Balefire or Unholy Lodestone

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Lemuria

Zombie
Feb 14, 2009
31
Zombies
25
Thusfire balefire has seemed a no brainer for me, especially since it can stack and has served me well at shutting down my regular opponent's tzeentch spells.

But I am considering a second cart with a lodestone as a support unit for my black knights... just because it singlehandedly doubles the effectiveness of IoN on that unit. Regaining 2 knights with each casting would be a big deal, and make my knights a lot more resilient.

What do people here think?
 
It probably depends on how you use your Black Knights. The Lodestone only has a 6 inch range, and I personally keep my cart behind my front line so that opponents can't easily take it out - the result is that most of the time my Black Knights aren't close enough to benefit.
The other thing I should admit about the Lodestone is that I tend to forget that I've got it... Balefire isn't usually a problem, but the Lodestone tends for some reason to slip my mind.
 
As Geraint said, range is very important to the usefulness of the Lodestone. It is very difficult to use the Lodestone to boost your faster units because it is most likely that they will not be pacing your infantry advance. It is great for boosting your infantry (you only need to get 3 ghouls or skeletons -or 2 GG - out of it for the Lodestone to pay for itself).

The Lodestone is more defensive, while the Balefire is more offensive. 2 Balefires significantly hampers opposing magic - just look at how frustrating Drain Magic is. Your biggest gains are against the level 6-8 spells.

Personally I'd double up on Balefires.
 
When I've been using a list centered around three large blocks of infantry, I've found the lodestone to be of great value. By keeping it in range of two units of ghouls as well as the central unit of grave guard, I gained alot of extra models through the summonings. :)

I've never really tried the balefires myself, though they are clearly quite useful.
 
I think Balefire is the way to go, as it is so could against magic armies for its point cost.

Every time I have played against in the mirror match it has been the MVP, as regen makes the cart hard to get rid, In the one game it held up bloodknights for like four combats because my opponent made 30+ regen saves in a row. That -1 to cast is so good against vamps.
 
I go for Balefire. My only units are ghouls so I'm not that fussed about getting the extra one a turn. I have enough magic to raise a couple of dozen each turn anyway. The balefire on the other hand stopped my opponent getting pandemonium off twice in my last game. It's worth it just for the look on your opponent's face when you tell him the spell he thought had gone off was actually one short. :D
 
From an outsider's point of view, Balefire is ghastly. While the Lodestone is useful on large infantry blocks, the Balefire hampers the little Magic I take and against an opponent with only two Mages, I've seen Balefire shutdown a magic phase pretty handily.
The lodestone, however, is also nasty. My regular Vampire Counts opponent usually plays four Carts, two Lodestones and two Balefires, and the Lodestones are on seperate sides of his battle line ensuring that all of his infantry blocks are effected by it. It's not pretty, but it's also risky.

In general, I'd probably take Balefire over the Lodestone, although that said there are definite uses for the Lodestone. Just think about your army composition, whether you have more cavalry than infantry, more mages than not, and make a decision that compliments your list. In a Raise heavy list I'd probably take a Lodestone, although with larger blocks of infantry with less Raisey stuff, then the Balefire looks like the better option.
 
I've been thinking of taking two Corpse Carts with Balefire, the Skull Staff and the Staff of Sorcery for -2 to all spells cast from my opponent and +2 for me to dispell :)

They will have to get 4 higher to get a spell out effectively :)
 
I'd also go for double balefire. -2 on spells is such an annoyance. It seems oligatory against a tzeentch player as well.

Cheers, Warlock593
 
Unfortunately it would seem that I am a sheep, as I will be following the majority.

The lodestone, whilst well worth its points, is not as much fun as two Balefire carts. Against most armies with the exception of dwarves they will be very worthwhile, and against magic heavy enemies they are superb.

One main advantage that I've seen, is the psychological effect they seem to have. They see a lodestone - meh, pretty good, but nothing to prioritise.
They see two balefires buggering up their casting attempts and suddenly they make a beeline for them, trying to destroy them and get their magic back on track. A canny general will use this to great effect, especially as with their regen they can be a bugger to shift as well.
 
I see your reasoning for considering the Lodestone... but unfortunately it explicitly doesn't allow that. It says you only gain the one wound for models with the vampire special rule.

I like using 3 balefire corpse carts. A -3 modifier to the magic phase just draws those enemies in.

so I am settling with the majority here.
 
That was what I thought originally... and had I said blood knights you would indeed be correct.

But black knights do not have the 'vampire' special rule... and thus would regain 2 wounds for each casting of IoN.

Albeit, this is a very specific situation and I don't know that it would be enough for me to take lodestone over balefire against anyone except poor magic armies.

My point is that it is not quite as useless as it first appeared to me.
 
Sorry Lemuria, the limitation to one wound restored per casting of IoN also applies to non-infantry models and ethereals. In the table at the end of the book, Black Knights are clearly called out as cavalry (as if the fact they were on horses weren't enough already).

Re-read the IoN description more carefully...end of first paragraph.
 
True, but the Unholy Lodestone only specifies models with the "Vampire" rule as not getting the benefits; it does not mention Ethereal or Cavalry models. Therefore, the Black Knights would get two wounds from a casting of Invocation, as they get the benefit from the Unholy Lodestone, but Blood Knights would only get one, as they do not benefit.
 
I'll be horn-swaggled...

I stand (or lay in my coffin, rather) corrected. An excellent tidbit!
 
It still seems too situational to me. To be effective, you'd have to get your battered knights back through your lines (or somewhere in the middle) to where your CC can hang out somehow within 6". It just seems like a lot of very defensive manouvering.
 
By extension this applies to a number of other units, namely dire wolves and the wight king.

A wight king with 1 wound remaning could be healed back to full with a single IoN!
 
See, I thought you had meant the Blood Knights, because that was the track my mind was on...
sorry.
The lodestone is good in that case.

I've used it as a support unit for Things like Fell Bats who I return to be 'recharged' in the area of the corpse cart. Since Fell bats can (theoretically) be increased beyond their starting strength, this is a really nice maneuver.
 
Double Balefire is huge. For a single cart, I prefer the Lodestone because one balefire is annoying but typically not game altering. There are at least a couple threads you can search for which talk about the usefullness of one Balefire.

I also agree with the comments about pairing lodestone cart to heal your knights. Typically lodestone carts are centered around blocks of infantry in a position where the effect can lap over on 2 or 3 unts. I would be hard to keep the cart in a position to benefit cavalry.
 
I'm not a huge fan of Balefire, simply because it doesn't provide any bonus against a fair few armies, and I hate to waste points! Lodestone I used for a while, and it was fantastic when I'd be raising Wraiths and Black Knights if they happened to be nearby. I played one game recently where I used a silly unit of 10 Wraiths- knowing my opponent was magic heavy I took Balefire, but he was able to keep most of his Mages at the perfect distance to blast my units in front of the Cart- but that's dancing Dark Elves for you. if I'd had Lodestone, then that first turn where he killed 5 Wraiths with an incredible magic barrage would have been countered easily.
 
having 3-4 balefire's vs a magic heavy team is soooo great, the opponent gets so frustrated when his wizards suffers a -3 to cast ^^

Its almost as frustrating as High Elves god damned Drain magic spell
 
I'm planning a double-balefire too, especially as my vamps are going more "fighty" than "casty" and I'm not planning on taking any scrolls. Having less spells be successfully cast will mean that I can use my more limited dispel pool to greater effect. Also, double-cart of any type means 2 more bound spells for my opponent to have to factor in to his plans when dispelling my stuff.
 
What EvC said. In tournaments I rarely see Corpse Carts unless it's a single one with Balefire. Too situational, and with Loadstone - too short reach.

They are a fluff choice, imo.
 
will lodestones allow you to raise a unit above starting strength without the applicable mastery power?
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu