accepting of a loss, I can roll with it, and have fun playing the game (What little I do), where as I feel most players can get really butt-hurt, and sore over a loss which.. just ruins the game for me. I'd rather lose with a friendly/happy opponent than waste 2-3 hours listening to someone bitch about what's going wrong, and how ridiculously powerful X/Y/Z is and why it shouldn't be in the game. I really get far less appeal out of victory in this game.
 
For me, it depends on exactly how bad a nice model is (and how much I like the model), and how ugly a strong unit is. It can also depend on my army's theme.

As an example, I think my current 2000pt army would be stronger with a Lv4 VL/MN. However, my winged-SGK is my favourite model, so I'm determined to make him work (even if I have to make do with Lv2 casters as a result).
 
Hey Guys well i think that aesthetics is a division of viewpoint working with the characteristics of art and flavor with the development and admiration of beauty.Thanks!!
 
Looks are great and all but 9/10 times the model looks amazing but just isn't very good. I personally don't take aweful looking toys, but there are some awesome toys that I don't take because they aren't good. Mainly the Black Coach, The Zombie Dragon, Blood Knighs, the Corpse Cart. That's just from the Vamps side of things. I mean I can use some of the stuff as 'counts as' but it's not the same.
 
Definitely aesthetic. Some people play to win, and I understand that, but I got into this hobby by staring at 'eavy Metal paintjobs of brilliantly sculpted miniatures. My inspiration comes from seeing a great conversion, or fluff for a great-looking themed army, not from numbers and stats in a rulebook.
 
  • Like
Reactions: robtion
Count Darvaleth said:
Definitely aesthetic. Some people play to win, and I understand that, but I got into this hobby by staring at 'eavy Metal paintjobs of brilliantly sculpted miniatures. My inspiration comes from seeing a great conversion, or fluff for a great-looking themed army, not from numbers and stats in a rulebook.

Exactly the same for me. Aesthetics > performance. I play to win, but I enjoy the visual style of my army, and its theme and fluff, much more. It gives a more satisfying and rewarding feeling to have this great war host I assembled, painted, and made.
 
Now I'm not saying that Aesthetics aren't super important! They are, and that is easily 95% of why people start any army that they start! But I don't see a lot of people running Cair Wraits in units, Black Coaches, Blood Knights, Corpse Carts, Zombie Dragons, Ghoul Kings on TG's, Most of the special characters? Is it because the models are horrible? Deffinetly not! Instead it's because they're pretty bad in game!

Vlad - Way to point heavy, but that model is sweet! Minus the shoulder spike of course
Krell - Again way to point heavy!
Kemmler - I've seen him ran but not often. He looks like Ivan Ooze from the Power Rangers movie! How is that not cool!
Isabella - I don't think I have ever seen her in a list .. Like not ever. She has frilly panties, Nuff said.
Konrad - He's a sweet model and fun to play with but too unreliable
Cair Wraiths - They don't make sense being in a unit of ghouls or Grave guard, Their fluff shows them in their own unit, yet their never ran.
Black Coaches - There are too many other good rare choices
Blood Knights - Same as above
Corpse Carts - Just bad, But the models are sooo good!
Zombie Dragons - Big, Bad, Scary undead dragon! yet their huge targets, and no body wants their general getting cannon ball murdered turn 1.
SGK on TG - Same as above, except more squishy


If I wasn't worried about the look of my army then I just wouldn't paint them, But everyone likes to win and that is why these models don't often get played. Especially by the more expirienced players.
 
I'm going with aesthetics. I've never been a tournament player I'd rather make friends play fluffy armies and have fun at the gaming table instead of trying to grind them into dust with a super awesome powerful cheese list
 
I've seen Cairn Wraiths and Corpse Carts both run quite a bit, and you have to look at the units that are run as well as not to make a fair assumption - Hexwraiths, Black Knights, Terrorgheists, Vargheists, Grave Guard - these are all sweet looking models as well.

The only models in VC I find displeasing are the zombies and dire wolves. And most people just convert their zombies, or have some cool unit filler etc. And the characters, the only decent looking one is Konrad. The GW vampires are - to me - awful.
 
Definitely aesthetics for me. It is the reason why I started gaming all those years ago in the first place. I actually started of just painting a few models and the gaming part came three months later.

If I hate a model I won't buy it no matter how good its stats might be. That said I might look into a nice conversion that suits my tastes better.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu