Ok.
At the base of every campaign are its battles, how these are determined have a significant effect on the campaign.
To me, a much better system would not require the player to play battles in real life, but still give an incentive to do so.
Ulthuans style, where you build armies and have them duke it out using a program, is nearly infeasible to us, as we have no people with such skills.
If we instead had the online battle system simplified, I'm considering this method.
You may buy "soldiers" with "gold, money etc". If you go to a neutral node, its is automatically captured. If you travel to an enemy node, with no soldiers on it, it is suposed there is a small garrison. However with more than 10 'soldiers' you automaticaly capture it, killing the garrison.
When facing an enemy army, the army with more soldiers has a higher chan
ce of winning, subject to other factors, including location.
Fairly standard and simple so far.
However a good campaign has strategical value, so there are a few gameplay mechanics I'd like to introduce.
1. Roads:
Armies can only travel along roads, these roads are between nodes. An army can travel a certain amount of nodes a turn. This mimics real travel, meaning that soldiers can't just magically appear in a location on the other side of the map.
2. Supply Trains:
An army has a supply train running from it, to the nearest depot, i.e. HQ and captured castles/forts/etc. If the supply train is cut, the army immediately is weakened, after a few turns, it dies out. This makes protection of them paramount, and gives a way for weak factions to defeat stronger factions attacks.
3. Special Projects:
Projects that do certain things, like poisoning wells, building new depots, assassinating etc.
4. Faction Leaders: They want certain things, which may not always be tactically sound. Help them and you get bonus', disobey them and they might just decide to be spiteful. You could always decide to assassinate them...
The political side can be just as fun, so I'm all for defecting, bribing, assassination, etc Included in special projects.
Location:
It has to be somewhere which hasn't really been done so far, so no Ulthuan, Araby or dark lands or Sylvania (well the Sylvania didn't really pick up, so maybe).
It also has to be relevant to a large player base, though this is mainly in the factions.
Somewhere with a coast could introduce interesting mechanics.
Factions:
3 is to little for Politics, so I'm thinking four, to maintain them at reasonable size.
Roles:
At the beginning it will just be bouncing ideas off eachother, on fluff, game mechancis etc. Once we get somewhere roles can be assigned.
This is an outline of what I was thinking,