WHFB - 7th Corpse Carts in units?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
grishnakh99 said:
I think Skillmatic11 meant a monster you can field alone that can also be fielded with a rider.

Well whatever he meant (who knows), I gave examples of all types of monsters, of every type. I even had the Great Eagle in my list in the first place. Though I guess there's no harm in restating what I've already said ;)
 
Yep, was quoting you actually, just didn't use the quote function. Credit goes to you. I'm sure (I hope!) he meant he didn't know of an unridden monster because... well... I have more faith in people than that. Every army has a monster I believe. There's tons of monsters in Warhammer.

Any other monsters that can be mounted and fielded on their own?
 
I've though about this a little before, and I think the Eagle is the only one, in High and Wood Elf books. Unless you consider the silly old Necrarch list and its unridden Zombie Dragons :D
 
Max zero said:
Why would it be a chariot? What chariot like features does it have?

Enough to actually BE a chariot if you go by the meaning of the word. It is two wheeled, pulled by mounts and a vehicle. Of course the fact it fits the dictionary definition does not mean it has to follow the rules GW has for them.

Besides I certainly don't think it should be a chariot, or that GW wanted it to be. I was refering to the GW designers note refers to it as: not truely a Chariot or a Monster.

Max zero said:
I don't think its a accident that a mounted CC comes in just under the 5 unit strength limit for mounted characters in units so they can't be picked out and benefit from the 'LOS!' rule.

Actually this is one of the things that makes me doubt their intent, I find it very unlikely they intended for the Corpse Cart to be able to hide within units.
- - -

As I have already said I completely agree that the corpse cart should be treated as a monster / monsterous mount.
I'm just expressing my personal doubt that GW had even considered this situation when they published the rules, I don't (and can't) know this for certain and it doesn't affect the game.
 
I don't think they anticipated it either, really. But it's fair enough, as a Necro on a Corpse Cart would be virtually useless otherwise.
 
I'm sorry there EvC...I MEANT monsters that are mounts that can be fielded alone, the only one on your list was the great eagle...
And I know the rules for monsters...and reaction tests...I was just making my point on how its stupid you don't have to take a test if u field the CC solo, but if mounted by a necro and if he dies, you have to take one...it just sounds stupid to me....
 
Do you also think it's stupid that the Great Eagle doesn't have to take a stupidity test whenever it's fielded without a rider, when it would have to take one if its rider was killed?
 
actually...yes I DO...lol being though its coherent and well behaved enough to follow orders without a rider then it should be able to do so when the rider is DEAD...I'm not disagreeing with YOU per say, but anything that is a monstrous mount that can be fielded WITHOUT a rider, should not take a test when that rider dies....
 
The point about things being stupid will have you sat here for ages as so many things in Warhammer do not make sense. Considering how it works, especially mount wise I would use the monster reaction test, as someone mentioned above you can make up a vareity of reasons fluff wise.
 
But if a mount has more than two wounds it counts as a mounstrous mount right? And these can't join units.
 
you're wrong. Monstrous mount can join units, take archaon as an example.
Mostly of the montrous mounst also fly and the fliying monted monsters can't join units.

Another example of monsters than can be fielded as mounts or alone is the lizardmen stegadon.
 
Chobber, it's posts like yours that make threadromancy so depised! For one you're wrong because mounted monsters CAN join the rulebook, and for two, it's even been FAQed that a mounted Corpse Cart can join units. Time to lock the threads friendly neighbourhood admins! :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu