Balancing imbalanced games

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

PureSphinx

Ghoul
Jul 16, 2014
178
Zombies
153
A while back a few friends and I did a 3000 point 1v3 game, me as VC vs Skaven, DE, and Empire. It was a kind of desperate allies scenario, where the empire was beset by the other two until the Vampire army showed up to wipe them all out.

The only reason I lost is because we let the skaven player take a Vermin lord even though he only had 1000 points (this was before UL) and because we misunderstood Skaven magic. Even so, it was a narrow victory for the allies, because my 1300 point Blood Knight Star flanked the empire Gunline turn two while my massive skeleton blocks held down the other two for my Vargs and Hexies to chew up.

Now obviously 750 points of lords isn't equal to 250, even if there are 3 250 point ones. I could have taken a fully kitted Dragonlord level 4 and they'd have had a wizard or partially kitted combat lord. Undead Legions 50% though...

Rares and specials don't seem too imbalanced because they altogether have equal points, so if they built their lists synergistically, one could take an anvil, one could take a fighty unit, and one could take chaff. Is this true enough?

Magic, though, is another story. Having three people to share 2d6 between means that anyone who invested in the magic phase wasted points. 7 dice for 3+ wizards is almost nothing, when each of those is a lord and the "+" is X number of supporting casters. So we house ruled 3d6 with dispeller getting the high and low of the three dice. Balanced or no?

Also, with 50% lords and heroes now a real thing, does it make lopsided teams more in line with each other? 1500 to 500/750 is a lot better than 750 to 250/375 (1v3/1v2). Also, is there an optimal points value for these kind of games? Any house rules that would help it out? We want to do more games like this, so help making them fun is appreciated.

I hope this is the right forum for this. Thanks!
 
Multi-player games are always tough. You can make your own rules but in this case, I actually think Triumph & Treachery is a really good expansion from GW that takes care of these games really well. I have the set and I think it is one of the best expansions GW has ever released. It makes the game a lot more random which makes the game less about tactics and strategy is some ways but creates a really fun environment. I would highly recommend it.
 
I had heard about Triumph and Treachery, but didn't give it much thought as I read it was about more free for all than mismatched team games. I'll look into it though, see what I can find out.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu