Characters and Banners

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Narenzade

Wight King
Mar 22, 2012
465
Zombies
370
Lets say a unit has 5 characters in it and is five wide. Those characters are in the front five ranks, so it misplaced the Banner, Champion and Musician. Does the banner still work if it's magic? IE would I get Armor Piercing if I had armor piercing banner even if the banner is in the second rank?
 
Yes. Banners work in second ranks. Ask any skaven player who puts his bsb in the unit pushing the bell. :)
 
Yorga said:
Yes. Banners work in second ranks. Ask any skaven player who puts his bsb in the unit pushing the bell. :)

That is a misleading reference as skaven have a special rule that allows this to occur
 
Why won't it give +1 to CR?

Also, if a unit is 5-wide and has full command, only 2 characters will be in front. The other 3 will hang in the back, and can Make Way! when needed...

Anyways, Banners always give their magical effects to the Unit
 
@ Johnny, unless I am missing a line, that is incorrect. You still get +1 bonus for CR. The BRB only says that "a unit with a standard gets +1 to combat resolution" and makes no mention of this being removed if the banner is not in the front rank. There is also no mention of it being removed in the characters in units section.

This is part of how the bretonnian combat resolution bus works. The unit has 3 ranks of knights, 2-3 paladins taking up the front rank, one of whom has virtue that gives +1 if the general is alive, one of whom is the BSB, and the unit has the warbanner. Total static CR is 7 before any swings are made (3 ranks, banner, BSB, virtue, warbanner), and all attacks must go towards paladins with 1+ armor saves. It takes advantage of still getting the standard bonus for being in the 2nd rank.

Oh, but remember, per the FAQ attack bonuses caused by things like the banner of eternal flame or the armor piercing banner do NOT pass to characters carrying a magic weapon. Bonuses to character stats still work, however, as to banners that provide other bonuses (so hydra banner will still work, as will the chaos banner that gives the unit frenzy).
 
Lynks said:
Yorga said:
Yes. Banners work in second ranks. Ask any skaven player who puts his bsb in the unit pushing the bell. :)

That is a misleading reference as skaven have a special rule that allows this to occur

No....they don't. 'Lead from the Back' was last edition.

@ Johnny: Why doesn't it get a plus 1 to CR? Even if it doesn't it is a good tactic since the Skaven BSB is usually there for the Stormbanner and re-rolls. Plus, I try to keep my Seer out of combat as much as possible.
 
Yorga, unless I am missing a line in the BRB, they DO still get +1 even if in the 2nd rank. Nothing in the BRB that I have found suggests otherwise. Just says "if the unit contains a standard" you get +1.
 
Gatti said:
Yorga, unless I am missing a line in the BRB, they DO still get +1 even if in the 2nd rank. Nothing in the BRB that I have found suggests otherwise. Just says "if the unit contains a standard" you get +1.

I'm taking Johnny's silence now as him conceding the point. ;)
 
The only command member that doesn't work when not in the front rank is the musician.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu