Anybody use grave guard anymore?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Vipoid said:
Well, I think one of the issues is that most wizards are stupidly undercosted at the moment. Lv4s in particular just seem ludicrously cheap at ~200pts base for many armies. The +4 to dispel alone is probably worth a good chunk of that, then they have versatility, and the ability to affect enemy and friendly units at range. Finally, with the current #6 spells, they can basically play football with a sphere of annihilation. :slapface:

TBH I don't think its the wizards that are undercosted but rather the magic lores don't just support a army, they decide how a game will end more often than. They got psykers right in 40k, I think magic needs to go more in that direction, I don't know why the designers think you need spells that can remove whole units, it isn't fun.

With a Wight king more often than not I find myself wondering if a bunch of extra graveguard would be a better investment than a few extra attacks.

That would certainly be nice. Lt would also be useful if our lords didn't explode from CR (at least, not as easily as zombies).

Vampire Lord - "Well, I've cut a couple of them down like vermin, and they've yet to scratch me. Looks like I've got this one... OH DEAR GOD - RANKS! RANKS!! AND A BANNER. ARRRRAGH!" :grave:

Well maybe they will fix it next edition, rumors seem to suggest it won't be all that long until we get 9th ed, fingers crossed! I still like the current book, it's just a shame the rules are designed to shift those new shinny kits. I would rather the rules be designed to shift all the models ;)
 
I usually rock a unit of 38 GG w/GW and banner of barrows in horde formation, usually put 2 wight kings in there and I'm usually top 4 in all tourneys I play in, I also bring two terrorghiests to deal with monsterious cav, I don't take any vampiric units/characters and usually rock 2 Lvl 4 necros one on death, black peript and a Lvl 1 scroll caddy. 2x35 skeletons, 2x30 zombies and 2x5 dogs, the graveguard wreck face after their targets have been weakened up a bit with magic. Worst opponent for them is a troll horde though.
 
logan054 said:
I don't know why the designers think you need spells that can remove whole units

It was a pretty obvious design intent with 8th edition. Make huge units ultra powerful, then give those huge units an achilles heel with spells like Purple Sun.
 
Blutsauger said:
It was a pretty obvious design intent with 8th edition. Make huge units ultra powerful, then give those huge units an achilles heel with spells like Purple Sun.

Yep, problem is it doesn't just work on big units, so it's a flawed designed that over powers single models.
 
logan054 said:
TBH I don't think its the wizards that are undercosted but rather the magic lores don't just support a army, they decide how a game will end more often than. They got psykers right in 40k, I think magic needs to go more in that direction, I don't know why the designers think you need spells that can remove whole units, it isn't fun.

I think that's definitely part of the problem. As it stands, the BRB magic lores are far too strong, compared to the army lores.

But, even then, mages seem dubiously priced. Let's say we have player A and player B. Player A buys a 200pt Lv4 wizard, whilst player B buys 2 100pt lv2 wizards. So, both players wizards know a total of 4 spells. However, player A's wizard is getting +4 to cast each of his spells, and +4 to dispel each of player B's spells. On the other hand, player B is getting only +2 to cast each of his spells, and +2 to dispel each of his opponent's spells. That's a hell of a difference. And, it's not as if player A spent any more points on his magic phase than player B - they both spent 200pts.

I think the real problem is wizards adding their wizard level to the dice, and the fact that channelling is unreliable and rarely doe anything (so, there's a huge bonus for having a single, high-level wizard; but virtually no gain if you instead spend the points on several Lv1 or 2 wizards).

logan054 said:
With a Wight king more often than not I find myself wondering if a bunch of extra graveguard would be a better investment than a few extra attacks.

Sadly, that's probably the case. Unless you need your wight king as a bodyguard for a vampire (with Nightshroud), or for a magic banner, there's not much he can do that more GG couldn't do better.

logan054 said:
Well maybe they will fix it next edition, rumors seem to suggest it won't be all that long until we get 9th ed, fingers crossed! I still like the current book, it's just a shame the rules are designed to shift those new shinny kits. I would rather the rules be designed to shift all the models ;)

I agree.

I have to say, I am interested to see what 9th will bring.

Blutsauger said:
It was a pretty obvious design intent with 8th edition. Make huge units ultra powerful, then give those huge units an achilles heel with spells like Purple Sun.

I'm not so sure that's an Achilles' heel, so much as both of Achilles' legs and his entire torso.
 
Vipoid said:
I think that's definitely part of the problem. As it stands, the BRB magic lores are far too strong, compared to the army lores.

But, even then, mages seem dubiously priced. Let's say we have player A and player B. Player A buys a 200pt Lv4 wizard, whilst player B buys 2 100pt lv2 wizards. So, both players wizards know a total of 4 spells. However, player A's wizard is getting +4 to cast each of his spells, and +4 to dispel each of player B's spells. On the other hand, player B is getting only +2 to cast each of his spells, and +2 to dispel each of his opponent's spells. That's a hell of a difference. And, it's not as if player A spent any more points on his magic phase than player B - they both spent 200pts.

I think the real problem is wizards adding their wizard level to the dice, and the fact that channelling is unreliable and rarely doe anything (so, there's a huge bonus for having a single, high-level wizard; but virtually no gain if you instead spend the points on several Lv1 or 2 wizards).

I certainly agree that adding your level to your casting roll is a big problem, I think how they did it in 4th/5th was far better, simply getting +1 to your roll for being a higher level. I actually like the idea that you don't need to spam wizards in order to have a decent magic phase, remember in 6th/7th you always have to spent your entire character allowance to have a decent magic defense. I do the advantages of having several lvl2 over a single level 4, the first being that you can multiple arcane items, the 2nd being you can have spells from different lores rather than being forces to take all your spells from one lore.

Sadly, that's probably the case. Unless you need your wight king as a bodyguard for a vampire (with Nightshroud), or for a magic banner, there's not much he can do that more GG couldn't do better.

Well exactly, and for his points, your paying a lot for a W3 model (which is cool on a hero) is only going to add 2 additional attacks at the same strength. He would probably be a lot more useful if he could still have sword of kings (if it granted HKB). With my WoC army I can't say KB really bothers me, it effects one unit (which wouldn't get a save anyway) and one character in the army, the rest is all immune.

I agree.

I have to say, I am interested to see what 9th will bring.

Well if they start reducing the amount of rerolls in the game (like from ASF and magic) I think we would be heading in the right direction :)
 
logan054 said:
I certainly agree that adding your level to your casting roll is a big problem, I think how they did it in 4th/5th was far better, simply getting +1 to your roll for being a higher level.

That does sound better.

Another possibility would be if wizards deducted their level from the casting value of a spell, instead of adding it to the casting or dispelling dice. So, higher level wizards can cast spells more easily (potentially with fewer dice), but don't have a big advantage over lower level wizards when it comes to dispelling.

logan054 said:
I actually like the idea that you don't need to spam wizards in order to have a decent magic phase, remember in 6th/7th you always have to spent your entire character allowance to have a decent magic defense.

I agree, but then I think the gulf between a single lv4 and multiple lv2s is just too wide at the moment.

logan054 said:
I do the advantages of having several lvl2 over a single level 4, the first being that you can multiple arcane items, the 2nd being you can have spells from different lores rather than being forces to take all your spells from one lore.

That's true, but then the Lv4 can afford arcane items over 50pts (e.g. Black Periapt, Book of Hoeth), and/or have an arcane item and some protection.

logan054 said:
Well exactly, and for his points, your paying a lot for a W3 model (which is cool on a hero) is only going to add 2 additional attacks at the same strength. He would probably be a lot more useful if he could still have sword of kings (if it granted HKB). With my WoC army I can't say KB really bothers me, it effects one unit (which wouldn't get a save anyway) and one character in the army, the rest is all immune.

I think the wight king needs either some better melee stuff (so that your opponent may be unwilling to just ignore him to death), or some sort of buff ability.

With regard to killing blow, I think the rule itself needs a change (mainly because of all the monstrous stuff that's been added):

Killing Blow - any roll to-wound of 6 ignores armour saves.

Heroic Killing Blow - Any roll to-wound of 6 ignores armour saves, and target successfully wounded is killed outright.

Essentially, killing blow now works on all targets (not just infantry and cavalry), but only can only kill 1-wound models outright. HKB stays the same.

logan054 said:
Well if they start reducing the amount of rerolls in the game (like from ASF and magic) I think we would be heading in the right direction :)

Rerolls do seem a bit too easy to obtain for a lot of armies at the moment.

I'd quite like to see some more interesting items - like some higher end weapons with a bit more creativity than +3A or +3S.
 
Vipoid said:
That does sound better.

Another possibility would be if wizards deducted their level from the casting value of a spell, instead of adding it to the casting or dispelling dice. So, higher level wizards can cast spells more easily (potentially with fewer dice), but don't have a big advantage over lower level wizards when it comes to dispelling.

Well that sounds cool as well, whatever really something would need to be done to make a lvl4 seem less like the auto include it does now to many.

I agree, but then I think the gulf between a single lv4 and multiple lv2s is just too wide at the moment.

Depends on the game, if your playing one of those games when someone is just throwing 6 dice at a mega spell it probably isn't going to make all that much of difference.


That's true, but then the Lv4 can afford arcane items over 50pts (e.g. Black Periapt, Book of Hoeth), and/or have an arcane item and some protection.

Well thats certainly true, but say with VC it would allow you to include of the cheaper bounds spells rather than having to simply pick one, it situational really.

I think the wight king needs either some better melee stuff (so that your opponent may be unwilling to just ignore him to death), or some sort of buff ability.

With regard to killing blow, I think the rule itself needs a change (mainly because of all the monstrous stuff that's been added):

Killing Blow - any roll to-wound of 6 ignores armour saves.

Heroic Killing Blow - Any roll to-wound of 6 ignores armour saves, and target successfully wounded is killed outright.

Essentially, killing blow now works on all targets (not just infantry and cavalry), but only can only kill 1-wound models outright. HKB stays the same.

Some kind of buff while in grave guard would be the way to go rather than having the grave guard buff him if they have a certain banner, hell even using his WS would be cool!

I don't see a issue with how KB itself work, it would be nice if normal killing blow did something against larger targets, it would also be nice if HKB was more effective against smaller targets.

Rerolls do seem a bit too easy to obtain for a lot of armies at the moment.

I'd quite like to see some more interesting items - like some higher end weapons with a bit more creativity than +3A or +3S.

Yeah and it's not pretty lol, especially when one of those ways happens to be lore of light, now that fun for the whole family.

More interesting magic items would be very cool, I would just be worried that it could lead back to hero hammer.
 
I'm now switching one unit of 8 CH to 36 GG. Wonder how they will do. I used to run 2x8CH and my blendy lord in ghoul horde and also 2x Banshee for anti 1+ AS units. This didn't however do much good as banshee screams are just not reliable enough. I found it hard to do any damage vs Empire or WoC. Also the only hard hitting vamp lord+ghouls bunker was always so obvious to the opponents and easy to block/counter/concentrate on. SO now by fielding 8 CH, 36 GG, 40 ghouls i get two possible bunkers for my Lord. But more importantly by putting the vamp lord into ghouls, and 1 or 2 Wight Kings into to GG horde i get 2 pretty killy blocks.

What do u think? Are the GG still worth it?
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu