Charging out of cavalry question

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

eggsPR

Vampire Count
True Blood
Aug 28, 2011
1,136
Dublin
Zombies
878
Ok fellas, it's been a while since I needed some clarification on rules, which I guess is a good thing!

Here's the scenario...

I have characters in a Black Knight unit.

Enemy flies harpies 1 inch in front of my cavalry unit.

I want to charge a character out the unit to the harpies (so that the harpies rank up which allows another character on the corner of the black knight unit to charge out the unit as well to hit what's behind the harpies).

However, since the cavalry model is longer than 1 inch, is it a failed charge since the 1 inch gap is too small for the unit? Is the black knight unit pushed back to make the charge legal? Are the harpies pushed back?

Please provide page numbers and/or FAQ information if you can!

Thanks,
 
Only 1 character can charge out of a unit at a time, the rules for characters charging out of units say this
'A character can charge out of a unit.......but the unit will stay still, and is NOT permitted to declare a charge of its own'

That would be including any other characters in the unit as well, so as soon as one model charges out, the rest can not move at all

pg 101

From the way its written, the rules stopping the unit from moving come into effect when you declare the character is charging, not when you move them, meaning as soon as the character declares a charge out of the unit, no other character in the unit can make a charge, they are still part of the unit, putting your characters in seperate units will solve this though
 
Also, I believe that, if you are unsure you will fit, and then when you move the charger(s) into position it turns out you won't fit...

Unless the opposing Unit can "close the door" so that you are in legal BtB contact...


it is declared a failed charge...

=____= <- and this is my face when that happens. Stupid Units that won't fit.
 
lost_shadow said:
Only 1 character can charge out of a unit at a time, the rules for characters charging out of units say this
'A character can charge out of a unit.......but the unit will stay still, and is NOT permitted to declare a charge of its own'

That would be including any other characters in the unit as well, so as soon as one model charges out, the rest can not move at all

pg 101

From the way its written, the rules stopping the unit from moving come into effect when you declare the character is charging, not when you move them, meaning as soon as the character declares a charge out of the unit, no other character in the unit can make a charge, they are still part of the unit, putting your characters in seperate units will solve this though

I've seen this argument before... you're saying only 1 character because you're interpretting the meaning of "A character" meaning 1.

You put too much stock in A which does not just mean only one by any stretch of the imagination. Earlier it also say a character can join units. That does not mean that only one character can join a unit. In fact taking your interpretation the rules would mean only one character in the army could join a unit and the rest must run around solo.

Theres a little more stock with the unit not being able to charge and the remaining characters are part of that unit. 'Whilst a character is part of the unit, both he and the unit I treated as a single combined unit for all rules purposes, save for the exceptions listed here'. But then this rule is true also for the character charging out of the unit. The act of charging means he is no longer part of the unit. Surely this would be true for other characters in the unit also. If they stay with the unit they can not charge, but if they charge they are no longer part of the unit.

Try this:

A unit with three characters e.g.:

Charge One - A character declares a charge out of the unit.
We are now left with a Unit with two characters.

Charge Two - A character declares a charge out of the unit.
We are now left with a Unit with one character.

Charge Three - The last remaining Character charges out of the unit.
We are now left with a Unit that can not charge anything.

No rules broken.
So they do.

I'm playing in ETC this year and rest assured my team captain is going to raise this small issue just to make sure.

OK... now if we agree that characters (plural) can charge out of the unit, there's this:

In the movement section (page 13) it states that if two units end up too close, they can be 'nudged' back. Also, it says that when charging, the charger is allowed to move within 1" of other units. So I would say that the knights are nudged back. But, if your opponent is being difficult, you could angle the charger in an extreme angle. Then, the harpies would have to align to you since you cannot 'close the door.' Those would be the two options I would go with.

Worst comes to worst I charge out with a character on the other edge of the unit, extreme angle it and be able to pivot as the black knight's ass end can wheel since he was on the end and make him close the door, within 1 inch of the unit (black knights).
 
It wouldnt have anything to do with a character joining a unit, its quite clear in the fact it states the MOMENT a character declares a charge from a unit, failed or not the unit may not charge, where is the confusion?





Theres nothing saying anything similar when joining units.


Charge One - A character declares a charge out of the unit.
We are now left with a Unit with two characters.

Charge Two - A character declares a charge out of the unit.
NO, the unit cannot charge now, rules are broken, the second character is in the unit that CANNOT make any more charges, it says character not characters.






It DOES say the rest of the unit cannot charge, its not like it doesnt say it, your saying it doesnt say this, it does! If we are going by those rules where if it doesnt specifically say it, then Ill be taking 5 vampires with terror and declaring charges at the start of the game at 5 different units and cause them to flee the field even though I cant make the charge, they must still take terror tests because they have been charged by a unit causing terror, because it DOESNT specifically say I cant do that even though I cant make the charge, it says as soon as they make a charge you must take a terror test before you roll the distance
Besides the part im quoting DOES say you cant do it, just because its a character in the unit doesnt make it exempt from the rules of the rest of the unit, if they cant perform an action for any reason, he cant either,

A second character has no option to charge, he is not allowed to, its so clear.
It has nothing to do with joining units

I never said at any point only 1 character can join a unit, where did I ever mention that?

Its not an interpretation, its what the rules say.
All I quoted was that as soon as a character declares a charge, according to the rules the rest of the unit (other characters with them are in no way removed from this catorgory, as the rules state 'a character that joins a unit becomes part of the unit and moves and fights as they do until he leaves' (which he cant do at the moment)
So he follows the rules the unit are bound by, if this wasnt the case and he was exempt from this rule, it would mean every other rule the unit is bound to (movement reductions, curse of years that targets him as well) would then suddenly have no effect on him


Really someone else needs to put up their interpretation of this


I can see why its in the rules, its so you dont send out 5 characters and block 5 enemy units all by one character (which with red fury on 5 vamps that are mounted may be entirely possible they cause enough wounds each turn to hold enemy units there alone for a couple of turns, which in essence is the dark elf stubborn pendent lord all over again)
 
My apologizes...

Here's the most recent ETC FAQ, came out yesterday... this was in red text so it was updated...

9. Can multiple characters charge out of the same unit in one turn? Can they charge from the second rank? If Yes, what’s their line of sight? Can they start their wheel inside the unit? Can they charge if they can’t clear the unit before hitting the enemy?

A. No. Yes. Use the model(s) in front of the character for line of sight. Yes. No.

Ok that settles it, even in ETC only 1 character can charge out of the unit.

Regarding the other issue on the 1 inch rule, I could have definately charged the harpies bc I can freely wheel 90 degrees while in the 2nd rank, so I'd clip the harpies at an extreme angle and make the harpies close the door on me. Not really sure I'd do that anyway being that my intention was to rank up the harpies for another (illegal) charge :slapface:
 
Excuse my noob-ness...

but what is ETC?

how come there are rules for things not described in the GW Page and, above all..

are there any clarifications there regarding our 8th Ed. Book? D:
 
ETC stands for European Team Championships. It a 5 man team match that goes on over in Europe.

ETC faq's are not GW approved and hold no weight and are not official. Although I do agree with their interpretation of the rules in this instance.

Not as yet....:rolleyes:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu