Can the coach ride again?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Dklyn said:
Just used it two nights ago against wife's brets. Was powered up by turn 5 (and that's with two snake eye WoM phases... owie!). On turn 4, it ran into the flank of a unit of Grail Knights (rare knights for Brets) and chewed away quite a few of them for I think 4 CC phases before breaking them (without taking any wounds despite the knights having magical attacks :D). While not a must take unit, certainly a worthwhile choice in my book. I don't think she'd disagree!


Did you wear your "Wife Beater" shirt? :smash::lol:
 
I think it's nerfed - The old Coach was so good it was almost broken. Now it powers up at half speed, and you lose the - awesome- magic defense it provided. The average magic phase has 7 dice = 1 power up per turn = Ethereal turn 5, Flying turn 6 meaning the latter stages of Evocation of Death aren't relevant in many games and Killing Blow and Flaming aren't important against the majority of targets in the game. What matters are the first two that help out in all combats, +1 impact hits and +1S (a trade-off for losing hatred). Depending on target I probably wouldn't charge before it's at stage 2, meaning you have almost 200 points doing nothing for two turns.

the old Coach:
* powered up fast enough to be relevant in the early game.
* good magic defense for a combat oriented list that didn't depend on magic to work.
* could cripple your own magic phase but the magic absorbing could be mitigated by Master of the Black Arts and Black Periapt (in other words you could come prepared, but your opponent couldn't, still giving you the edge).
* Hatred.
* Vampire.

the new Coach:
* lesser choice of targets early game due to charging up really slow, meaning your opponent can ignore it for parts of the game.
* doesn't affect your magic phase negative.
* doesn't affect your opponent's magic phase negative (in other words it lost it's role as a magic defense for fast, combat oriented armies) also makes it less of a target your opponent has to deal with, meaning your army lose pressure.
* slightly better in protracted combats (not were you want to be).
* Flaming against Hydras.
* Can no longer give marching to other units on the flanks, in other words no longer adding depth in deployment tactics and movement phase.

The most productive way of looking at it is probably from the view of - what role does the Coach fill?

- No longer magic defense.
- No longer helping you out in the movement phase.
- Less help with target saturation due to less early threat.
- We now have better fast hammers (Vargheists)

So what does it do for us that no other unit does? Outside of 'I like the model', I've always liked it because it's strong against our toughest matchups - DoC and DE. It has the speed to get the drop on things like Flamers, Flesh hounds, Furies, Hydras and fast elven infantry, it has enough strenght to wound easily and bypass light armour, and it has enough Toughness and armour/wards to be really hard to hurt with ranged attacks or wound in combat, and both DE and DoC relies on doing wounds in combat.
Basically, it's still our toughest single model hammer rare choice and still good against our bad matchups, but no longer overall good enough to make it into a tournament list.

My two cent.
 
MoridinUK said:
Guys it's Vampric.

Send it with hexwraiths!!!

Why can't it help out with the movement phase in this way?

Because in the new book we only get a march from the general. (like it was before)
Vampire rule now means the unit can march, only for the unit itself. (varghulf, vargheist etc)
Of course as noted by Gojira, this does not exclude rules from BRB like chariots not able to march.
 
From my (newcomers) perspective, the Coach struck me as a really well balanced unit.

A heavy chariot that can reap immense rewards (see above!), tied to a time based gamble, pointed appropriately.

I also like that it really messes with your opponents mind game. Once they know how it works, especailly if it siphons a couple of power dice early on, most opponents will put a disproportionate amount of effort into ending it sooner rather than later. That can be very useful for dictating their play style and tactics; a very valuable effect.

I'm seriously thinking of taking it instead of a terrorgheist at 1000pts.
 
Try taking the Coach in a Storm of Magic game. It brings me back to the 'fully powered up by turn 2' days of the previous book. Awesome stuff. :konrad:

Granted, I think it's taken a bit of a hit as far as comparative power goes. It's not quite as good as its previous incarnation, but that's also not to say it's useless. It just behaves more like a normal chariot now instead of a march-supporter and magic defender. Most opponents will have a really tough time dealing with a T6 chariot that has a 4++ save anyway, and once it gets Magic Resistance + Ethereal, there's practically no way it can be killed aside from a Dwarven cannon-shot.
 
Bravo_10 said:
Try taking the Coach in a Storm of Magic game. It brings me back to the 'fully powered up by turn 2' days of the previous book. Awesome stuff. :konrad:

Granted, I think it's taken a bit of a hit as far as comparative power goes. It's not quite as good as its previous incarnation, but that's also not to say it's useless. It just behaves more like a normal chariot now instead of a march-supporter and magic defender. Most opponents will have a really tough time dealing with a T6 chariot that has a 4++ save anyway, and once it gets Magic Resistance + Ethereal, there's practically no way it can be killed aside from a Dwarven cannon-shot.

Dwarfs and their pesky cannons... :(
 
Guidebot said:
I also like that it really messes with your opponents mind game. Once they know how it works, especailly if it siphons a couple of power dice early on, most INEXPERIENCED opponents will put a disproportionate amount of effort into ending it sooner rather than later.
I fixed that for you. Most veterans are well aware what kind of threat the Coach is, or can become. No one should get his knickers in a twist because those ~200 points may perhaps become ethereal at the end of the game.
 
N.I.B said:
Guidebot said:
I also like that it really messes with your opponents mind game. Once they know how it works, especailly if it siphons a couple of power dice early on, most INEXPERIENCED opponents will put a disproportionate amount of effort into ending it sooner rather than later.
I fixed that for you. Most veterans are well aware what kind of threat the Coach is, or can become. No one should get his knickers in a twist because those ~200 points may perhaps become ethereal at the end of the game.

Yea, that's probably fair. I pretty much only play friendlies and stuff.

having said that, it is still a threat that gets harder to deal with the longer it persists; inexperienced or otherwise, that's a fact. Most opponents will want to hit it sooner than later, if they're going to; use that as you will.
 
N.I.B said:
I think it's nerfed - The old Coach was so good it was almost broken.

The people I played with (my group and tournament folks) DID consider it broken. I think that more than anything is why we see Black Coach mach 2. I agree with the poster above that it is a very balanced piece now.
 
Balanced, probably. Maybe a bit overcosted, even. The ethereal threat new VC can bring is very real though, but comes more from excellent heroes and lone Spirit Host bases, and I do expect a slight change of the meta game towards cheap magic weapons becoming more popular.
 
With the previous book, my only regular opponent never seemed to take anything that could deal with the Coach.

Even if he knew I was taking it....
 
You shouldn't be using it to fight anything that has +3CR over it. Otherwise, try and keep BSB nearby and get an invocation off each turn and will probably never die.

Mine is doing just fine. In the games in my blog, it's terrorised Dark Elves, bagging Cauldron and Shades, got it into a Slann and ALMOST killed it (but crumbled eventually), killed about 300 points of Dwarfs including a cannon and preventing the Anvil from shooting for 1/3 of the game, absolutely murdered some Ogres leading to a concede turn 2, and killed a ton of TK gear (including a level 3 Liche Priest). Each time it's either done amazingly or done pretty well and died doing something amazing. It has a lot of versatility and is almost unstoppable.

I think a lot of people will stop using it however, since a) Mortis Engine is cooler and (b) they're used to it from 7th where it was pretty broken. It's still awesome though!
 
My first try was a flop. But mainly because my winds of magic rolls sucked. I never rolled above a 6 in five turns. The Coach charged my opponent's Hell Pit Abom on turn one. I had had the scythes by then and scored an impressive 4 wounds on the impacts. He regenerated them ALL. Score a couple hits in combat but he once again regenerated them. He did no wounds to me. I won combat because of the +1 to for charging. He blew his stubborn 8 roll and ran 6 inches. With 'swift stride' on my side I was sure I had him. Not when you roll a 4 and two 1s though. :slapface:

Next turn he rallies HPA. My next turn I am now +1 to str as well as I charge again. But I needed the dang flaming attacks. Hit him with another impressive 7 impact hits. He regens all but 1 wound. Wraith and steeds fail to wound after his regen rolls. He comes back with an attack that puts 11 str 6 hits on my Coach. Does five wounds. I fail to make a single armor or ward save. :thumbsdown:

So I can't really tell how effective the Black Coach is due to my abysmal luck. I mean one more inch of pursuit on turn one would have seen the HPA destroyed.
 
I've been using mine regularly in my campaign games. I've had god luck with it in each game. I don't worry about getting it totally powered up. Once you hit the MR2 point, you're pretty solid. I normally don't send it into combat alone, instead I use it as a flanking unit as much as possible. Otherwise a block of infantry will combat res it to (final) death. I've only had it destroyed in one game and that was a watchtower scenario. I sacrificed it to hold up a huge unit of advancing high elf spearmen. It did it nicely for two full turns before being brought down. Plus, it had suffered one wound from a bolt thrower as it approached. All in all, it's ability to survive some harsh beatings make it a worthwhile choice for me.
 
I enjoy it. I use it to screen many of my other beasts from cannon balls. It also does great on a flank. In a hard pressed pinch, it can work as an anvil.

However, saw someone mention the fly rule thingy. Keep in mind, chariots can never march move. So the fly, unless I'm missing something, only adds two inches of movement to it (which sorta sucks, except you can charge over intervening models).
 
Flying is the last thing. +2 inches is nice to have when you declare and resolve your charges. I'd be happy just to get up to flaming attacks. That's what I really needed last Saturday.
 
Yorga said:
My first try was a flop. But mainly because my winds of magic rolls sucked. I never rolled above a 6 in five turns. The Coach charged my opponent's Hell Pit Abom on turn one. I had had the scythes by then and scored an impressive 4 wounds on the impacts. He regenerated them ALL. Score a couple hits in combat but he once again regenerated them. He did no wounds to me. I won combat because of the +1 to for charging. He blew his stubborn 8 roll and ran 6 inches. With 'swift stride' on my side I was sure I had him. Not when you roll a 4 and two 1s though. :slapface:

Next turn he rallies HPA. My next turn I am now +1 to str as well as I charge again. But I needed the dang flaming attacks. Hit him with another impressive 7 impact hits. He regens all but 1 wound. Wraith and steeds fail to wound after his regen rolls. He comes back with an attack that puts 11 str 6 hits on my Coach. Does five wounds. I fail to make a single armor or ward save. :thumbsdown:

So I can't really tell how effective the Black Coach is due to my abysmal luck. I mean one more inch of pursuit on turn one would have seen the HPA destroyed.


Isn't the HPA unbreakable?
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu