Anti-Magic Umbrella: List Archetype?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Coyote

Black Knight
Aug 8, 2009
318
Zombies
273
So, as I've gotten back up to speed I've been hearing a consistant refrain: "We get owned by <insert magic-heavy army list here>! How can we fight this?" There's been some discussion about the idea of tipping the Winds of Magic in our favor, using one or more MotDA. I'd like to start a discussion to see if we could find a way to take things to the other extreme.

The core concept is to create an "umbrella" that ensures that we don't have to worry much about the enemy's Magic Phase. Doing this would allow out Fighty-Lord and WKs to shine. With the changes in Winds of Magic, the obvious threat is the number of Power Dice being thrown at us.
  • Black Coach gives us a lovely, if unpredictable, way to deal with this. Fielding 2x Black Coaches would allow us to force Power Dice to be rolled twice, reducing the enemy's average Winds roll from 7 to 5 Power Dice. But this requires a minimum of 1600pts, is variable, and only gets us to near parity between Power and Dispel Dice (5:4 vs. 7:4). (DUH. Thank you, Forge.)
  • I've previously suggested fielding lots of naked Necros (can't get that image out of my mind :slapface: ) in order to Channel lots of Dispel dice. This doesn't seem any more reliable than Black Coaches.
  • Another technique would be to field one ultra-Dispel-wizard. A Lvl 4 Vamp with a Staff of +1 Dispel would give us a base +5 to our Dispel rolls. But if the number of Dispel Dice are not in our favor, or if we flub an early Dispel roll, we're hosed.
  • Balefire Corpse Carts are nice. But at 100pts/-1 to cast, and a 24" radius, are they enough? Should we field a silly quantity?
What are your thoughts? Is there a way that we can build a list-archetype that shields us from the dread Purple Sun?
 
It also occurs to me that our core assumptions may be skewed. The old 2PD + 1-2PD/wizard kept magic to a minimum in lower points games. Now, we're seeing as many PD in 500pt games as in 3k. Is this causing us to assume that the Magic Phase is more important than it should be? Perhaps tournament point levels will go up for exactly this reason.
 
you dont roll the power dice pool twice for the black coach, its very specific in the army book, you randomize which coach gets the benefit. 6 Casters has done me well in getting ready for ard boys along with the black coach, i usually end up with more dispel dice then my opponent has power dice.
 
My original thought was to use Death magic to assassinate the enemy wizard. However I've yet to not miscast my first spell each game (including using only 2 dice a couple of times!!!!), thereby losing the rest of my casting pool! :suck:

A Vargulf could potentially do a better job without relying on magic, and since it can't be challenged, it can hit the wizard as long as it survives. Most wizards should be dealt with easily enough, but striking at I2 might be a problem.

Sadly, the Death and Shadows idea that I've been using just doesn't seem to work with as fast as movement is in 8th edition.

Still, I think that simply seeking and killing out the wizard is the best option.
 
Personally I think a combination of most of the above would work. The Black Coach is a great choice anyway so that, plus two CC with Balefires would really screw things over. -2 is a pretty decent modifier and would make most opponents choose an extra dice, good to reduce the enemy PD pool fast.

I would then suggest a Necro with the Feedback Scroll to hopefully take care of the enemy caster, especially if he is lord level. This would probably only leave hero level casters, which if you have the CC will be having a hard time getting spells off.
 
For 2400 points, this is what I've found.

For VC, I don't think you can do better than the coach for raw anti-magicness. It can be great for balancing out PD vs DD, if not skewing the balance in favour of defense.

I saw the most extreme example of this last night. My opponent rolled 3 for the pool, I channelled 1, he didn't. Coach ate 2, so I had 3DD to his solitary PD.

CC's are also great. Yes it costs 100 points, but it means that each of our casters can be one level lower than an opponent's caster (under CC influence) and be on par for casting/dispel bonus.

Toss in a 15 point staff, and our Necro is on par with a Lvl 3 for casting vs dispellage.

The frog scroll is also great for those low-level mages throwing lots of dice around.

None of this is news, but unless there's a lore with anti-magicness, there's not much else I can think of.
 
Good topic! Maybe we should classify what troop types would be good to have depending on what lord we choose? So far I´ve seen this:

Combat Lord
- Black coach
- Corpse carts
- Multiple necros with the new fancy scrolls
- Varghulfs

Caster Lord
- Level 4 caster

Missed anything?
 
ive used 2 Balefire corpse carts, its doesnt really do jack, it was REALLY good in the last edition because everything was a low casting, you didnt add your wizard level to everything and you could onlyuse 1 more dice then your power level so it was great against those level 1-2 wizards that everyone ran, but now its not very important. and for 200 points thats a varghulf that can go kill those wizards, or every defensive scroll in the book, thats how I think of it. and the corpse cart Always strikes first bound spell aint crap now that you have to waste power dice on it you might as well just cast vanhel's danse on your unit and get rerolls as well. i think the 200 points can be much better spent imo.
 
If you cast a lot of RIP spells then their magic phase is weakened if they use PD to dispel them.
 
This is one thing that I did notice after extensive use of lore of shadow. With all the remains in play spells in that lore my opponent had to use a lot of their power dice to stop all of the fun spells that were on his units.
 
One option is to have a sniper general (@445) and try to take down and distract enemy casters:

+1 magic level
forbidden lore (death)
hunter in the dark
dark acolyte

trickster's shard
talisman of the lycni
wristbands of black gold
nightshroud (in case he his charged by light troops) or spellshield
sword of battle (so he is also good at taking down war machines)

It's an all-in strategy and it requires some skill too, but it leaves considerable room to create combat-tailored heroes and should work well against skavens and elves.
 
Since the release of 8th, my all-comers list has morphed into a list that is described in this thread.

I typically play at 3000 point levels. I bring one Black Coach, two Balefire Corpse-Carts and two fighter type Vampire lords. I also bring etherals (wraiths).
The use of the Black Coach is great at reducing high-powered magic phases like those generated by High Elves and Demons. By leaching a few power dice a turn, these augmented magic phases are brought down to manageable levels that can be handled by a level 2 caster with the use of a few Balefire Corpse Carts.

In 8th edition some people claim that the Corpse Cart is just not worth the points, but I would like to disagree. The Corpse Cart's innate casting of the Miasma of Deathly Vigor is a huge buff for the undead. These carts are essential to defeating most enemies, and allow for a low level magic phase to exist and flourish. Throwing 4 or more dice to get this bound spell off is more than worth it, and will allow your lower level Vampire Casters some breathing room. (Corpse Carts do not miscast as the spell they cast is an innate ability. So making sure the Miasma of Deathly Vigor is cast is really important when fighting all the Elf armies, and will ruin a Dwarf players day. A 6 die cast of the Miasma of Deathly Vigor against a High Elf player will ruin the re-roll misses that the High Elves rely upon.)

This style of list is not going accommodate a wild and destructive magic phase, but it will frustrate anyone who is trying to do so. The truncation of the power dice pool by the Black Coach will make casters like Teclis wince at how difficult it will be to get more than a few spells off a turn, and if the VC player plays the odds, then possibly no spells will get played at all.
When you bring this style of list you will enjoy not placing your caster in perilous situations caused by the mis-cast table. Nothing is worse than losing a key component of your army to an over-reaching and greedy magic phase. Not to say that you will use no magic, but you will have to economize what you can cast and when you can cast it.

Bringing etheral units is really good in this style of list. With the reduction in power dice, most enemies will be placed in a predicament of how to deal with a troop type that is only affected by magic, and his magic is being hampered to the point of possibly only being able to get only one spell off. (The twin horns of the dilemma will force bad decisions. Shoot the Wraiths, or the Grave Guard is a predicament I would not want to be in.)

This style of list is a decent list but it has its problems. The lower powered nature of this style of VC casting phase will make units like Chariots, Giants, Abominations and other large nasties a problem. The problem being that these units are best defeated at range with missile or direct damage spells, and lower level casters are going to struggle to muster these ranged spells in the quantities needed to blow these problem units up.
 
I think that the following are essential, and every army should have them:

Black Coach - Nerfs your magic phase aswell, but that's ok since you can cast those needed spells multiple times, your opponents can't!!

Additional Magic lvl - An absolute must have for your lord, he's going to be doing the majority of your dispelling no matter what you do

Caster Lord - I hate caster lords, I like Combat Lords, but Caster lords just make soo much more sense. Since having a thrall caster nerfs your spells by 2 compared to a caster lord, also you've got the risk of your lord actually getting stomped and you crumbling.

Forbidden Lore (Death) - The ability to not only snipe opposing casters, but to also gain PD in the process is just insane imo. You can use 1PD and cast Caress / Spirit Leach at the end of the phase, and potentially get 2-3 PD back from each (To use for an extra IoN maybe). Even 2 dicing them is well worth it.

Corpse Cart + Balefire - Did have this as a bit lower on my list of priorities, but Stirogi has a good point. You can 1 dice a corpse cart's deathly misama, or 2 dice it whatever, it's not going to stop your vamp from still casting if you fail though. And remember that if they're equal/lower I than you, and you have ASF and they don't, you still get rerolls. But that your attacks will be simultaneous vs high elves or anything else with ASF (even if they have 10 I and you have 2 lol)

And then the optional ones

Skull Staff - +1 to casting / dispelling. imo a good option, but could be wasted points if you have enough magic to control the phases anyway.

Dark Acolyte - imo not worth it unless you're running 2 lords, as after MotDA you're still only packing 4x random spells.

Dispell Scroll - Handy for a necro or thrall. No point in giving to a lord imo, as a wand of jet or scepter of stability would just be better, since they'll save your arse when you definitely need it.

Feedback Scroll - These working or not would depend alot on your opponent. If they're smart, you'll never gain much out of it, maybe 1-2 wounds max. Since if they're throwing lots of dice at a spell, that means you probably really really don't want it to go off lol, so will try to dispell it instead. If they don't throw a lot of dice at it, you won't kill their character, and they'll likely have some way to regain their hp next turn (Maybe even same turn if lore of life). If they're stupid, and just throw their last 5 dice at a puny magic missile or something, then you were probably going to smash them anyway lol.

Hex Scroll - Could be good if it's backed up with lore of death to snipe them while their stats are low. But if they're a lvl 4 wizard, then it's only to go off 1/3 times, so it's not that reliable, thus imo it's not worth using up the arcane slot unless you're using necro spam tactic.


Remember as well, that you only get 1x arcane magic item per character, and only vamps / necros can carry them. So you have to be really picky on which items to take.

I do also like the idea of using your Varghulf to just hunt mages once he's finished off any war machines. Although I would be concerned about him, since he can't challenge a character, so he has to be in base contact (which means he can't flank / rear charge), he's often going to die before he gets to actually attack them. Probably best to just maximise his +1 flank +1 charge bonus by hitting an existing combat, although his terror spam might be handy for units outside BSB / Lord range once warmachines are down.
 
Wow. Touched a nerve. I really appreciate everyone's feedback and comments. I think the concept is getting somewhere.

So to pick-up where Mikael left off, the archetype presently looks like this:
  • Black Coach - Removes 1 in 6 Power Dice every Magic Phase. For 200pts, we begin to tip the balence in our favor.
  • A Balefire Corpse Cart - I'm not sure that I can justify two. But one makes good sense, since the Miasma is likely to be under- or over- estimated. And now you've essentially reduced all opposing Wizards by 1 level for casting.
  • Dispel Lord - A Lvl 3, or better yet Lvl 4, General that is your go-to-guy for Dispel rolls. Maybe give him Wand of Jet or Skull Staff for extra juice.
    • I'm torn as to whether to recommend Dark Acolyte or MotDA here. Lvl 4 grants 1 spell and +1 to cast/dispel. MotDA is +2 PD in our phase (which are subject to the Coach and the 12 PD limit). I think it may depend on whether you go with Lore of Vamps or Forbidden Lore.
  • One Dispel Scroll - Somewhere. Always a good thing for the one spell that you CAN'T let through. Maybe best on a Necro, since he can double on Dispel duty if your Lord fumbles a Dispel roll.
  • A Mage Hunter - Nothing nukes the opposing Magic Phase like killing his mage. Varghulfs seem to be the concensus ATM. At least for All-Comers lists. Some have suggested a sniper-wizard that uses FL(Death). This seems less reliable. Maybe taking FL(Death) on the Dispel Lord gives us that option.
What this Archetype let's us do:
  • Field Combat Characters - We all love 'em. Well, most of us. But the current magic-heavy environment makes this really difficult.
  • Field Etherals - With an "Umbrella" over their heads, some of our most feared units make a lot of sense.
  • We Own the Night - ...or at least the Magic Phase. By tipping the ratio of Power Dice to Dispel Dice in our favor, first with the Coach and then with MotBA, we do something every general wants. Take the opponent off balence and out of their comfort zone.
Great stuff. We're currently looking at this not being viable in lists <1500k points, so I'd be VERY interested in playtest results from smaller games. Let's keep this thread current, as we all dig deeper into 8th ed. Thanks, all!
 
I'm not all that sure that channeling through caster spam is something we ought to be trying too hard for.

If a caster survives until the 6th turn magic phase, we can expect each caster to channel one PD and one DD in the game.

Two casters have a 3/36 chance of channeling at least one PD or DD each phase.

One caster with the channeling staff has a 1/3 chance of channeling a PD or DD each phase. Your odds are 4 times better, and you can pocket the points spent on the second necromancer and get half a core unit.
 
What about the black periapt? You can save power dice to go into the dispel phase which might be useful...

I am going to try the +5 cast / dispel lord in my next game against my mates grey seer... I hadnt even thought of how that coupled with a balefire corpse cart and the periapt might help me tip the magic phase in my favour...

Then again it will be 6 dice on 13th spell every phase regardless...
 
Coyote said:
Wow. Touched a nerve. I really appreciate everyone's feedback and comments. I think the concept is getting somewhere.

So to pick-up where Mikael left off, the archetype presently looks like this:
  • Black Coach - Removes 1 in 6 Power Dice every Magic Phase. For 200pts, we begin to tip the balence in our favor.
  • A Balefire Corpse Cart - I'm not sure that I can justify two. But one makes good sense, since the Miasma is likely to be under- or over- estimated. And now you've essentially reduced all opposing Wizards by 1 level for casting.
  • Dispel Lord - A Lvl 3, or better yet Lvl 4, General that is your go-to-guy for Dispel rolls. Maybe give him Wand of Jet or Skull Staff for extra juice.
    • I'm torn as to whether to recommend Dark Acolyte or MotDA here. Lvl 4 grants 1 spell and +1 to cast/dispel. MotDA is +2 PD in our phase (which are subject to the Coach and the 12 PD limit). I think it may depend on whether you go with Lore of Vamps or Forbidden Lore.
  • One Dispel Scroll - Somewhere. Always a good thing for the one spell that you CAN'T let through. Maybe best on a Necro, since he can double on Dispel duty if your Lord fumbles a Dispel roll.
  • A Mage Hunter - Nothing nukes the opposing Magic Phase like killing his mage. Varghulfs seem to be the concensus ATM. At least for All-Comers lists. Some have suggested a sniper-wizard that uses FL(Death). This seems less reliable. Maybe taking FL(Death) on the Dispel Lord gives us that option.
What this Archetype let's us do:
  • Field Combat Characters - We all love 'em. Well, most of us. But the current magic-heavy environment makes this really difficult.
  • Field Etherals - With an "Umbrella" over their heads, some of our most feared units make a lot of sense.
  • We Own the Night - ...or at least the Magic Phase. By tipping the ratio of Power Dice to Dispel Dice in our favor, first with the Coach and then with MotBA, we do something every general wants. Take the opponent off balence and out of their comfort zone.
Great stuff. We're currently looking at this not being viable in lists <1500k points, so I'd be VERY interested in playtest results from smaller games. Let's keep this thread current, as we all dig deeper into 8th ed. Thanks, all!

Why take an item that gives you extra power dice and then take another item that removes these dice?
Fielding a Black Coach and a model with MotBA, an all ready pricey ability, is a misalignment of points. Sure you could argue that an increase in pool size is justifiable, but at what cost? MotBA is a large chunk of a Vampire's cost that is only going see any return if the recalcitrant coach decides to leave these dice alone.

From first hand experience, I can say that two Balefires and one Black Coach has shut down some potent magic phases; I have prevented Thanquol from getting off all but one spell in a 6 turn game. This was done with a level-2 caster, mind you. While a magic level upgrade is by far cheaper than a Balefire Corpse Cart, the cart can spam the Miasma of Deathly Vigor without problems of the miscast chart.

I agree very much that this kind of magical defense is great for fielding our rare choices and fighter characters. Not only will Wraiths benefit, but Blood Knights will be able use more aggressive banners and items.
 
One other thing to consider is the Staff of Sorcery. DA+ the Staff gives you the same dispelling power as buying an extra level, and if you're already going Forbidden Lore, you don't really care much about getting 'that spell'.

It also frees up more points for your second lord, if you're going that way.
 
I have found that at 2000pts a LvL 4 Lord with Skull staff, Summon Ghouls and MOTBA is very effective at forcing through spells and blocking magic in their turn. I usualy back this up with a Vampire hero with MOTBA, Scepter Du Noirot and a Black Periapt and a Necro with a dispel scroll.

The general plan is to let him cast most damage spells and only worry about remains in play spells or things like Drain Magic. I own my magic phase, since even against a LvL 4 dispeling wizard, on two dice I am about 2/3 odds on favourite. I usualy open with Curse of years if I can in each of my phases, as the trend towards huge units makes this spell a must dispel. My lord casts it on 3+ using 2 dice and generaly my opponent will need to use 3-4 dice+ to have good odds of dispeling. This combines with MOTBA to give me a huge advantage in power dice, which lets me cast Summon Undead Horde and multicast IoN and Vanhels.

My opponent now faces an enormous horde of undead. He can't hope to kill them all unless he devotes magic to the task. However, my lord gets +5 to dispel, and if necessary, can store a die from his phase, since he is so far ahead there. These advantages combine to make it relatively easy to fend off magcal attack. My only real worries are miscasting/failing to cast with my Lord, and Death Magic (character Sniping is a pain). However, since only Summon Undead Horde or Winds of Undeath ever require more than 2 dice, I rarely have more than a 1/36 chance of Miscast, and similarly, Curse of Years and below all cast on a 3+, so on 2 dice, failing to cast is only a 1/36 chance. Death magic is a real issue as most of the spells are potentialy game over, however, provided my Lord has a ward save, his high stats are generaly enough of a defense.
 
Mannfred + Skull Staff + Book of Ashur. +6 to cast and dispel. It seems like you would crush your opponent's magic phase pretty hard as long as you don't completely whiff a dispel roll. Plus, you can usually safely dispel things with fewer dice if you field this guy.
 
true that bravo 10. although some will argue bout the book not being from the actual artefacts of death list...

nevertheless... your opponent will totally waste his DD before you can finish PD then sneak in some damage dealing Lore of Death spells.. i like PURPLE SUN! or Bjuna's.
and maybe gain back 2-3PD at worst... (assuming worst is not a misfire on the artillery dice).. then totally spam that vanhels, or get off a curse of years, or summon undead horse... i mean horde...

just make sure to cover him real good cuz 5 wounds isnt just 5 wounds with VC...
 
Yeah, so do I, Balleflass. But I don't want to start this debate again. I feel perfectly legitimate with fielding Mannfred this way, but others don't, and they don't have to. Plus, some people don't use special characters like Konrad or Mannfred at all.

But think of +6 to cast/dispel along with the magic-strangling powers of the Black Coach. Fun stuff!
 
If you're strictly focusing on magic defense, you could just go Skullstaff+Staff of Sorcery for the +6 to dispell and save you some points.

Personal favorite Manny load-out: Skullstaff+Crimson Gem of lamhia. Lotsa dice and a solid +5 to all of your spells.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu