Always Strike First Rule

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

gilliek

Zombie
May 11, 2009
42
Zombies
49
Have been playing High Elves alot lately and have been struggling. Was wondering, with their ASF rule, even when i charge they get to strike first. But how about if i charge, and then in my magic phase Cast Van Hels or use the corpse cart bound spell? Do i then get to strike first as i charged? Or does it go on Initiative Order? And how about in consecutive rounds of combat? Im sure in consectutive rounds if i cast ASF and they have it as well its initiative order, but what about when i charge? Gillie
 
The rulebook covers this pretty clearly already. If two ASF meet, it goes down to initiative orders (charging momentum is ignored) which means that the elves will pretty much always get to strike first against you, no matter what you do. Same thing in consecutive rounds of combat. So don't even try, it's a waste of effort. :tongue:
 
ASF always goes in initative order if you both have it, sadly. Thus, outside of our vampires, nearly all elves will always go before us :( Charging does not make a difference.

You need stuff that goes before fighting - impact hits - or can't be effected by the high elves - Ethereal units. Another route is to get tough well armoured troops who the elves will have trouble killing.

Edit:- Beaten to it by Masterspark
 
MasterSpark said:
The rulebook covers this pretty clearly already. If two ASF meet, it goes down to initiative orders (charging momentum is ignored) which means that the elves will pretty much always get to strike first against you, no matter what you do. Same thing in consecutive rounds of combat. So don't even try, it's a waste of effort. :tongue:

If you have the same Initative value then you roll off for the ASF. That is also an each round thing.

There is only one thing that strikes in combat (not counting impact hits) that hits before a High Elf without going to Initative. Doomseerker from the Slayer Army. Maybe that is why the game designers decided not to update that SOC list but did update the Daemons.
 
Technically, if I remember correctly from the BRB, if you both have ASF and equal initiative then the side that won the last round of combat goes first. If that was a draw as well *then* you dice off...
 
Paksos said:
Technically, if I remember correctly from the BRB, if you both have ASF and equal initiative then the side that won the last round of combat goes first. If that was a draw as well *then* you dice off...

Is that still in effect, or is that from 6th Edition?
 
MasterSpark said:
The rulebook covers this pretty clearly already. If two ASF meet, it goes down to initiative orders (charging momentum is ignored) which means that the elves will pretty much always get to strike first against you, no matter what you do. Same thing in consecutive rounds of combat. So don't even try, it's a waste of effort. :tongue:

Not quite.

While its true if both sides have ASF it goes on Initiative order charging happens BEFORE initiative.

The competing ASF rule says nothing about ignoring charging.

1) ASF trumps Charging

2) Charging trumps initiative.

An example:

Say there is a unit of Human Spearman lead by a character with ASF. They are charged by a a unit of Orcs.

How would the attacking order go?

1. ASF character
2. Charging Orcs
3. Human Spearman

The ASF rules does not negate charging but just goes before it.

Now lets say the charging Orcs have a character that has ASF too.

How would the attacking order go? Would the attacking Orc character now strike after the rest of the other Orcs (maybe after the defending Humans due to initiative?) because his ASF has been negated? No. He may not have ASF anymore but he is STILL charging.

Charging goes before initiative.

No wonder the OP is having problems with High Elves. VC are one of the few races that can deal with armywide ASF.
 
ASF does indeed to say ignore charging. And if that's not enough, the FAQ clarifies that with ASf vs ASF the ONLY thing that matters is Initiative. Really.
 
Count Flapula said:
ASF does indeed to say ignore charging. And if that's not enough, the FAQ clarifies that with ASf vs ASF the ONLY thing that matters is Initiative. Really.

The ASF rule does but not the rule concerning conflicting ASF.

I see the errata. What a bizarre ruling. As shown in my example. The Orcs by not having ASF strike earlier then they would before.

If fact its so strange, going to have to check into this further. Since most tournies I play DO NOT play it like this.

Bah! My mistake! So much for putting common sense into GWs rules!
 
Ha, surely you've been playing long enough to know that common sense and things like physics have no place in the rules?
 
I actually thought it made a lot of sense. If you and your enemy are that fast, charging is more likely to get you killed than holding your ground.

I think there was one edition in which Dark Elf Executioners got ASF for the turn they were charged, the reason being (well depicted in the Malus Darkblade series) was that they are trained to kill you the second you are about to strike them.


And I think I see where you're going wrong there Max; when ASF meets they don't actually cancel out, they simply go in initiative order (ignoring charging and Great Weapons). That's worked out, then chargers strike and then from there you go on normally.

VC are one of the few races that can deal with armywide ASF.
How exactly?
 
Kaladas Harkon said:
I actually thought it made a lot of sense. If you and your enemy are that fast, charging is more likely to get you killed than holding your ground.

I think there was one edition in which Dark Elf Executioners got ASF for the turn they were charged, the reason being (well depicted in the Malus Darkblade series) was that they are trained to kill you the second you are about to strike them.


And I think I see where you're going wrong there Max; when ASF meets they don't actually cancel out, they simply go in initiative order (ignoring charging and Great Weapons). That's worked out, then chargers strike and then from there you go on normally.

VC are one of the few races that can deal with armywide ASF.
How exactly?

Yeah I figured it all out now.

The way I played it before seeing the errata was:

Close combat as normal (ie charge, great weapons) for all ASF.

Then close combat for everyone else.

The ASF still went before everybody without ASF but still had to follow rules of charging and Great weapons against other ASF.

Great weapons striked last not because not because the people wielding them were slow but because they were big heavy weapons.

But none of that matters now have to follow the errata.
 
Max zero said:
The ASF still went before everybody without ASF but still had to follow rules of charging and Great weapons against other ASF.

Indeed, if you go back a year or two, you might find a thread where I noticed this and suggested that perhaps there was a way to defeat ASF, to allow our Zombies to strike before Swordmasters. The online community was divided, as short-sighted High Elf players insisted that initiative is the only thing that should ever count when two models with ASF fight. Eventually an FAQ was released that confirmed that we were right, and when you get ASF vs ASF, then you act like they don't have it. The High Elf players went mental and the ruling was actually officially reversed a couple of months later.

And then Dark Elves were released. They have an ASF banner, and the units that can take it have initiative higher than most High Elves, as do Assassins. So thanks to their incessant whining and getting the ruling reversed - all for the sake of Swordmasters never striking after Zombies - it meant that High Elves with ASF would now be striking after ASF Dark Elves, even when charged, even with great weapons.

As you might predict, the whining from those few High Elf players multiplied several times over at this fact. I had to smile a little :)
 
i played my first game vs high elves in the new edition of the game...not with my undead but with my WoC and i struggled big time. despite getting the charges off i took a rare hiding before i got to hit back. swordmasters and pheonix guard handed me my ar*e. i was thinking how my undead would fare against a similar army and im proberly going to go down the route of zombie spam them to death, raise piles of them and wade in, i'll die in droves but pin them down long enough for a flank charge and hopefully break them with outnumbering/fear. in combat i won't be risking them hitting any of my decent units or vampire bunkers, they'll carve through them.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu