WHFB - 7th Corpse Carts in units?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.

brentrb

Zombie
Dec 13, 2007
6
Zombies
3
Can a Corpse Cart, mounted by a Necromancer, join a unit? They move and fight like monsters, and apparently can be mounted like monsters. Does the rule stating that monsters mounted by characters may join units therefore apply? If so, how are ranks calculated?
 
Well, sorry for repeating my question twice (under Bloodlines title - Hiding Necromancers). But if a Corpse Cart with necromancer join a unit, what happens to the Corpse Cart without a rider? A monster is not allowed to join a unit but we do have a monster in the unit now :)
 
These are my relevant postings from another thread.

Corpse Carts can join units. I believe any character riding a monster can join a unit, I don't see a US restriction, only a restriction for "Look Out Sir!" rules (characters in units can benefit from Look Out Sir! as long as their US < 5. A ridden Corpse Cart has a US of 4).

Relevant pages from the MRB:
"Character and Units" first two paragraphs, pg. 72
First paragraph under "Monster Model" pg. 58.
Look out Sir! Bottom left. pg. 75

Well, sorry for repeating my question twice (under Bloodlines title - Hiding Necromancers). But if a Corpse Cart with necromancer join a unit, what happens to the Corpse Cart without a rider? A monster is not allowed to join a unit but we do have a monster in the unit now
I don't think it is a monster, I think it just moves like a monster but I'll have to double check this, I'm not certain.

I'll have to take a look at the rules to determine if it would make a roll on the monstrous mount reaction table; it would be really strange if the corpse cart went berserk (strange but awesome!).

There are a number of ways a unit can become illegal, such as two characters in a unit and the whole unit gets wiped out except for the character. This has been discussed already on this forum and multiple times on warseer.

I won't start the discussion up on here again, but there are problems no matter how you handle it. I believe the best way is to keep it a unit until there's a good opportunity to separate it into different units. If you want to bring up counter arguments please revive the old post.
 
So do we interpret "moves and fights as a monster" as "Corpse Cart is a monster"? If that's the only relevant posting on whether it's a monster or not, I would have to say that it should be a monster.

PG 59, MRB: "If a mount has 2 or more wounds it is classified as a monstrous mount..."
It's a mount, and it has more 3 wounds, so I guess this is what it is.

If it's not a monster, I don't know what it is. Doesn't fit anything else, except maybe Chariot. I would argue that it should roll on the monstrous reaction chart (frenzied zombies with hatred? Finally, I can get my "Land of the Dead" zombies...).
 
Whilst the descriptions in the monstrous reactions chart may not fit how the CC would work if you are going to treat the CC as a monster in every other aspect - mount, being included in units etc then I would treat it as a monster for eveything else, including the monster reaction chart.
Admittendly thinking of that I am tempted to paint a bullseye on my mounted necro just to end with 2d6 re-rolling hits :grin:
 
illusionarypresence said:
if they are amount then yes i think they can join units because they dont fly. as for ranks i'm not too sure, i guess it would be reasonable to treat like a screaming bell....

I disagree. The Screaming Bell has about a page of words and diagrams explaining how it interacts with the unit it's placed in in its bestiary entry. The Corpse Cart doesn't. This suggests (to me, at least) that the developers didn't intend for it to be used like that, or at least didn't think of it. The chariot base supports this: anyone remember how they put all the Chaos troopers on the same base size to make the units, well, actually work?

Tragic oversight on their part, but hey, that's par for the course with development teams in general.
 
Well based on the key points so far:

- It counts as a monster
- A character "riding" a monster can still join a unit though it can get picked out

So I would say it could. But thats just me
 
It's US is 3. With a necromancer, it's 4. It can only be picked out if it has a US of 5+... so no, it can't be picked out.

As far as I know, there are no diagrams of Stegadon's joining units, CarnoSaurs joining Lizardman units, etc. But it can be done.

In any case, I wish they were more specific. It's either a chariot or a monster. If it's a monster, it's a ridden monster and so can join units. If it's a chariot it can't. What else could it be?

Edit: Looking at the back of the book, its a monster.
 
Look at the page 96, the corpse cart was listed on the monster subsection, so it is a monster.
So it can join units when mounted, just like any other non flying mounted monster.
 
I don't believe it's meant to be able to join units but being pedantic according to the rules if you have a Necromancer ride on it then yes it can join a unit in that situation. With no Necromancer on it then no.
 
Well thats the way I see it and I've created mu army list that has a Necro riding CC in a unit of Ghouls. The main question is how does it work out for ranks? I.e I have 12 Ghouls so how many ranks can I claim?
 
We play that the Model, no matter how big, takes up the space of a single model. So to get a rank bonus of +3, I would need 19 ghouls + Corpse cart. There are no rules on how to do it, the only rule is that there needs to be 5 models per rank. There is nothing saying a model can or cannot be used for multiple ranks. With the size of the Corpse Cart, I think if it took up 4 ranks that would be too strong. You'd only need 16 models to get a rank bonus of +3.
 
Don't the Screaming Bell (for Skaven), Slann (for Lizardmen) and Archeon (Hordes of Chaos) all talk specifically how they fit into units, and rank up? While I don't have the books on hand right now, I believe they count for as many models as they displace (i.e. Archaeon for 2, a Slann for 4, and the Screaming bell for 6).

The issue is the chariot base vs. 20mm bases - doesn't fit evenly. (i.e. it is 2 1/2 bases wide, and 5 bases deep) (vs. 2 and 4 for 25mm).

I figure at this point it is much simpler to take the hit and not include it in a unit. Personally, I've never seen a character on a monster (with the exception of Archaeon) being put in a unit at all - until this discussion came up I had never even considered it.
 
Well, different bases matters little, you can join a vamp on a nightmare with a unit and they wont evenly rank up but that doesnt mean you need a passage showing how they´ll rank up. The Ccart is a monster as per defined in the back of the book, I think we´re getting stuck on the appearence. Looks like a chariot but is a monster. If it would have been a big angry undead monster we wouldnt be having this discussion... but as said, above dont hang yourself up on the look of the model!

Cheers
 
I would play it as the Corpse Cart counts as one model in every rank that the base covers... because, well, it does. No rules to support it, but yes, it would mean that you could get +2 rank bonus for 12 models and +3 for 16. I've seen some play it as grishnak and some the other extreme, that it counts as being 2 (or even 3!) models wide, which I think is taking it too far. So counting it as one model per rank is a fine compromise and fairest to all involved, IMO.
 
I can't see that it say that Corpse Cart is a monster in the rules for Corpse Cart(only on the Reference list).

I have read the battle report in White Dwarf and the crossbowmen shoots down the necromancer on a Corps Cart but he don't do a monster reaction test (or I miss it).
 
This is exactly the source of my personal confusion. If it's a monster why didn't they say "The Corpse Cart is a Monster.". Saying it moves and fights like a monster is implying that it is not a monster, just acts as one in certain ways.

Perhaps this was to get around rolling on the Monster Reaction chart; I can think of no other reason if their intent was that the Corpse Cart functions in most respects as a monster.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu