chariots

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
well thanx for the awesome Rules description given.
I agree i looked over some of the details u are mentioning.
Was i condescending? that wasnt my intention, my cynicism wasnt directed to anyone personal, more to a confunkshun of all those rules you have been breaking down so thoroughly for us.

It needed a post like yours to really clarify and link all the pieces together, which others clearly didnt, thus still leaving confusion.


I still feel that AB would overrule the BRB and that our chariots should be the only ones being able to march as a grant for not having anything ranged :D
 
True the Black Coach cannot march (unfortunately, I've long since given up assuming anything in VC's favor since 8th ed), but does get swiftstride on its charges like all chariots. Also, it does not crumble when the general dies. The unit is vampiric, hence no crumble, as I assume the slumbering elder within is centuries older than the army general anyway.
 
Thanks for your reply SKITTELZ1981 and I am glad that I cleared it up for you. It sounds more like a frustration at a rules mechanic now instead of not understanding the rules.

I accept your intentions of not being condescending - thanks for clarifying. It can be difficult to read someone's tone in written text.

Not to deviate from the discussion of rules mechanics too much, allow me the opportunity to clear some more things up for everyone.



The synergy works fine in our army and they didn't make our chariots different than other armies because we have a castable spell, in a lore no one else has, that gives an 8 inch move. Furthermore, the developers decided us fit to give us the spell in a second form (The Book of Arkhan) so that you can cast it twice.

So you cast Vanhel's Dance Macabre (AoE) to cast on all your units. Doesn't get dispelled? Great your chariot essentially just marched. Chances are, it will be dispelled.

So you cast the single target version from the Book of Arkhan on your chariot. Now it marched.

Oh and keep in mind that we aren't the Tomb Kings who don't even get to march at all regardless of general.

In addition, the chariots you're complaining about have a movement of 8 inches. Our army has a movement of 4 inches. Even if you didn't cast either of the Dance spells and even if you had the +1 movement banner, you're chariot will only be 2 inches behind your infantry (without marching).

Finally ... Etheral special rule on a chariot is AMAZING because it doesn't have to do dangerous terrain tests. Other chariots do and when they fail their dangerous terrain they suffer d6 wounds. D6 wounds!! That's enough to wipe out most chariots every time.

Oh - and then there's the fact that Chariot's have 3d6 swiftstride for charging. So that 2 inches behind isn't an issue for them.

As for the "close the distance to get out of enemy shooting" comment... we resurrect our troops at a very reliable rate. Unless we are fighting a true gun line army, we wont even have a scratch. If it is an enemy gun line, they will do to us the same as anyone else fighting them.

If you should be complaining at all about anything, its the Corpse Cart which NEEDS to be close to our units. It only has movement 4 and it's considered a chariot, so the only way to keep it close is the Dance spell. That is the real complaint a Vampire Count should have.

Really ... lets step back and look at our army as a whole. The Vampire Counts have some of the dirtiest tricks in the book! Our army is very strong and capable! If you gave our chariots the ability to march, is that a fair upgrade to an already strong army? What would the balance be? What would you be willing to make weaker in order to do that?

We don't need shooting just like the Dwarves don't need magic. If any of this bothers you, then you should consider another army because this is the mechanics of the Vampire Counts. It's what makes us different than others and separates us as unique.

There are things that Games-Workshop does that bother me just as much as the next person. But the new 8th edition Army Books aren't one of them.

When you think something isn't balanced or that a mechanic isn't working, think about how you would realistically fix it in a balanced and fair way. If you can honestly come up with a good solution that keeps the game fair and balanced, but also correlates to the lore, then you may have a legitimate claim to something the author messed up.

On the other hand, it may clear your mind of some frustrating and unnecessary anger. After that - the game will become more enjoyable and much more fun.
 
Well TrevO, if i am going to answer to that this would be going way off-topic so i will withhold from doing so even though my fingers are itching. :D
All i will say is that i feel the VC are way too much dependant on succesful magicphases to have the synergy you are talking about. Failed magicphases for other armies have far less impact imo, for VC it is a downright disaster, especially around turn 3-4.

All i really still need to know is:

A CorpseCart or CovenThrone, mounted by a necromancer and a vamplord is counted as a character right? I read an faq about that although it was abit outdated, looked for some more info but wasnt able to find it.
A mounted character may always march (in our case vampiric or undead within 12"), this would mean that the Coventhrone is always marchable and that the CorpseCart under the right circumstances may too.
 
Skillelz: Which FAQ did it state that mounted characters could always march? I mean I just did a quick skim so I could have missed it.

As far as VC's magic phase, yeah, it is a lot more important than other armies magic phases. But if you (not specifically you, but anyone) were to design an army around not relying on magic then one wouldn't have to worry about it to much, that or you could always take the Master of the Black Arts! I mean it is super expensive, but it makes for a lot more reliable magic phases all game!

I see exactly where you're coming from but the only thing that really gets me has to be that chariots can't march in the basic rulebook (this we all know). I mean tomb king characters on chariots can't march and chaos characters on chariots can't march, I'm just not seeing why VC would be an exception.
 
It's on the army book, under the Vampiric rule.

However, it says "can march as normal/usual" which means it is only used for Monsters and War Beasts (Cavalry)
 
TheTrev0 said:
Really ... lets step back and look at our army as a whole. The Vampire Counts have some of the dirtiest tricks in the book! Our army is very strong and capable! If you gave our chariots the ability to march, is that a fair upgrade to an already strong army? What would the balance be? What would you be willing to make weaker in order to do that?

We don't need shooting just like the Dwarves don't need magic. If any of this bothers you, then you should consider another army because this is the mechanics of the Vampire Counts. It's what makes us different than others and separates us as unique.

There are things that Games-Workshop does that bother me just as much as the next person. But the new 8th edition Army Books aren't one of them.

When you think something isn't balanced or that a mechanic isn't working, think about how you would realistically fix it in a balanced and fair way. If you can honestly come up with a good solution that keeps the game fair and balanced, but also correlates to the lore, then you may have a legitimate claim to something the author messed up.

On the other hand, it may clear your mind of some frustrating and unnecessary anger. After that - the game will become more enjoyable and much more fun.

Seriously? We got our claws clipped in a huge way in 8th ed. I had a 6k point army of VC, massive, expensive, and carefully painted, enough units to try every single possible build. In 6th and 7th ed, I was an unbeatable monster, now in 8th I'm the local joke. 26 games lost in a row, and by a landslide. Our weaknesses could fill an encyclopedia, and our strengths can be countered by anyone with half a brain and a 2k army.
I was happy to ebay off 5k of my force for bargain basement prices, at least now I have some cash to spend on different (and far, far better) armies. As a pleasant side-effect, I noticed that when I played 1k games, I won every time. Undead wreck face at low points, but once it gets much over 1.5k, we're the red-headed stepchild.
Do what i did, sell your VC down to a 1k strikeforce (heavy on zombies and skellies), and you'll be much happier. I'm done with big armies, you put hundreds of dollars and hours into collecting and painting, only to have a rules change destroy your enjoyment of the game. Collect several tiny forces, then when a new edition comes out to screw one army, you can always box them up for a couple years and play your other ones.
 
In principle, I think it is fair to make a case for ethereal and/or flying would allow chariots to March. It can be argued from a rule perspective but the counter arguments just as valid.
Warhammer rules are weak since there is no set structure or system as to which rules override eachother. Furthermore they use words like "as normal" which can refer back to many different variants of normality. (normal as the core rules, normal as the unit type rules, normal as the unit including special rules ect).
In some case FAQs will seek to follow the RAW, while in others it will go against the RAW in favor of game balance.

Personally I feel its a shame that a flying black coach would be unable to march. RAW wise, I think the ethereal ability prevents other special rules from slowing it as well. But game balance wise, it's a very strong army, and of course marching undead chariots would further strengthen the army. GW gave us the FAQ allowing no overrun against unstable units crumbling... but only for a while, then they changed it to allow overrun instead. No doubt GW will be carefull about ruling chariots+ethereal/fly in favor of an already strong VC army, no matter what justification there may be in the rules.
 
"in which case they can march as usual.”"
I'm sorry but there is no wiggle room.

march AS USUAL
And how does a chariot usually march?
It doesnt.

Case closed

If it didnt say "as usual", it would be arguable.
 
No need to be sorry. I was not looking for wiggle room. I was pointing out that the rules are not clear on this. I'll will be happy to put forth various arguments just to prove that it is arguable.

The Ethereal Case.
P. 68 Ethereal: "They are also never slowed by any special rule, spell or item..."
P. 86 Split Profile: "...as the beasts are slowed by the chariot chassis, a chariot cannot march"

The Flying Case
p. 79 Flying March: "A unit that is flying can march as normal, doubling its flying move to 20" the second part of the sentence is the explanation of what the first part means. So "as normal" means you get the double your 10" to 20" because that's the normal rules for marching. It does not refer to the way a non-flying chariot would move on the ground since it is established earlier in the fly rules that flying models can select to move on the ground OR do a fly move. Naturally the fly move follows a different set of rules since the model is flying.
p. 80 Hover: "Models with the Hover special rules follow all the rules for Flyers, but cannot march" So if a flying black coach should not have been able to march, it would have been given the Hover rule instead. That must be crystal clear.

The Marching Ghosts
P. p. 68 Ethereal: "They are also never slowed by any special rule, spell or item..."
P. VC p26 Undead: "In addition, units with the Undead special rule cannot make march move unless.."
You can easily argue for all ethereal units to ignore the Undead special rule here if your want. Weather it can be applied to chariots have already been discussed plenty which just proves my point that these things are arguable due to a weak rule set.

Whatever you conclude on the rules, I don't care. I play that my stuff cannot march, and I can just as easily do the reverse argument if needed. But please don't tell me that GW has written a strong and clear rule set on this. I lost count on how many times I have seen lengthy threads on marching chariots, that itself should be evidence enough.
 
Lastly, ill just throw in that the no march for chariots is not very intuitive. Is it not just a bit odd, that when crossing open ground with no enemies, a unit of swordsmen will advance faster than say a cold one chariot? I mean even in warhammer roleplay you will get there many times faster by taking a Four Seasons Coach than just marching down the road. Not an argument in itself, but definitely a driver to why the marching chariot topic will keep coming back. Some people won't accept that their chariot cannot march because "It just feels wrong", and that combined with poorly written rules is the perfect cocktail for a nice long argument.
 
Smogg: I agree 100% that it makes no ligical sense at all that chariots can't "March" I mean, saying that the weight slows the beasts just is a very flimsy case, this is why there are 2 beasts pulling it! It is so that they share the load and can keep up with the rest of the cavalry.

Now as far as the rules go, Your first point can be cleared up by the fact that movement for a chariot (the fact that it can't march) is not a special rule, but a unit type specification.

Your second point I agree, there is a straight up conflict in the rules. Flying = March As Normal, Chariots = No March, vampiric means that they can march As Normal. So what exactly is As Normal then? As normal per chariot rules or As Normal per flying rules. Unclear for sure.

The third point I want to see what everyones opinion is!! I didn't even think about it so WOAH! Can my hexies march outside of my generals bubble!! Can Black Knights since they move as ethereals?? PLEASE, ANYONE ANSWER THIS QUESTION!!!!!!
 
The point smogg made about ethereal marching....

614378.webp
 
Tbh, it would make sense for hexwraiths to be able to march always.
with their 8" move it is nigh imppssible to ever move through any unit unless they can march. especially if fielded in 2rows of 5.... Try moving through a small squad of anything, most likely its gonna cost u so many turns just finding that one perfect ppzition to move 8" and be 1" away from the unit u passed thru.
It is just ridiculous how bad they are without marching, and that for a whopping 300 points, u get a unit that doesnt live up to its cost.


So about mounted characters. he is still a character. just mounted on what happens to be a chariot, does the character gain the chariot status? my superduper general pimpass wizard combatlord sits on a coventhrone or corpsecart and they cant make that thing march?

actually to me, it simply makes sense that my general can make everything march, simply because he is the magic leader of this lifeless horde that does his biding.
 
I agree with you Smogg! Chariots should be able to march (maybe throw in some dangerous terrain test? just so they distinguish from, say Cavalry perhaps?), and Ethereals even more so...

Yes, Undead special rule is the one "slowing them down" and it would actually stand in a RAW discussion because... you found the right wording there!

However, "slow down" is just a fluff concept, not a ruling concept (like... -x to their Movement value, for instance). I can also mean that Ethereals should never move any less than their maximum allowed movement value...

I know, that is silly. But that's why it's not covered in the rules (sadly)
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu