Best background: WHFB or WH40K

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Disciple of Nagash

Libidinosus
Administrator
True Blood
Feb 12, 2008
28,011
Yorkshire
Zombies
13,979
So a question for you all - which background do you think is better - WHFB or WH40K.

In the past this was always easy for me: WHFB. The big fat army books back then had so much depth, the story of Nagash's uprising and creation of the Undead / Vampires was fantastic and very much dragged me into the lore of the old world.

But if you asked me know, I have to say WH40K, and there is one reason for that. The Horus Heresy Novels.

I was never too much interested in the WH40K, I played Nids at first and their background was basically:

Omnomnomnomnom
*burp*
Go to sleep / evolve
Travel

Rinse, lather and repeat xd

But the HH are really good.....I mean I rate them as good as other high profile series like the Game of Thrones AKA "Everyone Dies"

From that I began to explore the background and I just think it is seems more indepth, and yes whilst many elements are copied, how they are mashed together seems a lot more original for me. I still eagerly await each release of the HH series.

Don't get me wrong, if I had to pick one "saga", Nagash would win out. But for overall universe, I think WH40K wins out.

What do you think, overall and specific saga?
 
Originally for me it was Fantasy before I started looking at 40K.

Overall I think 40K wins out, it's just got a lot more going for it. Horus Heresy is the single best series of events in either universe I feel. Then I find the factions a lot more interesting and varied than those in fantasy.

Personally my favourite stories however are those of Gaunt's Ghosts, the Tanith First and only :D
 
I've never been able to relate to the fluff in 40k as I have for fantasy. I'd say that the deep space is too big for me and I like the clearly defined nations of the Warhammer world better. It's got a real sense of familiarity for me at this point.
 
MasterSpark said:
I've never been able to relate to the fluff in 40k as I have for fantasy. I'd say that the deep space is too big for me and I like the clearly defined nations of the Warhammer world better. It's got a real sense of familiarity for me at this point.

I find the Imperial Guard relatable, to be honest they're what makes the 40K universe cool for me.
 
Get of W said:
I find the Imperial Guard relatable, to be honest they're what makes the 40K universe cool for me.

Oh yeah, the different races are cool and all but the world itself is just too vast. Almost so that most of anything is reduced to insignificant little specks in the bigger scheme.

Though I suppose that 40k campaigns do zero in on a smaller area than the entire galaxy to give it a sense of importance.
 
MasterSpark said:
Get of W said:
I find the Imperial Guard relatable, to be honest they're what makes the 40K universe cool for me.

Oh yeah, the different races are cool and all but the world itself is just too vast. Almost so that most of anything is reduced to insignificant little specks in the bigger scheme.

Though I suppose that 40k campaigns do zero in on a smaller area than the entire galaxy to give it a sense of importance.

I feel it also allows for a larger amount of freedom when it comes to writing your own fluff.

I can't make up my own province in the empire but I can create my own planet in the Imperium with it's own regimental history. :clown:
 
Get of W said:
I feel it also allows for a larger amount of freedom when it comes to writing your own fluff.

I can't make up my own province in the empire but I can create my own planet in the Imperium with it's own regimental history. :clown:

True, but I'd argue that it can come to the point where it's too free, if you know what I mean. Fantasy fluff is easier to root more firmly into the world and to cross-over with other players' fluff since it's all going on over the same piece of land.
 
MS - I think I had that issue as well. For me it really was the novels that helped with that. Gaunt's Ghosts is fantastic at doing that (though I much prefer the earlier novels than the last few), and the Horus Heresy novels do a superb job of making space marines relatable. If you haven't read them just give the first a try, it is worth it.

Ghouly & MS - Any particular saga in WHFB that stands out to you?
 
MasterSpark said:
Get of W said:
I feel it also allows for a larger amount of freedom when it comes to writing your own fluff.

I can't make up my own province in the empire but I can create my own planet in the Imperium with it's own regimental history. :clown:

True, but I'd argue that it can come to the point where it's too free, if you know what I mean. Fantasy fluff is easier to root more firmly into the world and to cross-over with other players' fluff since it's all going on over the same piece of land.

I understand what you mean but I just really don't feel that way but perhaps it's because the Fantasy Fluff does nothing to make me care at all for the well being of anyone in it (from the entire black library I can't think of one story where I cared about the characters. I have liked them but not cared about them).

Where as everytime a grunt from Ghost's Ghosts dies I tear up :'(
 
I actually haven't read any novels for either 40k or fantasy, so I'm only going on armybook and rulebook fluff. That certainly doesn't give you much personality for all the characters involved, which in honesty probably makes all the old fantasy tales (Vlad's war on the Empire, Grom's attack on Ulthuan, Mortkin's siege of Ostland in the 8th ed rulebook, and many many more) seem more like retold legends than fully-fledged stories. And I like it. :clown:
 
Ghouly said:
for me the Heroes and Villains are more Badass, when they face each other it is an actual battle like their actually trying in 40K its all guns

To be fair a lot of the time they fight in melee combat (inexplicably since their are guns!).

Also guns aren't actual battle? Inform the worlds historians! :tongue:
 
Shareya said:
Fantasy all the way.

Not that I'm surprised by the answer ;), I'm just curious to know a bit more as to why.

As for me, I like both of them. They each have their well written pieces of background, and the not so well written pieces. I like a lot of the background for the undead in Fantasy, and the rich history of the Empire, but 40K background is of much more interest to me from the Chaos perspective, which I don't find very compelling in the Fantasy setting.
 
It's a bit hard to put into words why I prefer fantasy over 40k when it comes to background/fluff. Believe it or not I don't mind sc-fi! Heck I would drool all over Bioware if they released a new mass effect game or mmo.

When one of my guild members in WoW ( this was 7+ years ago I think) started to rant about Warhammer I quickly got interested. I went through almost all of the fantasy army books, read some novels and eventually got into Lahmians/vamps and so forth, so forth.
I adored the world, I adored the fights and the struggles. I did also enjoy the theme that was dark but not quite OMFG SO GRIMDARK AHHHHH! Naturally it helped that you rarely ran into a character that was fully good and many of the "villains" of the world where damn likable ( I am looking at you Malus ).
I heavily dislike the numerous "I-WIN" buttons the forces of good get at times. A good example are the High elves vs Dark elves where the Darklings are suddenly defeated because a certain mage and his brother got either superpoweritems or dragons or god so forth. Why can't they just struggle, fight and eventually claw a win -.- But ah well.

Now when the same friend started to talk to me about 40k, I actually got interested at first and then the more I learned about the setting ( via him, games and books ) the more I started to dislike the setting.
While the fantasy world rarely sees massive shifts in power, it is even worse in 40k. Losing one planet? two? Hundred? Who the heck cares! There are thousands if not millions more. The grim darkness at times seems to be just so over the top that it is just funny/silly and nothing more. Don't even get me started on the god emperor and the horrific space marines! The more I learned about it the more I sighed as their stories where all just some teenagers dream. Super soldier with no flaws! But wait! They got flaws! They ha-Just no -.-"

Now I can accept and see why some people find 40k more appealing then fantasy. How big the unvierse is but for me it's all quite meh. Over the top grimdark that is silly, space marines that are at best clowns and even Dark Eldar don't hold up to Druchii :( The only time I ever found something redeemable in 40k was when I read Dan Alb-...something books! Now he is a wonderful writer and I very much adored to read about his Imperial Guard group? Gaunts ghosts I think? Heh maybe I was unlucky. If I would have got with his books I might have been bit more accepting. But for now? For me -personally- it's a boring universe where most things have been built up to push space marines in the spot light one way or the other.

Ugh! Sloppy post but ah well it was mostly a 4AM rant xD
 
I can't really decide because Fantasy has normally better books and heroes, and the 'main' faction isn't blindly clunking away in an endless cycle where no one seems to know what's happening and learning is forbidden, but at least with 40K you can invent just about anything, because the fluff isn't quite as sealed tight, and any faction can be considered evil in some sort of way-"Learning is forbidden, get that stake in here!", "Join the greater good!" "No!" Bang!, Chaos, "Must-torture-to-survive!" "Worship the emperor!" "No!" Bang! and other examples of evil behaviour, which can be found in any faction, but in Fantasy, each faction has a clearly defined side (TK are more good, and Ogres aren't exactly evil).
Unfortunately, there are the I win buttons Shareya mentioned-Teclis' magic, taping into the Lord of Heaven's power, Ghal-Maraz (how does that kill the God of Undeath!?)- and most Fantasy races are copypasted real countries-Germany, Arabia, China, Japan, India, Russia, Vikings. So, in the end, it's Fantasy.
 
i find myself significantly more invested in fantasy-most likely as a relic lf me being a tyranid player myself :P

40k seems to be very over-the-top or no real consequence at all, just a mindless ongoing war. That's kinda cool in it's own respect but it gets a bit dull after a while for me.

Having said that, while in general i find the setting less interesting, 40k has far more interesting 'sideline' characters and races like the umbra or solar macharius than fantasy does (save for the fishmen of course :P )
 
i like both universe's and it has just occured to me that i like vampires in both i fell in love with blood angels the minute they got released my two favorite stories are gabriel seth and his screw it if were going out were going out with a bang attitude and also the model is badass and mephistons wierd story were hes just a boss like Abhorash and conquers the curse and becomes something ... greater but a sisister feeling is about that story starnge that the eldar just pop in weigh mephiston up then bugger off lol
 
Shareya said:
It's a bit hard to put into words why I prefer fantasy over 40k when it comes to background/fluff. Believe it or not I don't mind sc-fi! Heck I would drool all over Bioware if they released a new mass effect game or mmo.

When one of my guild members in WoW ( this was 7+ years ago I think) started to rant about Warhammer I quickly got interested. I went through almost all of the fantasy army books, read some novels and eventually got into Lahmians/vamps and so forth, so forth.
I adored the world, I adored the fights and the struggles. I did also enjoy the theme that was dark but not quite OMFG SO GRIMDARK AHHHHH! Naturally it helped that you rarely ran into a character that was fully good and many of the "villains" of the world where damn likable ( I am looking at you Malus ).
I heavily dislike the numerous "I-WIN" buttons the forces of good get at times. A good example are the High elves vs Dark elves where the Darklings are suddenly defeated because a certain mage and his brother got either superpoweritems or dragons or god so forth. Why can't they just struggle, fight and eventually claw a win -.- But ah well.

Now when the same friend started to talk to me about 40k, I actually got interested at first and then the more I learned about the setting ( via him, games and books ) the more I started to dislike the setting.
While the fantasy world rarely sees massive shifts in power, it is even worse in 40k. Losing one planet? two? Hundred? Who the heck cares! There are thousands if not millions more. The grim darkness at times seems to be just so over the top that it is just funny/silly and nothing more. Don't even get me started on the god emperor and the horrific space marines! The more I learned about it the more I sighed as their stories where all just some teenagers dream. Super soldier with no flaws! But wait! They got flaws! They ha-Just no -.-"

Now I can accept and see why some people find 40k more appealing then fantasy. How big the unvierse is but for me it's all quite meh. Over the top grimdark that is silly, space marines that are at best clowns and even Dark Eldar don't hold up to Druchii :( The only time I ever found something redeemable in 40k was when I read Dan Alb-...something books! Now he is a wonderful writer and I very much adored to read about his Imperial Guard group? Gaunts ghosts I think? Heh maybe I was unlucky. If I would have got with his books I might have been bit more accepting. But for now? For me -personally- it's a boring universe where most things have been built up to push space marines in the spot light one way or the other.

Ugh! Sloppy post but ah well it was mostly a 4AM rant xD

I agree with the space marines, I tend to avoid a lot of space marine novels except for those such as HH, some of the Space Marine battle series and Iron Snakes I believe it was. Also the Ultramarines series wasn't bad. They all wrote the Spacemarines as Super Soldiers but far from perfect and as flawed as any (perhaps more so due to the arrogance many of them seem to have since they're "superior).

I also see the consequences thing many people are putting out but I can't get behind it because of how stale things are in fantasy. IF things actually happened and there were loses and gains then I would be 100% in agreement but as it is, I can't see how the point matters one way or another.

To be perfectly honest it's not the background itself that gets me, I just think there is more superior pieces of fiction in the form of Novels for 40K than there is for Fantasy. Both have good and crap books of course but I think the very best of Black Library are 40K books (e.g. Gaunts Ghosts, Horus Heresy, Battle of the Fang etc), but that's just me.


...also I think knights in armour are giant twits, give me a futuristic army with lasers using napoleonic tactics any day of the week :tongue:
 
I find comments that Fantasy is better than 40k because 40k's fluff is stagnant to be a little hypocritical, given that the good guys in Fantasy inevitably get an 'I win button' that saves their bacon and prevents the world from changing significantly in favor of the baddies. That aside, the sheer size of 40k and the Imperium can be a strength. So much room for exploration, so many machinations of military and state. But a major weakness, to me at least is its overwhelming focus on Space Marines when there's so much more out there. Fantasy at least has it better here, in that it isn't always about Karl Franz saving the day or something.
 
I really enjoy the fantasy setting far more than I do that of 40K. I find that I can actually read the books and get invested in characters from the Fantasy world, whereas the 40K books I have tried to read (for the most part) bore me to the point where I can't read them.

I especially found this with the Horus Heresy series; I have the first ... 3/4 books, but I've never got further than partway into the second, because I just got really bored with the characters within it.
I also think it's because I have much more interest in battles such as those fought in the fantasy universe; the tough, gritty melee battles are much more personal and involved than the huge, impersonal scale conflicts of the 40K universe where an entire world can be destroyed and no-one feels the difference; it's just a minor ripple in the sea of space. If something like that happened in WFB, the implications would reach far further and impact everything!
 
I like the fantasy ideas a lot better than 40k. In 40k you never really have a single character or set of characters that are truely the "good guys". I mean you have these characters who decide what "Heresy" is and then punish people for doing it. You have humans killing other races because they refuse to beleive in what the human race beleives in. I mean, Really??

Where in fantasy you have a very deffined good and evil. High elves, Empire, Bretonia, Dwarfs, they all show a very clean idea. Fight for what they believe in and defend their home, where the evil (Vamps, Chaos, Skaven, Dark Elves, O&G) all want nothing but to destroy and rule over everything. I think it's moreso that 40k creates more moral problems with the so called "Good Guys" and makes you hate bits and pieces of them until the defined good and evil just becomes a loose shade of grey.
 
What you described is however the main point of 40k

DA GRIMDARKNESS

Also 40k:

Johnny+Grimdark.+Woah+Emperor_705496_4398709.webp
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu