Black Knights

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Kuwanger23

Skeleton
Jan 17, 2012
78
Zombies
77
I just realized that you won't out rank a block with these guys. So they will be steadfast and if you aren't breaking people on the charge than the knights are not doing their job. So what is the point of cav in this edition? You certainly aren't buying them deep. I was thinking of running a 12 man unit of Black knights and maybe a 6 or blood knights in some games. Both units rack up enough CR to break units no problem but not if they are just going to be stubborn to begin with. And I certainly don't want to pay 350+ points for a unit I have to try to flank with because that is easy to avoid. So how do you use these guys?
 
In big games, I've added them together, either as 30+ black Knights, or 15 in each unit. It is expensive in points, but I don't see any other useful set up. In smaller games, I simply don't use them. But this is not a VC problem, it is now a general problem for cavalry.
 
A proper BK bus should have at least 2 ranks, but far from all blocks will outrank you when it counts - after combat. Even if you can't get enough kills to strip Stubborn from the enemy block, it's better to break it in your opponent's turn, giving you the combat reform and a choice of what to charge, at the start of your next turn. If you really want to rack up the kills, have a Varghulf or two flank your bus and help out with the charge. Should be a brutal experience for your opponent.
Also, Aura of Dark Majesty is now cheap enough to put on a vampire, and help out against break tests.
 
Kuwanger23 said:
I just realized that you won't out rank a block with these guys. So they will be steadfast and if you aren't breaking people on the charge than the knights are not doing their job. So what is the point of cav in this edition? You certainly aren't buying them deep. I was thinking of running a 12 man unit of Black knights and maybe a 6 or blood knights in some games. Both units rack up enough CR to break units no problem but not if they are just going to be stubborn to begin with. And I certainly don't want to pay 350+ points for a unit I have to try to flank with because that is easy to avoid. So how do you use these guys?

I've only started playing with the new edition and I haven't enough Vampire counts yet to play with (just started two weeks ago...), but it looks to me like the good way to use cavalry now, is as support for your infantry blocks. Get the enemy up front with your infantry and then charge in the side with your cavalry to wreak some havoc in there and cause disruption.
The advantage is that they still have more movement than an average infantry unit so they can be where they need to be rather fast.
 
Vintersorg: While Cavalry is certainly not the powerhouse it used to be (and I play VC and WoC so I know), I still think 8 ed is much better balanced for many reasons.

I did play dwarfs a lot, but even they were next to powerless to stop the knights once they got into close combat, even though there was only 5 chaos knights and a character (often even a sorcerer in earlier editions). This only encouraged players to bring as many war machines etc to the games as possible.

With chaos knights at 80 points a pop, the game became more of a game of pure luck, not skill. It all came down to a few precious armour saves.

In this ed, you can't just buy 5 knights and a lord, and then obliterate a 100 man unit of Imperial Halberdiers on the charge, which too me used to be rather ridiculous. Pretty happy with the Steadfast rule in fact.

As you say, we still have movement on our side with knights, and we now need to use them with a bit of skill to get the maximum out of them. The days were we just charged across the table and "won" on turn two is gone. Thankfully, as it makes for far better games overall in 8.ed.

With how powerful the Cavalry used to be, their price was much higher as well. Quite like the new cost of cavalry, as you can now have "proper" sized units.

All this said, I'd still like to see some special cavalry rule be made, which could allow them to "break through" the enemy unit of they won the combat, so that they didn't automatically get bogged down in combat. Something like allowing them a LD test (or Strength or Initiative for that matter) to escape out through the rear of the enemy unit's formation etc.
 
Kuwanger23 said:
And I certainly don't want to pay 350+ points for a unit I have to try to flank with because that is easy to avoid. So how do you use these guys?

If you put a unit like that, (with a character), on a flank it is NOT going to be avoided. It will either be shot, blasted by magic, tarpited, or faced by a similarily threatening unit depending on the enemy. I play against dwarves a lot and I can tell you that when I place my knights on the flank (but still 12" or less away from general on first turn), the dwarf player reacts by either refusing the flank and planning to shoot me to pieces, or places a big unit opposite me. I almost always take the big unit of Knights with a Vampire who can invocation them and with ironcurse (for that 6+ save goodness :)). Anyway, even if I cannot break through his 30 or 40 man unit of Great weapon warrors (for example), he still has to invest and equal number of points to stop them. Of course every game is different but you get my drift....
 
Wojmir Von Carstein said:
Kuwanger23 said:
And I certainly don't want to pay 350+ points for a unit I have to try to flank with because that is easy to avoid. So how do you use these guys?

If you put a unit like that, (with a character), on a flank it is NOT going to be avoided. It will either be shot, blasted by magic, tarpited, or faced by a similarily threatening unit depending on the enemy. I play against dwarves a lot and I can tell you that when I place my knights on the flank (but still 12" or less away from general on first turn), the dwarf player reacts by either refusing the flank and planning to shoot me to pieces, or places a big unit opposite me. I almost always take the big unit of Knights with a Vampire who can invocation them and with ironcurse (for that 6+ save goodness :)). Anyway, even if I cannot break through his 30 or 40 man unit of Great weapon warrors (for example), he still has to invest and equal number of points to stop them. Of course every game is different but you get my drift....


by flank i literally meant get a flank with them to take away their stead fast.
 
Kuwanger23 said:
by flank i literally meant get a flank with them to take away their stead fast.

Flanking cannot take away Steadfast. Your unit must still have as many or more ranks than the enemy unit in order to deny Steadfast. Also, you count the actual number of complete ranks, not the rank bonus.
 
Indeed. In fact, flanking a unit is only useful for added CR. You need more ranks in order to put the CR to good use. "Disruption" pretty much only gives you +4 CR on your opponent (-3 ranks from them and +1 for flank...often another +1 for charging). You still need a large block to negate steadfast.

Funnily enough it might be noted that it is, in a way, more effective to flank with a block and charge head-on with knights. You get less attacks to the flanks, so knights can weather the large number of return attacks with their armor, and your weaker block troops will take less wounds on the flank. As such you will keep more ranks after attacks back, and losing a knight or two is more efficient in CR than losing 3-5 RnF.

Killing might be the name of the game in 8th: but you can not take advantage of that killing without a sizable presence in the combat (IE: ranks to overwhelm the enemy, kind of like fear autobreaking in earlier rulesets).
 
Nedar said:
Indeed. In fact, flanking a unit is only useful for added CR. You need more ranks in order to put the CR to good use. "Disruption" pretty much only gives you +4 CR on your opponent (-3 ranks from them and +1 for flank...often another +1 for charging). You still need a large block to negate steadfast.

Funnily enough it might be noted that it is, in a way, more effective to flank with a block and charge head-on with knights. You get less attacks to the flanks, so knights can weather the large number of return attacks with their armor, and your weaker block troops will take less wounds on the flank. As such you will keep more ranks after attacks back, and losing a knight or two is more efficient in CR than losing 3-5 RnF.

Killing might be the name of the game in 8th: but you can not take advantage of that killing without a sizable presence in the combat (IE: ranks to overwhelm the enemy, kind of like fear autobreaking in earlier rulesets).

I've actually done that to great effect. In 3000 pts I use 3 units of calvary, 2 units of 10+ black knights and one of 5 blood knights with 2 mounted vampires that go where needed depending on the army. I usually line up one unit of black knights with my combat lord straight across from their most dangerous unit, and have the grave guard try to pull around and flank them. Usually the unit protecting their dangerous units flanks can't stand up to grave guard and even if I lose some black knights my lord does enough wounds that I usually win combat the next two phase. It definitely takes some skill and a little bit of luck to pull off, but that's how it should be.

Granted my blood knights and other unit of knights go after their flanks and the pure target saturation usually confuses enemies who try and death star at that points level.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu