Anyone else having still having severe problems with war machines post 8th?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Well.. he can actually target the mortis engine because he can see it. (a mortis engine is slightly large than a zombie)

An other alternative you could try is running a 40-man unit grave guard with banner of swiftness. You should be able to charge by turn 2, especially when you get a vhd off.
Run them sword & board against their great weapons. You get 6+ 6++ save instead of no save. Take something else as a hammer unit, which you charge in in turn 3.

Also take an ironcurse icon in your gg horde. And a banner of the barrows bsb. Make sure to block a flank charge with something in his wheel path if you charge the center unit.

You both hit on 3+, you wound on 4+, and he on 3+. (he can't possible take so many longbeards together with warmachines in 2.5k)
You both have a 6+ armor save left, but you also have parry. This puts him in a slight advantage, but you strike first, can regenerate your unit, and can put a red fury lord in the same unit to make things more "even". Taking nightshroud will be fine protection for your lord (and some of your gg). Then you'll win as he runs his units in size 30, and your lord kills an avarage of 7 per turn (without magic weapons)
 
My anti war machine is an iron curse icon for 5 pts. other than that I let them mis fire, and maybe use my vargheists to take em out if there are no better options for charges.
 
Perhaps try taking no worthy targets for his cannons and minimal war machine hunters(a few fell bats or dire wolves maybe) and focus on busting through his lines. No vargs, terrorghiests, black coaches, corpse carts, MI etc

Take a big ranked up GG unit along the lines of what FJHamming suggested.

Then take 5 hero wraiths in a massive unit of zombies (or spear skellies if ya want). Heck you could squeeze in 10 hero wraiths in 2.5k and run 2 of these units. Fight cheese with cheese.

Something like this:

625 of killy vamp and master necro (try and squeeze ICI and book of arkhan in maybe)

600 of hero wraiths

50 skellies-fc,Sp, magic banner
50 zombies-s,m
20 dire wolves (4x5 or 2x10 what ever floats your boat)

40 GG-fc, HW/S, BotB/+1 movement
8 fell bats in units of what ever

Vamp into the GG, 5 wraiths in each of the other units making up the front rank. Master necro can hide in the 2nd rank of one of the core units. Send your GG up against any dwarf unit that has character in it to avoid magic weapons against the wraiths.
 
Speedy ghast has a good point in the hero wraiths. Dwarves anti ethereal comes from their shooting, but you can't shoot the wraiths in a unit of zombies, it will just kill zombies, and that's a waste of shots. When you hit the front lines, 15 Str 5 attacks, you take no hits, and you outrank him. Not that you really wanna go and buy 10 wraiths and that many zombies for one game, but it's and idea for the future.
 
fjhamming said:
Well.. he can actually target the mortis engine because he can see it. (a mortis engine is slightly large than a zombie)

True. However he can not put it in front of the base if he can not see where he is aiming for. Example: in the diagram above, he can not say "6 inches from the Mortus Engine" only "Targeting the Mortus Engine" then rolling the first artiliry die to see if it hits.

I may be mistaken, but if you target the mortis engine I think it starts in the middle of the base, meaning odds are that it will hit behind it then bounce even further. I'll look into the BRB and FAQ's later to see if I'm just mistaken about this.

However, even if he can put it in the front of your base, it has a chance to miss if he rolls 6+ (maybe 4, not sure the base size). But if he targets something smaller like hexwraiths, a 4+ will miss, and on a 20mm base, it will miss alltogeather.

@maxtoreador, I hope this clears up the tactic of screaning units. It is not without disadvantages and you may have to challenge your opponent in a LoS debate (which is never fun) but it is the way the rules are. This is not a loop hole, this is both RAW and RAI. To play it any other way is unfair to you.

Remember, if he can see the point inbetween the zombies and the mortis engine, he can aim there. Best thing to do is get a laser pointer, if the red dot touches, he can shoot there. Same goes for the grudge thrower, however thats a taller model and rarly has problems with LoS like cannons do.

As far as arguments, bring them to a more experenced player first, point out the page number I quoted and explain how I did. Then go confront the dwarf player. If he says it works the way most dwarf players do, then have him explain from the rules how it works. Thats how I deal with those types of players. Don't try to prove them wrong, make them prove they are right.

More info: LoS pg 10 BRB, The War Michine, pg 109 BRB (Checking FAQ's now).
 
maxtoreador said:
Example 2500pt game: Last night at first he deployed only 3 units of dwarves in a sandbag formation then after I deployed everything else of mine he dropped 3 cannon, a bolt thrower, and a grudge thrower behind that line along with 2 organ guns to the side pointing right at my Blood knights and one of my 3 10pup dire wolves. Before turn three started he had killed all but one BK(model not unit), my coach, 2 bat swarms and half my core(not counting pups) using war machines to remove all except my 2 units of 10 pups which got single turn destroyed after charging ONE of his 50 dwarf hordes. By the end of 3 I had 2 characters, 14 skellies, and the swarms. End of 4, nothing.

Edit: And before you say "purple sun/other vortex spell/etc" he scrolled/dispelled EVERYTHING not IoN or Vanhels and my first 2 phases I had a Mortis and 10+ PD Including 2 Purples and a Wind of Death.

This is going to sound very defeatist but you really don't have a hope. That is the trouble with those campaigns. Your opponent can see who his likely adversary is and build an army just to counter it. It happen to my undead back in 6th edition. I was pitted against a wood elf who out magicked me everytime. Stayed hidden in the woods and used the super scouts (can't remember the name) to keep most of my army from marching.

Don't waste your time. Sit this campaign out or ask the GM if he can place you in another location or make some campaign rules to limit warmachines or something. Warhammer is so often rock-paper-scissors. Your scissors found it's rock.:thumbsdown: The Dwarves and their magical flaming cannons that never misfire really SUCK! :swear:
 
Its a tough game but by no means is it unbeatable. As it is one of our tougher matches ive playtested it extensively. Once i found lists and strategies i liked i won most of the games.

One thing that would work against that is 50% of your points in GG with iron curse. Use hit banner and hw shield. Have some fighty vamp, master necro and two 60 man skelly units to keep it from getting flanked. Overrun the sandbag, gg? (also unless he kills that ENTIRE unit he gets very little points and none if he doesnt kill your skellies).

Fight cheese with cheese right? (you can split this into two units for boards with alot of terrain and you still shouldnt lose them approx 45 gg each). As soon as your in combat he cant shoot anymore and then you just keep overrunning warmachines until the games over.
 
Are you playing with the 6 random scenarios out of the BRB?

Are you playing with correct amount terrain? (5-10 pieces of sight blocking terrain?)
 
StirogiPerogi said:
Are you playing with the 6 random scenarios out of the BRB?

Are you playing with correct amount terrain? (5-10 pieces of sight blocking terrain?)

Scenarios and terrain WOULD have been random but thanks to battle locations both were "predetermined." This happens when you fight Dwarves on 'barren plains, bogs, and the entrance to a bloody mine." (BTW what imbecile at GW decided putting the "dwarven stronghold" on a single mountain in the middle of the plains on the Blood in the Badlands map was sooo bloody brilliant?)

So far I've formed 2 lists based on you guys advice to try and stomp this guy. :vampire3:

Worse case I'll retreat back towards my capital, lose a tile or two, and force him to fight in the mountains... MY terrain. Get him up there, force him to abandon those damned cannons at the foot of the mountain, then come up to my fortress to TRY and take me one on one. Valdesia will feast on dwarven blood that night. :vampire2:
 
I'm quite new to the vampire counts but have played with TK for quite a while.

But first I got a few questions about the warmachines,
When placing your army don't you have to start with placing your warmachines -> core/special/rare -> Lords and Heroes.
So how come he can place his warmachines after you have placed your cavelry?
I could be wrong ofcourse, but thats how we play it here in my shop.

Also don't warmachines need a complete line of sight? Unless its a catapult/grudgethrower it would need a hill to fire over your own units, unless the target is a large target.

I got a friend who play Dwarf and when he uses a cannon on flat terrain it will look something like this:
00000000---------00000000
0dwarfs0-cannons-0dwarfs0
00000000---------00000000

That way the canon will have enough vision to shoot without its line of sight being blocked by the other dwarfs.

Ontopic:
When playing against cannons I normally go for large units and with VC that should not be a problem. Furthermore I would put a flying V-Lord in a squad and when he gets close enough to charge a warmachine I would make him move out of the unit to charge the cannon while the rest of the unit will try to charge some dwarfs.
Also having a Ironcurse item is recommended it could safe quite a few lives of your troops with its 6+ wardsave and its cost are nothing to write home about.
 
Best item to take when fighting a douch like this is a laser pointer. When they set up behind their troops you will be suprised on what he can and can not see. Hold it up to the barrel of the cannon and then see what ground he can see/target. Keep the little stuntie honest.
 
Lord Sathir said:
I'm quite new to the vampire counts but have played with TK for quite a while.

But first I got a few questions about the warmachines,
When placing your army don't you have to start with placing your warmachines -> core/special/rare -> Lords and Heroes.
So how come he can place his warmachines after you have placed your cavelry?

Because he squeezes in a single 'naked' character dwarf in each unit of the 'pivotal' war machines so they can deploy at the same time as my characters. This player is known to exploit this. Our GM/TO ruled in a previous game that since the character is part of the crew they deploy as one character model, to say otherwise would be like saying we have to deploy the throne or zombie dragon as a "normal unit" without the character according to him. :slapface:
 
maxtoreador said:
Lord Sathir said:
I'm quite new to the vampire counts but have played with TK for quite a while.

But first I got a few questions about the warmachines,
When placing your army don't you have to start with placing your warmachines -> core/special/rare -> Lords and Heroes.
So how come he can place his warmachines after you have placed your cavelry?

Because he squeezes in a single 'naked' character dwarf in each unit of the 'pivotal' war machines so they can deploy at the same time as my characters. This player is known to exploit this. Our GM/TO ruled in a previous game that since the character is part of the crew they deploy as one character model, to say otherwise would be like saying we have to deploy the throne or zombie dragon as a "normal unit" without the character according to him. :slapface:

Thats quite a nasty move of him and very unsportmanlike to do it with every unit.
Even my dwarven friend is like 'thats nasty'
I would personally not play with someone like this person as they try to push the limit of every thing they do and try to get on your nerve.
There is a similiar person around at the store where I play and most of the time I just refuse to play against him, only in tournaments when he gets pitted against me I play against him.
For me those people just seem to ruin my game.
 
characters cannot join warmachines since 8th. Read the dwarven FAQ. The master engineer works for every warmachine in 3" of him, instead of him joining a unit. So he'll have to deploy the warmachines somewhere before his characters, and all at once.

Then the master enigineer can barricade one of the warmachines, but thats after all deployment has been done, but before vanguard move etc.

And you deploy your characters when you are done deploying the rest of your army. You don't have to wait till the rest of the army of the opponent is deployed. SO if he has 5 drops (3 units, warmachines, characters) and you take 3 units of wolves and 2 units of bats, You don't have to deploy anything (other than those) before he deploys his characters. And thats even after warmachines.
 
With no hills his cannons can't really shoot at all. Cannons must see a point in the ground to aim at, not one of your figures. The dwarfs are in the way so he can't really see any ground at all and therefore can't shoot.

If you'd like to try magic I've got an idea. Take two thralls with Forbidden Lore (heavens). Pray for the comet and place it the middle of his warmachine pile. If you roll IF (or just high enough) he won't be able to dispel and that means certain doom for all the warmachines, unless he runs away with them (not likley with movement 3 xD)
 
fjhamming said:
characters cannot join warmachines since 8th. Read the dwarven FAQ. The master engineer works for every warmachine in 3" of him, instead of him joining a unit. So he'll have to deploy the warmachines somewhere before his characters, and all at once.

Then the master enigineer can barricade one of the warmachines, but thats after all deployment has been done, but before vanguard move etc.

And you deploy your characters when you are done deploying the rest of your army. You don't have to wait till the rest of the army of the opponent is deployed. SO if he has 5 drops (3 units, warmachines, characters) and you take 3 units of wolves and 2 units of bats, You don't have to deploy anything (other than those) before he deploys his characters. And thats even after warmachines.

Absolutly correct. I didn't catch that he was placing war machines down one at a time.

Please see pg 2, Dwarves FAQ v 1.3. A character can not join a war machine crew.
 
Aeviaan said:
...
Can't believe we didn't think of this before. I totally second the Comet idea!!! =D

If conventional methods don't seem to work, throw everything at him with one desperate maneuver! Pray for IF.

I'm looking in the BRB right now, for warmachine shooting, cannons are allowed to shoot either enemy models or a point on the ground. As long as he has something to target. I don't know how other dwarven war machines work, you would have to check his army book and see the individual entries.
 
I wish I could be there to see the look on this turd's face when he's forced to acknowledge that characters can't join warmachines, and he's been flagrantly cheating for all of 8th edition.
 
I second the laser pointer idea and the comet idea.

Earthing Rod + throwing 6 dice at comet every magic phase.

I really don't understand how he can have units in front of his WMs and still shoot, either. Grudge throwers being an exception.
 
Just playing devil's advocate...

On brb pg 112, "choose target" section of cannons. It says "Your target does not have to be an enemy model; it CAN be a point on the ground if you wish." It does not have to be a point on the ground. It could target the head of a skeleton in the 4th rank (because he can see it). He simply pivots the cannon and puts down a marker. It doesn't have to be only on the front of the unit or on the ground.

In addition I haven't found anything to state that if you target a model it is from the middle of the base.

+1 to no lords/heros joining a war machine.

Again, just opinions.
 
I guess it depends where exactly you draw line of sight from.

That's why we don't play with TLoS. We just have a hierarchy of large targets > buildings > monsters > cavalry/chariots > men > war machines > walls/light obstacles > skirmishers > swarms. Saves a ton of argument.

Otherwise you can just use a silly model to gain an advantage.
 
Aside from the long list of dodgy things that seem to be going on (warmachine deployment etc) when playing a gunline you basically have 2 effective options:

1/ Fake him out by deploying some chaff and once he has begun to bunker on one flank deploy everything as far away as possible. You can get everything ~5ft+ away from his army and play for a draw. This depends on how you score the game (not losing 100pts may be difficult).

2/ Attack on mass. Given the points he is spending on that 50 man block, warmachines and characters he can't have much else. It seems you're playing no comp Warhammer so there's nothing to stop you fielding 5 Hero Wraiths (starting in a Zombie block) and 3 seperate spirit hosts. Use the Periapt to get some use out of your normally wasted dispel dice.
 
Since I also play Dwarfs, this guy is CHEATING big time. His cannon can't see, so can't aim. characters can't join warmachines. He is deploying illegal units. We would disqualify him immediately. Take all the posted arguments to the GM, and explain that this guy is flagrantly playing with total disregard for the rules as written and as intended. If possible, get another player to add his voice. Then just refuse to play him until he learns to read. " THE MOST IMPORTANT RULE- HAVE FUN". Hopefully this fuckwit will get the message- but I wouldn't hold my breath.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu