Coven throne - Battle of wills.

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Swoosh

Ghoul
Aug 11, 2013
180
Zombies
127
Locked in CC, does the opponent do BoW every combat round or just the first one? I don't think the description is that clear:

Battle of Wills:
Immediately before the first model in an enemy unit rolls To Hit against the Coven Throne or a character upon it (either in close combat or shooting), the opponent must roll a D6 and add it to his unit's Leadership
(attacks that do not roll To Hit are exempt from this effect). Next, roll a D6 and add it to the Coven Throne's Leadership . To find the result of the Battle of Wills, subtract the enemy's
total from the Coven Throne's total, and apply the result to the table below - the results last until the end of the turn.

It doesn't specifically say anywhere.
 
It apply every combat round. There are other effects that only apply the first round of close combat, but those limitations are stated very clearly in the rule.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Swoosh
Sun King and I don't agree on this.
When the rules say "..before the first model in an enemy unit rolls.." I would say everytime that unit attacks the coven throne, there is a moment before the first model in the unit rolls. Therefore it can apply several times for the same unit during the battle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mad 'At
I don't think that I agree with Smogg and Lord... As I read it - it only triggers ONCE per enemy unit... this does not reset in subsequent rounds.
Sun King and I don't agree on this.
When the rules say "..before the first model in an enemy unit rolls.." I would say everytime that unit attacks the coven throne, there is a moment before the first model in the unit rolls. Therefore it can apply several times for the same unit during the battle.
Based on your logic, Sun King, whatever the result is on the first one, so it would be for all subsequent rounds. So if they pass once, they never take it again, but if they fail, they would suffer the same consequence every turn thereafter. But because the rest of the rule says the effects only last until the end of the turn (regardless of different phase), it only makes sense that they would have to retest in subsequent turns. If a unit fails and attacks themselves, they suddenly have the WILL to attack at their leisure in subsequent turns? This doesn't make sense.

I agree that it should happen every turn and, pending reading the whole rule again, may happen multiple times in one turn, if there some unit that were able to shoot and have close combat with it in the same turn.
 
Based on your logic, Sun King, whatever the result is on the first one, so it would be for all subsequent rounds. .

Where do you get this from? :) The FIRST unit can logically only apply once in a game... the second time a model in a unit tries to hit it cannot be the first. Your intrepretation presupposes that the rules read: "Immediately before the first model in an enemy unit rolls To Hit EACH TURN " This is not the case however. This "logic" that you say I'm propagating is not logic at all since the rules explicitly state: "the results last until the end of the turn".
 
Where do you get this from? :) The FIRST unit can logically only apply once in a game... the second time a model in a unit tries to hit it cannot be the first. Your intrepretation presupposes that the rules read: "Immediately before the first model in an enemy unit rolls To Hit EACH TURN " This is not the case however. This "logic" that you say I'm propagating is not logic at all since the rules explicitly state: "the results last until the end of the turn".

It doesn't really need to say each turn though. Because if it did it couldn't happen more then once to the same unit on a turn. Which it can with shooting and cc.

It only says to test before the first model in a unit makes a to hit roll, nothing about the first time a model in a unit makes a to hit roll. Which is how I think you are reading it. The first model in a unit can make a to hit roll multiple times in a game.
 
The first time a model makes a to hit roll can only happen once. That's the first time he rolled.

The first model in a unit however can make 12 shooting and/or 12 close combat attacks in a game. Doesn't happen once.
 
So if I charge archers, they have to do BoW if they choose Stand and Shoot and then again in close combat?

Edit: Nah guess they don't as it applies rest of the turn. Or?
 
The first time a model makes a to hit roll can only happen once. That's the first time he rolled.

The first model in a unit however can make 12 shooting and/or 12 close combat attacks in a game. Doesn't happen once.
That would only make sense for units where every model attacks at the same time. If there's a character that has higher initiative, then based on this, you would have to kill the highest I model before causing the unit to retest. This doesn't make sense.

@The Sun King My point was that it doesn't make sense for an Empire (or any other) unit to FAIL battle of wills then on the next turn suddenly be unaffected. The CT and the handmaidens on it are no less seductive after a BoW. It would be like sailors wrecking their ship because of sirens then suddenly being able to fight them normally.
 
So if I charge archers, they have to do BoW if they choose Stand and Shoot and then again in close combat?

Edit: Nah guess they don't as it applies rest of the turn. Or?

Applies any time a model is about to make a to hit roll.

@Alabaster427 the reason the rule even bothers to specify the first model in a unit is to make sure people don't think their higher initiative characters get to strike before the unit takes the test.
 
Applies any time a model is about to make a to hit roll.

@Alabaster427 the reason the rule even bothers to specify the first model in a unit is to make sure people don't think their higher initiative characters get to strike before the unit takes the test.
I agree. I was making my point against the argument that a would retest because a different model is striking first.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu