Bladewind vs Lord on Dragon

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Drakim

Skeleton
Apr 23, 2010
92
Zombies
67
So, I just played a match, and this very nasty Dark Elf spell, Bladewind, was cast against my Lord general on a Dragon.

My Lord had the Wristband of Black Gold, but in the description of the Bladewind spell it says it causes "close combat attacks upon the target" and the spell also lets you specify which target to hit within a unit.

So, basically, he just picked my general lord for the bladewind spell, so I got no protection from the zombie dragon, and no protection from my ward save. In short, my general died.

I'm at part at fault for not giving the general any armor. I was thinking that in close combat I would avoid letting the enemy strike back at all, and that my Wristband of Black Gold would make me safe from ranged attacks. I was obviously wrong, as this spell can easily kill my general in this situation, at range.

I agree with my opponent that this is how it works from reading the spells, but like, really. It seems a bit too convenient at sniping out people with ranged protection at range.
 
A lord on dragon is always a risky choice in a list. Its alot of points to invest and it comes with the large target rule. This makes is a big target for enemies and your opponent had a good spell to counter it. It especially sucks because unlike other armies when our general dies we lose additional models for the rest of the game. Thats some tough luck with your opponent getting the spell off, hopefully next time you have better luck and can get behind his casters Line of sight
 
Yanda said:
A lord on dragon is always a risky choice in a list. Its alot of points to invest and it comes with the large target rule. This makes is a big target for enemies and your opponent had a good spell to counter it. It especially sucks because unlike other armies when our general dies we lose additional models for the rest of the game. Thats some tough luck with your opponent getting the spell off, hopefully next time you have better luck and can get behind his casters Line of sight

It's hard to navigate around Dark Riders, unless you are planning on doing absolutely nothing with the dragon for the whole game ><

Next time, I'm getting the Flayed Hauberk though, it should help a lot.
 
You must have rolled really poorly, or they rolled really well.

WS 4 S 4 should hit on 5's and wound on 5's, so only 1 in 9 attacks should have gotten through.

Or were you already wounded?
 
Fodderboy said:
You must have rolled really poorly, or they rolled really well.

WS 4 S 4 should hit on 5's and wound on 5's, so only 1 in 9 attacks should have gotten through.

Or were you already wounded?

You are incorrect. WS4 against our Lord's WS7 means it hits on 4s. Also, it's 3D6 attacks (my opponent rolled 13, which is slightly above average 10.5).

We worked out that it would on average take 2 wounds if everything went like it "should have". Which is dangerous for a vampire with 3 wounds. My opponent happened to roll 13 and hit slightly above average, so game over.

In the next turn the Zombie Dragon died to crumbling with it's low leadership. :(
 
Drakim said:
You are incorrect. WS4 against our Lord's WS7 means it hits on 4s. Also, it's 3D6 attacks (my opponent rolled 13, which is slightly above average 10.5).

Cloud of Flies - your opponent gets -1 to hit the model in CC.
 
Fodderboy said:
Drakim said:
You are incorrect. WS4 against our Lord's WS7 means it hits on 4s. Also, it's 3D6 attacks (my opponent rolled 13, which is slightly above average 10.5).

Cloud of Flies - your opponent gets -1 to hit the model in CC.

Cloud of Flies
Enemies in contact bla bla bla...

Pretty sure the wizard who is 24" from you isn't in contact with the Zombie Dragon.
 
Please point out the last sentence of Bladewind to your opponent (bold emphasis is my own):
Dark Elves Armybook said:
ONE of these attacks can be allocated against EACH character and champion in the unit

So, that should have been ONE attack on the Vampire, and 12 on the Dragon...
 
Bishop said:
Please point out the last sentence of Bladewind to your opponent (bold emphasis is my own):
Dark Elves Armybook said:
ONE of these attacks can be allocated against EACH character and champion in the unit

So, that should have been ONE attack on the Vampire, and 12 on the Dragon...

I was his opponent in this game, and while this might be true for a normal ranked up regiment, it does not transfer that smoothly into the situation that is a monstrous mount and its rider.

That being said, how we played it was most certainly wrong as only one attack could have been directly aimed at the lord, while the rest would have to be randomised between the lord and the dragon, as per normal.
 
Bishop said:
Please point out the last sentence of Bladewind to your opponent (bold emphasis is my own):
Dark Elves Armybook said:
ONE of these attacks can be allocated against EACH character and champion in the unit

So, that should have been ONE attack on the Vampire, and 12 on the Dragon...

Yeah, we realized this way after the match was done ><

Still, the spell's description is a bit sub-par, but now we know how it works.
 
Indeed, you'd randomise where the rest of the hits go. Also I'd say if an opponent wishes to circumvent the Cloud of Flies, then you'd get to take the Wristbands ward save. After all, it's either in contact or ranged, I don't think that the DE player should get to have it both ways :D
 
Lord Fear said:
Indeed, you'd randomise where the rest of the hits go. Also I'd say if an opponent wishes to circumvent the Cloud of Flies, then you'd get to take the Wristbands ward save. After all, it's either in contact or ranged, I don't think that the DE player should get to have it both ways :D

I'm not so sure about that. It's a spell that inflicts close combat hits.The Wristband ward save obviously doesn't save against close combat hits, despite that they are generated by magic.

Furthermore, the Cloud of Flies doesn't give -1 to hit on all attempts to attack the Dragon or Rider. It gives models in base contact with the dragon -1 to hit when they try to attack in general. This is even regardless of who you try to attack. If you are touching a Zombie Dragon but you want to attack some Crypt Ghouls that are also touching you, you get -1 to hit against the Crypt Ghouls.

I'd even argue that if the Wizard is touching the Zombie Dragon and wants to cast Bladewind on another target, it gets -1 to hit on them instead (but I don't think you can cast Bladewind out of combat like that, but I was just using it as an example)
 
Order of the Blood Dragon said:
It just seems unfortunate that it bypasses the common defences used by a VC dragon lord, at least it randomly allocates most of the hits though.

We found out it's actually only a single hit on the Lord, and with the high WS and T the vampire lord has, it's hardly a problem really.
 
Can someone clarify what is supposed to happen in this situation? It seems like the attacks shouldn't be randomized like shooting since they're not, and it also seems like it there shouldn't be any attacks allocated against the dragon itself since it is neither a character nor a champion...

but I don't have the exact wording in front of me, so it's hard for me to know ...
 
Magic damage is allocated like shooting damage as per the main rulebook, and confirmed in the Dark Elf FAQ. So you can put 1 attack on the Lord, but the rest would be randomised.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu