Beguile

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

sabien

Zombie
Apr 8, 2010
11
Zombies
8
I know this was talked about in the last edition of both the BRB and our army book, but I wanted to ask this quesiton agian.

With beguile, it says after challenges have been issued/and or accepted, you pick a model in base contact and force them to take a leadership check -3 or I get to reroll to wound.

No where in that does it say the challange has to be completed before, just after issued. I was trying to look for clarification on this, and haven't had much luck.

Thoughts?
 
This allows you to use it either in that Vamp's challenge, the challenge of another character in which he is in btb with the other character's opponent (so that mini has to re-roll hits vs your peer) or any other mini in btb.
 
I'd like to pick up on questions relating to Beguile.

If my Vampire Beguiles a rank and file troop, and then proceeds to kill a bunch of rankers, does (one of) the remaining guys still suffer the effects?

Or have I already killed the Beguiled victim?
 
Thanks for quick reply Johnny.

I'd be grateful if you can clarify the logic as my opponent is still uneasy on this.

My Vampire is in base to base with a single Ogre Bull. I Beguile the Bull at the start of combat phase. Vampire has high initiative so goes first doing, say, 5 wounds. Clearly that Bull is dead. (Though the casualty is removed from rear rank so the physical model remains.)

When it is the Bulls turn to strike my opponent insists that I have killed the Beguiled Bull so now face 6 attacks back on the Vampire (inc. supporting attacks).

How can I be clear with him that the Beguile should still, as your answer suggests, be in effect?

Thanks again and sorry for pedantry!
 
with the high initiative of vampires they will nearly always strike first and get at least a killing rank and file. Reason that to play it his way makes beguile almost useless.
 
I don't have my book with me but doesn't it say" pick 1 model in B2B"? If so that 1 model suffers the effects of beguile. In the example of the Bull if the vampire kills that bull the other bulls stepping up do not suffer from beguile. Beguile IS pretty useless against r&f. It is designed to help kill characters that are in B2B contact with the Vampire. Whether in a challenge or not.
 
Remember the new beguile forces the nomimated model to reroll successful to hit rolls in the new army book.

Although I can understand the logic it would be an incredible injustice to have the step up rule not count when the model is nominated but then have it count when it comes to the model hitting back at the vampire.
 
Injustice or not if beguile helps you kill the model you want count it good. If you use it to kill a single R&F your wasting it if there are character targets around. You don't get to mesmerize everybody that steps up to you....one model means just that. One model.
 
Aren't there also two other models in base contact with the character? So, logically, the beguiled model isn't necessarily dead. Quite possibly your vampire was smart and swung at the other two files of troops.
 
I agree that if you are in b2b with more than one RnF model you could be directing your attacks at the model not beguiled. As the rest of the unit would continue to step up into that one position while the beguiled model stayed there.

However, I must say that if your vampire is stuck on the corner of a unit and is only in b2b with a single model, that will be the only one he can direct his attacks to and so it will be the first to die.

Beguile is definitely intended to be used against characters, but it can help to sway a combat against RnF in your favor at least a little, and if you paid for it why not use it? In most situations my first example should cover what is happening and allow the effect to last, but in the occasional situation when there is only one model to direct your attacks at, and you kill that model before they are able to attack, then the beguile effect will be lost.
 
That's how I understood it to work. As long as you have something else to swing at, that model will remain beguiled. And, while it usually doesn't matter against RnF, every little bit helps for things like a vamp riding with blood knights.
 
This thread's been dead for a while... but it most certainly IS VERY useful for rank/file models like Ironguts, Trolls, Demis, etc.

I've had opponents today say that I can't target specific rank/file models, so I can't say "I'm hitting the non-beguiled guys". Therefore if I killed 1 rank/file, my oppoenent would take off the beguiled guy.

I don't agree with this at all and it sounds ridiculous, however I don't know of a clear way to define how the beguiled guy stays.
 
Dividing attacks rule with errata:

"...If a model is touching enemies with different characteristic profiles, or two or more characters or units with the same characteristic profiles, it can choose which one to attack when its turn to strike comes (before any dice are rolled).

Similarly if a model has more than 1 attack, it can divide its attacks as the player wishes. Only the most skilled, experienced or formidable warriors have more than a single attack on their profile, and it seems sensible that such fighters would have the wits to strike at more than one fore should the opportunity present itself.

There's no right or wrong in such a decision - just make sure you declare your intentions to the opponent before any dice are rolled."



To me it is pretty clear that you're allowed to do anything with your attacks as long as you hit something in B2B. But some people will argue till there is a FAQ that specifically states that using beguile on a RnF and targetting an other RnF is legal.. :thumbsdown:

I would argue that beating such people with sticks should be allowed alas it is not...

Beyond beating assholes with sticks the following would be advised:
Position your beguiler so it can be used on a unit champion if there are no characters.. Failing that use the most important rule and roll for it, at the very least you get a 50% chance to be able to target RnF...
 
Bullhax said:
Dividing attacks rule with errata:

"...If a model is touching enemies with different characteristic profiles, or two or more characters or units with the same characteristic profiles, it can choose which one to attack when its turn to strike comes (before any dice are rolled).

Similarly if a model has more than 1 attack, it can divide its attacks as the player wishes. Only the most skilled, experienced or formidable warriors have more than a single attack on their profile, and it seems sensible that such fighters would have the wits to strike at more than one fore should the opportunity present itself.

There's no right or wrong in such a decision - just make sure you declare your intentions to the opponent before any dice are rolled."



To me it is pretty clear that you're allowed to do anything with your attacks as long as you hit something in B2B. But some people will argue till there is a FAQ that specifically states that using beguile on a RnF and targetting an other RnF is legal.. :thumbsdown:

I would argue that beating such people with sticks should be allowed alas it is not...

Beyond beating assholes with sticks the following would be advised:
Position your beguiler so it can be used on a unit champion if there are no characters.. Failing that use the most important rule and roll for it, at the very least you get a 50% chance to be able to target RnF...

QFT as hard as possible (Especially the beating people with sticks part, I like that part).

If "There's no right or wrong in such a decision - just make sure you declare your intentions to the opponent before any dice are rolled." Declare your intentions, if that line can't clear things up, then perhaps a fist to their face would :devil2:

But really, I honestly have no idea how people get by in this game playing RAW :Vampire1:
 
People say, "you can't specifically target rank/file models to hit in CC, so u can't target the target the guy next to the beguiled guy."

Then, when I cause wounds, he says, "I'm removing the beguiled guy bc I can choose who I remove, then the Step-Up rule applies and fills the empty spot from the back rank"

It's a pretty dick move alright... and i don't think there's anything in writing that says I can't.

I suppose i could say I'm beguiling the musician or banner-bearer... But in the fluff it says troops die and others pick up the banner or horn..

Or I could target the Maneater holding a great weapon in a mixed unit of other maneaters with additional hand weapons... That'll work, yep, remove the GW guy bc u choose who dies :)
 
Tell that guy to get his head out of his ass, and have him find where in the BRB it states that you yourself is allowed to chose who to remove.. Logically you use the step up rule but no way in hell is he allowed to dictate who you hit..!

RAW says you remove from the back as per the BRB. Which would allow you to beguile him.

When applying some logic, you attack people in the front row and guys step over fallen enemies (says so in the BRB too), but also states that a warrior elite enough to have more than one attack can attack who ever he god damn pleases, and why on earth would you attack the heavy armoured blind guy that can't hit worth a damn over his just as armoured friend that might actually hit you.. Which would allow you to beguile him.

The maneater rule specifically states that you remove from the back row no matter what equipment that model might have in regards of gear, so that would leave the guy beguiled as it would normally too.!

In conclusion:
Wow what a huge dick! And not in the "wow that guy has a huge dick"-way
 
It's a case of Fluff vs Game mechanic. So my opinion on either:

Fluff:
So according to fluff the warriors behind step up, taking the place of their fallen, also picking up the standard of a fallen unit standard. In the same way you could argue that as the vampire beguile a model, but then kill him, a new guy will just step into her gaze, being just as weak minded as his brother and therefore still have the effect.

Game mechanics:
This tells you to remove models from the back. So no, you are actually not allowed to move a rank and file model in the front and then move models up to take his place.


Anyway, lets just imagine this:
A pretty vampire is engaged in the back of an ogre deathstar and use beguile on a rear model. Now a blender vampire lord with higher I is engaged in the front causing 9 wounds to the unit. Would the beguiled model survive the 9 Blender wounds? I think not... as models are removed from the rear. In any case, you cant have it both ways.
 
I agree, beguile targets a model in base contact while slain models are removed from the back, so the beguiled trooper wont be removed. Its pretty clear in the rules and if he tries to apply logic to it, tell him to go find a real life dragon for you and then stuff it up his ass.
 
His response in a private forum...

"Please give me page and paragraph numbers from the rulebook please.

Page numbers ?? Quotes ?? Your opinion or anyone else's doesn't matter if you want to use this against me in a game you have to show me it in the book, or your argument is moot."

So basically I can't select which rank/file I hit, yet he can choose which rank/file I hit.
 
eggspr said:
His response in a private forum...

"Please give me page and paragraph numbers from the rulebook please.

Page numbers ?? Quotes ?? Your opinion or anyone else's doesn't matter if you want to use this against me in a game you have to show me it in the book, or your argument is moot."

So basically I can't select which rank/file I hit, yet he can choose which rank/file I hit.

Ask him to prove his point; why does he not have to put forth an argument? As least if he pointed to something that said you removed the models in a certain order, or something that referenced what he's trying to put forth then it would make sense.

I really hard vote for kick him in the d!ck.

I'm glad at least that this is by far and large the minority of players, but it's exactly the kind of person I avoid tournaments/public events for, and why I would only consider playing Warhammer with friends. The rules are not nearly clear enough to allow you to present actual facts in many outlier cases, like for instance this.

It's hard too, because my response in general to duche bags is really just to give up and let them have what they want (At worst to use the 50/50 "Golden Rule") but that doesn't teach them they are wrong, or that they shouldn't be that way. But honestly besides beating the living sh!t out of a goddamned idiot like that, I have no idea how I can impart the knowledge that they are wrong and being complete duchers.

You know, I believe if you write GW, their team will response with an official ruling; Granted I think that is just an opinion from the people working on the e-mail team over at GW, but you could very well get an "Official GW answer" and present that to him, and if he refuses at that point. Seriously punch his fu#$*ng D!ck.

Alternatively, you must be playing in some sort of organized play right? Or is this a "friendly" game? Because if there is an organizer/Tournament head, you should always defer to their judgement (Which should be much more sound than the D-bag who is RAW-retard).
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu