Competitive players

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
bobajelly said:
Aedin said:
I think 6 Crypt Horrors in front of a Mortis Engine is a great tactic. The Horrors get the extra regen and the Mortis Engine benefits from hard cover. Compliment the build with a good points denial list with a killy Vamp Lord on a flying mount with caster heroes in a bunker and just let attrition kill your opponent. The last fight i did with a list like this I ended the battle in turn 4 and had more models than I started the game with on the table :thumbsup:

Sorry but being a highly visible target means pretty everyone can see it and its a large target, therefore it doesn't benefit from cover.

I consider it better to use the Mortis Engine to provide the regen and be protected from CC by the Crypt Horrors. Hopefully get it in range so its often ignored aura of death can grind down enemies.

I disagree on this because in the Warhammer rulebook examples in shooting it shows infantry providing hard cover to cavalry models so it would seem to make sense that monstrous infantry would provide cover to large targets.
 
The Large Target special rule only applies to cover from obstacles, anyway, so intervening units should still work, provided they're big enough to actually shield half or more of the Mortis Engine from view.
 
The best solution would be to make your own Model for the Mortis Engine (One carried by zombies pehaps) and make it small enough so that the CH block it from view or cover atleast 50%
 
Marche Funebre said:
The best solution would be to make your own Model for the Mortis Engine (One carried by zombies pehaps) and make it small enough so that the CH block it from view or cover atleast 50%

This is called modeling to advantage and is cheating.
 
Cobra7 said:
Marche Funebre said:
The best solution would be to make your own Model for the Mortis Engine (One carried by zombies pehaps) and make it small enough so that the CH block it from view or cover atleast 50%

This is called modeling to advantage and is cheating.
Even if its only a cm smaller than the original model? And In the case of a proxy its not cheating? sure both players have to agree to the use of a proxy but still.

Dont get me wrong im just trying to understand where the line is between 'that model was made smaller to get an advantage' and 'that is one cool conversion, i especially like how its carried by zombies and not that hunking great blob of ectoplasmic farts'

Or i know of a black coach model which was modelled to be doing a wheely. This model is now atleast 4 cm taller than it was. Would that be called 'modelling to a disadvantage' and also be considered cheating/just plain stupid because the player wanted his model to look cool? Sorry if it soundes like im encouraging people to cheat, was not what i wanted.
 
I'd say the flaw lies in the los rule detracting from the hobby. Should modelling factor into the rules of the game? No. Does modelling factor into the rules of the game? Yes.
 
One solution that springs to mind is something the old fps games use called hitboxes. Would be one way of making sure that modelling doesnt influence the game. Would probably also settle quite a few disputes in competitive groups/tourneys.

But i doubt that its feasable

To get back to the previous posts. If you can succesfuly argue that the banshees and the spires of the Mortis Engine do not belong to the main body of the model i think the CH would be providing cover.
 
Zeleck said:
I'd say the flaw lies in the los rule detracting from the hobby. Should modelling factor into the rules of the game? No. Does modelling factor into the rules of the game? Yes.

Surely, should modelling factor into the rules of a fair, competitive game? No, Does it, yes.

If the game was played like chess (as fair and balanced as possible) then modelling wouldn't come in at all, but obviously that's not the game we play. There will always be inconveniences and annoyances when taking a ruleset designed for fun into a competitive setting (if you take it far enough, dice become one of them). Even using the GW models with no converting, you'll not find it fair, as they aren't designed to be fairly proportioned with regards LOS; they're designed to look awesome.

I almost think we need 'Warhammer Fantasy: Competitive' for those players who want to make a sport of it.
 
I think the true LOS rule was introduced to WHFB only so they could sell more junk like this: http://www.games-workshop.com/gws/catalog/productDetail.jsp?prodId=prod1410001

Saw one of those today in my local gaming store and it all became clear to me.

Sorry for the OT post...
 
Dont let this get out of hand agan guys, you can start other topics about LoS. Used 3 vargheists today to great effect. They have plenty of attacks and the unit isnt super expensive. 18 of them? Dont know, 3 units of 6 would probably be better than one big unit.
 
i can only conclude that if you want to be competative it is best to be as competative as possible within the limits of a game that isn't precise enough for any result to be truly absolute. That is you can be labelled the grand champion of warhammer but it will never be free from speculation.

Catch 22

what is the most competative army we can field using the new army book?

Collection allowing i would say an attritional army/points denial is the most effective for us. Take only tough/easy to raise units and force your opponent towards them for lack of anything better to kill. You dont even have to deal much damage in return. Just enough to ensure that they are getting weaker and you are not. I can't vouch for sure because i dont have enough models to try it out yet but i plan on taking cheap level 2 mundane vampires with da and forcing my opponent to roll 2 dd for every 1 pd i throw at ion.

I want to make my enemy feel he is chiselling out of prison with a rock hammer.
 
I think your right Zeleck. Point denial seems to be the way to go. Its not the only way but it plays best to our advantages. For me competitive means knowing what goes where, when to twist and which tools are right for the job. To stretch the analogy even further, tactics that try to do things with our army which it wasn't meant for is like picking locks with spoons. *rambles on and on......*
 
What you really want is one part of the army that is easily raisable infantry that can take a charge and pin stuff in place. The other part is characters and heavy hitters to deal the killing blow. I dont think having just zombies would work if one wants to win and have a competitive army. Still, it´s a fina balance to fit both in.
 
Mikael.K said:
What you really want is one part of the army that is easily raisable infantry that can take a charge and pin stuff in place. The other part is characters and heavy hitters to deal the killing blow. I dont think having just zombies would work if one wants to win and have a competitive army. Still, it´s a fina balance to fit both in.

i think this is the way to go. it actually looks alot like the way we used to make lists now ghouls have become zombies though..
 
In all my years of playing Undead (since Nagash was Lord and Master now his model has been reduced to objective marker status) this has been my favourite rendition of the book. Undead have always relied on their shit troops to slow and grind while our elites brought the hammer down, it's just now we have a few more tools to choose from and a core section that is cheap enough to actually field in the multitudes that our fluff dictates.
That aside I have to say combo front charge between Skellies and Crypt Horrors, use the majority of frontage as the CH and the one or Two Skellies in combat just take advantage of the rank bonus provided to break Steadfast. Once I slip and fall into a pile of money I intend to buy quite a few more Horrors and I think I would like to try out an army of Dire Wolf Core, I think it could be a fun army...
 
Johnny-Crass said:
My Scream Heavy 2500 list has gone 6-0 so far and 4 of those games I have tabled the person.

I've been debating trying this. Mind giving me an example of the general list that you take that includes this stuff? I'm imagining a ton of banshee heroes, maybe a scabscrath character and some cairn wraith/banshee's from the rare column? Maybe a mortis engine? What's the rest of your troops look like though?
 
Long time skaven player here, and just now looking into trying VC.
I see lots of people talking down core choices and talking about specials and rares at lot in this thread. I'm beginning to wonder why people act like VC core are some horribly depressing thing.

It has been my experience that large numbers of tarpit core can set you up for flank charges which ultimately allow for combat resolution. And unlike skavenslave tarpits, a good zombie tarpit with IoN vampire leading a small force of GW grave guard strolling along beside it could lock into an opponent with ease.

Just eat the first failed combat like it is nothing with 30+ zombies then drill the flank with your vampire and the grave guard. Anyone trying to win a fight with zombies is foolish because that isn't the purpose of cheap units with crap stats. They are there to eat wounds (that unlike skaven you can bring back) and open you up to a make a counter charge.

Truly competitive players don't just hold up sheets of paper and compare stat lines, because if that were the case skaven would never win.. positioning, knowing when it's ok for units to just die, and knowing how to bite back twice as hard are all vastly important.

I've also been wondering why I don't see much mention of putting a banshee in a zombie anvil unit. I mean, against most units you aren't going to lose her, she bumps the zombies up to leadership 5 instead of 2, and with her scream their is a truly good chance that you'll tip combat res closer to your favor and thus reduce anvil losses. She brings terror to the unit which can make the lackluster zombies actually land some hits with some luck. It's a hefty point investment but certainly not a risky one.
 
Xander said:
Johnny-Crass said:
My Scream Heavy 2500 list has gone 6-0 so far and 4 of those games I have tabled the person.

I've been debating trying this. Mind giving me an example of the general list that you take that includes this stuff? I'm imagining a ton of banshee heroes, maybe a scabscrath character and some cairn wraith/banshee's from the rare column? Maybe a mortis engine? What's the rest of your troops look like though?

All the characters go into the Skeillies


Ghoul King 455
Curse of Revenant
Dark Majesty
Fear Incarnate
Skabscrath
Dragonbane Gem
OTS

Banshee 95

Banshee 95

Banshee 95

Banshee 95

Vampire BSB 207
Armor of Destiny
Shield
Dark Majesty

50 Skeletons 305
Full Com
Screaming Banner
Spears

40 Ghouls 400

2 Wraiths 1 Banshee 175

2 Wraiths 1 Banshee 175

Terrorghiest 225

Spirit host 45

Spirit Host 45

Spirit host 45

Total: 2462
 
Screams to no care about buffs and hex's (besides things that target movement which I always dispel). Most Direct Damage is dealt to all the ethereal and honestly it is not so bad as long as my lovely laddies live. Spells like dwellers hurt but honestly I am not stopping a I-Forced dwellers any way so why try?

And as for my own magic phase if I get a IoN off great if not it really does not matter as I can not heal my units very fast anyway. Also if you get near them and scream their big mages unit away then they can't really be a problem can they? :thumbsup:
 
SGK on TG w/2 TG's for rare and take 2 units of Hexwraiths and flank the shit outta your enemy screaming up and down his ranks
 
Johnny-Crass said:
Screams to no care about buffs and hex's (besides things that target movement which I always dispel). Most Direct Damage is dealt to all the ethereal and honestly it is not so bad as long as my lovely laddies live. Spells like dwellers hurt but honestly I am not stopping a I-Forced dwellers any way so why try?

And as for my own magic phase if I get a IoN off great if not it really does not matter as I can not heal my units very fast anyway. Also if you get near them and scream their big mages unit away then they can't really be a problem can they? :thumbsup:

I guess if it works for you, then good job. I'll probably try something similar, but i'll include some magic defense.
 
Speaking of competitive list. I have taken the gloves off for my recent build. 3000 pt Vampire Counts

It is the last post. The list has two vampire lore masters and 2 skeleton blocks lead by 5 ethereals each. I feel bad for the poor guy that only has 2 or 3 magic weapons in the entire army. I have played with the idea of getting a death wizard to snipe enemy magic weapons:devil2:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu