Basic CR question

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

MacGruber

Zombie
Feb 23, 2014
2
Zombies
2
I have been lurking on the forum for a month or so, as I have just recently been painting and collecting Warhammer again. Today my cousin and I played our first game together in several years. It was my first 8th edition and first VC game. He played Skaven, as always.

Looking back at the game and rereading the rules, we messed up numerous things.

I had a question about a pivotal battle involving his plague bearers vs 6 dogs and 11 black knights. We messed up the rule for supporting attacks only getting 1 attack, so he ending up having a ton of attacks (I think 36) vs my 6 dogs. He did something like 23 wounds that carried over to CR, making everything crumble. My question is, can more wounds be dealt than there are models or is it capped at 6 in this case, since all the models would be dead?

Thanks in advance.
 
Yes. Combat Resolution is unsaved Wounds, not how many unsaved Wounds it took to kill a unit, so you can get more Combat Resolution Wounds than models killed.
 
In this case, even if he caused 36 wounds on your dogs, it will only give him a combat resolution +6, so no, he cannot gain more than 6 CR for killing your dogs. So in your case:

Lets say your dogs and knights charge. Knights in flank. (+2 CR)
Your knights cause 9 wounds. (+9 CR)
Your dogs do 0 wounds.
His plague monks do 23 wounds on your dogs. Killing your 6 dogs. (-6 CR)

So here you would win combat with 5 CR.
 
Smogg said:
In this case, even if he caused 36 wounds on your dogs, it will only give him a combat resolution +6, so no, he cannot gain more than 6 CR for killing your dogs. So in your case:

Lets say your dogs and knights charge. Knights in flank. (+2 CR)
Your knights cause 9 wounds. (+9 CR)
Your dogs do 0 wounds.
His plague monks do 23 wounds on your dogs. Killing your 6 dogs. (-6 CR)

So here you would win combat with 5 CR.



Are you sure about this? im not so sure. Im gonna look it up but i think you can score more in CR. i dont think its capped at just the number of models. Its as if a character would take more wounds than it actually has. There is overkill, which gives +5 CR even if the character only has 2 or 3 wounds....
 
Mmmkay,

so BRB p.52:
"Each side's basic Combat result is equal to the wounds caused in combat. It's important to tally up the number of wounds, rather than the number of casualties. Most characters and monsters have more than 1 wound"

This indeed says nothing about doing 30 excess wounds on a unit of wolves. It just specifies models with multiple wounds.

Overkill only applies to characters or challenged models so that doesnt count.


Your skaven opponent would not get the bonus CR from doing that many unsaved wounds since he was already beating air when those 6 wolves got slain by the first 6 attacks :D

Thus CR would be 6 from the wolves, and then count all the other bonuses and CR from the fight with the knights.
 
Smogg said:
In this case, even if he caused 36 wounds on your dogs, it will only give him a combat resolution +6, so no, he cannot gain more than 6 CR for killing your dogs. So in your case:

Lets say your dogs and knights charge. Knights in flank. (+2 CR)
Your knights cause 9 wounds. (+9 CR)
Your dogs do 0 wounds.
His plague monks do 23 wounds on your dogs. Killing your 6 dogs. (-6 CR)

So here you would win combat with 5 CR.

100% correct
no overkill unless in a challenge
CR is for unsaved wounds!
Wounds is the key word here. 6 Direwolves can only give 6 unsaved wounds.
Now if your Skaven friend also did some to the BK unit they are added to CR for the whole combat.
Plus, if you were in his flank or rear with 2 or more "at least 5 wide" ranks. He can not add any rank bonuses :)
CR is the MOST IMPORTANT thing to VC!
charge, downhill, ranks, standards, BSB
I recommend studying up pg. 52 BRB.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu