So, I've been agonising lately over my Vampire Lord builds.
He's mounted on a Zombie Dragon. In this regard, the Nightshroud is very useful. It stops the dragon itself from getting trashed by units with Great Weapons (like Kroxigors and Ogres and things like that) and allows the dragon to fight before its enemies, mitigating the penalty of it's Initiative of 2. It also adds +1 to the Vampires armour save, and makes enemies with magic weapons and great weapons (who think they have a shot at dropping the Vampire) groan. However, it chews up my magic armour slot.
The Charmed Shield, on the other hand, helps mitigate the biggest liability of the Zombie Dragon, which is getting smashed by cannon balls on turn one. However, it only works once and only works against the first shot. A canny opponent will sucker out that 2+ save with a weaker warmachine, like a bolt thrower or mortar, or with a volley of crossbows or something. Additionally, the Charmed Shield is very cheap, so I can afford both Quickblood AND Red Fury on my Vampire. So on paper it gives both better protection AND better offence. However I'm left with a lower armour save, and in combat I'll be facing off against great weapons and magic weapons where I really need that extra armour save.
What are peoples thoughts? Charmed Shield or Nightshroud?
EDIT: On a related note, the army has lots of Warmachine hunters, so it's pretty rare I have to face more than two rounds of warmachine shooting, and often I only have to face one. Not to mention there is only one Dwarf player in our local group, but stonethrowers and bolt throwers are still an issue.