Cairn Wraiths' Chill Grasp in units

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
I put this one out there to see how many silly responses it got (funny, but the only time I get inane responses is when I have a serious question that needs answering).

It would seem that the correct answer is that Cairn Wraiths cannot use Chill Grasp in place of supporting attacks.

To do so would be unbalanced and a gross misuse of the rules.

Also Chill Grasp requires the Cairn Wraith to forego ALL of their normal attacks, and a Cairn Wraith in the second rank can only use one out of it's three attacks.
 
Don't see why not either. You can make one attack from the second rank. Chill attack is one attack. Sacrificing ALL your attacks to make a single attack doesn't limit making the attack.
 
Yes please explain why they would not be able to use their chill grasp as a supporting attack. Citations of the rules that support your position would be preferable.
 
This again, is outrageous extrapolation.
Exchanging "all" your attacks is not exclusive to the attacks on your profile.
Infantry can only make one supporting attack, so they definitely could exchange that one, or "all" of their supporting attacks for a chill grasp.
 
Interesting points.

I don't know how the troll vomit rule works though, so using that as a comparison is useless to me. I don't have the relevant army book.

I can see the point that Chill Grasp is an alternative to using the Great Weapon (and as such is not subject to ASL), so choosing to use this as it's attack would also include those giving supporting attacks.

It still seems a bit of an unbalanced attack form, when you consider 10 Wraiths attacking, needing on average 4+ to hit (so 5 hits from the unit on average), wounding automatically and no armour saves, leaving only ward saves, if any. But given that such a unit would cost 500 points (or 525 with Tomb Banshee), it does seem fairer.

That said, I'm off to buy some more Cairn Wraiths.
 
And did you take the cost of those 10 wraiths into consideration when you argue that it is unbalanced? They are very vunerable to anything with a magic attack and thus you take a chance putting so may of your points into a unit of 10, on average they would deal 5 wounds since they still have to hit... I really fail to see how you can even suggest that it would be unbalanced for 500 points, but ok.
 
Valle said:
And did you take the cost of those 10 wraiths into consideration when you argue that it is unbalanced? They are very vunerable to anything with a magic attack and thus you take a chance putting so may of your points into a unit of 10, on average they would deal 5 wounds since they still have to hit... I really fail to see how you can even suggest that it would be unbalanced for 500 points, but ok.

My god! Does anybody even bother to read the post before replying.

If you read my post properly, you will see that I am saying that prima facie it SEEMED unbalanced, though at the huge points cost is more than justified.
 
Wilhelm das Blutige said:
I put this one out there to see how many silly responses it got (funny, but the only time I get inane responses is when I have a serious question that needs answering).

It would seem that the correct answer is that Cairn Wraiths cannot use Chill Grasp in place of supporting attacks.

To do so would be unbalanced and a gross misuse of the rules.

Also Chill Grasp requires the Cairn Wraith to forego ALL of their normal attacks, and a Cairn Wraith in the second rank can only use one out of it's three attacks.

Not going into an online argument, I think your post above speaks for itself...
 
Valle said:
Wilhelm das Blutige said:
I put this one out there to see how many silly responses it got (funny, but the only time I get inane responses is when I have a serious question that needs answering).

It would seem that the correct answer is that Cairn Wraiths cannot use Chill Grasp in place of supporting attacks.

To do so would be unbalanced and a gross misuse of the rules.

Also Chill Grasp requires the Cairn Wraith to forego ALL of their normal attacks, and a Cairn Wraith in the second rank can only use one out of it's three attacks.

Not going into an online argument, I think your post above speaks for itself...

You ARE going into an argument. In fact you are coming close to trolling my posts.

What I put in my second post was largely the viewpoint of my gaming group, and to a certain amount I agreed with them. Having read the comments from other people, however, I saw their point, agreed with them, and even talked it over with my gaming group.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu