Competitive players

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Vallek said:
Long time skaven player here, and just now looking into trying VC.
I see lots of people talking down core choices and talking about specials and rares at lot in this thread. I'm beginning to wonder why people act like VC core are some horribly depressing thing.

It has been my experience that large numbers of tarpit core can set you up for flank charges which ultimately allow for combat resolution. And unlike skavenslave tarpits, a good zombie tarpit with IoN vampire leading a small force of GW grave guard strolling along beside it could lock into an opponent with ease.

Just eat the first failed combat like it is nothing with 30+ zombies then drill the flank with your vampire and the grave guard. Anyone trying to win a fight with zombies is foolish because that isn't the purpose of cheap units with crap stats. They are there to eat wounds (that unlike skaven you can bring back) and open you up to a make a counter charge.

Truly competitive players don't just hold up sheets of paper and compare stat lines, because if that were the case skaven would never win.. positioning, knowing when it's ok for units to just die, and knowing how to bite back twice as hard are all vastly important.

I've also been wondering why I don't see much mention of putting a banshee in a zombie anvil unit. I mean, against most units you aren't going to lose her, she bumps the zombies up to leadership 5 instead of 2, and with her scream their is a truly good chance that you'll tip combat res closer to your favor and thus reduce anvil losses. She brings terror to the unit which can make the lackluster zombies actually land some hits with some luck. It's a hefty point investment but certainly not a risky one.

You would be correct, but you've ignored the thorn in the side of every undead player: unstable. A unit of 20+ Zombies can be wiped out in one round of combat while all the player can do is sit there and cry. Ya raising 2d6+ caster level sounds like a lot, but in practice you will not be raising faster than they die half the time (pending the skill of the opposing general). Skaven get ld bonuses from generals, re-rolls from bsbs, etc. etc. We get none of that.
 
setual said:
Vallek said:
Long time skaven player here, and just now looking into trying VC.
I see lots of people talking down core choices and talking about specials and rares at lot in this thread. I'm beginning to wonder why people act like VC core are some horribly depressing thing.

It has been my experience that large numbers of tarpit core can set you up for flank charges which ultimately allow for combat resolution. And unlike skavenslave tarpits, a good zombie tarpit with IoN vampire leading a small force of GW grave guard strolling along beside it could lock into an opponent with ease.

Just eat the first failed combat like it is nothing with 30+ zombies then drill the flank with your vampire and the grave guard. Anyone trying to win a fight with zombies is foolish because that isn't the purpose of cheap units with crap stats. They are there to eat wounds (that unlike skaven you can bring back) and open you up to a make a counter charge.

Truly competitive players don't just hold up sheets of paper and compare stat lines, because if that were the case skaven would never win.. positioning, knowing when it's ok for units to just die, and knowing how to bite back twice as hard are all vastly important.

I've also been wondering why I don't see much mention of putting a banshee in a zombie anvil unit. I mean, against most units you aren't going to lose her, she bumps the zombies up to leadership 5 instead of 2, and with her scream their is a truly good chance that you'll tip combat res closer to your favor and thus reduce anvil losses. She brings terror to the unit which can make the lackluster zombies actually land some hits with some luck. It's a hefty point investment but certainly not a risky one.

You would be correct, but you've ignored the thorn in the side of every undead player: unstable. A unit of 20+ Zombies can be wiped out in one round of combat while all the player can do is sit there and cry. Ya raising 2d6+ caster level sounds like a lot, but in practice you will not be raising faster than they die half the time (pending the skill of the opposing general). Skaven get ld bonuses from generals, re-rolls from bsbs, etc. etc. We get none of that.

This is true. And even worse, with unstable you can't flank charge because the unit that flank charges will be destoyed even if they take no CC damage themselves due to unstable. The enemy just concentrates on the zombies and both unit suffer. You have to be very carful about charging any unit in the flank that is being "held up" by zombies.

Oh, and Banshee Scream doesn't add to combat resolution.
 
Thanks for clearing all of that up for me... I see where my confusion was. So then, let me ask this.

Whats the point of zombies if you can't reliably anvil with them? It would seem to me that skellies make a good bunker unit for necromancers (especially with a mortis engine nearby 5+ AS, 6+ Parry, 6+ regen) and wolves are great for throwing ahead to lay into the enemy ranged units/war machines. But Zombies are baffling me for purpose.

Zombies just seem like a liability for anything other than summoning BEHIND nearby enemies then getting to land a rear charge next turn. I'd love to see how they can be used in truly competitive play.
 
Vallek said:
Thanks for clearing all of that up for me... I see where my confusion was. So then, let me ask this.

Whats the point of zombies if you can't reliably anvil with them? It would seem to me that skellies make a good bunker unit for necromancers (especially with a mortis engine nearby 5+ AS, 6+ Parry, 6+ regen) and wolves are great for throwing ahead to lay into the enemy ranged units/war machines. But Zombies are baffling me for purpose.

Zombies just seem like a liability for anything other than summoning BEHIND nearby enemies then getting to land a rear charge next turn. I'd love to see how they can be used in truly competitive play.

The point with a unit like Zombies isn't to win or help you win a combat. It is to tie up a unit for a few combats. They aren't expected to last the whole game, but while a unit is wasting its time fighting Zombies, you can deal with other units. Hopefully by the time they have chewed through the zombies, you have delt with other units and are able to set up zome kind of combo charge on that unit.

Is this viable for tournament play? Maybe, maybe not. Zombies might still be too aweful to even hold up a unit for any amount of time. You essentially want three combats. The turn they charge, your turn, and then their next turn so that they lose at least one movement phase.

As for bunkers, they aren't supposed to fight at all, just protect the necro from missiles. Therefore, you just want the cheapest. For this zombies are the best.

Oh, and regen doesn't stack with ward saves, so it would be either parry or regen for the skeletons.
 
datalink7 said:
Vallek said:
Oh, and regen doesn't stack with ward saves, so it would be either parry or regen for the skeletons.

But the unit is capable of either/or. So, lets say that somehow a ranged unti/war machine actually gets a chance to shoot at you. That 6+ Parry save can't be used but the 6+ regen can. Conversely, lets say that you're facing one of the dozen army banners that gives the unit firey attacks.. 6+ regen stops working but 6+ parry saves the day. the only time having both is worthless is with ranged fiery attacks (dwarven cannons/skaven warpfire throwers) but those are few and far between.

My fear for bunkering a necro in zombies is facing things with what can come in on the table edge. A small unit of gutter runners or gorgers is going to wipe that unit pretty damn quick. This also applies to burrowers, fliers, ect that can effectively bypass the bulk of your army to go for the tender rear line. I'd want something around my necro that can take SOME beating as opposed to none.
 
Skeletons, while better than zombies, aren't going to turn the tide against any kind of dedicated combat unit when operating as a bunker. Besides, if those gutter runners or Gorger charge your unit, they're just going to target your Necromancer anyway and kill him right off the bat.
 
Vallek said:
datalink7 said:
Vallek said:
Oh, and regen doesn't stack with ward saves, so it would be either parry or regen for the skeletons.

But the unit is capable of either/or. So, lets say that somehow a ranged unti/war machine actually gets a chance to shoot at you. That 6+ Parry save can't be used but the 6+ regen can. Conversely, lets say that you're facing one of the dozen army banners that gives the unit firey attacks.. 6+ regen stops working but 6+ parry saves the day. the only time having both is worthless is with ranged fiery attacks (dwarven cannons/skaven warpfire throwers) but those are few and far between.

My fear for bunkering a necro in zombies is facing things with what can come in on the table edge. A small unit of gutter runners or gorgers is going to wipe that unit pretty damn quick. This also applies to burrowers, fliers, ect that can effectively bypass the bulk of your army to go for the tender rear line. I'd want something around my necro that can take SOME beating as opposed to none.

Right, but (and please correct me if I'm wrong) they can't charge the turn they arrive. So when that unit arrives or on the turn the fliers, etc. get into charge range, the Necro leaves the bunker and stands there raising the zombies that the unit tries to kill. And keep in mind zombies grow beyond starting numbers, so that 20 man bunker is a 30 man bunker by the time that unit arrives. A "small unit" will not be taking down 30 bodies any time soon. Couple that with a CC w/ Lodestone and the zombies MIGHT even pull out a win v. an exceptionally small/weak unit. All this for less than a 10 man unit of skellies w/ command. Of course it's not without risk, but basically nothing in 'hammer is.
 
for dealing with gorgers just close of a table edge with a unit of zombies on a line. turn
them around too if you want them to grow. heh.

I have been trying out a semi screaming list as well.
but im sort of training for an upcoming tournament with a pretty strict comp system
so i can't include nearly as many.

anyway about the zombie i've actually returned to my roots and only include one or two units now. one for bunkering and one for closing of table edges and such. by returning to my roots i mean i've started using mainly ghouls again since they don't bleed res like zombies and every other core we have :/..

anyyway i have a question which would you include and why 2x1 spirithosts , 1 banshee, or corpsecart with raise upgrade i cant really decide it's the only part of my list that's not solid yet.
 
Bune said:
for dealing with gorgers just close of a table edge with a unit of zombies on a line. turn
them around too if you want them to grow. heh.

I have been trying out a semi screaming list as well.
but im sort of training for an upcoming tournament with a pretty strict comp system
so i can't include nearly as many.

anyway about the zombie i've actually returned to my roots and only include one or two units now. one for bunkering and one for closing of table edges and such. by returning to my roots i mean i've started using mainly ghouls again since they don't bleed res like zombies and every other core we have :/..

anyyway i have a question which would you include and why 2x1 spirithosts , 1 banshee, or corpsecart with raise upgrade i cant really decide it's the only part of my list that's not solid yet.

Spirit Hosts. CCs are not as protected or effective in practice as they look on paper, than for raising zombies. 1 banshee is ok, but not as good as the Hosts. The Hosts are good for extra drops, but mainly they tie up units. It will take two turns for them to crumble against basically anything out there with static CR, and another that has none can be held indefinitely. Imagine a war hydra killing nothing all game because of a 45 point model. It happens. With two you're almost guaranteed to get at least one of them into combat with something you want neutralized
 
setual said:
Bune said:
for dealing with gorgers just close of a table edge with a unit of zombies on a line. turn
them around too if you want them to grow. heh.

I have been trying out a semi screaming list as well.
but im sort of training for an upcoming tournament with a pretty strict comp system
so i can't include nearly as many.

anyway about the zombie i've actually returned to my roots and only include one or two units now. one for bunkering and one for closing of table edges and such. by returning to my roots i mean i've started using mainly ghouls again since they don't bleed res like zombies and every other core we have :/..

anyyway i have a question which would you include and why 2x1 spirithosts , 1 banshee, or corpsecart with raise upgrade i cant really decide it's the only part of my list that's not solid yet.

Spirit Hosts. CCs are not as protected or effective in practice as they look on paper, than for raising zombies. 1 banshee is ok, but not as good as the Hosts. The Hosts are good for extra drops, but mainly they tie up units. It will take two turns for them to crumble against basically anything out there with static CR, and another that has none can be held indefinitely. Imagine a war hydra killing nothing all game because of a 45 point model. It happens. With two you're almost guaranteed to get at least one of them into combat with something you want neutralized

I see your point. it should be mentioned i already have a banshee in the army and a terrorgheist so that would make it three screams a turn. but im actually leaning towards the spirit host to or the corpsecart just stick it near my bunker behind my main line so it is in cover from bs shooting and when you heal it you heal it so much it's fully restored requiring my opponent to take it down in one turn.
and because of the terrorgheists presence and the killy lord in BK my opponent has alot of things to shoot at with his warmachines..
 
There is one thing skellies have going for them as bunkers, thats champions. Great for calling out challenges and to be re-raised. The opponents character will have an uphill battle against static CR every turn. In zombies, where there is not champion the opponent can just place his character so he is in base contact with what ever squishy is in there and direct all attacks on him.

A good player wont let this happen, but there are good players able to handle bunkers aswell. Just saying :D.
 
I like the sound of this, as in the few games of this edition I have played until now (2500 points), I have fielded my naked general Master Necromancer in a zombie bunker (just to have more bodies for less price, as it is a unit that should not face combat and if it does, there's not much less to do). However, switching this unit by a skeletons one, in getting to this situation, this champion could potentially buy an extra turn for the Master Necromancer, which of course could prove to be vital.
 
Luvadin said:
I like the sound of this, as in the few games of this edition I have played until now (2500 points), I have fielded my naked general Master Necromancer in a zombie bunker (just to have more bodies for less price, as it is a unit that should not face combat and if it does, there's not much less to do). However, switching this unit by a skeletons one, in getting to this situation, this champion could potentially buy an extra turn for the Master Necromancer, which of course could prove to be vital.

Go with full command on the skeleton bunker and buy two relatively cheap Cairn Wraiths and you have your front rank full thus allowing you to put the master necro in the middle of the second rank where hopefully he is never attacked. Plus the Cairn Wraiths give you some decent attackes. When the master necro gets off a successful Vampire spell he can heal a wounded Wraith with the lore attribute.
 
Yorga said:
Go with full command on the skeleton bunker and buy two relatively cheap Cairn Wraiths and you have your front rank full thus allowing you to put the master necro in the middle of the second rank where hopefully he is never attacked. Plus the Cairn Wraiths give you some decent attackes. When the master necro gets off a successful Vampire spell he can heal a wounded Wraith with the lore attribute.

Well, I actually play two Cairn Wraiths heros in my current list, although I use them more offensively in the front rank of a ghoul horde and a grave guard horde so they can give the unit Terror, some punch and even be used as speed bumps or monter tarpits. Hence, I don't see what you comment as a default option, but it becomes indeed interesting if you see you are facing an opponent who could get easily to your bunker unit (DE pegasus hero, Bretonnian pegassus...). That way, as you deploy your heros in the last place, if you see your bunker should not face in principle any dangerous charge, you can field the CW in the frontline units and if you see some Scout, flanking or flying actual concerning units, they can maker their way into the skeletons lines.
 
After getting a few more games under my belt; Crypt Horrors and Mourtis Engine are amazing! The Aura it emits is aswome and crypt Horrors are just a brutal unit, anything with the ability to shred them of joist has to be tarpitted but even against hard hitting units they fare well, Vans Dance is a must of course to get the most out of them but just give a nearby character the Book of Arkhan to guarantee the spell. How easily they raise is borderline criminal I'm actually considering taking 2 Necro Lords and a Horde of these with a Double ME to guarantee one surviving once I slip and fall into a pile of cash... Our core can perform quite well with the help of a Defensive kitted vamp as the static combat meets his survivability (people will generally try to drop him in my xp) so it won't work every time but it helps.

As it stands I'm trying to run a multi threat list at 2000 with a Lvl.4 Necro w/ BP and RoFD,ME, block of 6 Crypt Horrors (these buggers single handedly held up a Plague Furnace and Horde for a whole game, the key is to have your enemy charge you as this minimizes casualties till help arrives), a Lvl.2 Vamp with Glittering Scales and Sword of Might along with Ld. Bomb skellie unit, a unit of spear Skellies to tie up a unit, x2-5 Wolves for redirecting and a unit of 20 Zombies with a Necro carrying the book of Arkhan to plop in them and last but not least a nekkid Wight King with lance barded steed with 9 Black Knights to hit flanks (Raising 5 per round makes them amazing IMO, High AS with good damage output, consistent easy raising means they are invaluable to me another unit that is going to grow in the very near future)

I like the double wraith idea in the Skellies to protect my unprotected Master Necro... Hurts my feelings that I didn't come up with this earlier as that could have helped me out quite a few times... Something I'm really going to have to look into ;)
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu