Challenge, overkill and static CR

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

nabongote

Zombie
Apr 7, 2010
3
Zombies
5
I hope somebody can help and enlighten me please.
The following situation:
A Star Dragon with prince has attacked a regiment (20 models including a full command group) of grave guards.
As you have described it a various places in this forum the Star Dragon with prince will be challenged by the champion.
Let's assume the dragon and prince manage to kill the champion and inflict the maximum of +5 overkill points.
When it comes to the CR i.e. to figure out how many of the grave guards will crumble does that mean:
the 5 overkill points will be reduced by
1 point for outnumbering another
1 point for the standard and another
2 points for extra ranks
and in addition to the killed champion only one more modell will crumble because the final CR is +1 in favor of the dragon and prince or is the full overkill of 5 points going to count and another 5 grave guards will crumble?
Thanks in advance for all your comments and answers.
 
The procedure is like the one you described yourself, really. Remember that there's no bonus for actually Outnumbering your opponent any more. In your example, that would mean that an additional 2 Grave Guard models would die to combat resolution. :)
 
You're forgetting the initial wound you caused on the GG champion.

Dragon has: 1x Wound; 5x Overkill = 6.

GG Have: 1x Standard; 2x ranks = 3.

The GG crumble three models.
 
Thanks a lot to all for your quick answers they were very helpful indeed.
With the above mentioned facts in mind I would say a Star Dragon and Prince (as you mentioned it in other threads of the forum is one of the most powerful combinations in the warhammer world) has lost much of its fear-factor.
If only the standard counts against this foe a VC player is going to loose not more than 5 models per turn. Even if all IoN will fail this is going to keep the dragon and prince -who are worth ~ 500 points busy for 4 long turns at a own sacrifice of approx. 300 points. In the mean time a tar pit of zombies can be made available and the little High Elf player is occupied until game end. If some of the IoN succeed the dragon with his prince is not going to see any other combat during that battle :tongue:
 
nabongote said:
If only the standard counts against this foe a VC player is going to loose not more than 5 models per turn.

In you example, where we 'assume' that all ION attempts fail, should we remember that you will no longer have a champion following the first turn of combat? If this is the case, overkill wont play any further part in the combat and the dragon and rider will be free to kick some wight ass! The combat res will start to stack up against you even quicker than you were expecting, and then bang, no more GG.

If anything, this just highlights the importance of using ION and re-raising your champion in this situation, as with most situations to be honest!
 
This is a TOTALLY different rules question but...

In this circumstance, isn't it very unlikely that they get full (5 points) overkill. Because, due to initiative order, the High Elf prince fights (and probably kills) the GG champ in the ASF initiative "step" (inflicting a maximum of 3 overkill since they have 4 attacks), and the dragon does not get to fight, because his only possible target is dead long before his initiative step comes up?

(I guess if he had the Bloodbath/Strife/LeapingGold swords he could get +5 overkill -theoretically-, but thats not the point.)

The question is, does the dragon get to attack the corpse simply to contribute to overkill?

I was under the impression this changed in the new edition.
 
Originman said:
This is a TOTALLY different rules question but...

The rule book does mention that a mount involved in a challenge will not get to strike if the enemy has already been removed by the rider. Works the other way around as well I suppose, however often you'll see a character riding a monster with a higher Initiative than himself, heh~

You can check this on page 103 under the heading "Challenges and Mounts".
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu