Banshee scream in CC

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Smogg said:
couqonfeis said:
I called GW to get clarification on this. Kyle answered like you said. If you charge then the shooting phase happens before the CC and she can scream as normal, if she wants to scream in subsequent turns she will have had to make way so that the Tomb Banshee model is in base-to-base contact.

I'll admit that he sounded a little... unsure when he said so, might just be that he's brittish though. xD

But that's how the GW employee interprets it and he said he'd take it up with the guys to enter it in the next FAQ/Errata

I don't know Kyle, but while he is no doubt a good guy, i am sure he is neither a game designer nor involved with writing the next FAQ. But he might have thought he was just helping out a small gaming group rather than being quoted in a major rules forum.

The interpetation is really problematic though. It basically imply that you can have models in a charging unit that does not count as being in close combat in their shooting phase.

So basically a unit of 2 rank pisotilers could charge a unit of 5 dire wolves. But then the 2nd rank of pistoliers could still shoot at something else in their shooting phase because they are not in close combat in before the CC phase? and how about the first rank. They are in base to base contact, but are they not in close combat yet? maybe they can shoot too? or be shoot at?

I hope you see the problem with Kyle's interpretation.

Oh yeah, definitely. This is by no means cleared up because of GW customer support.
At the end of the day, the way it is right now we can only ask the ref of each tournament to interpret the rule and FAQ/Errata before we play.

Regarding the Pistoliers shooting. Most shooting attacks cannot occur after a charge but this one states specifically that it can. I'm pretty sure that is something that was in GW customer supports mind when explaining his interpretation.
 
Sorry but Kyle's idea that you don't count as being in close combat before the close combat phase is simply wrong. There are lots both spell types and ranged attacked in the magic phase and shooting phase that are restricted based on if the target unit is in close combat. Both from a user perspective and from a target perspective.

The simple example is that you are not allowed to shoot at a unit in close combat. Using Kyle's logic you would be able to charge a unit, and then target the same unit with missile fire after a succesfull charge.

I do think Kyly had somthing in his mind when explaining his interpritation... "what do I need to tell this guy to sell him some banshees" :)

That said. I dont have my book at hand, but I will be happy to look up why you count as being in close combat even before the CC phase. If I am wrong in this, then its not a banshee issue. Then its a huge gamechanger in 8th edition.
 
Smogg said:
Sorry but Kyle's idea that you don't count as being in close combat before the close combat phase is simply wrong. There are lots both spell types and ranged attacked in the magic phase and shooting phase that are restricted based on if the target unit is in close combat. Both from a user perspective and from a target perspective.

The simple example is that you are not allowed to shoot at a unit in close combat. Using Kyle's logic you would be able to charge a unit, and then target the same unit with missile fire after a succesfull charge.

I do think Kyly had somthing in his mind when explaining his interpritation... "what do I need to tell this guy to sell him some banshees" :)

That said. I dont have my book at hand, but I will be happy to look up why you count as being in close combat even before the CC phase. If I am wrong in this, then its not a banshee issue. Then its a huge gamechanger in 8th edition.

I'm pretty sure you are wrong here. The charge happens in the Movement phase. The Tomb Banshee is not shooting, she is performing a special attack in the shooting phase. A phase that happens before the close combat phase and therefor before a chance to make way or any other placement-modifiers.

You don't have to be a game designer to have a sound understanding of rules, and you are giving Kyle a hard time for no reason ;)
 
Personally i think that question from the faq was more aimed at ppl playing banshees either in their own or in the front rank.

the special rules for the howl states it can be fired into combat.

She isnt in base to base so that question in the faq would not apply.

That is the way my meta interprets it.

Reminds me alot of the nightshroud arguement about second rank.
 
@Skittelz1981 Welcome to you.
With regards to your argument about common sense. Keep in mind that the Banshee is also designed as a champion upgrade for the Wraiths. This would put her smack in the front of the unit, so nothing in the design suggest she is not meant to be in front.
Of course she is weak if she face up against magic. However... for your points you get:
- Terror (which is really nice combined with a specific banner and a psychology vamp)
- A powerful scream (My last fight, she took out a steam tank which the rest of the unit was struggling with)
- Immunity to normal weapons (you can use her to charge out of a unit to stop some incoming hydra if you like)

@couqonfeis Also you deserve a welcome!
I will try not to be so hard on Kyle :)
p. 13 "... the 1" apart rule makes it absolutely clear whether two units are merely close to one another (in which case there will be an inch between) or in close combat (they will be in base contact)"

So if a unit containing a banshee in second rank charges another unit successfully, then the two units will be in base contact during the magic and shooting phase. According to the 1" apart rule it should then be absolutely clear that they are in close combat.

Now if the unit with the banshee is in close combat, then she must follow her special FAQ ruling for using her Howl attack in close combat:
Q: If a Tomb Banshee wishes to use her Ghostly Howl attack in close combat, does this have to be targeted against an enemy unit that the Tomb Banshee model is in base contact with? (p31)
A: Yes


Meaning if she is in close combat, there are two options. Either she is in btb contact with the target unit or she is not. This will determine if she can target that unit or not.
 
So, that would mean that if her unit is in close combat but she is not in B2B with anyone she could target a different unit. So if there were another enemy unit within 6" when the rest of her unit is in close combat she could target it instead? That seems odd.
 
No, it would mean that if her unit is in close combat but she is not in B2B with anyone, then she is not able to target any units with her scream.
 
Smogg said:
No, it would mean that if her unit is in close combat but she is not in B2B with anyone, then she is not able to target any units with her scream.

I'll play the game like this until GW says otherwise. It makes sense and fits both the design and fluff.

Thanks Smogg, +1 rep on you!
 
Seems the FAQ doesn't specify what happens when the unit is in CC and the banshee is not in BtB contact with anything.

Yes, we all know that if the banshee is in the front rank on a corner and is in BtB contact with a chaos chariot, she must scream at the chariot and NOT the DP on the other side of the unit which she can still otherwise see. Seems to me the FAQ was used to prevent banshees from cherry picking targets in CC.

But the FAQ doesn't clear up if the banshee is NOT in BtB contact with anything, what then? Was the FAQ designed to address a specific issue (screaming at what's in front of her), or nerfing the scream to the point of ridiculousness? GW needs to clarify, in my opinion.
 
It's clearly not meant to be that way. They meant that you can scream only at that unit while in CC.

Bitches be trippin'
 
I agree as that would make the most sense, and I would like it to be the other way as you could keep the banshees safer, but I'm still leaning towards how the rules read vs how they're intended to be played.
 
I'm pretty sure they never intended to have any characters in the second row. Having 5 cairn wraith characters plus banshee character seems a bit extreme.
 
Well, I think it makes up for the fact that they totally intended that the High Elf banner that gives the unit a 2+ ward to magic screws pretty much every other character in the game out of their attacks. So screw you GW! I'm kidding! Please don't make vampires suck next edition!
 
I find that having one banshee on their own getting their free reforms hovering just behind a tarpit works wonders. They can dance around and scream and unless the enemy has magical ranged shooting they can't be hit.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu