Blood Knights vs. Chaos Knights: A Final Showdown.

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Adam_Barrow

Sleepless Knight
True Blood
Dec 25, 2010
3,068
Nashville, TN
Zombies
1,655
Short and to the point, who has the baddest heavy horse unit in the game? Daemon worshiping Northmen with a penchant for spiky accouterments, or blood-drunk monsters with what can only be called a debauched code of honor.

To be brief in the This or That portion of our story, Blood Knights have only a slight Strength edge, and Khorne Knights will be Frenzied just like our guys. The Blood Knight mount is up by one point of Toughness. Chaos Armor is better, Blood Knights can be resurrected, The Hunger, The Will of Chaos. Chaos Knights get Ensorcelled Weapons, you get the idea.

Who brings the most fear in Warhammer?

(Nightmare Mode: A Challenger Appears) And for kicks, throw Mournfang Cav into the running as well.
 
Are we talking equal points or equal numbers? Who gets the charge? Are they fighting each other? Are they fighting chaff or elites? Shouldn't we add both of the lowly Grail Knights and Demi-griff Knights?

About "The Hunger", it only applies to characters plus the BldKn only have one wound, so even if they could use it, they'd be dead when it came time to feast. Perhaps I am misinterpreting it, as there is no mention that the Vamp needs to be alive.... :suck:
 
I request BloodCrushers be added to this. they have herald stats for a fraction of the cost ;)

S6 rider, S5 Mount, Both have killing blow and with a doubler-save makes em pretty survivable in the right situation
 
Point for point best heavy cav in the game is Knights Errant but I digress.

Also you can not really compare them due to Chaos Knights being special...
 
Without shiny bits (banners and such) I'd say Blood Knights have the edge, on the charge at least.

But when it comes to extra bits and pieces, I'd say the Chaos Knights steal the show. Banner of Rage (unlimited frenzy that works on steeds too) + mark of nurgle (-1 ws and -1 to hit with ranged) is just too damn good.
 
Soren said:
About "The Hunger", it only applies to characters plus the BldKn only have one wound, so even if they could use it, they'd be dead when it came time to feast. Perhaps I am misinterpreting it, as there is no mention that the Vamp needs to be alive.... :suck:

:slapface:
 
Blood Knights don't even have The Hunger as a special rule, so I don't know where this nonsense is coming from. As far as overall viability, the Chaos Knights are far more useful than Blood Knights, and I can say that with confidence. The reasons why are superior banner selection, those ever-so-handy Chaos Marks, lower points cost, and the better armor save.
 
I have to side with the chaos knights.

Savage orc boar boys with 2 hand weapons in the first round is pretty scary.

If we start trying to compare monstrous cav we've opened a whole new bag of worms.

You could have a unit made up of gobo heroes on grate cave squigs, OH MY!
 
Blood Knight have the edge, its a slight one but they have it.

- We get 3 attacks each which they would need to take a banner to get
- They get the same strength when you take into account their free magic weapons but on a charge we are strength 7 going to 5 after, they are strength 6 if lances going to 4s or staying at 5 with magic weapons.
- We can All accept Challenges.
- We have the same speed.
- Chaos Knights have +1 armour on us.
- Our unit champion can be given a magic weapon.
- We get a nice ranged ward save banner.
- We are slightly more expensive at base but they have to pay for marks unless they want vanilla knights....
- We can come back to life.


Monstrous Cav don't feature in this, they are something else all together, its like comparing High Elf Sword Masters and Ogres.
 
From OP:

(Nightmare Mode: A Challenger Appears) And for kicks, throw Mournfang Cav into the running as well.
So yes, MC ARE in this. :tongue:

Even if it is just to be boiled down to point for point efficiency. (which as it stands, can be in all courts)

And I'd say High elf swordmasters have more than enough edge against ogres. what with those super light great weapons that not only add +2 strength but give them ASF too. so thats 3s to hit, with rerolls and 3s to wound (@-2 AS) Bad example :lol:

But that comes down to the nonesense that is swordmasters.

Points for chaos knights: Can get 3 attacks simply with mark, banner would only be for unlosable frenzy.
Can have a built in 6++ from MoT
Can also get ward save against range. (banner)


and thats about it, sure, they (CK) are cheaper per model, but BK's can come back to life. that is an unreal advantage over any unit in the same roll.

I have yet to see the two face off head to head in an actual game however. I will however report back with the results!
 
I made the point Mesa as one is a single wound model with a higher strength and the other a multi wound model, thats the point but in this case you have not picked up on it.
The knights are all single wound, the monstrous are not, I would not considered them in any way as being comparable on this.

Really depends how your using your knight, I still think they have the edge one on one even against upgraded CK because at the days end they would work in tandem with the armies magic and not fight everything in a bubble.
Also I would expect a character in the unit considering its cost. n
 
Duke Danse Macabre said:
Really depends how your using your knight, I still think they have the edge one on one even against upgraded CK because at the days end they would work in tandem with the armies magic and not fight everything in a bubble.
Also I would expect a character in the unit considering its cost. n

Yeah but then you would have to take into consideration that the CK might have gifts betoved upon them from the warshrine. But I don't actually think you should consider this when looking at the units as both magic and gifts depend on other models and then you would have to also consider the cost of these units.
 
You also need to consider the units role- As far as I see it heavy cav are a linebreaker, designed to smash into units and do as much damage in the charge as possible and hopefully break the enemy, or to smash into already engaged units.
 
Unless they are using Cav blocks which is a waste most the time I don't see it happening.

Actually from what I hear O&G can do well with lots and lots of wolf/spider cav but thats an entirely different army :p
 
But if they take it, the Blasted Standard either stays at a weaker save or they don't get Frenzy. It's not directly comparable.
 
In a game.....of say 3k I'd say Blood Knights have the upper hand, as with our magic we can raise them back, give them re rolls to hit and to wound or make them go an extra 8". Plus, ours are just so much cooler, vampires riding nightmares that have a code of honour....and eat little kids for breakfast XD
 
Aren said:
In a game.....of say 3k I'd say Blood Knights have the upper hand, as with our magic we can raise them back, give them re rolls to hit and to wound or make them go an extra 8". Plus, ours are just so much cooler, vampires riding nightmares that have a code of honour....and eat little kids for breakfast XD

Yes but you can't just take that into consideration. WoC has some nasty spells of their own. One lucky infernal gateway it's its bye bye.
Also chaos knights are very cool too... especially nurgle ones.
 
Knights you can raise back gets me everytime...
Chaos Knights have failed to impress me (well outside of statline/AS) since the time a unit of 5 hit my 10 HE archers and died before they got all those big nasty attacks...
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu