chariots

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Skittelz1981

Varghulf
Apr 28, 2013
707
AMS
Zombies
623
Can a mortis engine and black coach and corpse cart march?
B coach is vampiric: yes?
M engine undead + inspiring presence: yes?
Corpse carr undead + IP: yes?
Coven throne undead+IP: yes?

The army special rules clearly state:
Units with the undead special rule that are within 12" of the army general are allowed to march.
Since special rules overrule trooptypes and that armybookrules overrule brbrules. Our chariots can always march as long as they are within the 12" range or have the vampiric rule.
 
You might want to check the BRB again.

Chariots, per default cannot ever march.

The only (and quite recent) exceptions are the DE Bloodwrack Shrine and CoB. But then, they aren't 'true' chariots anyways.
 
U are wrong there sir, all ths chariots are subject to fhe special rule; undead or vampiric. therefore thd armybook special rules always overrule the brb

is a chariot a unit?: yes
undead special rule prevents any unit to march, unless within 12" of the general or has the vampiric special rule.
All units wih the undead zpecial rule are allowed to march if they find themselves within the cditical 12". This includss the Undead and vampiric chariots.
There is simply no room for misinterpretation
 
Skittelz1981 said:
U are wrong there sir, ...
~snip~
There is simply no room for misinterpretation

Yet you manage to misinterpet the rules.

Both the 'Undead' as well as the 'Vampiric' special rules would allow the unit in question to march, if it were able to do so in the first place in regard to its troop type. Nothing more, nothing less.
A chariot is never able to march, dut to its troop type being 'chariot'. The special rules will not change that in any way.

Same reason a HE Skycutter cannot fly 20'' FYI.

But good luck finding someone playing it your way.
 
So for the sake of trooptype, my chariots can make flee reactions and not crumble?
no they are undead, so all of a sudden they would be subject to those rules.....
The army book always, always overrules the brb. and when AB says: all units, that means all units regardless of their trooptype

next thing ur gonna tell me is that tbe blac k coach has the vampiric rule so that in the case of general death it wouldnt need to roll for the crumble? lol that is just silly.
 
Skittelz1981 said:
So for the sake of trooptype, my chariots can make flee reactions and not crumble?
no they are undead, so all of a sudden they would be subject to those rules.....
The army book always, always overrules the brb. and when AB says: all units, that means all units regardless of their trooptype

next thing ur gonna tell me is that tbe blac k coach has the vampiric rule so that in the case of general death it wouldnt need to roll for the crumble? lol that is just silly.


Troll ?
Drunk ?
Both ?
 
I agree to the fact that chariots may never move.

Yet the chariot is subject to the special rules. which are referred to in AB... so how do you explain what you say.
This is very very conflicting, the errata and faq say nothing about this so its up to people speculating.

Special rule: Undead, undead=unstable, therefore never marches, never flees, crumbles if loses combat, immune to psychology.
Yet, Undead units (all) may march if within 12" of the general, the chariot is still a unit, an undead one. Chariot though it may be, it is undead therefore may march if within the 12"

Same for black coach, the cairn wraith(character) is riding the coach, it is vampiric and thus may always march... what use is a black coach with fly special rule? 2" extra movement or 4"extra march?
 
Skittelz1981 said:
I agree to the fact that chariots may never move.

Yet the chariot is subject to the special rules. which are referred to in AB... so how do you explain what you say.
This is very very conflicting, the errata and faq say nothing about this so its up to people speculating.

Special rule: Undead, undead=unstable, therefore never marches, never flees, crumbles if loses combat, immune to psychology.
Yet, Undead units (all) may march if within 12" of the general, the chariot is still a unit, an undead one. Chariot though it may be, it is undead therefore may march if within the 12"

Same for black coach, the cairn wraith(character) is riding the coach, it is vampiric and thus may always march... what use is a black coach with fly special rule? 2" extra movement or 4"extra march?

In any case i will wait for more people with experience to reply to this thread, coz obviously we disagree.

quote: "All units with the Undead special rule are Unbreakable, Unstable and cause Fear, as described in the Warhammer rulebook. In addition (this is the crucial part), units with th eUndead special rule(chariot being a unit) cannot make march moves UNLESS they are within 12" of the army General (or have the Vampiric special rule), in which case they can march as usual. Lastly, when a unit with the Undead special rule is charged, it can only elect to hold." unquote.
 
Hey! I hope this is a discussion where I'll find decency between forum members.

Now, to the matter at hand, the general rule is that Army Books trump Core Rulebooks, but only when they specifically say so. This means that all entries will have (in this case) something like: "Unlike other chariots, it can also march" -> from the Dark Elves 8th ed Army Book.

So let's not get confused here. Standard rules are only to be modified whenever the Army book does so specifically.

This is extra clear with armies that have their 8th ed released.

The only case where you would find an exception is when a FAQ rules it out. No further than that. Not even Bat Swarms (They have the Hover special rule) can march within 12'' of the General (NOT to be confused with his Inspiring Presence, because that is not the rule. Usually, our General is not mounted on a Large Target, and his IP range is the same as his "Undead March" range, but on a Zombie Dragon/Coven Throne/Abyssal Terror/Terrorgheist, his IP range is 18'' but Undead can only be allowed to march withing 12'' of him)

This last sentence says it all. Undead are not allowed to do "extra marching" but are restricted to 12'' March range of the General.

I hope this clears things up
 
Demian said:
Hey! I hope this is a discussion where I'll find decency between forum members.

Now, to the matter at hand, the general rule is that Army Books trump Core Rulebooks, but only when they specifically say so. This means that all entries will have (in this case) something like: "Unlike other chariots, it can also march" -> from the Dark Elves 8th ed Army Book.

So let's not get confused here. Standard rules are only to be modified whenever the Army book does so specifically.

This is extra clear with armies that have their 8th ed released.

The only case where you would find an exception is when a FAQ rules it out. No further than that. Not even Bat Swarms (They have the Hover special rule) can march within 12'' of the General (NOT to be confused with his Inspiring Presence, because that is not the rule. Usually, our General is not mounted on a Large Target, and his IP range is the same as his "Undead March" range, but on a Zombie Dragon/Coven Throne/Abyssal Terror/Terrorgheist, his IP range is 18'' but Undead can only be allowed to march withing 12'' of him)

This last sentence says it all. Undead are not allowed to do "extra marching" but are restricted to 12'' March range of the General.

I hope this clears things up


Nope it doesnt clear things up.

A coven throne is a mount, therefore it can always be marched like a corpsecart mounted by a necro, this is in the faq.

Quote:
Vampiric
Models with the vampiric special rule never suffer wounds because of a slayed general, and unless they have joined a non-Vampiric unit they (and their mount) can make march moves as normal.
unquote.


Both the Undead special rule and the Vampiric special rule allow the entire unit (regardless of trooptype) to march, each on their own terms, Undead within 12"of the general (not IP idd) and Vampiric always...
As far as i can see, the entire model/unit has the special rule. and since the AB rules clearly state; All units, i assume that it is regardless of any other rule.
 
I have both Rulebook and Army Book FAQs (updated April 13, 2013) and nowhere on them does it say that our Undead Chariots are any different from other Chariots in regards of march moves.

The only Chariots that do not move as normal are:

Dark Elves Cauldron of Blood / Bloodwreck Shrines
Skaven Doom Bell / Plague Furnace (still no 8th ed army book by the way)

Can you point me out where you have read that our chariots can overrule (specifically) their march restrictions?


EDIT: I have found something that will end this discussion, haha:

VC Army Book page 26:

"...In addition, Units with the Undead special rule cannot make march moves unless... ...(or have the Vampiric special rule), in which case they can march as usual"

There is no further need to FAQ this. This makes it cristal clear.
 
The fact that the entire model is Undead and Vampiric.

There is one Q that goes:

Q:Does a VC general mounted on large target allow non-vampiric models with the Undead rule within 18" to make march moves?
A: No

One can assume that the undead models are thus allowed to do so within 12" and that as stated Vampiric models may always march.
 
Demian said:
I have both Rulebook and Army Book FAQs (updated April 13, 2013) and nowhere on them does it say that our Undead Chariots are any different from other Chariots in regards of march moves.

The only Chariots that do not move as normal are:

Dark Elves Cauldron of Blood / Bloodwreck Shrines
Skaven Doom Bell / Plague Furnace (still no 8th ed army book by the way)

Can you point me out where you have read that our chariots can overrule (specifically) their march restrictions?


EDIT: I have found something that will end this discussion, haha:

VC Army Book page 26:

"...In addition, Units with the Undead special rule cannot make march moves unless... ...(or have the Vampiric special rule), in which case they can march as usual"

There is no further need to FAQ this. This makes it cristal clear.

So demian, what is your conclusion?
 
Yes, I see.. however you yourself gave the answer, just didn't read it well!

"unless they have joined a non-Vampiric unit they (and their mount) can make march moves as normal"

It says as normal, as usual, etc.


This means... well, as any other chariot. All entries, whether the Vampiric one, or the General's say so.

So bottom line is, undead are allowed to normally march within General's 12''... or if the have Vampiric
 
Demian said:
Yes, I see.. however you yourself gave the answer, just didn't read it well!

"unless they have joined a non-Vampiric unit they (and their mount) can make march moves as normal"

It says as normal, as usual, etc.


This means... well, as any other chariot. All entries, whether the Vampiric one, or the General's say so.

So bottom line is, undead are allowed to normally march within General's 12''... or if the have Vampiric

so no, they cant march??
I could interpret "normal" and "usual" as being regular units with the same rule

except for the Coven and the corpse cart when mounted... since they then count as mounts and not as chariots
 
I'm afraid they (we) can't march with Chariots, Hover bats, etc.

When it says "as normal" it means to follow the restrictions as any other chariot. Try to think of this as "Undead are allowed to march" but otherwise can't.

Remember this applies also when the General is slain. If he dies, and another Lore of Vampires wizard takes to the task to sustain the army, he does NOT become the General. He just prevents crumbling, but the rules don't make him the new General (as they say.. there can be only one!)

=)
 
All very vague and i still think it is just a way of interpretation.
Also i see absolutely no reason as to why a black coach would have the Vampiric special rule or could become a flying unit if it cannot use any of the benefits.
Vampiric (imo) is specifically designed to allow marching without general (and avoid slain general crumble as a welcome side-effect), what is the whole point of equipping a chariot with this rule if it cannot use it. (slain general happens once every 10 games orso?)
 
I'm gonna throw in my 2 cents (Which is about all it's worth lol)

I'm in agreement with demian and Mr. West here.

1. We all know Chariots cannot march.
2. We all know that a model within 12" of the general (or with the vampiric rule) can march per normal restrictions of the BRB
3. This leads to the conclusion that Chariots cannot march regardless of their proximity to the general or the vampiric special rule.


Skittelz1981 said:
Also i see absolutely no reason as to why a black coach would have the Vampiric special rule or could become a flying unit if it cannot use any of the benefits.
Vampiric (imo) is specifically designed to allow marching without general (and avoid slain general crumble as a welcome side-effect), what is the whole point of equipping a chariot with this rule if it cannot use it. (slain general happens once every 10 games orso?)

Now I think that they gave the vampiric special rule to models that it just simply made sense for. Think of it this way, A necromancer can be your armies general although he is not a vampiric model. In pure game mechanics this causes for some conflicting internal ideas, however, in the lore it makes total sense. I personally think that this is why the coach was givin the vampiric rule, simply because it makes sense.
 
Indeed Corien!

Interpreting rules and applying them as they are worded is one of the things most players tend to disagree.

We all know that some rules make little sense, because the way they are worded in the books gets in the way of how they "should be". Yes, it would have been better if the Black Coach had Hover instead of Fly. That would make a lot more sense...

The game is divided by Lore and System. The System intends for every army to interact with another, in battle and chance. Even if the Lore of some characters (Like Krell, who should be more of a Rank & File devourer, instead of a Challenger) is stated as one, while in the game's System it'll behave a little or a lot different.

In this case, a Vampiric Black Coach has a poor Ld value of 5, if the General dies, that expensive model would crumble tu dust. The Terrorgheist is another matter, because it's a different type of troop, much costier and a lot more dangerous. So... by the System's rules, a Coach may never march, but also will never stop grinding stuff unless it's killed.

Bottom line is, Rules as Worded are always going to be more important than Rules as Intended, unless the developers of the game change something via FAQs
 
Well, just for all you out there this FYI

A formal request has been written to GW FAQ section, so awaiting their answer and their faq/errata update.

Also on a personal note, i really dont care much about the fluff and the lore since whatever GW puts out there is often a bunch of nonsense and conflicting stories all the way through.
I care about rules, the clearer the better. This whole chariot/undead thing is one of the very vague and poorly clarified.

Fluff/lorewise i would be inclined to disagree altogether with nonmarching chariots, for that simply doesnt make any sense at all, clearly a chariot can alway go faster than any infantry and is able to march.
Also it is hard to imagine all these skeletal horsemen, banshees, revenants, cairnwraiths etc in the mortis model, not being able to make that silly thing march.
This all bubbles down to the fact that "making sense" is just something GW is really bad at, thats why i stopped long ago at trying to make sense out of anything they try to make and only care for the rules that are actually being put out and the FAQ/errata that come along with it.

Just a thank you for all posting forummembers for their 2 cents and clarifying it. Though i still not agree with it :D
 
I really hope they can march lol

But i allways was annoyed when mortis engines/coverns cant match.

The explanation of the lack of march in brb is because of how heavy they are. But they have ethereal movement which says they are not slowed down by weight hence no barding penalty etc.

I suppose this also applied to black coach when it becomes ethereal. So the rules do clash and i am on the fence with this one.

Pointless post i know.

If you dont mind can you tell us what you wrote to the faq section? Im curious
 
Skittelz1981 said:
Well, just for all you out there this FYI

A formal request has been written to GW FAQ section, so awaiting their answer and their faq/errata update.

Good!! I would like this to be a bit more clear also, because if it weren't for the "As Normal" statement then I would agree with you 100%.


Skittelz1981 said:
Also on a personal note, i really dont care much about the fluff and the lore since whatever GW puts out there is often a bunch of nonsense and conflicting stories all the way through.
I care about rules, the clearer the better. This whole chariot/undead thing is one of the very vague and poorly clarified.

Fluff/lorewise i would be inclined to disagree altogether with nonmarching chariots, for that simply doesnt make any sense at all, clearly a chariot can alway go faster than any infantry and is able to march.
Also it is hard to imagine all these skeletal horsemen, banshees, revenants, cairnwraiths etc in the mortis model, not being able to make that silly thing march.
This all bubbles down to the fact that "making sense" is just something GW is really bad at, thats why i stopped long ago at trying to make sense out of anything they try to make and only care for the rules that are actually being put out and the FAQ/errata that come along with it.

Lol True dat my friend! They are super sketchy with their Lore vs Gameplay, but we all love them dearly so we can't complain to much lol.


Skittelz1981 said:
Just a thank you for all posting forummembers for their 2 cents and clarifying it. Though i still not agree with it :D

No problem! And in a forum not everyone has to agree!! I mean, I can't count the number of times that I thought I was right and ended up being wrong! I mean, the best I can give you is a pretty solid guess, not facts. Then I pretty much go with majority rules on how things should work.
 
I would like to comment that these rules are absolutely crystal clear and there is no room for interpretation. Because of how clear they are, I will tell you Skittelz1981 (just as a friendly heads up) that Games-Workshop will not reply to your e-mail nor will they put in an FAQ.

You could call the toll-free Customer Support number however and speak to a representative over the phone. They are there to help you with any customer support issues (including Rules).

Their North America number is: (800) 384 - 4263

They will confirm everything I am about to tell you Skittelz1981.

I am directing this to you Skittelz1981, because everyone else is against you ... because you have misunderstood the rules. I am being direct here, because your written tone has been very condescending and not very polite.


So lets go over each rule individually as they are written within their respective books and clear this up for you.

Chariots:
Page 86 of the Big Rule Book (BRB): Under Chariots > Split Profile: “When moving, the chariot model always uses the Movement characteristic of the beasts, although as the beasts are somewhat slowed by the charior chassis, a chariot cannot march.”

Fly Special Rule:
Page 70 of the BRB: Fly: “In Warhammer, flight is represented by a swoop or glide of up to 10 inches. The flyer starts off on the ground, takes off, flies to where it wishes to go, and then lands.”
>>>It then continues<<<
“Units made up entirely of models that can fly can move or charge normally on the ground, using their Movement value, or instead choose to fly. A unit that flies can move over other units and terrain as it does so, treating the entire move as taking place over open ground.”

Flying March Special Rule:
Page 70 of the BRB: Fly > Flying March: “A unit that is flying can march as normal, doubling its flying move to 20 inches, representing a particularly long swoop or glide.”

Vampire Counts Army Special Rules regarding Marching:
Page 26 of the Vampire Counts Army Book: Undead: “… units with the Undead special rule cannot make march moves unless they are within 12 inches of the army General (or have the Vampiric special rule), in which case they can march as usual.”

Vampire Counts units as examples
Black Coach and Coven Throne // Page 46 and 52 (respectively) of the Vampire Counts Army Book: Defines each of these units as: “Troop Type: Chariot.” In addition, they both have the special rule “Undead” and “Vampiric.”

It states in the Main rule book that Chariots cannot march. This is clear and straight forward. We all agree on this.

Fly is a special type of movement (Not standard) and in fact it states very clearly that a unit with fly can use its regular Movement Value or make a special “Fly” rule to make it's Movement Value 10 inches and treat all terrain as open ground. Notice that this is simply stating that instead of its normal Movement Value, it can use 10 inches instead and treat all terrain as open ground. This doesn't affect any other rules as it says it only affects its Movement Value and what it treats terrain as (Nothing else).

Then it continues to state that a unit that is flying is also allowed to march “as normal.” This means that it will follow all rules for marching, except that it will still use the Movement Value of Fly (10 inches) and thus will have a 20 inch move instead. This means it will have to take leadership tests for units within 8 inches for example because its a standard march that follows all march rules "As normal"

In the case of Chariots, they cannot normally march at all. The special rule under “Flying March” simply states that if you fly you are still allowed to march if you would be able to march normally. However, chariots cannot march normally and thus cannot make a 20 inch movement regardless of the Fly special rule.

Now, the Black Coach and Coven throne are both Undead and Vampiric. The Undead special rule states that it cannot march unless they are within 12 inches of the Army General, in which case they can march as normal. Again, this would mean that units that are within 8 inches of an enemy unit would have to leadership test to march because it follows the standard rules for Marching. Which would also mean that Chariots could not make a march move since they could not normally make a march move.

Finally, the Vampiric rule is added to the Black Coach and the Coven throne for mechanics/balance.

Page 60 of the Vampire Counts Army Book: The Lore of Vampires > Invocation of Nehek: “… infantry gain d6 plus the caster’s Wizard level in wounds; other troop types targeted gain 1 plus the caster’s Wizard level in Wounds. However, models with the Vampiric, Ethereal, or Large Target special rules can never regain more than 1 Wound per successful casting.”

If the Black Coach and Coven Throne did not have the Vampiric special rule, they could regain all of their wounds from a single successful cast of Invocation of Nehek from a level 4 wizard (4+1). Furthermore, it protects them from Crumble, which could instantly kill the model. So the Vampiric rule is there to help promote a sense of balance. Vampire Count Players can’t instantly heal them, but they also don’t have to worry about them dyeing to crumble in one failed leadership role.


To summarize:
1) Fly is a type of movement that states your Movement Value is 10 inches (instead of whatever it normally would be) and that you treat all terrain as open ground.
Flying units are still allowed to march normally (if they could normally), making a fly march of 20 inches

2) A Chariot is a Troop Type that states you cannot make a March Move.

3) A Chariot with Fly special rule can make a Fly movement, which makes their Movement Value 10 inches (instead of their normal Movement Value) and that it can treat all terrain as open ground. However, because a chariot cannot march, they are not allowed to march even with fly because a Flying March move is simple a standard march using the Fly Movement value.

4) Vampiric Special Rule is put onto the Black Coach and the Coven Throne simply for balance purposes. You can’t heal more than 1 wound and you don’t have to worry about removing them from the table for Crumble.


I hope this clears it up.

If you have any serious rebuttal (disagreement), please back it up with actual written rules with their respective page numbers as a reference so that we can see the Games-Workshop Written rule as I have done with my side of the Argument.
 
Dear ... over at Games Workshop,

Lately i have been involved in a discussion about rules that are confusing and on the forums (Vampirecounts.net for examples) have also been the topic of mixed feelings and uncertainties.

Taken from the BRB, we all know that chariots are not allowed to make march moves and that no special rule can change that. Yet this is conflicting with the Ethereal special rule, with the Undead special rule and with the Vampiric special rule.





- Ethereals are never slowed down by anything that impairs movement, yet being a chariot trooptype would?

- In the VC armybook it is stated that ALL undead units are allowed to march if they are within 12" of the general as normal, yet since a chariot can never march, they would not be allowed to march within those critical 12"? Conflicting is the fact that Undead units can never march, yet those 12" would make it possible as would normally. Is normal, referring to the troop type or is normal referring to the fact that units would be allowed to march. The chariots are, after all, undead. This gets tricky when it comes to the further breakdown of the Undead special rule. Which makes it unable to flee as chargereaction. It makes it Unstable and thus crumbles through combat resolution and it would crumble if the General is slain. So this entire "Chariot" would have to bow down to the Undead special rules yet cannot benefit from it in the terms of movement? Kind of odd if you ask me.

- The Vampiric rule as written in the armybook states that any model/units with this special rule is allowed to march without the general presence at all, thus creating some welcome independance from the 12" rule, another beneficial side-effect (much less important though) is the fact that it would not crumble due to a slain General. Here again, one might wonder what the whole point is in giving this special rule to a Coven Throne or Black Coach if they cannot actually use the special rule for what it is mostly designed for. The only real benefit is the free and independant march-movement, not the slain-general-side-effect. Also for a black coach gaining the Ethereal AND the fly special rule would again make no sense for it would win 2" of movement? Rolling so many sixes would really only make it move 2 extra inches? with the ability to go over units clearly but still a very unbelievably awkward upgrade.


In any case, this chariot thing not being able to march hurts Vampire Counts really bad, it conflicts with unclear rules and kills some of the synergy this army can have, the 12" generalbubble is already small and we rely on some speed to take out all the shooting that we face and dont have, yet GW gives us 3 major chariots that cannot actually keep up with fast movement. Lets not even start with the CorpseCart with movement 4? really, movement 4 and no march?
It makes no sense at all from the way i see it, i hope that GW has a straight and clear vision about the Vampire Counts chariots and that further FAQ and Errata will take the doubt away from many a VC-player.

Much thanks for your time and i look forward to your official answer, which i will make sure to post on every forum to let the Warhammer community know what the deal exactly is.


Greeting, Skittelz








___ this is what i sent GW FAQ Council. I know a friend of mine also sent them a mail with the same question, i just dont know what he exactly wrote and how.____________
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu