Can't see the forest (of arrows) for the trees

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Mar 21, 2009
71
Chi-town
Zombies
114
Our Triumph &Treachery campaign has dissolved into a sea of 40k. There is one steadfast fantasy player who still shows up; JP and his wood elves. Last week we played 3000 Battle-For-Pass and he outplayed me, gaining 500-pt lead on my fangs, and I conceded once my general's GG force got surrounded between 4 archer blocks, a treeman, and a lone archer refugee that ran away. The writing was on the wall and JP earned a concession.

This week it's 2500 pts in the rematch. I know what my varghulf can do to archer blocks. When JP ran that hideous treelord Dorthu I had to expend my TG on it for 4 wounds and luckily finished it off with a Caress after the terrain-Sphynx turned my General into a Death Loremaster (!)

He runs 2-3 blocks of treekin and 2-3 treemen. They are ItP and a pain, and need to die pronto.

Ghoul horde of 40 got sandpapered by one treekin block. Skellie baby-Vamp/Necro unit battled it until game's end.

Varghulf+Crypt Horror block of 6 was an epic battle vs another treekin block.

GG & General pushed thru another.

Tried to run a Black Coach past one treeman. Almost got there, but nope; flank-snagged.

Hexwraithes got blasted by fire spells.

Wolves died like toothless rats against them.

I hide my TG behind a building until it gets its round in the sun, then dies to a hail of 60 archer trueflight fire.

So... How would YOU crack these wooden nuts?
 
What's that one Slaan spell that wipes out half the board with some sort of Chasm? Have you tried that? I have never been able to beat Wood Elves, even in previous editions. I wish that we could just burn the forests down or something. Maybe just march 200 or so zombies across the board, then when you have them where you want them, charge in with the heavy hitters.
 
How big are the treekin blocks? Remember that they are not stubborn like the TM.
What kind of arrows does he use (this is important)?

I'm thinking that two units of 8 Horrors is a good starting point (never field less than 8). Run two varghulfs if you feel like it and if one seems to be working (apparently he hasn't tried Starfire arrows yet). Don't give up on the Coach, it destroys Glade Guard like a knife through buttah.
Also, don't let him flank you. Deploy towards a corner and move forward from there. Elves lose their effectiveness when they can't assault you with a pincer attack.
 
Alabaster: Dwellers below? I know I've been immolated with Firey Convocation before. Need Forbidden Lore for that. Do I lose style points for running Lore of HighElves/ Heavens?

I've thought about running multiple tarpits, one for each treekin unit, and then trying to squeeze other units between the pits, but with the Fight For the Pass scenario space was at a premium.

Sen: I think the treekin units were 6-strong, two of them. Two treemen also. Ranks seemed to help against them.

He has *always* used Trueflight arrows, without fail. Lurves 'em.

Eek, I'd need to buy/proxy 10 more crypt horrors quickly. Hmmmm.

I ran the ghouls far left and the hexies far right. His only flankings were from Treemen mid-battle.

The Coach is fun. I'm glad I finally got it assembled/primered.
 
Last edited:
The coach is awesome. I think it's funny that Forbidden Lore forbids a lore, but you can't have dwellers below because we can't have Lore of Life, and I have never heard of Forbidden Lore applying to specific army lores. If you can take another army's lore (seriously doubt it), I don't think that using HE lore would lose you any style points; in fact, countering Elven Dickery with Vampire Trickery would gain you points. Out of any army vampires should have access to a spell called "Dwellers Below"
 
No poison arrows? Wow, that's different, I'm used to playing against at least 3 units of "Bane Guard (Hagbane arrows are what they are called)" and one of trueflight/starfire. Bring on the Horrors then! Proxy them, however, don't buy them. While I highly recommend 2 units (my own personal tournament list runs 16), they are still a hit in the pocket.
Plug away with the 'ghulf, too. You could maybe even try 2 mortis engines if you own them. Once he starts using Starfire though, you will need a change of strategy.
 
Take a good spread of different units that are vulnerable to different arrows. And threaten his blocks with fast stuff. Don't move up the table slowly allowing him to focus on one of your units at a time. Have many fast threats and keep him on the defensive. Go for the archer blocks, focusing on one at a time. His army becomes woefully ineffective if down even 1 archer block. If a Wood Elf player loses 2 archer blocks, it's basically impossible for him to win.

Wind of death, rod of flaming death, vanhel's dance bubble, big units of crypt horrors, terrorgheists, hex wraiths, vargheists, anything fast and hitty. Even gaze of nagash is pretty effective against elves. Crypt horrors will roll a treeman, hexwraiths need to soulstride, but if you have a mobile general, that's pretty easy since they're fast cav.

I've started taking a vamp lord on foot with vampiric flight and he just hops around from bunker to bunker each turn giving off 2 march bubbles and putting him in position to cast invocation effectively.

Elves in general are a tough match up for us because of those damned re-rolls to hit and their absurdly good armouries.
 
Sen: Although he exclusively uses Trueflight arrows, he also backs them up with a Fire Mage that enchants those arrows to magical flame, so it negates the CH regen for a full turn. It's annoying and rather a must-dispel spell. He also runs a Beastlore wizard and has a Level4 Dark Magic SpellWeaver. At least I don't think I'll be facing the horror that is Durthu this time...

In a funny way these games remind me of PanzerBlitz. Enemy tries to blockade access to his self-propelled artillery. We must find a way to break through and destroy the long range threat.

WoodElves scored points during scenario choice as well as deployment. The Pass gave him a constricted entry to defend; 48" width vs 72" width. Then he was able to clog up the entirety of the center width with an unbroken line of distasteful / dangerous / impassable terrain, a treekin unit or a treeman.

The setup made it tough to get through with the large blocks of units that would survive heavy archer fire the best.

My engaging treekin with wolves was folly. Also thinking the hexwraiths would survive a fireblast; those gotta be dispelled, or use other Specials. The Screaming Banner would only find Treekin/Men so it's useless. I could run multiple tarpits, but they render the treekin battles as impassable terrain, not kill treekin.

I'm thinking speed, flight and killy-ness will win this battle. Love the idea of the Flying, March-Enabling Lord. They have no cannons, so would this be a rare time to haul out the Hellsteed or the Abyssal Terror (or even the Zombie Dragon)?

Keeper-Units:

Rare: TG, Varghulf, Black Coach
595 of 625 possible. Sorted.
Just bought a Mortis kit, but want to paint-as-I-assemble and it's hard to displace these three.

Core Tax: 20 Dires for sure, necro bunker for sure, all else negotiable. Seems like Core will face treekin and even supported ghouls died like vermin against them.

Specials:
Leaning back to BKs over GG as Lord delivery system due to speed.
CorpseCart -- all his Wizzys are with archers so won't be near them most of the game. Me getting ASF does not cancels his ASF, correct? So no.
Crypt Horrors: Yummy, 6 at least show up. About 225 pts. 400 then available.
Vargheists: interesting but have none
Spirit Hosts: would keep Fire Wizzy occupied
Hexies: can be useful but guard vs instakills on 'em
Fell bats: thinking of bringing 2 groups of 2, then IoNing with Level2 SCotN to make 2 groups of 5, THEN send 'em out... 74 points wasted?
Bat Swarms: Have 3... They fly and give ASL. Another wastage?

Lord/Heroes:
L4 General-Blender, scroll caddy, IoN/augment/Gaze/WoD
 
Interesting. I would go a completely different way. Welves are fast and shooty, but lack numbers and armour. TG is our way to deal with high armour and will die fast to their shooting.
My tactic would be somewhat like this: Lots of Zombies or even skellies to decrease his manouverabilty. Some magical damage - Ring of Ruin and flaming rod to support that. And Impact hits - Coach, MEs or even a throne.
Horrors are also nice vs. woodies.
And spam Invos to encounter his shooting phase.

Edit: I would leave ethereals at home. Too much magical shooting. Even thought about not using dogs. They die like flies in the first round. Imo more blocks of zombies would help more. But I only had one game vs. the new woodies so i might be wrong on that one.
 
From what I found against the wood elves you want big blocks of troops like ghouls and grave guard and leave all your ethereals, dire wolves, knights and vargheists at home.
 
I'd think ghouls and grave guard would do well too. T4 infantry that can be summoned back quickly. Crypt horrors a must have.
 
Ala: Really? Leadoff page 2 of BRB says otherwise...

"Would you like a little... fire, Scarecrow?"
--Elphaba

Big blocks. Yes, for sure ghouls, and I found Grave Guard hold up well too. The problem with big blocks is, they do hold up, but each battle becomes impassable terrain to what I really want to do: march up to those 6 Glade Guard 10-peops squads, snap their longbows over my knee and give each a jagged, rectal probe. So we either fly over the battles, snakily slither forces around the battles, or beat the sap out of the Treekin and Treemen ASAP.

Crypt Horrors. The obvious auto-include. Or are they?
This WE player not only floods his core with 900 pts of Trueflight arrows, he also employs a Level-2 Fire Wizard to cast Flaming Sword of Rhuin on a nearby 10-unit and leads off with them in the shooting phase. So the only means of special defense for the CHs is negated. Oddly enough, Crypt Horrors odds-on lose a straight-up battle vs new-book Treekin by about a wound per round without support, losing their 5+ regen just exacerbates the problem, and this player is annoying in he doesn't often allow an IoN if he can help it. If I'm gonna toss almost 250 pts in the *Special* slot, I'd rather that unit either bring the pain quickly or beat the 6-man Treekin unit (270pts) outright.

So I sat down with a plate of my favorite takeout General Tso's and let my mind wander. Heh, someone must have spiked the Tso's, because, well...

OK, Core Tax. Gotta have ghouls. Gotta have a Skellie bunker (own more Skellie models than Z's). Usually should have wolves, but here, we may want to hedge our bets.

The ghouls were nice, but *did* get sandpaper'ed down by one 6-man Treekin unit. So how can we help? Well, fire. How? The only way I could figure out how. Create a Vamp BSB carrier and give him a Banner of Eternal Flame. So I wondered, since we're making this BSB carrier, should I go cut-rate and make it a Wight King, or go Vamp? Sadly, Killing Blow don't work on Monstrous Infantry, so despite his 5 Toughness, he's really just a not-so-killy pretty face. Now the Vamp, he has potential. Checked the other spell lists for help in Ghoul-v-Treekin. Shadow has 4 spells that actually help the ghouls tilt the scales in their favor by 4 wounds per round (after Flammability-doubling, they are MMMiasma, Enfeeble, Withering, Mindrazor). And don't forget ShadePit, lolz. For more fun, I can swap out the BSB Vamp on a successful Shadowcast with a Vamplore-Necro I'm planning on taking so he can be on-hand to raise ghouls as the need rises, then with another casting of Shadow, the Vamp pops back in. Can also extract the General if unlife gets too nasty. Oddly enough, for a magic-less Hero Vamp, QuickBlood helps out about as much as RedFury does against Treekin, so take QB, as well as Beguile, in case some wayward Treekin figures out killing the risky-business BSB-in-a-core-unit is a good idea. It's insanity, but doubling wounds due to Treekin Flammability really does put this ghoul unit on-par with a 6-Treekin unit and then some, and you just can't do this silliness with Crypt Horrors AFAIK.

Then there's the second 6-Treekin unit. That one I figured would be taken out by something Special. Grave Guard are proven up to the task, but they're not fast enough for my liking. Also, I fell in love with the idea of my General on a flying mount. Don't really have points for Zombie Dragon or Abyssal Terror (eewww). But I do for a Hellsteed. Sure a BK unit is riskier than GG, but they help out my General move things along quicker, and allow him to pop in and out of the unit by flight when he wills it. Besides, S6 lance hits on the charge mess up Treekin really well. Then I realized my General should be the one to mess up the trees personally. With Skabscrath. The WE player hates my Terrorgheist with a passion. So we should give him a surprise double-dose of Death Shriek. With a VL with RF/QB and Frenzy + Dev-Charge, the averages shake down like this: He charges in from long-range on his warbeast, Skabscrath shrieks during Shooting phase for 2 wounds (not doubled as not in CC), then 7 attacks go off and 6.222 of them hit and 3 wounds are meted out, which turn to 6 wounds due to Flaming-on-Flammability. So RF says take 6 more swings, which he does, for 5.333 hits and 2.666 wounds (call it 5 more when doubled). Then 10 BK attacks go off for on average 5 hits and ~4 wounds due to S6. The steeds could account for the 18th wound and wipe the Treekin in one round (perhaps overrunning into a Treeman :) ). I cackled with glee and ate more Tso's.

Wanted a utility-necro for the Skellie bunker, so I created one and gave him Arkham Book and the Ruby Ring of Ruin, because he's a character and he needs to set the world on fire too. Further, he can trade places with the Shadowmage.

Now, the chaff. The poor puppies got ripped up by Trueflights and Treekin. Didn't even want to consider them vs Treemen. I, too, considered not fielding any (Sacrelige! I know, I know...) but wondered how I could hedge my bets. And there it was, while I was looking for cute things to give my Lord-who-has-everything: SCotN. So the plan is to field the typical tight unit bunching around the General, but with two bare-minimum Dire Wolf units and two bare-minimum Fell Bat units trailing behind the General's unit. I'm spending less than 20 Dires which I normally would for this beastly lot, and just as importantly, I'm not tossing Dires out there as "Hey-we-gotta-Vanguard-and-we're-the-only-thing-out-here-so-shoot-us-to-Hell" 1st-round targets like I normally do. No, *this* game they will eschew Vanguarding (Madness! But fits the pattern of this army perfectly lolz), and hang around the Level-4 General long enough for him to get an IoN off, so that I suddenly have two groups of 10 Dires and two groups of 5 Fell Bats (ok one Bat per unit has only one wound, but still...) Then when we hit the just-before-30"-away-from-pincushioning-time, we run all the units to full speed so Target Saturation actually has a chance to work. Besides, at this special time, the WE player is still liable to train all his ordnance on the TG anyways. ;)

So, for your point-and-laugh amusement, here's what the army looks like:

Vampire Lord, Level-4 VampLore, RF, QB, SCotN, Skabscrath, Dispel SCroll, Hellsteed, HA, Sh
9 BK all barded/lanced up with full command
Beastly retinue of 2x5 Dire Wolves and 2x2 Fell Bats
all for 962pts

Vampire Hero, Level-2 ShadowLore BSB, QB, Beguile, Banner of Eternal Flame, HA, Sh
39 ghouls plus ghast
all for 636pts

Necromancer Hero, Level-2 VampLore, MotD, Book of Arkham, Ruby Ring of Ruin
21 Skeletons with Full Command
all for 305pts

Terrorgheist, Varghulf, Black Coach (aka, new anti-WE-meta)
all for 595pts

2498pts total. Minimum Core on the nose. Pray for me.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Uveron
Sen: Although he exclusively uses Trueflight arrows, he also backs them up with a Fire Mage that enchants those arrows to magical flame, so it negates the CH regen for a full turn. It's annoying and rather a must-dispel spell. He also runs a Beastlore wizard and has a Level4 Dark Magic SpellWeaver. At least I don't think I'll be facing the horror that is Durthu this time...

In a funny way these games remind me of PanzerBlitz. Enemy tries to blockade access to his self-propelled artillery. We must find a way to break through and destroy the long range threat.

WoodElves scored points during scenario choice as well as deployment. The Pass gave him a constricted entry to defend; 48" width vs 72" width. Then he was able to clog up the entirety of the center width with an unbroken line of distasteful / dangerous / impassable terrain, a treekin unit or a treeman.

The setup made it tough to get through with the large blocks of units that would survive heavy archer fire the best.

My engaging treekin with wolves was folly. Also thinking the hexwraiths would survive a fireblast; those gotta be dispelled, or use other Specials. The Screaming Banner would only find Treekin/Men so it's useless. I could run multiple tarpits, but they render the treekin battles as impassable terrain, not kill treekin.

I'm thinking speed, flight and killy-ness will win this battle. Love the idea of the Flying, March-Enabling Lord. They have no cannons, so would this be a rare time to haul out the Hellsteed or the Abyssal Terror (or even the Zombie Dragon)?

Keeper-Units:

Rare: TG, Varghulf, Black Coach
595 of 625 possible. Sorted.
Just bought a Mortis kit, but want to paint-as-I-assemble and it's hard to displace these three.

Core Tax: 20 Dires for sure, necro bunker for sure, all else negotiable. Seems like Core will face treekin and even supported ghouls died like vermin against them.

Specials:
Leaning back to BKs over GG as Lord delivery system due to speed.
CorpseCart -- all his Wizzys are with archers so won't be near them most of the game. Me getting ASF does not cancels his ASF, correct? So no.
Crypt Horrors: Yummy, 6 at least show up. About 225 pts. 400 then available.
Vargheists: interesting but have none
Spirit Hosts: would keep Fire Wizzy occupied
Hexies: can be useful but guard vs instakills on 'em
Fell bats: thinking of bringing 2 groups of 2, then IoNing with Level2 SCotN to make 2 groups of 5, THEN send 'em out... 74 points wasted?
Bat Swarms: Have 3... They fly and give ASL. Another wastage?

Lord/Heroes:
L4 General-Blender, scroll caddy, IoN/augment/Gaze/WoD

Not sure Im using the Quote function correctly here, sorry if I mess this up. Just wanted to correct you on the cart;
Yes, if you get ASF from the cart you cancel his ASF and this is good news, because then he doesn't get his rerolls from having a higher Initiative value.

The cart can be decent against elves, the trick is for it to keep up with your army and survive the trip.
 
Yep, found that rule, thanks for noting it for my attention. Corpse Cart could be viable, but it is soooo slow and the only Elves I'd face are Glade Guard and the characters. We eat WE GG for snacks.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu