Banshee challenge problem

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

benfm

Zombie
Jul 15, 2013
41
Zombies
37
So I played a 2k game the night before last, I had a Skeleton Warrior bus with a Vamp Hero, Vamp Lord and decided also to add a Banshee as I wanted a Scream also. The unit was configured 5 wide 10 deep.

It was against Ogres and my main bus ended up going toe to toe with his Ogre bus. His BSB challenged hoping to draw in a character as my Champion died to the explosion from Hellheart.

So I decided to accept his challenge with the Banshee and had both Vamps let rip into the unit which they did.

what resulted is that I wiped out the Infantry and his general over a couple of game turns but his BSB was stuck in the challenge with banshee. Neither could kill the other. As a result I could not get my VL out of combat and could not kill the BSB with the VL since only the Banshee could attack it.

So my 500pt blender lord suddenly became useless.

This doesn't feel right but it appears the rules support it...any alternative opinions on this?

thanks,
 
You had 3 ranks and banner, yes? They should have counted towards CR and I can imagine the BSB would have broken with a -3 to leadership (that would have made him LD 5 I think) even with the reroll.
 
The BSB had that stubborn crown and he repeatedly rolled awesome on his LD tests and my Banshee fail screamed every time not managing to get any wounds at all :(
There was a bit of bad luck on that but just seemed a bit harsh having my VL trapped in the end by this never ending challenge...
 
Was your vamp lord also in base 2 base contact with the BSB? If he can leave the unit to continue his rampage.
 
No he can't. A character cannot leave a unit if the unit is in combat, BRB pg 101.
Annoying to have your own unit being ethereal-blocked!
 
I'm afraid there's not a lot you can do about that, I personally would accept challenges with your vamp lord against ogres, it's a bit risky with their high strength attacks and a stomp in a challenge but you probably should kill them especially if they are the hero choices. And use the banshee to sit on the corner of the unit to block their unit attacks. This is why I prefer wraith characters to banshees that scream always let's me down too. :)
 
If it was an open list game and you knew his Stubborn Crown BSB was issuing a challenge, then you totally should have accepted with the VL, no questions asked.

If it was a closed list game, then, well... I still would have accepted with the VL since he'd kill the BSB.

If his unit champ issued the challenge, then if have accepted with the banshee, provided the VL was in BTB with other models in his unit.
 
In my opinion, without the ability to kit them, cairnies and banshees seemed to be a waste as heroes.

As others have previously stated, your VL would have been the safest bet, in this situation ...
 
SheBeast76 said:
In my opinion, without the ability to kit them, cairnies and banshees seemed to be a waste as heroes.

As others have previously stated, your VL would have been the safest bet, in this situation ...

I agree to a certain extent regarding ethereals.
Like most tactics it depends who you are fighting.
In this case he was unlucky as he had a few rounds of screaming and still did not wound him.

Never mind we live and learn by our mistakes
 
In 2K games there´s always some room for their screams to support the damage delivered by a unit in return of a low percentage of the army points. This case has been just a good example of extreme bad luck (or good for your opponent), that´s all. In my opinion, if this combat takes place another 99 times, you will destroy the enemy unit, or at least force its retreat, most of the times.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu