Banshee Howl + lore of death question

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

gkgnight

Ghoul
Mar 2, 2010
108
Zombies
109
hey guys... i ahve some questions involving ghostly howl, hopefully you'll be able to answer them.

Lore of Death: Doom and Darkness - target suffers -3 penalty on leadership. Hex Spell.

Banshee Howl - 2d6 + 2 and causes a wound for each point you beat targets leadership.

My questions are:

1. What happens when you banshee howl on a unit with a character in it? Does the howl get compared to the unit's leadership value? or the characters? (I ask because its not a leadership/psychology test).

2. And does the howl benifet from the doom and darkness -3 leadership modifier?

3. Also, does having a BSB nearby/in the targeted unit affect our ghostly howl attack in any way? I.E. bonuses to his leadership or other modifiers?
 
1 - Use the character's (or general's) Ld.
2 - In this edition, the howl does indeed benefit from Doom and Darkness.
3 - BSB's do not have any effect on the howl. You're not forcing a Ld test, which is what BSB's are used for.
 
I got into a big rules discussion over what "line of sight" means with regard to a banshee's howl; My opponent insisted the howl target MUST fall in the banshee's front arc (i.e. 45 degrees). I disagreed citing pg 10, and that the howl is NOT a "shooting" attack, but a special magical attack.

Any GW FAQ's out there?
 
While it does not say specifically that it has to be in the front arc, that does not mean its suddenly an LOS-unrestricted attack.

A Banshee's howl follows the standrad BRB rules for targeting which requires LOS
 
You can't really trace LOS through the back of a model's head, so I'd say it doesn't necessarily have to be in your front arc, but about 150 degrees or so towards whichever way the model is facing

No, I don't think this is covered in the BRB FAQ (or at least I didn't see it if it was)
 
True. There is no exact language regarding the howl's targeting. So, some arguments are sure to arise.

But, as we know the howl happens in our shooting phase and given the restrictions outlined in its entry, if you wish to target something simply make sure you use your movement phase to remove as much doubt as possible where target eligibility is concerned;)
 
Friendly Dead said:
A Banshee's howl follows the standrad BRB rules for targeting

This is not true as there are no standard rules for targeting.

With that being said I normally give this to my opponent as honestly it is bad enough I can scream at anything I want in range.
 
I was Evil Ernies opponent...

These were my thoughts, and don't forget I'm (occasionally now) a VC player too... we're getting ready for a tournament and this is the way I understand it all:

Units can only "see" through LOS what is in their range of vision.

These are basic BRB rules, there are exceptions - but exceptions are clearly listed as exceptions in army books (i.e. High Elves always (!) ASF, blah blah blah)

So, for Charges unit can only charge units in the 45 degree LOS arc...

For Magic, magic missiles etc. the unit /caster (or unit, i.e. Pink Horrors) can only target units in the front 45 degree LOS arc...

For shooting - including characters in a unit - including skirmishing units can only fire at the 45 degree arc of their line of sight...

Etc.

The Banshees were bunkered in a unit of Skeletons.. I have no problem with that.

He was ***EPICALLY*** Screaming at my Doom and Darkness suffering Mino bus unit, killing 9 minotaurs in 2 rounds... Cool!

***EDIT*** For Scream, the Banshees need LOS.*** The argument was - What can the Banshees see? They see - in the VC army book rules - LOS.

LOS for the ***Unit*** (Skeleton unit) is the 45 degrees. If the skeletons were to charge, they'd only charge in their charge arc. Magicians requiring LOS in the unit, would only target 45 degree LOS targets, if there were actual shooters... they too would require 45 degree LOS...

Wait, the Banshees - although *not* shooters per se, are using the Shooting phase...

So there's a connection there...

I know, I know... blah blah blah, need FAQ.... blah blah blah, "***special***" attack...

Well, treat it like any other attack is what I say. The if you don't want to deal with a units LOS, then don't bunker it in a unit...

Evil Ernie was masterful in destroying the unit in 2 turns (while they were tarpitted by Zombies), we didn't have an issue with LOS in the game, but if some VC players think that even RAW you have an argument about "special" attack that means you get a different standard of LOS...

Well, expect to get zero comp at a tourney. I see it as a non-issue, and not even worth arguing - trying to make an issue about it is just going to waste good game time arguing something that is a waste of time.
 
My whole point is LOS is not defined as front arc in the BRB. I agree that it should not be 360 for a basic model,may be 180. But take the charge: You need LOS AND the target unit must fall it least partially in the attacking units front arc. It's two different things, and you need both to charge. Just because they are linked in charges, shooting and magic missiles is not making them one and the same.
 
It is not a shooting attack and does not follow the restrictions of s shooting attack.

That being said most of you should READ the banshee scream entry. And I quote
"Even if the Tomb Banshee has marched, charged or is engaged in close combat. This attack has a range of 8" and needs line of sight of its target"
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu