Crimson Gem of Lahmia- how many times?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Kain

Zombie
Feb 15, 2008
26
Zombies
19
When I first read this item, it seemed pretty straight forward. You can sac wounds to gain PD as long as you don't die. So we came up with a neat combo where I played Count Mannfred with the Gem and put Isabella in his unit and her almost useless ability of healing did well since he'd wound himself and she'd heal the wound every magic phase. Plus Isabella is cheap so it was like saving a ton of points for 2 PD instead of the 1.

My friend however was saying that you can only use the gem once per phase since he says "a wound" means the same thing as "a single wound" thereby giving it a restriction. As well he says that "at any time in the magic phase" means the same thing as "at any single time in the magic phase" giving it yet another restriction.

I tell him he's overanalyzing and reading between lines where you shouldn't but he wants to know what you guys think.

So can you use the Gem more than once per magic phase?
 
I think you can. There's no restriction saying you can only use it once per phase. You do have to sacrafice a wound per powerdie though. The item is pretty terrible as it is anyways. Just get the bloodline ability that gives you 2PD and it's a safer combination. Isabella isn't very good.

The only combination with the Crimson Gem that isn't terrible I think is with BloodDrinker.
 
Indeed. Also remember that you can only use Isabella's healing ability at the start of each magic phase, you can't wait until you've used the Crimson Gem and then use Isabella's Chalice to restore the wound.
 
Isabella's healing ability at the start of each magic phase

Because you can use the item to gain a PD at any time in the magic phase, you can say the time is at the start of the magic phase, before isabella heals anyone, so you take the wound at the very start of the magic phase, and then isabella heals it. Besides, you generate normal dice at the start of the magic phase, and when resolving multiple events that happen at the same time, the controling player has always been allowed to determine the order everything is resolved.

The problem I have with the item is this... 'time' and 'wound' are both singular. Thus, you may lose a wound; but 'a wound' is not logically or gramaticly equivlent to 'multiple wounds'. So, if you lose more than 'a wound', for example if you lose '4 wounds' on mannfred, then you have broken the rule, as the item says 'a wound'.
 
I'm not sure about that. I tend to think that actions that must come at the start of a phase must happen before items that you can choose the timing for. But oh wel, that's just one interpretation.
 
Only in this case, it says you heal at the start of the magic phase. You also generate all dice at the start of the magic phase. So if you use the item to gain a regular old die at the start of the magic phase, at the same time as other regular dice are generated, and you must heal a wound during this time as well, you need to specify an order.

To me, its the same concept for choosing which units rally first, and which chargers move first, and which combats are resolved first.

I do understand what your saying though, and fortunately it takes an otherwise unremarkable special character to get this ability anyway, so there shouldnt be too many problems with it.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu