Are we having problems on the tabletop?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Alixen

Ghoul
Aug 17, 2012
126
Zombies
172
By we, I mean the VC army as a whole.

While painting up my Ulrika and basing some Grave Guard, I listened to around nine battle reports from various people on youtube. By the eight I was actually slumping a little in my chair. Not until the ninth did the Vampires actually win a game. And that was due to bad rolls on the opponents side, and a rematch ended in a win for the opponent.

From listening, we have severe problems actually getting IoN off, our magic pool generation causes us problems, and a great deal of our troops (even Grave Guard and Black Knights) get the crap beaten out of them by a lot of the stuff other armies field. Crumbling really does seem to cause us a lot of problems, if only because, again, in the battle reports all but a few of our units seem to usually lose combat badly. It was varied armies such as Orks, High Elves, Chaos Warriors, Beastmen, Bretonnians and Dark Elves.

I'm just hoping I got the unluckiest selection of videos I could, and our own written battle-report section doesn't seem to reflect the same thing, but I thought i'd get some opinions. It doesn't really matter to me deeply either way, i've already sunk hundreds of pounds into my army and love the background and concept, but it would be a shame if we are struggling with our army book on the table.
 
I would not say VC are struggling. From what I can tell VC can be very strong, but it is an unforgiving army. One horrible magic phase for certain builds can ruin the whole game. However when everything works VC can be super competitive. Several people on this forum have done very well over the years. I'm sure oers can add on more to what i have said
 
Ah yes. I almost pooed my pants when I watched a boat load of youtube batreps. A lot of them were BlueTablePainting and some others who seemed to not understand Vampire Counts as a whole. They kind of just marched and had at it. Looking back (after reading up on this fine forum for months ;) ) I see this army is one that requires some tact and you sometimes have to pick your battles. Running around willy-nilly with Chaos is one thing, but VCounts will get torn apart if you just start throwing units around. Find good match-ups, and use our tarpits to stifle their death stars. A sweet theme helps too :)
 
I find it a fun and challenging army to play. You have to have a good tactical plan in place. And you can't apply tactics that work for other armies. Have to watch combo charges with elite and tar pit units. When to charge and when to get charged. And they are a very unforgiving army. One screw up and your not coming back from it. You really can't judge our strengths from youtube. You just don't charge zombies and blacknights into the same unit...yah just don't....:slapface:
 
Many vampire players don't know how to play to avoid our weaknesses. Vampires do not play like other armies and its easy to make mistakes because you do something that seems like it should work, but our weaknesses get in the way. The top weak points:
1) elite units crumble to easy - do not charge elite units into combat with tar pits or bad match ups. The bad cr will destroy them.
2) dependant on a good magic phase - you need to play like you don't needed magic. Magic is fickle, and pays off big when you don't count on it but it goes well. But if you play to count on it, you will lose big when it goes v wrong.
3) each unit has a purpose and its easy to take the wrong units for the job - many players use their units wrong. Three things cause this. Characters get used wrong. Players take too many hard to keep alive units at once (over relying on vampire or ethereal units). Players use hammers as anvils, tarpits as frontline , chafe as tarpits, etc.

Plus, vampire armies are vulnerable to high toughness and armor saves, especially with high leaderships. Chaos warriors and Bretonnia can prove troublesome if you don't know how to deal with them. If you don't use screams or know what units should charge or get charge and when, you can end up with a big mess that is hard to come back from.

Any rate, I think vampires has a steep learning curve and you see that in those videos.
 
PLus, BlueTablePainting NEVER get their game right from beginning to end. I mean, they are nice guys, they deliver a very good paint job, but they make SO many mistakes. Espcially the "Hey hey BlueTable fans!"-guy
 
Alixen said:
By we, I mean the VC army as a whole.

While painting up my Ulrika and basing some Grave Guard, I listened to around nine battle reports from various people on youtube. By the eight I was actually slumping a little in my chair. Not until the ninth did the Vampires actually win a game. And that was due to bad rolls on the opponents side, and a rematch ended in a win for the opponent.

From listening, we have severe problems actually getting IoN off, our magic pool generation causes us problems, and a great deal of our troops (even Grave Guard and Black Knights) get the crap beaten out of them by a lot of the stuff other armies field. Crumbling really does seem to cause us a lot of problems, if only because, again, in the battle reports all but a few of our units seem to usually lose combat badly. It was varied armies such as Orks, High Elves, Chaos Warriors, Beastmen, Bretonnians and Dark Elves.

I'm just hoping I got the unluckiest selection of videos I could, and our own written battle-report section doesn't seem to reflect the same thing, but I thought i'd get some opinions. It doesn't really matter to me deeply either way, i've already sunk hundreds of pounds into my army and love the background and concept, but it would be a shame if we are struggling with our army book on the table.

I'll be honest - yeah, I generally struggle to win with my Vampires.

Maybe it's just the points we play, but I rarely have the casters (let alone the power dice) to spam invocation. In fact, I struggle a lot with magic in general.

You see, 2000 is the most we play, so I have to choose between a Vampire Lord, SGK or Master Necromancer. And I didn't pick Vampire Counts to have my army led by a necromancer. ;)

Also, I've recently switched from great weapons on my grave guard to swords and shields. Much as I like the extra strength, I realised that virtually every enemy I'd want them to stand against would slaughter them before they got to strike.

I still enjoy the army, but it would be nice to win a little more often.
 
@Vipoid there's a sharp learning curve with VC, but when you get it nailed the book is so balanced, with great units and synergies that you can run a killer game with them. Keep at it. You'll hit your stride eventually!
 
As long as we arn't talking 'Eldar versus Grey Knights/Necrons' style learnign curve, I will embrace that challenge when it comes time to actually play wth my army.

@Vipoid, thank you for your experiences.
 
I agree. You have to bust out the nasty tricks like Screams and Ethereals and Red Fury Vampires for VC to really shine. Just marching up to people and trying to hit them in the face won't work - there's a lot of armies that can take VC troops on and win, even with raising to back them up.
 
I think I need to hit youtube and have a look at some of these battle reports... They sound... interesting :grave:

But anyway- Can't agree with more with the general consensus that has already been reached that is that we have quite a harsh learning curve...

But I would go a step further and say that we are a very all or nothing army- All the games I play are either an absolute debacle of a loss, or an absolute massacre.

In my local meta- it is pretty much standard practise for EVERYONE to ALWAYS take a level 4 caster of some sort- almost as a deterrent to the level 4 that their opponent WILL have, and it pretty much comes down to whoever kills their opponent's high-level caster first, means that they have near total domination of the magic phase- Which for me means healing ALL my units, mopping up, and getting a win with almost no VPs handed to my opponent- A massacre...

...Or, my high lever caster dies (usually also my general) and I turn to dust...

I don't think I have ever gotten a draw, a near victory, or a near loss with my VCs- its always been utter failure, or total victory...

Having the right mix of specialist troops is vital for us- or we pay for it massively- Having too many vampiric/ethereal units can spell death for an army before it has even hit the table...

For every unit that is difficult to heal (Blood Knights sping to mind- as I use mine a fair bit...) You need to use some points on easier ot raise specialist troops (GG or Black Knights are my usual options).

Tis' my thoughts anyway,

VC :grave:
 
Johnny-Crass said:
I dont think VC have a hard learning curve at all hhonestly. You just have to realize that our book is about fighting dirty.

What I mean by harder learning curve is the counter intuitive parts of the army. For example, nonundead armies can lock an enemy down with a tarpit unit and then come in with an elite unit and turn a stalemate into a win. If vampires do this, the tarpit becomes a liability to the elite because of how crumble works. Your enemy just has to keep killing tarpits and survive against the elite and the crumbling will kill the elite off.

Second counter intuitive element is a lot of vampire players overload on specials that don't synergize with the army well. Or they use units like varghiests to frontal assault, but those things only have T4 so they better hunters than hammers. When your trying to keep your ethereal and vampiric units all alive with IoN, your already playing uphill and then its made worse with a bad magic phase.

Third counter intuitive element would be efficiently using the general's march bubble. Every month there is mention of a player not knowing how to use the bubble to move his units correctly. Hex wraiths being exemplary of this as so many players can't use them well, but those who can know how to maximize the march bubble each turn.

Also, fighting dirty is counter intuitive for some players.

all in all, vampires play differently than other armies. They are a think outside the box army. Players who do well with them either learn this or already think this way.
 
What I mean by fighting dirty is not trying to out stat-line somebody. Fly a terrrghiest behind them, throw a P-Sun through them, hex them and you will win
 
Ironically, vampires are an army that has obstacles to manuvering but can really dominate when they do out manuver. Getting the right positions for screams, charges, redirecting and spells is critical. One of the reasons book of arkhan is so useful.

And I agree with Johnny. When playing vampires, go for the throat. We are vampires after all, think and play like one.
 
I agree with Johnny I really think VC is a strong army and there's not much to it(although I can see Najo's points as well about the counter intuitive stuff). Bring Razortons. Or bring TGs. Or bring CH blocks. Or bring ethereal spam. Or scream cheese. Or death snipe. Honestly we have so many strong archetypes at the moment that I think the real problem is that you have to "play dirty" as JC puts it rather than making a "thematic army". WoC can easily make a thematic army and still win because all their units hit like a ton of bricks. This cannot be said about VC. We have to take all the good stuff in our army and that doesn't always make for a fluffy list with a nice theme... but it kills in abundance.
 
This is one of the more forgiving armies out there in my opinion. Don't try to build magic heavy lists if you are new to the army, try using combat lists that focus on generating CR. Time and again I see people making what they call "magic heavy lists" when all they have are 3 casters with no way to generate extra power dice or casting bonuses. That's not "magic heavy" at all.
 
Seneschal makes a very good point here - bringing lots of casters doesn't make you a magic-heavy army, being able to cast and force through tons of spells does, and they are not necessarily the same thing. You usually need bonus power dice to ensure you can cast lots of spells, and while that alone might be enough to sneak spells through an opponent's magic defense, it doesn't hurt to get casting bonuses on top of that, especially because then you can hit casting values more easily.
 
I'm of the opinion that it's not really worth it to go magic heavy for VC, to be honest. There are so many other archetypes out there that work as well or better with less effort.
 
I traditionally have played magic heavy and have been learning the combat heavy style of play. I actually think people playing the two styles is where some of the misunderstandings and disagreements on these forums comes from. Magic is a whole fickle beast unto its self, and if you don't know the rest of the game (i.e. how to deploy correctly, move correctly, bend odds in your favor and break units) then you focusing on magic only makes your army weaker. Also, a good warhammer player will destroy your magic phase with a properly timed dispel.

The key to really playing magic heavy is know how to poker face, bait dispel dice and slip the real spells you want through. You also can't be predictable. But you can't be random either.

Also, study the math hammer of the magic phase. Look at each lore, ask yourself what is the worst spells I can get and what can I do with those? What is my best and worse match ups with those spells? What happens when i get snake eyes or box cars on my winds? What happens when i roll a 6 & 1? How do I get through a bad magic phase and make it work? What magic items help me maximize my strategy?

You need to know this part of the game as well as the rest to pull it off, and even then against a player who knows how to disrupt it you will get derailed often. I'll tell you this, when I play heavy magic, I run a necro with vampire lore and periapt. I usually always find a place for book of arkhan. That item has won me games. I always include a blender or couple of mini blenders. You still need to generate cr.

It is possible to have level 4 vamps. I would build them blender though and avoid MotDA except in the way Johnny used it in his mind razor army. The 75 points are just more well rounded and effective in other powers.

Likewise, I haven't done this yet, but I think vampires using forbidden lore to build a vampire light council army might be viable. I have used FL to bring in light and metal when facing certain armies and it was very effective.

Finally, dark acolyte has hidden value. It makes your opponent have to throw an extra dice into dispelling your IoN from that vampire. Mixed with mortis engines and periapt and you can make a vampire lore driven army using ghouls, crypt horrors and then support from chafe and elites that fit your play style that is very deadly. Always get vanhels and IoN on your level 4. Only take gaze if dealing with removing soft targets and curse if for hordes. Hellish vigor only if using wights (because of killing blow). Raise dead is the best redirector in the game. I always swap wind for IoN. Winds is our worse spell.

And if you can use special characters, lord Manfred is awesome. Especially in a black knight bus. His sword and lore master in both vamps and death...crazy.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu