Can A Hidden Assassin Drink A Potion?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Adam_Barrow

Sleepless Knight
True Blood
Dec 25, 2010
3,068
Nashville, TN
Zombies
1,655
All the One Use Potions in the BRB: "The Potion of XX can be drunk at the start of any player's turn."

Revealing Assassins (we'll use pg. 52 of the Skaven book for example, if anybody's interested in page references): "Hidden Assassins can be revealed at the start of any friendly turn or at the start of any Close Combat phase."

Is there any reason an Assassin that has yet to be revealed cannot drink a potion? Say two units of Clanrats are positioned in charge range of an enemy unit. One of the two units is about to get hit with a charge, but there is an Assassin hidden in one unit.

First, when the opponent is about to declare his charge, I imagine there isn't a greater joy than seeing his face when you declare "My Assassin drinks his Potion of Strength" right before he declares the charge, and suddenly he knows there's a 50/50 shot he'll charge the hidden Assassin's unit.

But what's the verdict on hidden characters performing actions like that? Is there any official word? Is there any situation where a hidden Assassin would even /want/ to drink a potion while still hidden?
 
But it has to be at the start of the player turn, so before any charge has been declared yet right ?
 
I have found so many people play this wrong. They wait till they get into combat and then say " I'm drinking my potion of X." Sorry, but you needed to declare that at the beginning of the turn. "But I didn't know if I was going to make it into combat then!"......:slapface:
 
You are in the right though. Like people who make way before the combat step. If someone makes way in the movement phase they have clearly and knowingly missed their magic and shooting phases.
 
It's nuance to some people I guess, but the rules are plain about it. I just don't like people arguing with me when they don't know what they are talking about.

Anyway, I love it when my bro tells me his assassin drinks his potion of x. It's such a...OMG nooooo...moment when he does that.
 
midean said:
I have found so many people play this wrong. They wait till they get into combat and then say " I'm drinking my potion of X." Sorry, but you needed to declare that at the beginning of the turn. "But I didn't know if I was going to make it into combat then!"......:slapface:

Oh yes, I know that one.

It's one of the things I really hate, because (when I say 'no you can't drink it now') I end up feeling like the bad-guy, just because I'm actually following the rules.
 
If I'm aware that my opponent has a potion, I remind them at the start of turns so that things like this don't happen, but I refuse to yield if I was unaware they had it and forget. There's a difference between being the bad-guy and keeping to the rule that makes potions the price they are.

However Johnny, I don't think I'd go so far as to say 'You've now skipped your shooting and combat' if they make way. I'd just tell them they've done it at the wrong time and get them to right it. Although I've never really played very competitively.
 
Notice that dark elves have a more expensive potion of strength available which is declared at the start of combat.
 
Mad said:
My bad about the point stuff, don't know what I was thinking. But I'm not convinced about the effect of it being a khanite item, can't check cause I don't have the DE book available right now.

The fact of the matter is that it is not listed in the "common magic items" section, which is where you take the points from, using the rules from the BRB.

The item actually has it's own listing in the Khainite items and as it includes both a points value and it's own rules it is a seperate item with the same name for added confusion
 
hey guys.
about the potion of str in DE book,
I don't know where you are looking, but it is an enchanted item in my book, NOT a khainite. BUT, also shadowblade has it, and is listed as enchanted on him too.
still, pointcost is higher, and it states at start of combat, instead of like the one in BRB

just hit me, by khainite items you ment 'treasures of naggaroth'. not the gift/item part for assasins/witches ?
 
Well, I just said that's where it was from because it was previously stated to be there. My point still stands as it is not in the 'common magic items' list which is what that rule about where to use points is meant for.
 
yes, sorry. didn't meen to be anal about it, just making sure there wasn't a missunderstanding due to the item belonging on shadowblade.

so, with no mention under 'common magic items' the druchii potion should be treated as unique, since both point cost and wording differs.

this should also meen you can buy druchii version on 1 character, and brb version on another then? or that would be stretching it;)?

sadly, DE assasins can't use potion, since its not khainite...
 
BRB page 500, Selecting magic items.
If a magic item is listed both here and in your Warhammer Armies book, use the point value printed in the latter...

There is no mention of it having to be a Common Magic Item to fall under that rule. Still, I too think it is quite likely that it should be read like that. Also, there is no mention of which rule description to use (which I had thought there was o_o).

All in all it just seams like some classic GW wording with no clear answer. In the spirit of the game, and because non of the items are very powerful, I'd say DE can use both.

(wonder if there are any other new common items that share the name of old army specific?)
 
think empire had luckstone, and HE healing potion
mad at @ found discussion on swfbr:
swfbr.ipbhost.com/index.php?showtopic=3617&st=0&p=48408&hl="potion%20of%20strenght"&fromsearch=1&#entry48408
Swedes say its same, cost from book, ruled from brb.
only allowed one potion.
wording in DE book is way.better though. and I see a problem showing when using shadowblade, and brb rule on it. since he's a special character with the potion "use start of any combat". and falls same fate as Skaven assasin.
if its changes to brb wording...
(finally I got this on topic again :) )
 
Johnny-Crass said:
....If someone makes way in the movement phase they have clearly and knowingly missed their magic and shooting phases.

I think this is flexible from group to group but completely firm when in a turney setting. Maybe I'm just guilty of letting people get away with too much, but if someone(from our group) forgets something in the heat of battle I let them go back and do it if they want to. Our group builds cheesey lists for smiting, but are fairly flexible within the rules & build of our armies.

That being said, when it comes to me & forgetting, & having a terrible memory, I refuse to go back, but accept the consequences & learn from them. If I wasn't harder on myself then I am on others, I wouldn't be forced to remember & face turning into 'that' guy. I've also started writing out the special rules for my items within my army list, this has been great for learning the rules.

My DE DL build frustrates the hell out of everyone in my group, he has a 2+ re-rollable AS and 4+ ward. What they don't realize is that they can all make the exact same build, not that I'm going to point it out.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu