Blood Knights vs. Chaos Knights: A Final Showdown.

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Johnny-Crass said:
Point for point best heavy cav in the game is Knights Errant but I digress.

Also you can not really compare them due to Chaos Knights being special...

How in gods green earth do you figure knights errant are anything but rubbish? Poor stat line makes them a terrible choice. Low initiative, leadership and weapon skill can't be overcome by a decent armour save. Too many things can chop them down or weather thier first assault.
 
Thindol said:
Johnny-Crass said:
Point for point best heavy cav in the game is Knights Errant but I digress.

Also you can not really compare them due to Chaos Knights being special...

How in gods green earth do you figure knights errant are anything but rubbish? Poor stat line makes them a terrible choice. Low initiative, leadership and weapon skill can't be overcome by a decent armour save. Too many things can chop them down or weather thier first assault.


[Inset Not Sure if Serious pic]

Errants are cheap as chips
Have one of the best banners in the game
have a 2+ armor and a ward
Ignore peasant panic
Get ITP when they charge
And did I mention they are core?
 
Johnny-Crass said:
Thindol said:
Johnny-Crass said:
Point for point best heavy cav in the game is Knights Errant but I digress.

Also you can not really compare them due to Chaos Knights being special...

How in gods green earth do you figure knights errant are anything but rubbish? Poor stat line makes them a terrible choice. Low initiative, leadership and weapon skill can't be overcome by a decent armour save. Too many things can chop them down or weather thier first assault.


[Inset Not Sure if Serious pic]

Errants are cheap as chips
Have one of the best banners in the game
have a 2+ armor and a ward
Ignore peasant panic
Get ITP when they charge
And did I mention they are core?

Id have to be with Johnny on this one, cheap core with good armour?
nasty good.

even under the old rules i loved my silver helms when they were core..
 
Not really a competition at all. Blood knights are awesome looking models, and I love the lore, but all in all there is really no reason to ever take them (for me at least). Chaos knights are cheaper and much more versatile. Also, they don't come out of rare and blood knights do.
 
Johnny-Crass said:
Thindol said:
Johnny-Crass said:
Point for point best heavy cav in the game is Knights Errant but I digress.

Also you can not really compare them due to Chaos Knights being special...

How in gods green earth do you figure knights errant are anything but rubbish? Poor stat line makes them a terrible choice. Low initiative, leadership and weapon skill can't be overcome by a decent armour save. Too many things can chop them down or weather thier first assault.


[Inset Not Sure if Serious pic]

Errants are cheap as chips
Have one of the best banners in the game
have a 2+ armor and a ward
Ignore peasant panic
Get ITP when they charge
And did I mention they are core?

Chaos knights cost 2x the points of errants
for that you get:
+2 WS, +1 S, +1 T, +2 I, +1 A, +1 LD and 1+ AS.

so assuming 5 chaos knights vs 10 errants

Give them frenzy banner and they have 3 attacks each, striking before the errants and hitting on 3+ wounding on 2+. Roughly causing 10 hits resulting in 8 wounds. After armour and ward this comes down to maybe 3 kills.

Giving chaos knights mark of nurgle will have errants hitting them on 5+ wounding on 2+ the first round and 5+ rounds after provided they got the charge. Average is 2-3 hits and 2-3 wounds. Resulting in 1-2 kills. After this initial round of combat the errats have a hard time imo, hitting and wounding on 5+ and knights AS of 1+

I'd say Chaos Knights have the edge here in combat but as you say errants is core and having core knights with good AS is good.
But chaos knights have magic attacks and that is really nice.

*EDIT*
Forgot about the horses here but chaos horses are better so that will give them more of an advantage.
 
Knights Errant aren't used for what Chaos Knights and their ilk are. The whole advantage of their being cheap shows up because they are ferries for the characters in those units, who are the ones who do the actual heavy lifting. Also, 20 ppm for a 2+/6++(conditional 5++) and Lance formation is a pretty good deal.
 
The main problem with Blood Knights is they share the same list as Black Knights who are MUCH cheaper but no less durable and will get the job done more reliably due to their additional bodies. Where in a WoC list, CKs are pretty much your only option if you want anything that even approaches decent cav so you are far more likely to field them than the alternative (marauder cav lol).

Its the same problem (albeit in reverse) Silver Helms have now that they are no longer core. Why would you take them when for a few points more you get Dragon Princes who are better in almost every way?
 
I actually had a couple of games recently where blood knights got to fight chaos knights. Both times the blood knights won.

First time:
chaos knights charged the blood knights
chaos knights had mark of khorne and lances

5 chaos knights vs 4 blood knights
drew combat two rounds, got down to 2 blood knights vs 2 chaos knights, then a nightmare killed a chaos knight and the chaos knights were run down

second time:
blood knights charged the chaos knights
5 blood knights vs 5 chaos knights w/ mark of khorne and magic weapons

blood knights killed the chaos knights outright, mounts didn't get to attack.


admittedly, this is only two encounters so it's not a large sample size, but str7 charges and frenzy would seem to tip to the blood knights in my experience
 
Also, in an open list, Blood Knights will usually get the Flag of Blood Keep as their upgrade, sure; but in a dedicated list against WoC (note, not simply Chaos Knights, but the army in general), it would be wiser to give them the Razor Standard or even the Banner of Swiftness. Since their Ranged Ward is unknown to work against DD spells, not just magic missiles, I'd add to their killing power. If it does work, then its another story.

Surviving the first round of combat, I'd say Blood Knights will get some advantage, because they will be raised back as a priority in the encounter.
 
I don't think Blood Knights' ability to best Chaos Knights in a fight should be up for much debate - they out-stat the Chaos Knights, which is a big deal for an army who relies on having superior stats to everything else in order to win. What's really up for debate is whether both those units will be on the battlefield in the first place, and I'm firmly in the camp of bringing Chaos Knights whenever possible and avoiding Blood Knights whenever possible.
 
Competitive WoC players use Chaos knights.

Competitive VC players do NOT use Blood Knights.

In terms of point values and usage in battle, Chaos Knights win hands-down. Otherwise you'd see Blood Knight buses... but instead you see BK buses bc of survivability. Sure, Blood Knights get a 4+ save, but ususally there's only 5 of them. Although they WERE the shiznit in the last book with Blood Drinker sword.
 
Duke Danse Macabre said:
- We get 3 attacks each which they would need to take a banner to get

Incorrect, Chaos knights can have MoK and still take a magical banner, if they take the magical banner then they will never lose the frenzy, they can then combine frenzy with another mark. The options are MoT so it combines with MR for protection against against lore of metal or magic items for protection against warmachines and then still have a 6+ wardsave against close combat.

- They get the same strength when you take into account their free magic weapons but on a charge we are strength 7 going to 5 after, they are strength 6 if lances going to 4s or staying at 5 with magic weapons.

If they are both armed with lances its equal odds, if the chaos knights have enscrolled weapons then the odds are in the chaos knights favour unless the blood knights get the charge. Still even with strength 7 they are still getting a 5+ save (which is only marginally worse than what the blood knights are getting. If the chaos knights charge then the blood knights are getting a 4+ save while the chaos knights are getting a 3+save.

It really comes down to who gets the charge, the chaos knights are 10pts a model cheaper.

- We can All accept Challenges.

Only matters if characters are involved

- We have the same speed.

which basically means they can wipe each other out

- Chaos Knights have +1 armour on us.

it really does make a massive difference

- Our unit champion can be given a magic weapon.


While the whole chaos knight unit has magical weapons

[quote- We get a nice ranged ward save banner.[/quote]

MoN, MoT, blastered standard

- We are slightly more expensive at base but they have to pay for marks unless they want vanilla knights....

Chaos knights are still cheaper with marks, remember marks are per unit not per unit, also remember chaos knights special .

- We can come back to life.

Chaos has some of the magic defense, like the really stupid miscast modification which can be used on the enemies miscasts. Something to consider is while blood knights can come back chaos knights are generally harder to kill because of that 1+ save.
 
Considering the original question was which knights are better, it was not which ARMY has the better support system for their knights.

There are a million "what if"'s we could throw back and forth at each other to argue which is better. But to really get down to it, throw equal and base points against each other. 4 Blood knights = 5 Chaos knights which works out perfectly. The answer with this is if Blood knights get the charge, they kill twice as many as the chaos knights (3.3~:1.6~), if the chaos knights get the charge, our reduced numbers and armor means they kill slightly more (1.6~:1.3~).

There are two very easy answers for both sides here.

First without any outside help, the bloodknights are better if they charge and not if they don't.

Second, since we're all trying to argue army support as EGGSPR said,
Competitive WoC players use Chaos knights

Competitive VC players do NOT use blood knights
 
The reason Blood Knights win is because a simple Level 2 Vampire Hero in the unit can raise 3 Knights per turn with Invocation of Nehek. Chaos cannot *ever* overcome that advantage.

The Hero will pay for himself almost completely after one casting. And seeing as he will get several chances to do this per game...

The self-sustaining Blood Knight unit is utterly game-changing. You think they've been whittled down to a small number then *bam* back to starting strength. Chaos Knights can't do that.
 
Three Bloodies per IoN? They are Vampiric so they can "never regain more than 1 Wound per successful casting". So a level 1 can raise the same as a level 4, 1/IoN + 1/lore attribute or only 1/IoN if you think that the Lore Attribute only applies to Multi-wound minis.
 
Soren said:
Three Bloodies per IoN? They are Vampiric so they can "never regain more than 1 Wound per successful casting". So a level 1 can raise the same as a level 4, 1/IoN + 1/lore attribute or only 1/IoN if you think that the Lore Attribute only applies to Multi-wound minis.

Each *model* can only regain one wound per casting. As it stands the rules allow multiple Blood Knights to be raised; they follow the "one wound plus caster's wizard level". This has been discussed in another thread (in the Laws of the Night) so please feel free to discuss it further there. :thumbsup:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu