Corpse Carts. is there a better use of 100 pts?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Ferrum

Grave Guard
Nov 9, 2010
259
Seattle
Zombies
279
I just finished building my 2,500 point list, and realised taht i was spending 100 (with lodestone) points on a corpse cart. I looked at the bestiary again and saw taht all it was doing was giving me ASF sometimes, and an extra skeleton whenever i used Invocation of Nehek. I also had my necro mounted within it, making him a HUGE target for artillery etc...

Is this hideous thing truely worth the points???

if i were to remove this from my list i could add 3 warriors to each unit...or 6 GG...or 3 BK....or best yet another wight king with either sword of kings or tomb blade.

Which of these would likely serve me best on average?
 
I really like Corpse Carts.

First rule of the CC. Never put a necromancer on them. Ever. He's a sore thumb asking to be smacked with whatever projectiles your opponent might throw his way.

the ability to make your opponent reserve dispel dice is huge. The Bound spell can't burn out, so every turn that's at least one dispel dice your opponent must reserve to stop the nearby units gaining unholy speed. (High elves really don' care, though...) so you could factor that into your magic game. If they get the full 6 dispel dice (You get 12 power dice, in perspective) They really only have 5, especially if the Cart is in a vital point.

that leaves you with 12 dice to their 5, not including whatever other tricks they have. I like them odds.

And, if you manage to bring two carts (Just over the price of a 20 man skeleton unit with command, sadly...) you then make your opponent reserve 2 dice until the corpse carts are dead.

Also, using the True Line of Sight rules, I'd really recommend modifying your Cart to -not- have the lodestone standing out like a sore thumb. Nothing says you can't cut the supports and make it a more sleek, somewhat faster looking cart. And not an arrow magnet.


So, my opinion is to keep the cart. :)
 
Personally, I like the cart because you get 2 combat phases of ASF out of it, and you can just chuck one die at Miasma with no real penalty for failing. It's not bad if you can boost its strength (lore of beasts jumps to mind), and I find that my opponents often devote resources to killing it that I'm glad aren't going somewhere better. Also, the ASF applies to all friendlies in range, making it much better than Danse in two regards.

But if you don't want it, where to spend the points really depends on what else you're fielding. For example, there's no point in adding another 3 warriors to each unit if they're already 50 strong. I like enough black knights that I can loose a few on the approach, so that's an attractive option for me. But then, if you've already got 15, 3 more isn't too effective a use of the points.

You could buy a stock vampire; 3 S5 attacks usually hitting on 3+ is always a solid buy.

The wight king with the Sword of Kings is good; if you can scrounge the points to give him the Nightshroud he's great in a challenge.
 
I really like the Corpse Cart, great model, great potential, it seems to attract far more attention than its capabilities should.

I like the idea of using two in an army (my army is based on Ghoul Hordes), but only using the basic CC so saving 50 points for the two.
 
I like the model, and find it does become a target for my opponent's. If the spell get's off, it's astounding how fearfull they become of it.
 
Ferrum said:
I just finished building my 2,500 point list, and realised taht i was spending 100 (with lodestone) points on a corpse cart. I looked at the bestiary again and saw taht all it was doing was giving me ASF sometimes, and an extra skeleton whenever i used Invocation of Nehek. I also had my necro mounted within it, making him a HUGE target for artillery etc...

Is this hideous thing truely worth the points???

if i were to remove this from my list i could add 3 warriors to each unit...or 6 GG...or 3 BK....or best yet another wight king with either sword of kings or tomb blade.

Which of these would likely serve me best on average?

The bound spell that the cart uses is key and vital towards making undead core units effective. The Miasma of Deathly Vigor is a great counterweight against almost all opponents. A skeleton warrior, by its self, is not worth the 8 points you pay for it. An augmented ASF skeleton is now worth 8 points. A unit of skeletons under the effects of the Miasma will re-roll misses against Dwarves and most Lizardmen units, and will counter High Elf ASF advantages; so without the proper application of a Corpse Cart you are marching to war with soldiers that have an inferior stat-line.

The use of the options on the carts is another idea that is not appreciated or even discussed at length. A Lodestone pays for itself with just 3 ION castings on a skeleton unit, and a Balefire could easily pay for itself by preventing just one Magic Missile spell per game.

If you feel that the 100 points is better spent on more Grave Guard, then go right ahead and buy more of those units. I will keep my Corpse Carts and buff my horrible core choices.
 
your opponent must reserve to stop the nearby units gaining unholy speed. (High elves really don' care, though...)

Correct me if I am wrong. According to new rules if units on both sides have ASF, then none of them gets rerols and both units strike simultaneously. If I am correct then high elves do care :)
 
IMO the corpse cart is neither an auto include nor is it useless. The lodestone is useful if you wish to include black knights, wraiths or spirit hosts as it essentially doubles the output of your IoN. Put near skeletons or ghouls however and the extra 1 model doesn't give you much value for the 25pts spent on the upgrade.
Balefire is a favourite of mine, not because the -1 to cast is particularly game winning, but because it makes the opponent think twice about how many dice they should put into a roll. Furthermore it makes the enemy magic phase that little bit more manageable and if you run a caster lord (as I do) it gives you that slight edge over your opponent.
Miasma is not as good as it was in 7th when you could force a dispel dice or two off your opponent at critical moments, but it still has it's uses. It is essentially a buff spell that you can always rely on getting at the start of the game and can potentially help you out in a tight spot.
My favourite thing about the corpse cart though is that it draws enemy fire. Some people consider this a weakness, but I find that the corpse cart tends to shrug off bows and crossbows quite nicely and I would much rather my enemy waste shooting on the corpse cart and let me focus on fun spells than knock ranks off my units and force me to concentrate on raising.
 
Wow that's a lot of information!
It wasn't exactly clear when reading the book how good any of the upgrades it has were. But now that they have been thoroughly explained and examples of their effective use are laid out I'm gonna have to go with the balefire.

Another reason for this is because while I will be running a unit of ten BK, wouldn't they be doing their job better if they were galloping around with my black coach outflanking and charging the weak? I can't see how the unholy lodestone would even effect them useless they barely escaped a fight and I pulled them back. I think this unit would really shine if I were to build my list up from around a pair or trip of them.

On the other side of the argument Lasombra's comment has merit. A Wight King with sword of kings had the potential to significantly alter the tide of battle. It has more ability to protect (short term) my units from big scary lords, and is more obviously worth 100 points.

I think I like the strangeness of the cart, and will see how it runs at least for a few games
 
Ferrum said:
Wow that's a lot of information!
It wasn't exactly clear when reading the book how good any of the upgrades it has were. But now that they have been thoroughly explained and examples of their effective use are laid out I'm gonna have to go with the balefire.

Another reason for this is because while I will be running a unit of ten BK, wouldn't they be doing their job better if they were galloping around with my black coach outflanking and charging the weak? I can't see how the unholy lodestone would even effect them useless they barely escaped a fight and I pulled them back. I think this unit would really shine if I were to build my list up from around a pair or trip of them.

Balefire is my personal favourite, but lodestone also has merit, in fact it's probably even better with black knights in this edition than it was in 7th. Now that black knights are much less likely to demolish a unit on the charge, you can run up a corpse cart behind them and sustain them if they get entangled. Also, so long as you don't go full pelt straight away it's not too difficult to keep the corpse cart within 6" to help reduce the losses from shooting.
Put near a spirit host tar pit though, lodestone should really shine.
 
I think that balefire is the carts most attractive feature.2 carts w/ BF and a lvl 4 lord will really cramp the style of enemy wizards.Regeneration makes it a good obstruction as well.I killing blowed an enemy general just the other day with my WK w/ SOK,this plus the shroud or my favorite=Gem of Blood;really gives your opponent something to worry about.
I think the cart is a little over costed in 8th,ASF doesn't matter nearly as much,and bound items using power dice doesn't help.I often end my magic phase w/ a single die ION anyway.
I think you will have to build around the cart(s) for them to be effective;whereas the WK will do well in most builds.
I hope you use them and do well,post results.
 
I am about to be part of an eight player campaign so I will have many opportunities to test whether one is more effective than the the other when I spend 100 points on either. I will certainly post battle reports and any findings on CC vs WK effectiveness
 
for 100 points (Lodestone) or 200 points (Balefirex2, which is really the only effective way to run them in pairs) i would much rather dump those points into a black coach, wight kings, varghulf, GG, black knights ect. The miasma sucks and should not even be mentioned anymore, it was cool when it was free, and was good at wasting enemy dispel dice. all our troops have such low iniative and striking first really doesnt matter, they dont kill much anyways. VC core does not win games every thing else does.
 
The only half interesting thing is that Miasma + High I = rerolls to hit. I agree it sucks, but with Vampires all having stellar I values, it's something to consider. Blood Knights may benefit as well, or if you're fighting a Low I army like Dwarves, Orcs and LZ. Yes, greatly diminished. But don't discount the tactical options it opens up.

@Forge: Why do you feel 2 are necessary? Personally I would include only 1, as the tactical options with the Miasma aren't horrible. Just not well rounded. And I'm really trying to find reasons to include the Corpse Cart. It's a stellar model.
 
i agree 100% with Forge.
everyone knows u gotta use PD on bound spells anyways and miasma aint that good, a Necro with Arkhan is way more awsome and useful. my oponents rarely targets it and 75 points is much better spent on more GGs if ur unit is under 30 models or a Wight king with Hoffy if u dont have it.
 
Forge said:
for 100 points (Lodestone) or 200 points (Balefirex2, which is really the only effective way to run them in pairs) i would much rather dump those points into a black coach, wight kings, varghulf, GG, black knights ect. The miasma sucks and should not even be mentioned anymore, it was cool when it was free, and was good at wasting enemy dispel dice. all our troops have such low iniative and striking first really doesnt matter, they dont kill much anyways. VC core does not win games every thing else does.

The Miasma from the corpse cart should not be over looked. The benefits make our core useful in this edition. A unit of Skeletons armed with spears with ASF helps them against so many opponents. But of course you could just keep dumping points into the Grave Guard or Black Coaches or what other unit you deem as better, but these other units just do not have the numbers nor the regenerative powers as a brick of core infantry.
 
That is a very valid point. I am mostly a 40k player and so I have a tendency to go for smaller units of troops (7 plague marines!). It's really hard to shake that mentality and focus upon large indestructible units. My army does include GG and a coach, but I can see the purpose of a CC within a large force of core troops, it also seems to be very effective when combined with GG or other powerful units.
I'm mostly just struggling over which upgrade to use!
 
The fact that we often use lvl 3 lords as casters means that the balefire cart will give you an even break against enemy Archmages.I think it's the best option,as it allows the cart to participate in EVERY magic phase,not just yours.
 
Forgive me if this is really ignorant, but would it be necessary to field a level three wizard always? At the moment I am only planning on a level two and several level ones.

Am I just asking to get abused by my opponents magic phase by doing this?

Thanks for your input :)
 
I find myself with level 2's all the time, it just depends if your a all out magic army is all.
If you have alot of casting to do the extra level is worth it.

Anyway CC are always worth the points and I take at least 1, the 25 upgrade however is not always needed but if you do decide to take it use it for balefire.
Its the only one worth the points.

I always try and field 3 units of 30 ghouls and another 30 GG, CC, 2 vamps and a lord then hit the extras plus upgrades.
Striking first is worth its weight in gold! :P
 
Whew I'm glad it's alright if I don't run powerful casters!

How do you use it during games? And by that I mean where do you position it and such?
 
The CC is always best placed in the centre, you will have your battle lie or main bulk of troops and as you advance you make sure you just hug within 6 inches of both while staying away from any charge arks yourself, you don't want to lose ASF, it can turn a entire battle around.

My campaign army had 3 vampires, 2 hero level 1's and 1 level 2 lord.
I drew for first with a WoC army, campaign was 5 months long and called it a draw as winter crusade started so the 40k could be broke back out. ;)
 
That is the same vampire ration that my army has at the moment, plus an additional necromancer. As an added bonus i think the only really scary caster i could face in this campaign is a slann..a nice squishy slann :konrad:
 
not only is putting a necro on CC bad idea as he will just get targeted, it eats up your hero points which can be better spent on wight kings more necros or a vampire.... (remeber errted' mounted CC do not go in core)
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu