Black Knights with Lances?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Avent

Zombie
Feb 6, 2012
4
Zombies
4
Thinking about using a unit of Black Knights as a hammer unit. Do you find Lances to be cost-effective? Only helping on the charge turns me off, but it's a nice bonus, especially for a unit that's supposed to be killing things.

Thoughts? What do you like to give your mounted, hard-hitting units?
 
They only get one attack so I'd go with lances all the time. You need to win combat and in my my experience if Black Knights don't win in the turn they charge (thanks to the strength bonus) they end up crumbling from combat res as strength 4 doesn't really cut it. (I usually play against Dwarfs) In relation to what Tim put yes, if your against lightly armoured enemies with low toughness too you could probably get away with not taking lances, you get killing blow whatever so that's always a bonus.
 
I don't think it should even be an option to no take lances. Cav are designed to get the charge and they need to make that charge count! if you play a block of 6x2 12 strong that is 12 attacks min at str 6. What is str 4 doing for you? At that point you may as well just opt for GG. I'll pay the 24pts for the entire unit to win combat all day every day. Even against T3 I would still take lances. Wounding on 2's instead of 3's against most infantry in the game is where it is at. Why give an empire soldier a 6/6+ save? Why not just give him his parry and call it a day and make him make 2-3 more saves. That is 2-3 more combat rez! You aren't bringing more than 1 rank to the fight so you make up for it in the extra kills and getting the alpha strike. ALWAYS TAKE LANCES! :thumbsup:
 
If you're not going to take lances, then why not just grab GG with sword and board? half the cost and just as good of a hammer unit (mounted attacks aside). Str 4 is not an effective hammer, str 6 is.
Take the lances. Take them now! :mad2: xD
 
I always take mine with lances; I too wonder why they even have the option of not taking barding and/or lances. Without either, they seem to lack the "knight" in "black knight."
 
Lances cost '1 slave', compared to the price of the unit models and the benefit, i would always grab it. And in most cases i would call it a fail if they didn't get the charge or didn't try.

Not to go too much off-topic, but how about barding, is it viable to go without? 1,5 slave for a armour save improved by one?
 
In my opinion: "Barding yes, toatly, pretty much a must"

As stated above you want to win the fight when charging, and since you lack numbers and ranks every model counts.
 
Always. Always, always take lances. The difference between the charge with lance and not charging is MASSIVE (looks at my Bretonnian army).

Calvary model should ALWAYS take lances! I can't think of a single reason/exception.
 
Thanks for the great responses. It seems everyone is in agreement about lances, and even barding. Makes sense to me!
 
-Note: The single reason/exception would be chaos Knights, since you lose your magical +1 ST weapons if you take lances. :D
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu