couqonfeis
Zombie
Smogg said:couqonfeis said:I called GW to get clarification on this. Kyle answered like you said. If you charge then the shooting phase happens before the CC and she can scream as normal, if she wants to scream in subsequent turns she will have had to make way so that the Tomb Banshee model is in base-to-base contact.
I'll admit that he sounded a little... unsure when he said so, might just be that he's brittish though.
But that's how the GW employee interprets it and he said he'd take it up with the guys to enter it in the next FAQ/Errata
I don't know Kyle, but while he is no doubt a good guy, i am sure he is neither a game designer nor involved with writing the next FAQ. But he might have thought he was just helping out a small gaming group rather than being quoted in a major rules forum.
The interpetation is really problematic though. It basically imply that you can have models in a charging unit that does not count as being in close combat in their shooting phase.
So basically a unit of 2 rank pisotilers could charge a unit of 5 dire wolves. But then the 2nd rank of pistoliers could still shoot at something else in their shooting phase because they are not in close combat in before the CC phase? and how about the first rank. They are in base to base contact, but are they not in close combat yet? maybe they can shoot too? or be shoot at?
I hope you see the problem with Kyle's interpretation.
Oh yeah, definitely. This is by no means cleared up because of GW customer support.
At the end of the day, the way it is right now we can only ask the ref of each tournament to interpret the rule and FAQ/Errata before we play.
Regarding the Pistoliers shooting. Most shooting attacks cannot occur after a charge but this one states specifically that it can. I'm pretty sure that is something that was in GW customer supports mind when explaining his interpretation.
Solid pun there Sunny! I haven't been here long, should I still refer to you as Mr. King?